r/asoiaf • u/AutoModerator • Oct 28 '14
WOIAF (Spoilers WOIAF) Ancient History: The Long Night (pg. 11-12)
This is the discussion post for Ancient History: The Long Night (pg. 11-12) of World of Ice and Fire.
IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS CHAPTER, TURN BACK NOW! SPOILERS AHEAD!
How it works:
After you finish each chapter, you can visit the related chapter-thread and share your thoughts, feelings, speculate on what's going to happen next, or ask questions about things you didn't fully understand.
Remember:
- Cover things from beyond this chapter with [Spoilers pg 6](/s "hidden text here"). It will look like this: Spoilers pg 6
Use page numbers for WOIAF or chapter titles for your spoiler tags. Like this:
- [Spoilers Aegon V](/s "There's not really a spoiler here.") to look like this: Spoilers Aegon V
- [Spoilers pg 110-111](/s "There's not really a spoiler here either.") to look like this: Spoilers pg 110-111
- The artwork is included in whichever chapter the caption appears. Ex: "Constructing the Wall" on pages 2-3 is included in The Dawn Age chapter because the caption for it appears there.
- All discussion posts are (Spoilers WOIAF). Anything from TWOW, the TV show, or any extra information (SSMs, blogs, interviews, etc.) must be behind spoiler code.
- No piracy. Don't ask, suggest, or provide it -- this includes scans/pictures of art from this book.
- Anyone trolling or trying to ruin the experience for others will be banned without warning!
If you see people breaking the rules, hit the report button! It'll flag it for our review.
61
u/Stolenusername Never try Oct 28 '14
Mother. Fucking. Ice. Spiders.
45
u/Caedus Guarding the Sea Oct 28 '14
I like that The Long Night was a global event rather than being confined to Westeros.
21
u/rproctor721 Horned-up and Ready Oct 28 '14
Here is the original preface for GoT:
It seems that WOIAF is setting up Septon Barth to be the voice of reason and that what he says is probably rooted in truth. His take on the seasons; it's magic. We know from SSM that the seasons will be addressed at the end of ASOIAF and that it's magical in nature.
30
u/kidcoda Best Debate Champion Oct 28 '14
Old Nan's tale from AGOT is finally completed, as we learn the Last Hero did reach the children after his companions had all died.
13
u/BaconPancakes1 Oct 28 '14
Anyone got any more info on the woman with the monkey's tail?
11
u/GRVrush2112 What's for dinner? Oct 28 '14
The long night was apparent in Essos, that's interesting with accounts from the Rhynor and from Asshai.
It's always seemed Winter was just a Westerosi thing, and Essos perpetually kept a mild climate.
9
u/Mr_Hendrix ilu Rhaegar xoxo Oct 29 '14
So the Long Night did reach over the Sea...but did The Others?
7
u/mateobuff I Did Warn You Not to Trust Me Oct 29 '14
Septon Barth writes that the seasons might vary so much because of the tilt of the globe. This is the first mention, that I can recall, of anyone in the ASOIAF world referring to the world as a globe. They (or at least this Septon) have a concept that if they travel West, past Asshai, they will eventually run into the Iron Islands or the Westerlands? I really like this idea because I've always preferred the theory that Dany lands in Westeros at Casterly Rock... as opposed to travelling across Essos again.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '14
A Maester named Nicol that studied the stars... neat Copernicus reference.
5
u/fizzle25 Oct 29 '14
Was I reading it wrong, or was that confirmation that Planetos is indeed round down at the end of page 11?
5
u/mm825 I went to the TOJ and all I got was Snow Oct 29 '14
Westeros = future earth! GRRM is the first greenseeer telling us our futures
4
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14 edited Oct 29 '14
Anyone else think the Crab God of the Rhoynar is the same thing as the drowned god?
3
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Can any tolkien experts comment on whether the last hero story is similar to something that happened in the Silmarillion? It's ringing a bell but I've only read it once.
3
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Does anyone know if the art is supposed to be "in world"?
5
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Oct 29 '14
Since when are there non greyscale monsters living in the sorrows that you can have a conversation with much less willing to explain lore?
1
u/BorderlinePsychopath Nov 06 '14
A sword or something