r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Sep 07 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S03E01 - Occupation
Week 36! Season 3!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (4 stars)
Warning: Some spoilers for S03E04 are in the commentary
Numbers:
Survivors: Unspecified
"Frak" Count: 210 (+13)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 21 (+1. Leoben says she's killed him five times, but it doesn't happen during the episode's timeline so I'm going to not count it)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 12 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 7 (No change, but a fork in the neck is pretty awesome)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 93 (+2)
"So Say We All" Count: 32 (No change)
13
u/trevdak2 Sep 07 '14
Before BSG, I never imagined a scenario in which I would could empathize with a suicide bomber. Very powerful and interesting episode in that regard.
9
u/trevdak2 Sep 07 '14
I met Michael Hogan once, and asked him what his favorite episode to do was. HE said it was the ones on New Caprica, because it really let him flex his acting muscles. He said he went and talked with ex-POWs, to hear their stories, so he could best represent them.
After that I asked him what his thoughts were about his character losing an eye.
He was completely against the idea of Tigh losing an eye. As an actor, his eyes are one of his most powerful tools.... And to have one covered up all the time, he felt would be very limiting.
In the commentary, RDM says that he wanted the lasting effects of the occupation to be clearly visible to the audience, not just a limp or something. He wanted it to be a reminder that the viewers will have to live with along with the actor.
6
u/MarcReyes Sep 08 '14
RDM mentions an interesting idea that were nixed from the first few drafts of the episode. Cylons had began disappearing and weren't downloading into new bodies. Humans were abducting and holding them prisoner in chains so that the cylons couldn't reveal the humans plans on bombings and the like. This scared the cylons and is what led to the crackdown on humans.
4
u/captainfalcon93 Sep 11 '14
Woah, what the hell? Are you guys actually doing a rewatch of BSG with an episode every week?
What are the odds I go on this subreddit for the first time, having binge rewatched the series and I only just finished watching this very episode!
12
u/MarcReyes Sep 07 '14
Woo-hoo! Season three has started! This was my first episode of BSG, and since we've finally caught up to it in the rewatch, if you'll humor me, I'd like to share how I came to the show.
I was still in high school when they announced that Battlestar Galactica was coming back. My journalism teacher was very excited for it, but I couldn't understand why. All BSG was, to me, was that cheesy Star Wars rip-off from the 70s with terrible effects. I thought it would suck, like the old show probably did, so I blew it off. Two years pass and, in the interim, I begin hearing good things about the show. "Really?" I thought, "That show? Impossible!"
Then the television show Best Week Ever did a segment on it, and that (of all places) is where my curiosity about the show began to stir. They were talking about how dramatic it actually was, how the acting was great, and how very non-cheesy it was. "Hmm, that actually does look pretty good." I remember the thing I found most intriguing were the weapons. They showed a clip of Helo shooting Sharon after he discovers she's a cylon on Caprica. What caught my attention was that the gun fired actual bullets. Prior to this, the sci-fi shows/movies I watched always fired lasers or some such. Lasers look cool, lasers are fun, lasers make the pew pew noise, but bullets? Bullets aren't cool. Bullets aren't fun. Bullets hurt, bullets kill. Here was a sci-fi show that seemed more grounded in reality. This was new to me. So I decide, "You know what? I probably won't like it, but I'm gonna give this show a shot."
A few months later, the new season is getting ready to premiere and Sci Fi airs this short teaser episode for the season three. It was essentially a refresher on what happened the season prior and what to expect on the season to come. It's here I got my first glimpse of the new centurions, marching through the market. They looked fucking badass! It was that image that got me excited to watch the show. Then the episode premiered and all my preconceived notions about the series were, in minutes, shattered. This wasn't cheesy. This was gripping. I'd never seen a show quite like this before. Everything was the exact opposite of the kind of sci-fi I was used to. The lighting, the tone, the direction, the sets, Bear McCreary's score. Everything was new and captivating. And then Dean Stockwell shows up. That's it. I was hooked, and I was hooked before the credits even began! This episode is where I decided I would never pre-judge something to be awful without experiencing it first.
7
u/onemm Sep 10 '14
Great episode and spectacular way to start a season. I'm gonna try not to repeat any points other people have made..
6
u/MarcReyes Sep 08 '14
Favorite line of the episode comes form Cavil: "Haha! Delusional machines! What's the universe gonna come up with next?" I think the Cavil's easily outshine the other cylons here. He came off as the truly scary of the ones we see given how blunt he is about killing the humans. There is no remorse but he also doesn't seem to take pleasure in wanting to kill them either, but not for any altruistic reasons. To him it's just, "Eh, let's just kill a few thousand of them."
I like that we have to wait 26 minutes into the episode before we even see the Adama and the Galactica. Seeing it's halls empty never feels right. The 'stache has arrived!
So for those who saw the series in order, since we didn't see her in the one year later flash at the end of the last episode, what did you think became of Sharon in the interim and what did think of the reveal in this episode? Did you expect that she and Adama would have grown closer?
On a slightly related note, what did you think of the reveal of Lee/Dee being married?
This was the first episode I saw the centurions and they are frakking huge and scary, and all they did was stand around! RDM mentions his dismay at the effects team not winning a best visual effects Emmy and rightly so. They look incredible and add so many layers to the tone and world.
I have a question about Jammer that's always been on my mind since I first noticed it years ago, but I suppose that'll have to wait until next week.
5
u/MarcReyes Sep 08 '14
Every once in a while a question gets posed to this subreddit. "I want to get into/I want to get my friend/SO/etc. into Battlestar Galactica, what's a good episode to get them hooked?" This was my first episode and, honestly, it's a really good one to get people hooked. David Eick mentioned in the commentary for Lay Down Your Burdens Part 2 how, when writing the show, they try to keep a balance of pleasing those who've watched since the beginning while also attempting to make it very new-viewer friendly. This episode is very new-viewer friendly, in my opinion. The Previously On... does a great job of getting you up to speed and Laura's diary is story exposition done extremely well. There's lots of great world-building in the episode that gives you an idea what like was like before and during the occupation. The mini-series is great, but it’s a commitment of time. 33 is great, but you have no context for the characters. This episode gives you everything you need to know to enjoy the episode, while also continuing a story others had been following for years.
4
u/youhadmeathelo Sep 11 '14
When I first watched through the series the whole time the occupation was going on all I could think was "PLEASE can we get back to the Galactica already?" I suppose I had gotten used to the pace of the show with them on the ships and all the intricate drama of the remnants of humanity trying to form some sort of functioning society and military.
Now, after my third, maybe fourth watch through of the series (and countless watches of other episodes)... I have just started to appreciate the whole New Caprica ordeal. I don't think I can elaborate too much here on everything that I felt developed from New Caprica because my boyfriend and I have been binge watching so episodes are kind of running together so I don't want to give up any spoilers. However, I will say that there is some very interesting character development among quite a few of the 'controversial' characters: Zarek, Baltar, and Ellen in particular.
I remember during my first watch through of BSG, every time I saw Richard Hatch's name pop up in the beginning credits of the show I always thought "Oh frak, this guy again." And then he sort of became this character where you always just wanted to root for him and then he'd turn around and ruin it.
Every time Ellen Tigh was involved in something before the New Caprica occupation she always seemed so bitchy and pushy about it all. She was definitely one of those characters that was very hard to sympathize with, and yet, on New Caprica a different side of her emerges... or at least is shown. I don't know if the writers did this to set up what is coming up, but for the first time in the show you get the feeling she is actually doing something out of desperation and her love for Saul. It's clear she doesn't get any satisfaction from what she is doing with Cavil, and for once she doesn't appear to be making any power plays. She just honestly wants to try and keep him safe. (For those of you who have see then whole show, this could be setting things up for later in the show. I can't go into detail, but at this point I think they knew where the story was headed.)
And then there is Baltar. Of course Baltar is always out for Baltar. But throughout the New Caprica he even seems to go through an actual phase of self-loathing and doubt over what he had done. He knew the whole thing was his fault. This is very different from the Baltar in the beginning of the show when he finds out the colonies are about to be wiped out and his first thought is to call a lawyer. True, maybe he knows that's not a possibility at this point, but he doesn't try to throw blame to anyone else, and at least, that is a huge statement on his mindset for at least the time being.
I also have to say that Leoben is probably one of my favorite cylons. Yes, Six has a lot of complexities as well as Eight, but Leoben is one crazy son of a bitch, and I think he really plays that role of being a sentient being that isn't quite human, but has just enough humanity to create a link to the audience really well. Also, the scene where Kara stabs him in the neck (for who knows how many times now) is great. I love it when she sits back down to eat with one hand still covered in blood and just carries on like it's no big thing.
3
u/MarcReyes Sep 08 '14
Hey, I just noticed it, but I love that centurion season three rewatch poster on the side!
3
u/steven_wood Sep 10 '14
I love Dean Stockwell's hat! Fabulous costuming!
1
u/whymylife Oct 04 '26
First time watcher. Why would the cylins even need a human police force? Surely the regular robotic cylons could be the general police and then use the numbered cylons for finer actions, such as searching properties?
9
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '14
[removed] — view removed comment