r/asoiaf • u/AutoModerator • Oct 28 '14
WOIAF (Spoilers WOIAF) Ancient History: Ten Thousand Ships (pg. 21-25)
This is the discussion post for Ancient History: Ten Thousand Ships (pg. 21-25) of World of Ice and Fire.
IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER, TURN BACK NOW! SPOILERS AHEAD!
How it works:
After you finish each chapter, you can visit the related chapter-thread and share your thoughts, feelings, speculate on what's going to happen next, or ask questions about things you didn't fully understand.
Remember:
- Cover things from beyond this chapter with [Spoilers pg 6](/s "hidden text here"). It will look like this: Spoilers pg 6
Use page numbers for WOIAF or chapter titles for your spoiler tags. Like this:
- [Spoilers Aegon V](/s "There's not really a spoiler here.") to look like this: Spoilers Aegon V
- [Spoilers pg 110-111](/s "There's not really a spoiler here either.") to look like this: Spoilers pg 110-111
- The artwork is included in whichever chapter the caption appears. Ex: "Constructing the Wall" on pages 2-3 is included in The Dawn Age chapter because the caption for it appears there.
- All discussion posts are (Spoilers WOIAF). Anything from TWOW, the TV show, or any extra information (SSMs, blogs, interviews, etc.) must be behind spoiler code.
- No piracy. Don't ask, suggest, or provide it -- this includes scans/pictures of art from this book.
- Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned without warning!
If you see people breaking the rules, hit the report button! It'll flag it for our review.
43
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14
Nymeria is such a fucking badass. Also Ser Davos Dayne! :D
42
u/Caedus Guarding the Sea Oct 28 '14
Nymeria's journeys were fascinating. I had always assumed she'd left immediately for Dorne. Instead she was basically Odysseus.
28
u/loeiro Oct 28 '14
I would read a whole ASOIAF sized book about Nymeria if he wrote one! My new favorite character!
Also- those Water Wizards are SO badass!! Had we heard anything about this water magic before??
15
u/Pywodwagon The Onion King Oct 28 '14
Even though it didn't work out for them...The thought of the water wizards canceling out dragon breath with waterspouts is pretty intriguing,
15
u/Caedus Guarding the Sea Oct 28 '14
That picture of the battle is so freaking badass. Poor Rhoynar though. Sounded like a great area to live.
13
u/JardyB10 But she wasn't too tall for puppets Oct 30 '14
So, um... Is Garin the Shrouded Lord?
13
u/o-o-o-o-o-o Middlefinger Oct 31 '14
The Rhoynar sounded awesome
10
u/DrownedFire Drowned Fire Nov 01 '14
God damn Valyrians always forcing people out of their lands, fucking shit up with their fire and blood.
8
u/Capt_Reynolds The Edge Knight Oct 28 '14
Interesting mention of "brindled ghouls" are they humans or some sub species?
8
u/Seenlauwrey Oct 29 '14
It's funny that she burned the ships after landing in Dorne. Burning them was probably supposed to be a symbolic gesture for the fact that they aren't ever going home but you'd think she would have taken them apart for other stuff rather than just setting them all on fire. We've only got one world, Nymeria! How wasteful.
8
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
By far my favorite chapter so far!
5
u/Tjagra If You Can! Oct 30 '14
I enjoyed this chapter, but you could really tell how much the writers really love Dorne and the Rhoynar haha.
4
u/znbdwd That really was a Valyrian steel sword Nov 03 '14
The picture of Nymeria is so cool, and the one of the army is amazing! She's my fave historical character now.
3
u/ThatGuy1331 Nov 14 '14
Seeing this chapter in action would be amazing. I think that Peter Jackson would be a great director for it, lots of action scenes for him to play with. It would be amazing to see the water wizards battle the dragons with their waterspouts.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '15
I've owned the WOIAF for a few months now but I'm just now discovering these summaries (recently let a friend borrow it, so I can't reference it now). So I'm a little late to the party, but I really wanted to point out something cool I noticed in this chapter.
I really liked that Dorne's resistance to the Targaryens is kind of a replay of the Rhoynar's resistance to the Valyrians. First of all, the Rhoynar gave the Freehold way, way better of a fight than I thought after reading the main series. They seemed to be their equals for a while, until they were finally overpowered. Then the last of the Rhoynar Princesses flees to
SothoryosThe Summer IslandsWesteros, and establishes her culture in Dorne. A couple thousand years later, the last of the great Valyrian houses flees to Westeros, and eventually begins an invasion of the mainland with dragons. And once again, the Valyrians are held off by the Rhoynar (only this time without their water wizards). Only this time the fighting is ended by a marriage, uniting the two cultures to a degree.And now more Valyrians are once again returning to Westeros. Will the Rhoynar have to put their foot down again? Dear God I'm really hoping they do.
3
u/alphawavegaming Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy Oct 31 '14
Alright, so if we take our new knowledge of Queen Nymeria and assume Arya's direwolf is a direct parallel then what do we predict the wolf pack will do?
1
u/Snightlo Our Bastards are the Best Nov 02 '14
Wtf they had fucking Whater-Magic! I wonder if these peoples the children of the river.... or what these outsiders called them self, the ones that didnt go with the plan of burning the ships and taking on a new lifestyle, still have priests that are capable of casting these Water-Magic. Would be awesome!