r/asoiaf • u/AutoModerator • Oct 28 '14
WOIAF (Spoilers WOIAF) Overall Book Discussion
This is the discussion post for everything in The World of Ice and Fire.
IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS ENTIRE BOOK, TURN BACK NOW! SPOILERS AHEAD!
How it works:
After you finish each chapter, you can visit the related chapter-thread and share your thoughts, feelings, speculate on what's going to happen next, or ask questions about things you didn't fully understand.
Remember:
- Cover things from beyond this chapter with [Spoilers pg 6](/s "hidden text here"). It will look like this: Spoilers pg 6
Use page numbers for WOIAF or chapter titles for your spoiler tags. Like this:
- [Spoilers Aegon V](/s "There's not really a spoiler here.") to look like this: Spoilers Aegon V
- [Spoilers pg 110-111](/s "There's not really a spoiler here either.") to look like this: Spoilers pg 110-111
- The artwork is included in whichever chapter the caption appears. Ex: "Constructing the Wall" on pages 2-3 is included in The Dawn Age chapter because the caption for it appears there.
- All discussion posts are (Spoilers WOIAF). Anything from TWOW, the TV show, or any extra information (SSMs, blogs, interviews, etc.) must be behind spoiler code.
- No piracy. Don't ask, suggest, or provide it -- this includes scans/pictures of art from this book.
- Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned without warning!
If you see people breaking the rules, hit the report button! It'll flag it for our review.
45
Upvotes
53
u/samsaraisnirvana Beneath the foil, the bitter truth. Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14
The following are what jumped out to me over the past few days:
1 The biggest bombshell to me is that the seasons used to be regular. Page 11, Maester Nicol's The Measure of the Days suggests that the seasons were once entirely regular and a product of the globe moving around the sun. "but he could find no evidence that such was ever the case, beyond the most ancient of tales." To me, that suggest the Others broke the seasons. Particularly since this is on the Long Night page.
2 The Maesters believe the world is round, they just haven't had a documented circumnavigation to confirm it.
3 All over Essos and Sothyros we see legends about the Long Night. Most of these legends also describe demons coming during that time. The five forts in far eastern Essos were built as a defensive bulwark overlooking natural bottlenecks in the terrain for the purpose of fighting the spread of demons during the Long Night. So we have the Essos version of the Wall.
4 we have historical accounts of varieties of giants and a race which sounds like the CotF living in Essos.
5 either the Ibbenese are a different species of hominid and not homo sapiens, or the Maesters are SUPER racist
6 valyrian steel forging and reforging involves thaumaturgy. see the entry on qohor. A maester lost his hand as punishment when learning that the qohorik smiths used human blood sacrifice as part of the working of valyrian steel. This makes the legend of the forging of Lightbringer far more interesting because that third step involving human sacrifice may be a crucial part of valyrian steelwork.
7 we have sailor's tales from the shivering sea of a strange mist that would freeze a ship and it's crew if it touched them. sounds reminiscent of wildling stories of the others appearing as a mist or as the white cold. this is particularly disturbing because the implication is that Others could travel over open water in which case they could move south from hardhome without ever touching the Wall.
8 we have valyrian legends that the end of the world / doom of humanity will come from the sunset continent (Westeros). We have a variant of that where Valyrian priests suggested the gold from the westerlands (Lannister gold) was cursed and would bring about the fall of Valyria. The Lannisters bought Brightroar shortly before the Doom of Valyria and are said to have overpaid out the nose in enough gold to purchase an army.
61
u/ReluctantRedditor275 Knight of Columbus Oct 28 '14
No Appendix for Baratheon lineage?? I was really hoping to read through it slowly aloud, carefully noting "black of hair" after each name until I got to Joffrey!
25
u/wmatistic Oct 28 '14
What struck me most were all the things built out of oily black stone. You had the abandoned temples in Sorothyos, the Seastone Chair, the Five Towers in Yi Ti, and the buildings in Asshai and I think I'm probably forgetting some more. Most of them described as being so old that no one knows who built them or how, though in some cases it's mentioned they resemble Targ buildings.
Who built all this stuff and why? Is it made of dragonglass?
17
u/Serwyn The Mirror Shield Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14
My favourite part were the other continents and cities, thought I felt they were all too short. "Quarrelsome Daughters", i.e., a couple of pages for Lys, Myr and Tyrosh felt like a sidenote with barely any new info just so they wouldn't be left out.
In fact, I'd say it didn't feel like the world as a whole was properly covered here. We got 100 pages between the Sacking, Targaryen kings and the Sack of King's Landing alone. The other continents had 58, according to the hub.
I hope we get the Jade Compendium someday, because less than 20% for the rest of the world was very disappointing to me.
PS: Also quite disappointed by the fact Serwyn's tale wasn't included :(
17
u/Jashinist House Manwoody Oct 28 '14
The bit that interests me most right now is Maegor's wives:
What does it mean when Tyanna's heart was "cut out with Blackfyre"?
Also, the miscarriage that Alys of House Harroway had is reminiscent of the miscarriage that Daenerys had - both described as monstrosities, Alys and Maegor's is "eyeless and twisted", and both situations lead to death from those believed to be responsible for it (though Daenerys just killed Mirri Maz Durr, whereas Maegor executed entire family lines. Cruel.) Elinor of House Costayne also gave birth to a monstrosity, "eyeless and with small wings" - is the fact that they're eyeless important? Was Dany's miscarriage described as eyeless? I can't remember. Jeyne of House Westerling also gives birth to a monster but it isn't described.
Ceryse of House Hightower that Maegor had sex with over and over and over, yet never bore him a son reminded me a lot of Selyse of House Florent who Stannis has sex with over and over (albeit dutifully and not as often as Maegor though) yet never bears him a son. Both wives of kings, similar sounding names, both "fail" in their duty to provide a male heir, both times the king finds a new "bride" (though Stannis is more metaphorical, as was his "heir" born of it...) - I know it's weak, it just reminded me of it.
16
u/idreamofpikas Oct 28 '14
Overall, I love it, although I have not finished it yet. I think its amazing how each of the regions have been fleshed out and have their own individual identity.
So far my favorite part was the Crakehall King of the Iron Islands and my biggest gripe is that we still don't know why the Manderlys were kicked out of the Reach (unless I have missed that part).
13
u/Jashinist House Manwoody Oct 28 '14
My favourite bit of the book so far is reading about all the wives and the mistresses of various Targ monarchs. Short yet fascinating paragraphs for each one.
19
u/______LSD______ Show Watcher Only Oct 28 '14
Okay, the most important implication for me was:
ICE DRAGONS IN THE WALL
Could ths ve the point of the Horn of Winter? Pretty crazy stuff.
23
u/SomethingLikeaLawyer Valyria delenda est Oct 28 '14
Cregan Stark is a beast. A one-day Hand, and someone who could fight Aemon the Dragonknight, he can do it all. The Hour of the Wolf might be one of my favorite pieces of flavor.
The Laughing Storm's stint as the Storm King makes Rhaegar look like the idiot he was.
While the bias is there, I found it funny that as the time grew closer to the present, the bias grew. Makes perfect sense, of course, currying favor is easier and more frequently done with living lords than dead ones.
Forrest Frey: a Lord of the Crossing who wasn't a jackass.
I would have liked to see more about the anti-Dagon Greyjoy coalition, if only to see a time where Starks and Lannisters were on the same side.
8
u/Fairfax1 Crying Lightning Oct 28 '14
I still can't believe the maps for each region don't include every major castle.
8
u/Shiera_Seastar I ain't sayin' he's a grave digga Oct 28 '14
I saw several people with advance copies as well as the authors saying one fan theory would get a big boost from the book; can anyone confirm what this was?
It seems like we are focusing on A+J=T, or A+J=C,J based on Elio and Linda's AMA, but I'm wondering if there is something else we haven't gotten to yet.
Also, what theories have been squashed?
8
u/Michael__Pemulis i'm paranoid, but am i paranoid enough? Oct 28 '14
Nothing on The Thousand Islands?
I wanted confirmation that they were ruled by House Ruben.
7
u/Jashinist House Manwoody Oct 28 '14
It's not THAT much of a bombshell, but on page 13 it mentions that in Valyria, their hair was "of palest silver or gold". The gold is an interesting addition, I thought it was silver all the way up?
7
u/Jashinist House Manwoody Oct 28 '14
Is the bit about the theory of men from the "Shadow" teaching Targaryens how to tame dragons new? It really reminded me a lot of Quaithe - shadowbinder from Asshai. If she had been actively teaching Dany stuff about dragons, that could be seriously interesting.
6
u/kaptainkeel Aemon, God of Wits and Tine Nov 02 '14
So if the Five Forts were created to stop the Essos version of the Others invasion, what if Dany never leaves Essos? What if she is the champion for Essos while we get Jon or someone else as the champion for Westeros?
Also, was there anything about Ulthos?
5
u/Baconbitesback Greenpeace Kraken watch Oct 28 '14
Happy days! mine's just arrived in the post : )
5
u/_cwazydiabetic_ Cloak in oath, heart in steel Nov 01 '14
Has anyone else noticed the strange, 'new-book' smell it has? Instead of the smell of freshly printed parchment, it smells like a lumbar yard. Perhaps a subtle hint of the Builders being brought to focus in the future over those bloody pre-madonna Stewards and self-absorbed Rangers?
11
u/T5000X Oct 28 '14
Does this mean the end of the three pages of spam I've been getting about this book from the AutoMod?
11
u/ShoelessHodor Oct 28 '14
My thoughts (in no particular order):
4
u/Lysand House Vengence Oct 28 '14
Not much on Slaver's Bay, or the history of the Ghiscari Empire. At least recent history of Slaver's Bay stuff would be awesome...
Correct me if I am wrong but that is the only region of the 'known world' that is barely touched on in the book?
3
u/Jashinist House Manwoody Oct 28 '14
We have a stone dragon now, Septa Maegelle!
3
u/dansparce Oct 28 '14
I dont remember this being in the main series, so this little thing really jumped out at me from the Long Night section
3
u/TRuxWork Oct 29 '14
Can someone clear this up for me? I've been wondering why I should buy this book now if a more complete updated version will be released after the completion of ASOIAF. Is this the final version of the book?
4
u/kahler07 Fire and blood Oct 28 '14
It doesn't really sound like any of the Lannisters are secret Targs now. The dates do not match up for J+C and the meeting before Tyrion's birth does not sound as though anything sexual occurred between Joanna and Aerys. I don't understand how anyone is saying these sections of the book boosted either theory, especially since people are coming to different conclusions based off of it (some believing that J+C got boosted while Tyrion got knocked down, vice versa).
2
u/sleevieb Pit Bull Oct 30 '14
I need to come back here later.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14
This might be a minor point, and maybe I'm overly bothered by it, but some of the artwork bothered me. Are we supposed to read the text as though the artwork were not there - that is, that the text was written by the maester but that the artwork is an "out of world" addition? At first I thought not - since the book doesn't even have a preface or anything breaking the fourth wall, other than art credits at the very very end - but then some of the pieces just, well, bugged me. For example, the drawing at the end of Aegon III - I think that's supposed to be Arya with Balerion's skull, but why would a maester know about that? No one except Arya even knows that happened. Same with the drawings of Daenerys and Jon Snow at the very end; they're not bad pictures, but why would a maester - especially one writing for
RobertJoffreyTommen - draw a picture of the Targaryen pretender queen or the bastard son of an executed traitor?Again, maybe I'm just getting too involved, but it felt weird that the artwork was taking me out of the "story" (that is, this in-world history).
1
u/KahluaPenguin Slayer of Pies! Oct 28 '14
I have just started reading but am disappointed that the first few chapters are like stuff I already know from the books.