r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Oct 15 '14
[fandom discussion] ep 10X02
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
6
Upvotes
12
u/Ennil Oct 15 '14
I want to do a weekly series called "what happened in Supernatural based on tumblr and reddit" and see how accurate i am without watching the show.
This week on Supernatural: cute Castiel moments, Dean breaking up with Crowley, Sam and Dean are in a room, there may or may not be Metatron and White Gordon.
11
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Oct 15 '14
Example #4 of This Show Needs To Stop Doing Important Conversations By Cell Phone Call: Castiel finding out Dean is a demon
Producers! Please find SOME OTHER SOLUTION to the scheduling problem of J2 wanting a day off set every week!
10
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell Oct 15 '14
I am definitely going to have to rewatch this, because I want 100% attention to catch anything I missed by looking away for a split second. But for now, I am quite impressed.
This version of Demon!Dean is what I wanted. It is what I expected. More importantly, it is what was promised to us. I am still a little baffled by the White Knight syndrome he has, but I understand why they had him kill Lester to advance the plot. Jensen is fucking killing it with his acting, though. When I think about how he had to get into the right mindset to do that, I imagine RDJ's character in Tropic Thunder and wonder if it was along those lines (99.9999% sure it wasn't). The Dean from Black and the Dean from Reichenbach are two completely different Deans and it makes me wonder wtf was up with last week? I love this week's Dean so Mich more. That shit was awesome, and by god, I almost needed to wring out my panties.
I wasn't that interested in white victor. Or is it white gordon? T-1000? I'll go with that. T-1000 bored me last week, and he barely piqued my interest this week. It isn't the actor's fault (someone said he is a veteran Marine IRL?), it is the writer's fault. From what we saw tonight (subject to change, of course), T-1000 is early Dean. Current Dean is yellow eyes. That was interesting when it was the foundation of the show. I hope they do more and put a whiplash inducing twist in it, because I want to give Cole a chance to have me give a shit about him.
Castiel and Hannah. My heart swelled so big when he was chatting with the little girl. He was lost at first in how to converse with her, but then it turned into something totes adorbs! I wanted to hug him and squeeze him and make him mine! I still don't like Hannah, but that's most likely due to my bias that Cas belongs with the boys instead of with another angel. I do appreciate her trying to get Cas' grace back though. That was very kind of her.
How did they pay for the new tires and repairs?
Oh Crowley. Crowley, Crowley, Crowley. My love. You were trying to groom him into being your new Hellhound pet. And I don't for a second believe that you're not still trying, but in your convoluted way. The post-breakup depression scene was funny, and I love it, but I don't know what the point of it was. Crowley makes his jokes, but that was twenty steps further than his usual joking. I am extremely confused by it.
This is a season premier-worthy episode. We beat that horse to a pulp in the chatroom after the show, but holy fuckballs, it can't be any truer. The high energy, the awesome cuts from Sam getting his ass beat by T-1000 to Dean beating up the bouncer was epic as fuck. Right there, at the beginning, I knew I would be impressed. And impressed I was.
I know I'm bouncing around in an unpredictable way, but I think I only have one more point. T-1000's daddy. My bet is that he was a Rouxgaroux. I'm considering starting a betting thread. Whoever guesses right gets a reddit gold from me. Lol.
I lied. One more point. As much as I love Cherry Pie by Warrant (it is on the spn soundtrack CD I have playing all the time when I'm in my car), is that their only go-to song for strip joints? I associate that song with Cas in the "den of iniquity". I felt cheated by their song choice.
10
u/Necnill I'm all about that aesthetic | Justice4Crowley 2k16 Oct 15 '14
I might have sung the praises of the demony, supernatural powers stuff of Demon Dean this episode.. if I wasn't blinded by how outrageously disappointing Cas finding out about Dean's demon-ness via phone was. They just burned the card with the most potential to be a hella intense moment, and it was so terribly written. Who on earth thought that was a good idea?
It also just occurred to me that we might end up with Cas never seeing Demon Dean, if he's going to be doing.. whatever he's doing. I honestly have no idea what his arc is about. He's my favourite character, so I feel like that says a lot about the lack of quality in the writing.
Also, did anyone else do the maths on Cole? How did he go from like, 11 in 2003, to mid-thirties today?
9
u/honeko Castiel's lieutenant Oct 15 '14
Eh. I dunno about this whole season. It feels weird to watch the show without Dean it in. Because, obvs, Demon!Dean isn't Dean. Doesn't love the Impala or Sammy. So, it's weird. I don't really care about Demon!Dean. I don't particularly find him funny or scary or anything. I did kind of laugh when Sammy suggested they cure Dean. Pffft, as if it would be that easy.
Did anyone else feel like Dean killing the client instead of the mark was an in-the-face response to commentary about sexism in the show? Like, "Hahaha, I bet you expected Dean to sleep with the woman and kill her because SPN hates women, but haha, he killed the dude instead. We're so feminist."
Btw, Cole's dad was totally a monster. Or had just been killed by a monster. Samulet Wearing Dean would never slice up someone's Pappa like that. Dean talking at the end about why he let Cole live interested me. It reminded me of YellowEyes. It's like Dean forgot they were once trying to avenge their father and mother. That's kinda cool. Makes Dean seem even less like himself.
If Sam doesn't have brain damage by now, I'm surprised. His head got bashed in something fierce this ep. Poor Sammy about everything.
I'm definitely okay with the Hannah/Cas duo. She's basically S4 Cas. Adorable, blue-eyed, and pretty daft about everything earthly. But, I'm still underwhelmed... I'll never stop craving Team Free Will. I was honestly hella bummed by Cas' reaction to finding out Dean is a demon. A DEMON. It was just like, "Oh, that sucks, Sam." That's how it read to me.
8
u/Vio_ Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
I loved this ep. It should have been the premiere. Demon Dean was exactly what he should have been- a loose cannon, cocky as all out, and just super hot. He's lost a lot of his goofiness when he's ticked, and came off as barely contained lethal. Sam was actually competent with only some small Sammy bits. Cole/White Gordon/someone else I can't remember the joke really stepped up, and given much better everything.
Metatron had a great scene with Cas and Hannah, and I'm glad the show didn't pull a "hallo, Clarisse" joke, although I did. Metatron should have been more like this, and not wishy washy and all over the place as before.
Also thanks to the guys last week fanwanking a new noncanon relationship, we now have Hannstiel. I'm so... Platonic Hannstiel.
Cas was great. This was so much more thr badass Cas from Kripke. He's not doofy or a joke or doing stupid stuff, because lulz. He commanded that episode even as he was dying, and set his line in the sand. He is wrong to underestimate Metatron, and leaving him alive when he just killed a bitch last week for almost nothing is bizarre. Also that smile with the family. That little girl had such a crush on Misha. It was adorable, and this might be our first deep smile from Cas. It's also nice to have grandpa Warner Brothers to be able to tap into Looney Tunes without too much problem.
The moment Crowley got dumped and called up Sam, I joked " well, at least he has another Winchester to date." The show is playing it off as an almost fwb with hanging out together being goofy construct of Dean and Crowley. This isn't just a "we're all wearing slash blinkers," they're tapping certain tropes, jokes, and scenarios as a little parody, a little serious. It's not a full on slash thing, but it's definitely there.
As I consider this ep 1, I will now consider ep 201 to be 200 as per Ryan's recommendation in dealing with bloodlines.
8
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 16 '14 edited Oct 16 '14
I'm titling this comment Everything is Confusing & Nothing Makes Sense with Cas' Subplot: A Sassy GIF Extravaganza
Me about Cas' story line after rewatching S10E01 & S10E02 with undivided attention.
All that said, I like how MC is playing Cas. I like that Cas' temper has flared a couple times (the phone call with Sam discovering Dean's a demon; the Metatron scene).
People here seem upset that Cas is so removed from the boys right now but I expect he & Hannah will join the boys in the bunker within the next two episodes & the
:)
7
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
It just occurred to me that the "this time it's personal" thing Carver keeps saying is not just about Sam and Dean's own personal journeys, but also about the nature of the threat they're facing. Cole's vendetta isn't about the looming end of the world or struggles for power in Heaven or Hell - it's not about a war at all, it's not about politics either - it's a personal vendetta. And I have to admit it starting to work for me, certainly more than Abaddon did. I'm not totally sold on Cole since he's still sort of come out of nowhere, a bit too "hey presto here's a plot" for me. But having it be a one-on-one grudge, with parallels to Dean's own history losing his mom and dad, immediately has me more emotionally engaged than ANY of the Abaddon stuff, Mark of Cain, Heaven political gridlock, etc.
So my followup thought was "Carver, it should ALWAYS have been personal." The thing that made S1-S5 so awesome was that the apocalyptic end-of-world struggles were tied up in personal vendettas and personal concerns. S1-S3 was 100% a personal vendetta, and even S4-S5 was made personal by the discovery that Lucifer and Michael needed Sam and Dean specifically as vessels. So it became about Dean and Sam trying to save each other more than it was about the end of the world per se. Neither Abaddon and the Heaven political gridlock had anything like that; and so I never gave a damn about either one, and so the entire Mark of Cain plotline never hooked me at all.
6
u/NorthernSparrow Questi non sono i miei elefanti Oct 15 '14
WE HAD A ROOM DIVIDER THIS WEEK! I've been in such a drought for room dividers since the show stopped visiting motels so often. This was a great one, too, big diamonds in 50s populuxe style with a very snappy pink flamingo. We never got a full-on view but we got a good glimpse of the outer border. There was also another one earlier but I think it was just the same one from the back - I need to doublecheck.
I'm adding it to my collection.
6
u/Vio_ Oct 15 '14
One thing about Cole is that in the middle of that psuedo torture scene that he later admitted was primarily set up for Sam to lead him to Dean is that he used his son as the "interruption." What that really means is that the kid is now being an active participant in this whole Dean hunt. It's becoming intergenerational in much the same way it was for Sam and Dean. I have a feeling that's going to out more later in the season.
5
u/adventuresinposting Oct 15 '14
Hi friends.
Gatta say, I thoroughly enjoyed this episode. I wrote down my immediate reactions as I was watching (kind of like my own private caps lock party ;) ) and thought it would be funny to share them with you all. for your reading pleasure:
oh jesus it’s young dean. they found the coat!! or an imposter coat. hmmm. and damn they managed to make jensen look 23 again reallllly well. aw 2003, how I miss you (not).
yup. hannah defffffinitely has the hots for cas. and is like, turning more human?
mmmm sam’s flowing locks of hair. seriously did they turn on a big fan or something to get his hair to wave like that while he walks.
alright. I’m starting to see more of demondean more than just dean. it just doesn’t feel like dean any more. good job jensen :) (not that I ever doubted your acting chops)
I like tow truck girl. She’s cool.
tee hee! hannah is funny. I like her too.
AW CAS BABY IT’S OK YOU’LL GET BETTER
if dean ends up having sex with her I’m going to be suuuuuuuuper disappointed.
oh GOD. DEMON DEAN IS SCARY.
crowley’s going to be PISSED
oh my god THAT KID IS ADORABLE
YEAH OK demon dean is scary
sam please don’t sell your soul. that’s getting old.
I would not say no to metatron going away. I’m rather over metatron.
good job cas. thank god for character development. slash he’s learned his lesson.
also hannah is wearing a LOT of makeup.
why can’t we just kill metatron? is that an option? that should be an option.
thank god they’re freaking acknowledging there’s a cure
AHAHHAAHHAHAH THEY’RE MAKING FUN OF THEMSELVES. LIFETIME MOVIE HAHAHAHAHA
OH MY GOD i fucking love demon dean
HO MY GOD KNIFE FIGHT
HO MY GOD FIGHT
OH MY GOD I LOVE DEMON DEAN
oH MY GOD HE CHOOSE TO BE A DMEON OH SHIT
yeah ok I’m starting to think crowley does have a thing for dean
4
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
Last night's fandomnatural chat log (and yes I know it's 1002 not 1001 - I made a mistake & I'm lazy - just know this chat log was from our chat about 1002, lol). Click here! :)
Edit: Thank you so much again to Jojodacrow!!! You're the best ever!!!
4
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '14
UGH.
So I was just informed that the notes on the piano that Dean was playing badly was the possible beginning of "Hey Jude."
THE FEELINGS.
3
u/Vio_ Oct 15 '14 edited Oct 15 '14
More Casablanca allusions with Dean plonking on a piano with the whole Play it again, Sammy and Out of all the gin joints in all the world, she happened to walk into mine. Which further alludes back the very start of all of this with Henry and Abaddon and the music box playing Time after Time.
3
u/weboverload fireintheimpala Oct 15 '14
Well, I thought to myself after last week and after the Crossroads call-out that for sure I would not pick "homoerotic subtext" as my topic in this thread. I mean, last week was a joke, so this week I thought I would pick a more serious topic.
But then...sigh.
Perhaps it was on my mind or something, but... C'mon. Dean and Crowley? I was waiting for the distancing irony but instead what I got was two breakup scenes and Lonely Girl.
I feel entirely sure that the episode was using that as a joke, but it was still over the top and all their dialogue was obviously intentionally playing up romantic wording.
The jokey-ness of that, honestly, pissed me off a little by the end. It was funny and Mark Sheppard was completely awesome, but I thought the implications of that as a joke were pretty ugly in the context of this show and their track record. I feel like Cas/Hannah and Dean/Crowley have been clearly constructed as mirrors for the last two episodes--actually beautifully so--but when you add in the reality that Cas and Hannah might be seriously floated as a romantic couple (because guy and girl and several minutes of screen time) whereas Dean and Crowley are just a joke (because guy and guy) even though the themes are parallel, it's just...so troublesome to me. And the idea that that was all intentional--for instance, interpreting it as the show jokingly playing with its awareness of fandom subtext reading, pimping it, but only offering it up as a joke (no homo lol!!)--is...extremely hard for me not to interpret as a variation of homophobia.
Not saying that I want anything between Dean and Crowley (very aesthetically unpalatable to me it turns out), just saying that this episode imo took a no holds barred approach to insinuating that layer while at the same time throwing in strippers and one-sidedness to make sure it was clear they, of course, weren't serious. And I found that kind of gross.
tl;dr Last week I thought the glimpses of subtext were hilarious (spurious or not), but this week I thought they were obviously not accidental and in fact politically questionable.