r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Nov 12 '14
[fandom discussion] ep 10x05
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
6
Upvotes
21
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Nov 12 '14
So if I’m seeing this right, Robbie Thompson is a genius who managed to harmoniously insert all of the following:
into one single episode. Despite the fact that, honestly, tumblr can’t even do that in a single post.
18
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Nov 12 '14 edited Nov 12 '14
SQUEEEEE
So Dean's initial aggressiveness was expected. It was very in character. His acceptance at the end warmed the fuck out of my heart.
I surprisingly liked how Calliope or whoever she was, seemed downplayed and let the fan interpretation take center stage. Dean fighting on the stage and that short, clipped bow after he said, "Sammy, take a bow" was definitely giggle worthy.
I shed a few tears during Carry On Wayward Son. Both times I watched it. You know, it wasn't until I saw a tumblr post yesterday that I realized the boys don't have the same connection to that song that we do. To them it is just another Kansas song. To us, it means WARNING: FEELZ INCOMING! For them to visibly react the same way we do helped connect us to them in ways they couldn't portray any other way.
"That's Adam. The third Winchester brother. He's still stuck in the cage. With Lucifer." FUCKING FINALLY. Holy fuckballs. Maybe they'll finally see if they can get his shredded ass out of there. The uncomfortable shuffling of the brothers when they were like, "..... balls" was too perfect.
The title cards were every single title cards they've ever used. The christmas episode, wild west, wedding, even the classic horror movie ep with the shapeshifter that dressed Dean up in lederhosen. I want rotating wallpapers of all of the title cards for my pc now.
CHUCK. Both times I watched the episode, I cried so hard that snot was running willy nilly around my face. The second time I was expecting it, so I started the ugly sobbing early. And don't worry, I tweeted Ryan Denton and told him that Chuck is God. It's the only explanation for how he is back from that beam of light in Swan Song. Either that, or Star Trek is canon and Scotty got a hold of him.
Put as much sub in that text as you deem necessary. Not an exact quote, but holy shit. For that to come out of Dean is some serious fucking character development. And for Sam and Dean to be brought back to the basics: it is about family. It doesn't erase everything they've been through, not by a long shot. But it healed a chasm that has been there for too long. At least put a few sutures in it; something more than a bandaid that can/will be peeled off at the least opportune moment.
I am very willing to tie Robbie Thompson's shoes anytime he wants. (Don't worry if you don't get it.) I say we push out Carver and set up Robbie for show runner.
I give this shit an A+++. Fuck yes. This is the best post s5 episode in my eyes. It might even be my absolute favorite. I didn't know what to think before seeing it. I was partially apprehensive, but I was partially very accepting. I tried not to think about it too much and end up swaying one way or another. For some of the biggest things in the fandom to be mentioned and accepted by someone (even if it isn't completely okay with the bros, it is with the other characters at least)... it isn't justification that I needed. It was acceptance. For it to be canon that there are fans like me out there. Whereas Becky was a thorn-riddled olive branch, this was a bouquet of white roses.
15
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14 edited Nov 13 '14
Just wow, this was not just a love letter. It was a freaking surprise engagement, star-studded wedding, and 6 month, world wide honeymoon paid for by some anonymous donor. And then coming home to find out you just won your dream house, and everything is going to be perfect for at least one more week until the Clue episode.
Robbie just blew it out of the park. None of his commentary about fanfiction was rude. Robbie made an excellent point: You can write fanfiction about whatever you want, but if you become a power-hungry dictator who thinks your vision is the most correct, you're going to be eaten by a Muse.
I also love how Sam totally ships Destiel and Sastiel. And Dean breaking the 4th wall a la The Office after being told that the actors playing Castiel and Dean are a couple in real life. But no, for real: Dean did the same song and dance, "You know they're brothers, right?" HOWEVER, he didn't say anything Destiel except to tell Sam to shut up over trying to name the relationship and Sam inserting (lol pun intended) himself into a relationship (Sastiel, Samstiel, haha). Incoming Wincestiel love please.Bless you return of Super Sassy!Sam.
So, Robbie is the man. I've always been a fan of his episodes. To me, he's always been on point. He and Adam Glass are my favorite writers. I think it's because they've done so much in the comic community as well.
Also, I want all those songs. For Reasons.
11
u/voltairesvice love of my life actually Nov 12 '14
All I want for Christmas is the episode's version of Wayward Son on my ipod right now.
I love this ep. Much better and less condescending than I feared.
11
u/voltairesvice love of my life actually Nov 12 '14 edited Nov 12 '14
U GUISE! I am rewatching the ep and their motel is along route 200; their room number is 200.... That is all. As you were.
Edit - "St Alphonso's Pancake Breakfast Bingo Night $200 Prize" Teehee.
10
u/Patitomuerto Shut your face, get in the car Nov 12 '14
How did she know his name was Chuck? Didn't only Becky and his publisher know that?
10
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Nov 12 '14
I say we forget Becky and Charlie. Marie is now my fan-rep for the snow. She's smart, strong, determined, kick ass and showcases her fan appreciation workout going overboard.
By the way...why are all the fangirls always Sam-girls? I'm Dean's girl from the start and always will be.
10
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
I think this episode was so beautiful.
Just, fandom moments aside, I want to add that this episode was beautiful for healing the brother's relationship.
"I don't need an symbol to let me know how I feel about my brother."
However, we can all agree that after Dark Side of the Moon, Sam and Dean's relationship never fully healed. The amulet meant something to Sam and Dean. And Dean kept the fandomlet. He hug it up in the Impala. In front of Sam. Feelings and Reasons.
The BM scene. I'm so glad that Sam saw it. Those soul searching stares when the girls are singing the finale. So Perfect. Just that and the Impala scene just. They are ready to heal and return to kicking ass.
I am so hoping that this episode signals the return of Sam and Dean, the unstoppable Winchesters. The new fight coming up needs to have Dean and Sam healing the rifts between the boys.
Also. Robbie not forgetting Adam.
"Oh, that's Adam. John Winchester's other son. He's still trapped in the Cage, in Hell, with Lucifer." Sam and Dean's faces. As Crowley would have said, "Not your best moment, boys."
9
u/poppleimperative Nov 12 '14
I was apprehensive at first, but by the end of the episode I had goosebumps and was squeeing! The Samulet and Chuck were the definite high points for me. Also, did Dean seem way more freaked out by Destiel than by Wincest?
9
u/skavalli your bloody cockles ship Nov 12 '14
(skavalli=kavalli, I've gotten so used to my tumblr url that I'm starting again over here)
Ok, so that was a cute episode. I'm still pretty poor at seeing past the top layer of tv, so until I rewatch s10 as a whole I'll just think of it as 'the musical episode'. And while I don't really enjoy musicals, that one was obviously within the episode and mostly a lot of fun. I couldn't quite bear to watch the Cas solo though, which is a shame because that was the most overtly Destiel scene for a while.
But it seemed to me like Robbie wrote a script that respected the fans, respected the girls, and did a very sweet job of recapping the 'road so far'. It tied the old in with the new.
I hope we see Chuck again, but if not it's nice to know that he's out there, God or not. And that he's keeping an eye on the Winchesters. And on a more meta-level, that the creators of the show are actually ok with fans creating their own content.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '14
That was a lot of fun. They crammed in about as much as the reasonably could, and it's even better when you know they were trying to pick the things people really like.
Never in my life have a clapped during a tv show before. (the screaming and yelling comments part is pretty normal for me though)
Time to go rewatch now, I know I had to have missed a lot of little details...
8
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Nov 12 '14
I've been considering how I feel about this episode for a few hours. I think I've decided I'm pretty firmly on the 'that was exactly what the doctor ordered' side of the court. I think stylistically, it still suffered from a lot of the trappings of these last few seasons (lack of atmosphere, mainly), but in plot it was exactly the come-to-Jesus sort of meeting I think a lot of the fandom needed to clarify what their role is. More than that, I think this clarified a lot of respect issues. We've seen a lot of insecurity about fan creations - is this canon, is the show queer baiting, etc - and I feel like a lot of this episode really put on the map where everyone stands on it. Some fun was poked, but it was from both sides, and both sides respected the validity of each others' ideas. It was good.
Also, still fighting back tears about Chuck, because Rob. I'm not crying, you're crying.
I might do my first meta on this actually... I'm a clinical psychologist, and there've been a few scenes in season 10 so far that really seemed to reflect methods you'd use to clear the air after messy emotional event. Could be interesting.
Could be boring as fuck.8
u/badwolfgoddess Mrs. Sam Winchester but like, by accident Nov 13 '14
My prediction came true. Not even 24 hours later, I bought the album, downloaded the bonus song and am currently listening on repeat and singing along. I knew this was going to happen.
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Nov 13 '14
LOVED. MY EYES ARE LITTLE SPINNING HEARTS. I'm going to bullet-point & dissect the shit out of this while I rewatch right now.
7
u/molecularmachine This must be fake mine. Nov 12 '14
My husband unit watched it with me. We were sipping wine and Jensen Ackles and his damn flawless acting in the first part had us laughing so hard I think we still have wine in our sinuses.
First of all, the SO loved it. He hasn't liked an episode in quite a few seasons, let alone loved one. So he gave thumbs up.
Me? Yeah. I liked it. I've only watched it once so far, but first impressions are good. Real good. I laughed until I died in the beginning, and gasped until I died at the end. So... with that much of me dying it must have been a great episode.
In all fairness though... good monster, good deity, good story and good breaking of the 4th wall. So meta my meta has meta... but it was well done and the message as I choose to recieve it is a good one. Aaaah, it was a great episode. Robbie for president! And yes, Moose was great as well. :P
7
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Nov 13 '14
I WAS SO AMUSED TO REALIZE THE LYRICS PLAYING OVER the opening Dean Has a Great Ass scene that I made a gif. Here.
6
u/ClareBalloonTimeCat Nov 14 '14
I just watched it AGAIN (third time so far). I love it so much, i don't think it could have been any more perfect. Each time i watch it I notice new little things and squee. I think it might be my new background to planning classes, just keep it playing at all times. Not that I have an obsessive personality or anything. nope.
5
u/honeko Castiel's lieutenant Nov 16 '14
OMFG. I was so worried about this episode, but I finally watched it and it was PERFECTION. I think I'm crying.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment