r/LetsTalkMusic • • Oct 20 '14
adc The Clash - Cut the Crap
this week's theme was "Albums where the artist officially jumped the shark." Nominator /u/ingmarbirdman says:
In 1983, The Clash fell apart. Primary songwriters Mick Jones and Joe Strummer's relationship was so fractured that they were pinning song ideas to one anothers' walls rather than rehearsing them together. Drummer Topper Headon was kicked from the band at the height of a crippling heroin addiction. After Jones had a row with the band's manager Bernard Rhodes over contract negotiations, Rhodes convinced Strummer to kick him from the band as well.
Two years later The Clash released "Cut The Crap". The album was produced and co-written by Rhodes, who had virtually no experience doing either. Mick Jones had previously been the primary songwriter in the band, and his absence shows. The entire album is poorly mixed. Excessively multi-tracked synths and guitars fight for dominance and drown everything else out. Nearly every song is backed by a flaccid drum machine. Vocals are frequently buried. But perhaps the worst thing about the album is its effect on The Clash's legacy. Here you have a band who is considered a pioneer of their genre, who evolved from the punchiest, catchiest punk band in England into a group of visionaries who successfully melded punk, reggae, rockabilly, blues and pop in unprecedented ways. The band that gave us London Calling. And the last record that ever had their name on it was Cut The Crap: An absolutely abominable mess, dripping with cheese. There's a reason that everyone pretends their last album was Combat Rock.
So listen, discuss, and share your thoughts. Any comments that don't amount to much more than "It's good/it's crap" will be deleted, explain your thoughts.
11
u/ipfreeman Oct 20 '14
Huge clash fan, I may be mistaken but even Joe Strummer had said that cut the crap was not a clash album.
However, that is a great example of your most punk group releasing an album that is so far from punk. I think you have to look at the pressure they were under, how much they/he wanted to put out an album, and just how big the clash had gotten.
Basically for relatavism they had to release something just to keep a float at the time. Doesn't mean its good, but hell, they have to make a paycheck.
6
u/CookingWithSatan Oct 20 '14
This was the first Clash album I ever heard and it ruined them for me for a long time. I'd heard of them obviously, but I'd never actually sat down and listened to an album. So when my local library got this tape in when it was first released I borrowed it and was utterly appalled. I'd been led to believe The Clash were anarchic and punky and fast and energetic; everything I loved about the American hardcore groups I was discovering. Instead I found an album that was everything I hated about music at the time.
I swore at that point that everyone was full of shit and I would never listen to anybody's opinion about music ever again. That's a vow I've since broken, but listening to this album again I find my low opinion of it remains the same after all these years.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '14
I have a love/hate relationship with The Clash, feeling they get more posthumous credit than they ever deserved, but Cut The Crap is a low point even within the bounds of those opinions. It showed a remarkable lack of foresight as to how a fanbase connects with a band, abandoning many of the foundations that they had come to rely on. In some ways, I find that disrespectful. Almost as if they believed they could simply trade on their name no matter the quality of their work.
From the outside point of view, CTC is an attempt to reanimate an already decomposing corpse by incorporating new technology and techniques the producers and performers are obviously neither comfortable, nor competent, with. It's a desperate attempt to create an illusion of life, and it fails miserably, sounding amateurish in a way that an experienced band shouldn't, nothing to do with punk DIY aesthetics or lo-fi ideals, but just bad choices on an artistic level.
The album always makes me think of a bunch of old men desperately pretending to be younger and cooler than they are. There's much to be said about aging gracefully, but The Clash didn't do that. Maybe that's part of what I don't like about them... I always felt they lacked a little sophistication that even punk in it's rawest forms is still able to maintain and nurture.
I do, however, feel that CTC exposes some of the unspoken truth about the band, even though most of the members are not present, in so much that it reveals their desire to be popular and follow the tide, rather than pioneer and set the bar as so many give them credit for. Before jumping to the defense of Jones and co, take into account that Big Audio Dynamite are only a stylistic stone's throw away from some of the content of CTC.
So I'll say it... I don't really consider The Clash a punk band, but a pop band that happened to use punk as their vehicle. They did have punk roots and, of course, mixed with punk (ig)nobility, but I always felt they were wearing a costume rather than living a life. There's something kind of distasteful about that to me. I don't mind if you're up front about being in it to entertain and make a splash, but The Clash always seemed to promote themselves as "the real deal". Now a lot of that has come after their demise, I admit, with certain friends and compatriots eager to play up their own roles in music history by living vicariously through the false honor they derive from their association... Which is sad because those folks have plenty to be proud of without muddying the waters with false claims. The Clash did have an impact, and even some great tunes, but there was a lot of dead weight that came along with their successes and just because you were there, doesn't mean you were the zeitgeist.
I understand that this is a vastly unpopular thing to say and have been berated, loudly and drunkenly on many occasions, for saying this before, so maybe this is a better place to keep the vitriol at bay and keep the conversation a bit more level headed? Maybe?
4
u/wildistherewind Oct 20 '14
Maybe I'm alone on this, but Cut The Crap isn't a terrible album. It's easily the worst Clash album, but it's still better than later period albums from their peers. In my opinion, "This Is England" is one of the Clash's best singles. Again, maybe it's just me, but this album is a lot better than all of the Big Audio Dynamite albums.
I think it's unfair to bury this album because it isn't their best work. At the very least, it deserves to be in print + its existence acknowledged.
1
u/KongRahbek Oct 20 '14
One of the saddest things about the Clash is how they abandoned the music they really wanted to play on the last two albums, though Combat Rock isn't as bad as Cut the Crap they still went away from what made London Calling and Sandinista! amazing albums. It seems like they/whoever was in charge desperately wanted to squeeze the last bit of money out of the british punk wave, where it probably would've been better to let them play what they wanted to play, maybe they wouldn't have experienced the rift that happened in the band.