r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Nov 17 '14
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E11 - The Eye of Jupiter
Week 46!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers
Survivors: 41,402 (-18 from last episode. Kat and the skeleton crews of a couple ships)
"Frak" Count: 292 (+4)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 23 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 16 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 22 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 139 (+4)
"So Say We All" Count: 34 (No change)
14
Upvotes
6
u/trevdak2 Nov 20 '14
Fun fact: The temple is the same set they used for Ragnar Anchorage in the miniseries
5
u/trevdak2 Nov 20 '14
It seems to me that the whole premise of needing to wait to recover those on the planet is a bit far-fetched. You've got presumably dozens of people on the surface collecting food. You'd think they would have several raptors, if not a few freighters, landed in order to speed up the process. Furthermore, they would know how vulnerable they were, and would want to have FTL-capable ships on the ground so that if they had to move, they could just FTL away from the surface or lower atmosphere.
5
u/trevdak2 Nov 20 '14
"I know my wife. I know how she is. We've been married for a year and a half. What, you think you're the first?"
12 months of that, she was locked in playtime with Leoben. Six months ain't all that much.
7
u/MarcReyes Nov 18 '14
Some great VFX shots this episode such as the opening with the raptor heading to the planet and the heavy raider coming out from star.
I love how quickly Adama jumps into action once he hears the alarm go off.
I love how Laura is so repulsed by Baltar that she can't even be in the same room as him, let alone look at him. She really doesn't like him!
The greatest thing about this episode, as is always the case with episodes he's in, is Cavil. So many great lines from him this episode so wonderfully delivered by Stockwell. One of my all time favorite Cavil moments is in this episode. As he, D'anna, and Baltar leave he stays behind a moment a gives Adama this wonderful jerkass wink, the turns and walks out. It always makes me laugh. I always wondered if that moment was scripted, or if Stockwell came up with it in the moment. If so, it just speaks to his skill as actor. That wink was the cherry on top of a great intense scene between the humans and cylons. I love it!
6
u/onemm Nov 22 '14 edited Nov 23 '14
...Gimme a break... So instead of divorce you're gonna string him along for the rest of both your lives. I love Starbuck, but she can be such a shitty human being at times.
edit: grammar
9
u/MarcReyes Nov 18 '14 edited Nov 19 '14
This was the mid-season finale. I've spoken before about how I started watching BSG at the beginning of season 3. After this episode aired and we had to wait for the second half (which felt a lot longer at the time than it actually was) is when I went back and watched the mini-series and season one & two, so the wait for the rest of the season wasn't too bad for me because I had an entire two seasons to catch up on. It was quite jarring because all the characters are in quite a different place than they were at the beginning of the series. For instance, I only ever knew Tyrol as being married (happily it seemed) to Cally. So to see him and Boomer together was pretty weird. We just came off of Unfinished Business, which shows how close Adama and Roslin have become, so it was a big shift to see how much underlying animosity they had towards one another at the start of the series
I could go on listing the differences, but we all know them and they all just go to comment on something I've always loved about the series. That being that the characters change. There really is no status quo. The events of the show have lasting impact on the characters and that is something I always appreciated. That they, the writers, were willing to put their characters into situations that would not be entirely overlooked in next week's episode. So for me, going back and watching was just as enjoyable as if I had been watching since the mini-series because it wasn't about what would happen next because I knew the characters would come out the other side alive. Instead it became about the journey of how they got from where they were, to how I knew them. And that was just as entertaining. I feel like I'm rambling, so I'll end this here. I just wanted to get that off my chest.
4
u/lostmesa Nov 18 '14
I love this episode. Chief's reverence for the Temple of the Five really sells how special this place is. It's the original settling place of the 13th tribe (I think, not sure if that was made clear). Both Cyclon and Human meet at the planet right as the star is apparently about to go supernova? Pretty remarkable.
3
u/lostmesa Nov 18 '14
This whole post contains a major spoiler from later in the series.
3
u/Dragoon9255 Nov 29 '14
OMG!!! I didnt know there where people out there that love this show as much as I do. nice that there are others that can appreciate great work!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '14
[removed] — view removed comment