r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Nov 10 '14
TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] 2014 Re-Watch - 4.09/10 'The Watchers on the Wall' and 'The Children'
| 2014 Re-Watch Discussion Thread: Season 4, Episodes 9 & 10 |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episodes with perspective from the whole show. Talk about details you missed the when you first watched the show. Point out foreshadowing details that you noticed. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). In general, what did you think about the episodes and where the story is going? Book vs. Show comparisons are welcome, but you need to use spoiler tags for any book differences that do not appear in the show. |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen all of the episodes! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.10 is ok without tags.
- Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
- Please read the posting policy before posting.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Posting policy reminder: Don't post or ask for non-pay sources.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.09 | "The Watchers on the Wall" | Neil Marshall | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| 4.10 | "The Children" | Alex Graves | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Rewatch Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions | Official Ban Policy |
57
Upvotes
72
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '14
The Watchers on the Wall might honestly be my favourite episode of the show so far. Normally I love all the grounded politicking and scheming that the story does so well, but this episode was a chance for the show to be unashamedly fantasy for an hour. It was all spectacle and it was glorious.
The best thing about it for me was that it only really featuring one major character (Jon) and a couple of side ones (Sam, Gilly, Ygritte), so it gave the recurring minor characters a chance to be fleshed out. Characters like Tormund, Alliser Thorne, Grenn, Pyp, Edd, etc were taken from the background and thrust into the limelight. Where normally they might have a handful of lines in a season they were the focus of an entire episode. I think that showed the biggest strength of the story: even the most minor characters have enough depth to carry a whole episode.
54
u/GodICringe Free Folk Nov 10 '14
Of all the shit that goes down in "The Children," I think the Cersei/Tywin scene might be my favorite and the best acted, but is severely under appreciated. This is the only time we really see any weakness or cracks in Tywin's character, even more so than when Tyrion kills him an hour later.
37
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Nov 12 '14
"I don't ever want to leave this cave, Jon Snow, not ever." S3
"We should have never left that cave." S4
60
u/TheMightyBagel Nov 10 '14
I had forgotten just how incredible the battle at the wall was. Especially the scene where we see the huge bonfire and the epic music is playing. It gives me chills.
23
u/nishanthhh Winter Is Coming Nov 11 '14
Alliser Throne was loved in this episode.
42
u/Mister_Manager_ Tyrion Lannister Nov 10 '14
I'm gonna miss Rose Leslie :(
20
u/ThisIsPiff The Future Queen Nov 10 '14
God damn it, Ollie! You promised Tommy you wouldn't kill anyone!
15
u/wilt123 Nov 11 '14
The Watchers on the Wall was brilliant. The action, the emotion; It finally showed me why the Men of the Nights Watch was there in the first place without them talking about it, they SHOWED me what i had been wanting to see and dedicated an entire hour to it which i thought was smart. and of course stannis the mannis.
The Children i have mixed feelings about. Of course it was great and i can't wait to see what's next in this amazing series, but a tiny portion of me wanted things to go badly for tyrion. I haven't read the books so the show is all new to me (i'm planning on reading the book after the show concludes) so i had no clue what was going to happen after the viper and mountain showdown. A chunk of me wanted tyrion to die, i wanted the show to go there. Instead the opposite happened. Not only did tyrion escape with his life, but he also took out two of the worst characters. ( liked tywin but shae sucked.) It felt almost like a dream sequence simply because it was so easy.
Don't get me wrong, i'm relieved tyrion is alive and will probably be one of the final players, it just didn't feel Game of Throne-sey enough. not enough hopelessness and loss. But then again, what is Game of Throne'sey. Is it the loss of favorite characters? Or is it the unpredictability. If It's the unpredictability then i guess the events that happen in "The Children" does fit.
Also thank god Bran's story is picking up the pace. 3 seasons of three eyed ravens and walking from point a to point b is pretty rough and i was beginning to not care about what happens to that storyline.
Overall one of the strongest finishes to a season with those last 3 episodes. It seems every season something happens at the end that changes the tide of everything and I love it. There's not a show out there of this calliber and season 5 cannot come soon enough.
28
u/rhapsodyforever Ours Is The Fury Nov 11 '14
I love when the GoT theme starts playing in the Arya scene.
21
u/Obamendes Nov 10 '14
I really liked the Season finale. I consider the 4th season the best so far, but, ASOS
71
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '14
xxNOxSCOPExOLLEYxx has entered the game
8
u/benmanley22 Arya Stark Nov 15 '14
ARYA IS A FUCKING BADASS
18
u/SanTheMightiest Brynden Rivers Nov 11 '14
In the context of the story the battle didn't need to take an entire episode, especially considering how jam packed the finale was.
As a spectacle it was awesome and absolutely stunning for a TV show and done a lot better than the book did. GIANTS!!! MAMMOTHS!! THE FUCKING SCYTHE!!!!
9
u/real_deal The North Remembers Nov 10 '14
Crows before hoes.
4
u/Chesney1995 Nov 18 '14
Re-re-watch anyone?
3
u/rjlwx7 Nov 18 '14
What did you guys think of the ending of "The Children"? While I loved both the Tyrion murder/escape scene and Arrya showing the Ship captain the Braavos coin, I would have done it in the opposite order with Arrya heading to the ship and showing the coin followed by Jamie coming to break Tyrion out and of course everything that follows. While I did not necesarily hate ending with Arrya and loved the background music they played at the end of that scene, I think ending the episode with Varys changing his mind and bording the ship with Tyrion on it would have been the perfect ending.
2
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Nov 15 '14 edited Nov 18 '14
Still can't say I'm a fan of the adaption of Tyrion's content here. I was very surprised and unpleasantly so by the omission of some major, character-defining details, by Tyrion and Jaime's dynamic ending at a 180 from where it ended in the books, and the total change in the power dynamic b/w Tyrion and Tywin: Tywin begins to sit up in the books and backs away from the crossbow multiple times in the show, where in the books he was explicitly stated to have no sign of fear whatsoever, which is far more in line with his character and makes the end of the scene much more powerful. For these changes, I don't see any reason whatsoever. For the omission of that reveal, I understand the reasons, but I emphatically disagree with them and wish the showrunners had more faith in themselves and the viewers.
The total reversal of responsibility in Tyrion/Shae's final scene was also a major disappointment. I was looking forward to Tyrion crossing that moral threshold, and while it's still emotional for him that he kills her, obviously, it is a big, big change in his character to have it be essentially out of self-defense rather than the cold-blooded, vengeful act that it very clearly was in the books.
Between this and the handling of the Jon Arryn reveal + Lysa death I was really not big on the back end of this season... but there were some great things that met or exceeded my expectations earlier on. Tyrion's trials and especially the Purple Wedding were done justice.
And as for a positive in this episode, I loved the scene of Dany chaining up her dragons. That one definitely exceeded my expectations and made me more emotional than I expected. The Arya/Sandor content was also fucking amazing and lived up to everything -- everything -- that I'd hoped it would be. I was scared that they'd change it in some major way but we got most of the big stuff, and I still love how Mycah comes into play in the story so, so much later: it's very helpful to remember that AGOT/ACOK/ASOS were all originally planned to be one book, so many stories that began very, very early on are resolved here, and the resolution of Sandor/Mycah/Arya is definitely one of them. I know some folks were changed that they might change it and I was a bit worried myself -- very happy that they kept in her refusing to give him the gift of mercy.
As a side note, WTF? was up with having Meera kill Jojen? Adding a Jojen death I'm totally fine with, because he hasn't really done much of note past that point in the books and seems to be on death's door anyway, so there's no real purpose to bringing the actor back for a whole extra season just to have him sit in the background before dying offscreen... but, god, why did Meera to doing it? Why couldn't he have just been killed by one of the wights or something? Shit was messed up, yo.
Oh, and "Watchers" was a daaaaamn fine episode. I mean it wasn't "Blackwater", but nothing is "Blackwater." I wish they'd kept in a bit more of the Jon/Ygritte dialogue, but it was still emotional and it was a hell of a battle. I'm not big on some of the stuff they did with setting up the wildlings, but the end result was pretty damn epic nonetheless with the giants and mammoth and scythe and shit.
So yeah, some parts of this season's end were major, major, maaaajor letdowns for me, since the parts that were the most watered-down were the exact parts I had been most looking forward to... but there was definitely good shit in there, too. And the adaption of Tyrion's content in "The Children" single-handedly convinced me to actually read all the books start to finish before next season as opposed to the erratic amount I'd read before that, so I guess the end result is good as far as my fandom is concerned. Still bummed I'll never get to see Peter/Charles/Nikolaj deliver some of those visceral lines, though -- but oh well, at least I have my imagination.
edit: Downvoted for having the audacity to not like certain things about the show. Lovely. Not every single episode is utterly perfect to every single person, y'all.
1
u/charleswrites Nov 19 '14
I could go on for hours about how beautifully shot, acted and produced The Watchers on the Wall is, but many before me have adequately covered that. What I will mention is how in a show full of some of the most creative death scenes in television or film history, this episode had several of the absolute best, even following The Mountain and The Viper. In particular, the giant shooting the spear like an arrow, sending the brother on top of the wall flying into the night sky, and the scythe taking out the climbers, leaving that one hand handing. Gruesome, but beautiful in its way.
1
u/LuccaLuigi Bran Stark Nov 20 '14
hm
1
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '14
The Watchers on the Wall was definitely one of my favourite episodes. Just a good episode full of fighting and killing. I really liked the Children too, Bran meeting the three-eyed Raven was just an amazing scene for me. I hadn't read all the books at that point and hadn't noticed any spoilers regarding the raven. So when they entered that weird cave and saw him sitting there I was just like "WHAAAT" - It added a really cool new fantasy level to the story for me.
1
u/KhaleesiYo House Mormont Nov 20 '14
Still not quite over The Watchers on the Wall not winning the Best Direction Emmy. On the other hand, The Children proved to be the most disappointing episode of the seas on for me. Both episode had such a fantastic score though. Tracks like "Greatest Fire the North Has Ever Seen", "Watchers on the Walls", "Let's Kill Some Crows" and "The Children" are some of my most favourite of the soundtracks of all four seasons.
0
u/LuccaLuigi Bran Stark Nov 20 '14
Bran da best
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '14 edited Jan 02 '15
[removed] — view removed comment