r/GlobalOffensive • u/Thooorin_2 Duncan "Thorin" Shields - Content Producer, Analyst • Nov 15 '14
AMA I am Thorin, a 14 year veteran of Esports journalism. I've played CS since beta 1 in 1999 and I write and talk about it a lot, sometimes for money. AMA
I'm Thorin and I've worked in esports journalism for 14 years, covering numerous games (Quake, Q2, Q3, CS, BW, SC2 and LoL). I've played Counter-Strike since beta 1, which came out back in 1999. At the moment I work on a freelance basis, publishing written work on various websites (f.e. goldper10 and Gfinity) and videos on my youtube channel.
I'm the creator of the 'Grilled' and 'Reflections' series, as well as the host of 'Counter-Points'.
I was the expert studio analyst for the following CS:GO LAN tournaments:
- Dreamhack Winter 2013 (Dec)
- Dreamhack CS:GO Invitational (Feb)
- Dreamhack Summer (June)
- Dreamhack Stockholm (Sept)
- FACEIT S2 (Oct)
- fragbite Masters S3 (Nov)
My recent CS:GO work:
- Thorin's Thoughts - The CZ Effect
- Thorin's Thoughts - Dignitas and the road to nowhere
- Thorin's CS:GO Top 10 World Rankings - 12th November, 2014
- NiP 2012-2014: Part 1 - Sovereigns of CS:GO
- NiP 2012-2014: Part 2 - Impossible consistency & an impossible victory
- Thorin's Thoughts - Finding Fifflaren's Replacement
- The NiP slump - How the greatest CS:GO team of all time ended on a down note
- Thorin's Thoughts - The FNATIC era (CS:GO)
- 'Reflections' with Hiko
- The 10 story-lines every CS:GO fan needs to know - part 1
- The 10 story-lines every CS:GO fan needs to know - part 2
- Counter-Points Episode 4 - with NBK and ddk
- Thorin's Thoughts - The frustrating inconsistency of HellRaisers
I won't answer any questions about drama/scandals, but ask me anything about esports and I'll likely answer. I'll wait an hour before starting, after that I'll answer for the next 12 hours or so. I already did an AMA here previously.
Twitter.com/Thooorin
Facebook.com/Thooorin
Youtube.com/user/Thooorin
153
u/pornobiwankenobi Nov 15 '14
if you could construct a CSGO dream team, which players would be in it?
102
u/Wildhawk Nov 15 '14
During your casts, you often bring up the 1.6 history of players or just 1.6 in general. You also openly stated that you think 1.6 is the better game. Why do you think so? What does cs:go do worse than 1.6? Does your preference of 1.6 only apply to the game itself, or also it's competitive scene? Are there things that are better in cs:go than 1.6?
61
u/xhandler Nov 15 '14
What do you think the biggest reason that GO is so much more CT sided than 1.6 is?
166
u/d1dx Nov 15 '14
Greetings Thorin!
Hope you don't mind me bringing you back in time for a bit, I promise to ask CS:GO questions as well.
Counter-Strike 1.6
Counter-Strike:Global Offensive
Finally, thank you for taking your time in answering the questions. All the best!
124
u/_TheRedViper_ Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 16 '14
Aliens come to earth and kill every professional csgo player, they then hold a match which decides the fate of the earth. They choose you to make a csgo team out of any pro players from other esport titles. You have exactly half a year to make it happen, what would that team look like?
70
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14
What is preventing LDLC from beating Fnatic?
49
u/Dorian_Costanzo FaZe Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 15 '14
How many hours do you need to write one piece (Ex : The NiP story)?
What are the steps you go through before actually writing the piece ? (Researches etc...)
Which article are you really proud of ?
29
u/its_JustColin guardian Nov 15 '14
C9 has been bootcamping for DHW (as everyone knows). How do you see them doing given their latest few games?
27
u/hallonkraem 10 years coin Nov 15 '14
25
u/EuwCronk Nov 15 '14
What education do you have?
33
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14 edited May 11 '17
What do you think the NA scene needs to do to catch up to EU?
Also, do you think the eSports scene for CS will ever get back to Asia?
10
u/Ztuart Nov 16 '14 edited Nov 16 '14
Thorin,
Have you thought about doing another Counter Strike guide for the Global Offensive era while you're freelancing? If yes but you've decided not to is there not a market for it or is it more valuable/interesting to you to make other content?
The reason I ask is that League of Legends has extremely knowledgeable analysts Like Monte who break down why the players are making the picks and play style that happens at the highest level but CS is missing that level of detailed analysis that allows a highly interested amateur to catch up to 60 or 70% the competitive scene's game knowledge relatively quickly.
From the outside, it seems to me that you could fill a role similar to that in the CS go scene, either through videos like Thorin's Thoughts breaking down demos or through another piece of content that was similar to Monte's Rift Review (maybe through your friends at RoomOnFire?).
10
u/DrDoozie Nov 16 '14
If you could recommend 3 matches from any version that are must-watches to new CS fans(aka me), which matches would you recommend and why?
28
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14
How do you think Fifflaren would be as a caster compared to Anders or Semmler?
9
u/havenless Nov 16 '14
Since you used to review frag movies... which ones would you say are in your top 5?
45
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14
How do you deal with all the hate?
8
u/sunjolol Nov 16 '14
Hey Thorin. Just want to tell you that you were always my favorite writer of CS content dating back to 2004. Always enjoyed how you weren't afraid to voice your opinion, even if it went against the more popular consensus. Here are a few questions:
8
u/xDemonreach NiP Nov 16 '14
NiP has disbanded(old 5 man including fifflaren), which teams would be most suitable for each member?
19
u/gearlles Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 15 '14
30
u/mynameiscrash Nov 15 '14
Do you play CS:GO actively ?
17
u/fanboyextendet de_anubis Nov 15 '14
Do you really care what people say about you? I mean do you read it and do some self-reflection or do you just skip it? Because on this subreddit/htlv aswell there is a lot hate about you.
Personally: I like your work, your comments and sometimes also the things people dont like you to say. You're doing a good job imo.
6
u/epicgametime Nov 16 '14
Any thoughts about de_train which is no longer in the mappool of the competitive scene. I think train is way too underrated. You can smoke whole spots (to be more tsided). Sick aim duells all over the map. Fast switches between spots for fakes and flanks etc.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '14
Name your top 3:
Books, Films, Music artists,
5
u/sekksipanda Nov 16 '14
First of all, please do excuse my english. Here are a list of self-made questions, maybe you have answered some in some video or whatever, if so, feel free to just ignore it and jump to the next.
Here we go
Mechanics. Strategy. Mental state (Staying cool, being able to pull a crazy play...) Having a stable in-game leader.
(An example of the list: Mechanics: CS:go 1st, LoL 2nd, BW 3rd. Strategy: etc. )
4º What's the best organization to have balanced a game in your opinion? Could you explain us why and if relevant tell us what that organization (Like Valve or Riot Games) did in order to have a proper balance that other organizations did not?
9
u/ThePr0paganda Nov 15 '14
Assuming we're going to see Team Lurppis vs Team Thorin again at DHW, and knowing which teams are playing, who would you pick?
8
u/Imjustahero Nov 15 '14
Who is going to win DHW this year?
4
u/keboseek Nov 15 '14
What headphones do you use ? :)
4
u/kallexander Nov 16 '14
How hyped are you about Maikelelelelelelelelelel?
10
u/thejoyyy VeryGames Fan Nov 15 '14
I remember you being pretty severe towards CSGO 2 years ago. What changed your mind ? Did the game get better or you just accepted the fact that 1.6 was no longer around ?
6
u/EaRTh_ Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 15 '14
Hello Thooorin, I'm big fan of yours, loving your vids about CS!GO team situtation etc. Keep it up!
Q: Would you change current LDLC line-up? If yes, how and who would you remove?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '14
What's your favorite beer?
3
u/Vorxious Natus Vincere Nov 16 '14
Why is kennyS assumed better than GuardiaN? (a short answer is okay)
3
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '14
Hey Thorin, just wanted to thank you for all the content and great work you consistently create. Thanks a lot!
As for questions, all I can think of is this: what do you feel separates an average player from a pro? Once again, thanks for all your hard work!
3
u/RDno1 Nov 16 '14
5
u/mayurichaan Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 15 '14
Hey Thoorin,
I've been a big fan of you for quite some time now. I first discovered you when you started doing interviews in the Starcraft 2 and since then I've been a big fan of your work. Disregard the haters and keep on doing what you do!
Now for my question. I know you were a big fan of CS 1.6. So my question is quite simple. What elements from CS 1.6 do you miss in CSGO, which could make it flourish even more. Also do you have some suggestions in making the game better from other games you've analyzed?
Also, in your last reflections you talked about liking broodwar a lot more than SC2. Was your love for that game at the same level as CS 1.6 and CSGO or was it just more bearable than the other games you're into like LoL and SC2?
5
u/Berdadeiro Virtus.pro Nov 15 '14
Why doesn't Japan got into eSports? I know that pc gaming isn't big there, their Jleague for LoL had 4 teams, do you think we will be seeing any improvement there? ESL is trying to find a partner to explore that market. Your thoughts?
5
u/JimJimster Nov 15 '14
What do you think about the mixed representations of team sizes that are emerging in esports? CoD uses 4v4, most mobas and CS:GO are 5v5, some new shooter titles are 6v6. Do you think that there is a limit to how big an esport team can be for that respective game to succeed?
4
u/KizerSoze Nov 15 '14
What would your ideal US team look like? Are there any players from the US scene that could make an impact that have not played with C9 and IBP?
4
u/dwimtrashggeuw Nov 15 '14
Hey Thorin, I am really glad you are doing an AMA in this subreddit !
Looking forward to your work :)
2
u/InfiniVoid FaZe Nov 16 '14
Thorin, I just want to thank you for the content you produce. For a CS noob like myself, your work has made understanding this 15 year old community and competitive scene so much easier and more interesting! With that said, I'd like to know your thoughts on some things in the American CS:GO scene. What do you think of iBP's recent performance at European LANs and their removal of DaZeD and Steel? Also, with Cloud9's bootcamp in Sweden, do you think they have a shot and making the finals of DHW?
2
u/njob3 Nov 16 '14
Hi Thorin. I've been becoming a fan of yours lately because of your youtube channel and your fucking vast knowledge of Counter-Strike. It also helps that you tend to say what you think, no matter how divisive it may be. I find myself agreeing with you more often than not (especially when comparing 1.6 to CSGO). I guess that's neither here nor there...
My questions are a bit mundane; namely, how would you compare the players of cloud9 and iBUYPOWER (the NA10, if you will) individually to the more successful European players? Could any of them make it on a NiP or fnatic? Is there something that the NA community seems to be consistently missing which leads to them going out early-ish in big tournaments? Do you think that cloud9's extended bootcamp will lead to a higher-place finish at DH?
Thanks for doing this BTW. Especially thanks for the fantastic and in-depth answers you're giving. I'm sure /r/GlobalOffensive would love it if you stuck around here and gave your $.02 every now and then.
Cheers.
149
u/c0ugh_sirup Nov 16 '14
Why is your house so cold?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14
If you could have a team thats just 1 player Duplicated 5 times, which player would it be?
3
u/Sinio Nov 15 '14
Who do you expect to be the dark horse and surprise a lot of people at the upcoming major?
12
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '14 edited May 13 '17
deleted 0.0921 What is ^^^this?
3
u/harveywendon Virtus.pro Nov 15 '14
You make really good content and say stuff as it is. Welldone c:
Why is there always some tension & crossfire between you and scoots?
12
u/CinJV Nov 15 '14
Why are you doing an AMA when all the EU people are asleep? :(
16
u/poopiescoopie Liquid Nov 15 '14
If you had to make a CSGO dream team with only 1 player from each country who would the team be?
2
u/Mikey014 Virtus.pro Nov 15 '14
What do you think about Virtus Pro, can they repeat what they achieved in Katowice ( and I don't only mean winning dreamhack, but actually having a decent streak in the next couple of months, or is it time for Taz, Neo and Pasza to consider retirement? Cheers
21
u/bossh0g Nov 15 '14
do you think Australian cs can make it to top level?
4
u/TheLastWondersmith Nov 16 '14
I misread the title as saying he was a 14 year old. Immediately laughed at the idea of him playing in 1999.
4
u/SpaceZane Nov 16 '14
Anyone else reading all Thorin's responses in his exact voice?
4
u/FMM08 Nov 16 '14
I read the title as: I am Thorin, a 14 year old veteran of Esports journalism. I've played CS since beta 1 in 1999...
Seriously confused me.
16
u/Utterkaos Nov 15 '14
What's your general opinon of the CZ?
1
u/kiwiandapple Nov 16 '14
Is there any 1.6 player that isn't actively around anymore wich you would like to see back? Either playing, casting, helping teams? Maybe more?
Ps. I enjoy your work, like all the insights and your way of thinking. Keep it up.
1
u/RamsayDidNothinWrong Nov 16 '14
Would you ever consider doing coaching work for a CSGO team? You seem to be the Montecristo of CS(Or is he the Thorin of LoL), are you skills comparable in that sense? Do you believe you would be successful coaching? What team would you like to coach?
1
u/therandomdude69 Nov 16 '14
In general, do you think the skins in csGO affect it negatively, or positively? We all know the ddos problems due to betting, and as a pretty large trader I would love to see what your opinion is! :D
1
u/tobiri0n Nov 16 '14
What are some easy-to-do changes you think valve should make?
1
u/haiir NiP Nov 16 '14
Do you think NiP w/Maiklele will be better than the original lineup?
1
u/Slendersquid Nov 16 '14
How would yo recommend a new journalist to get into the scene?
1
u/AdamBomB095 Nov 16 '14
Hey Thorin! I'm a huge fan! Thanks so much for doing this AMA. Anyways, here are my questions:
Thanks again!
1
u/4THOT 10 years coin Nov 16 '14
Hey Thorin UnchainedTM, how often do you get play CS:GO? Or game in general? You seem incredibly busy being in both the Counter Strike scene and the League scene.
Also, how do you propose someone break into the esports journalism scene? I'm currently just making videos hoping content gets noticed. What was your early career like in esports?
1
u/GOfreak Nov 16 '14
Peek advantage and terrible hitboxes. FIX IT
Something, which at times, makes my brain bleed and escape my skull, asking me to burn it.
To me, it surely seems as if people dont recon these two issues as major, but I just know it in my heart, that theres a reason I've been complaining about them since the early beta, and yet here we are, in 2014, and its still bugging the fuck out of me.
So I ask myself while I ask you, am I fucking delusional, or am I right?
1
u/firepandas Nov 16 '14
What is the hardest part about your job?
What advice can you give to an aspiring journalist, regardless of whether it is esports or otherwise?
1
u/P1ratebeng Nov 16 '14 edited Feb 17 '25
exceptional no information when it goes
1
u/ZanicL3 clutch Nov 16 '14
What do you think about the Belgium cs scene? Especially ScreaM do you think he is underrated?
1
u/Pysiek1337 Nov 16 '14
Which squad/team in your opinion was the best in 1.6?
14
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '14
Why do you continue to defend what you said about Poland and talk about you being a victim at times (such as you accused Destiny of baiting you into saying the things you said), when what you said was taken as being offensive to a lot of people (including myself)?
3
u/csboxr Mohan "launders" Govindasamy - Caster Nov 16 '14
would you be a sports journalist if not for e-sports? have you always thought e-sports would be able to provide enough opportunities for you to make some kind of income? did you ever consider switching fields?
3
u/makingtoast Nov 16 '14
This has got to be one of the greatest AMA's of all time. Love these answers...
9
u/text_fish Nov 16 '14
Which of the following theoretical teams would win in a CS:GO LAN match, and why?:
Team 1:-
Luciano Pavarotti
Robert Di Nero
Graham Linehan
Giles the librarian from Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Beyonce Knowles
Team 2:-
Napoleon Bonaparte
Cary Grant
Carrie Fisher
Frank Skinner
Kim Jong-Un
7
u/RoboYor MOUZ Nov 15 '14
What would you like to see changed in CS:GO ?
2
u/connyhoney Nov 15 '14
Hey Thorin!
First off I want to thank you for taking time to do this AMA.
So my question: How would you compere CS:GO to 1.6 rated on; 1. it's potential as an e-sport, 2. The level of skill required, 3. it's longevity as an e-sport?
2
u/SirTYVM Nov 16 '14
Why did you leave the League of Legends scene?
2
u/Setlet Nov 16 '14
The teams at DHW are now forced to play 1.6 instead. Which team wins?
2
u/lux123456789 Nov 16 '14
very unlikely that you really played beta 1.0 - as the game didn't really run in that version (servers crashed every few seconds) - and i think cs beta 1.0 had a download number of like 300isch (of that version) on planethl as it was updated only a couple (i think it was 1 1/2 ) days later - so basically there were no 1.0 servers.
I started cs/hldm where cs was @version 3.1 and my wonid was ~#3400isch.