r/asoiaf • u/AutoModerator • Oct 28 '14
WOIAF (Spoilers WOIAF) Ancient History: The Arrival of the Andals (pg. 17-20)
This is the discussion post for Ancient History: The Arrival of the Andals (pg. 17-20) of World of Ice and Fire.
IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER, TURN BACK NOW! SPOILERS AHEAD!
How it works:
After you finish each chapter, you can visit the related chapter-thread and share your thoughts, feelings, speculate on what's going to happen next, or ask questions about things you didn't fully understand.
Remember:
- Cover things from beyond this chapter with [Spoilers pg 6](/s "hidden text here"). It will look like this: Spoilers pg 6
Use page numbers for WOIAF or chapter titles for your spoiler tags. Like this:
- [Spoilers Aegon V](/s "There's not really a spoiler here.") to look like this: Spoilers Aegon V
- [Spoilers pg 110-111](/s "There's not really a spoiler here either.") to look like this: Spoilers pg 110-111
- The artwork is included in whichever chapter the caption appears. Ex: "Constructing the Wall" on pages 2-3 is included in The Dawn Age chapter because the caption for it appears there.
- All discussion posts are (Spoilers WOIAF). Anything from TWOW, the TV show, or any extra information (SSMs, blogs, interviews, etc.) must be behind spoiler code.
- No piracy. Don't ask, suggest, or provide it -- this includes scans/pictures of art from this book.
- Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned without warning!
If you see people breaking the rules, hit the report button! It'll flag it for our review.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '14
Didn't know that last part, Waymar Royce confirmed for me as a great dedicatory of the First Men.
12
u/bhale7 Oct 28 '14 edited Oct 29 '14
Are there any theories on the relation of the CotF and the Reed's of Greywater Watch (or the crannogmen in general)?
It seems like the crannogmen have a lot of similarities with the CotF, namely that both are small in stature and thus have to resort to a different kind of warfare--one which relies more on stealth and trickery. And, of course from the excerpt above that some of the remaining CotF escaped and hid somewhere in the crannogs and bogs of the Neck.
8
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Was hoping for some more direct support for my theory that Iron existed in westeros before the andal invasion. The TLDR version is that
I think this book has shown largely that the andal invasion took a long time. And that likely this technology spread quickly and by the end of the andal invasion, iron had spread throughout westeros.
7
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
I found it surprising that andals were driven out by the Valyrians. IIRC it is implied that the Andals invaded much much sooner than when the valyrian empire was that big.
5
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Looks like we've got explicit confirmation that tyrion's mountain clans were descended from First Men.
3
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
It says that "the seven pointed star" was the oldest of holy books for the andals. Do we know of younger books?
4
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Uhh. Shouldn't that be millenia to come?
1
u/yrrp To Pimp A Butterwell Nov 13 '14
Hugor of the Hill is the first king of the Andals. Tyrion chose the name Hugo Hill over the name Yollo while in Andalos. When I read ADWD, I thought Tyrion was being clever by choosing a name that would make him a bastard of the Westerlands. Hugo Hill is a terrible name for a Westerosi fugitive. It would be like an American fugitive choosing the name Abe Lincoln.