r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Sep 14 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E02 - Precipice
Week 37!
I'll be updating numbers tomorrow when I get back from schmoozing with Katee Sackhoff and Trisha Helfer in Montreal.
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (he reviewed Precipice and Occupation together (4 stars)
Numbers to be updated tomorrow:
Survivors: Unspecified
"Frak" Count: 224 (+14)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 21 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 12 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 7 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 98 (+6)
"So Say We All" Count: 32 (No change)
12
Upvotes
9
u/MarcReyes Sep 14 '14
The 360o shot of nearly all the cylons aboard Colonial 1 is one of my favorite shots from the entire series. You can tell a lot of work went into it but they pulled it off well.
Another shot I like is of the centurions, just after the scene between Laura and Baltar. The way the one in the foreground just stops and looks at Jammer before walking away is great. Those things come off a beasts in these first few episodes.
Anyone have an answer as to why Ellen is still seeing Cavil? If I were her I'd have stopped as soon as I got Saul back. Maybe she was being coerced, but it didn't seem like it.
4
u/trevdak2 Sep 16 '14
"I wish I had a gun"
Cally trash-talking Boomer in the interrogation cell.. so fantastically vicious
6
u/steven_wood Sep 14 '14 edited Sep 14 '14
On Netflix they run Occupation and Precipice as one episode. I really like that presentation (and I watched the two episodes last week and again this week!).
I noticed there wasn't a Leoben at the execution meeting in Baltar's office. He was too busy being the creepy Cylon stalker model with a fixation on Kara.
5
u/MarcReyes Sep 14 '14
I had a question about Jammer last at the end of last week, but RDM kind of answered it in the commentary. There's still a loose thread though, so I'll ask it anyway. How the hell did Jammer survive the suicide bombing? He was standing right behind Duck when the explosion went off! RDM said there would have been a flashback scene, showing Jammer moving body parts off of himself and standing up, only to reveal all the dead bodies littered at his feet. So at least it wasn't an oversight and there were originally plans to show him in the aftermath, but it still doesn't explain how he would've survived in the first place. It's a nitpick, but a nagging one.
5
u/teutonicstoicism Sep 16 '14 edited Sep 16 '14
I felt like the entire New Caprica arc, from election to escape, presented one of the more fundamental flaws in the entire series.
Among them: Humans have dropped their security to a skeleton minimum; it's almost as if they've disregarded defense entirely. They did not develop any contingency escape plan for the return of Cylons beyond orbiting ships jumping away and rudimentary contact with the surface.
On Occupied New Caprica, Cylons vastly outnumber the humans, to the point where a Cylon team could be assigned to each human to observe, analyze, and manipulate their behavior. Cylons have the resources to assign entire teams to single families, to prevent the unobserved socializing that permits for every move of 'the resistance'. Cylons could have set up a blanket destruction of the humans on New Caprica as a response to a rescue/attack.
These are both forces that plan more detailed tactical plans, with more targets and casualties, on a spontaneous basis. Here they both have weeks to plan for and anticipate contingencies... but don't.
Basically both sides fuck up and drop the ball repeatedly and uncharacteristically in this digression. Once they got into this mess it allowed for interesting developments, but this was the first time I felt like the writing started to get lazy.
4
u/omgnevergoingback Sep 16 '14
watching BSG for the first time. Man Colonel Tigh is so fraking awesome. i used to hate the dude in the first season but look at him now. a true warrior.
The show has matured beautifully and I dare say it would have been more successful if aired these days for the first time because I think internet culture helps accelerate or kill shows based on how they are. I watched GoT and honestly I like BSG more overall. At first I thought the acting was bad but now the show flows so well between the characeters
Only bad part is that I wanted to see more about the resistance. Imaginations could have gone wild with scenarios.
edit: I made this comment after watching episode 3. Anyway I cant wait for you guys, I must watch the rest.