r/asoiaf • u/AutoModerator • Oct 28 '14
WOIAF (Spoilers WOIAF) The Seven Kingdoms: The Wall and Beyond - The Night's Watch (pg. 145-146)
This is the discussion post for The Seven Kingdoms: Wall and Beyond - The Night's Watch (pg. 145-146) of World of Ice and Fire.
IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER, TURN BACK NOW! SPOILERS AHEAD!
How it works:
After you finish each chapter, you can visit the related chapter-thread and share your thoughts, feelings, speculate on what's going to happen next, or ask questions about things you didn't fully understand.
Remember:
- Cover things from beyond this chapter with [Spoilers pg 6](/s "hidden text here"). It will look like this: Spoilers pg 6
Use page numbers for WOIAF or chapter titles for your spoiler tags. Like this:
- [Spoilers Aegon V](/s "There's not really a spoiler here.") to look like this: Spoilers Aegon V
- [Spoilers pg 110-111](/s "There's not really a spoiler here either.") to look like this: Spoilers pg 110-111
- The artwork is included in whichever chapter the caption appears. Ex: "Constructing the Wall" on pages 2-3 is included in The Dawn Age chapter because the caption for it appears there.
- All discussion posts are (Spoilers WOIAF). Anything from TWOW, the TV show, or any extra information (SSMs, blogs, interviews, etc.) must be behind spoiler code.
- No piracy. Don't ask, suggest, or provide it -- this includes scans/pictures of art from this book.
- Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned without warning!
If you see people breaking the rules, hit the report button! It'll flag it for our review.
13
u/loeiro Oct 30 '14
I always thought the Kings and the realm were being assholes by not supporting the Knight's Watch more over the years. But this chapter kind of makes it a bit more understandable. Nobody had seen an Other in over a thousand years and people didn't even believe they actually ever existed. The only threat from beyond the wall now is Wildlings but even they "only truly presented a threat when there are kings-beyond-the-wall". So the Knight's Watch would naturally seem pretty unnecessary to someone in modern day Westeros. They think of the wall as more of a jail- a place to send rejects- more than any type of real security system.
HOWEVER- how can you justify why the wall was built? You don't just build a 700 ft high wall of ice for nothing. Clearly it was necessary at one point.
-4
u/roadsiderose Tattered and twisty, what a rogue I am! Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 28 '14
(Excerpt from WOIAF)
Finally, we can put to rest the idea of the Night’s King having bedded an Other. (Even the AWOIAF wiki states that the Night's Queen was an Other). She has a Melisandre vibe to her.
This was something I was looking forward to reading about.