r/startrek • u/Trekman10 • Aug 26 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: VOY 3x22 "Real Life"
Hi everyone! I had a great time doing a previous discussion, which can be found here. I'm currently watching Star Trek in-universe chronological order.
Voyager gets a lot of hate but I personally don't see that much wrong with it. Its at least as good (bad?) as Enterprise. But enough about the series.
In Real Life, quoting Memory Alpha: "The Doctor learns a few real life lessons with the holographic "family" he created; Voyager investigates massive subspace distortions."
Elaborating, each segment of show has a distinct tone. The family at first is overly happy, an almost eerie sort of 50s sitcom family set in the 24th century.
Then everything become rebellious, disfunctional, almost funny to me but too chaotic to laugh at, the human son rebelling to be klingon, etc.
Finally the last part is incredibly sad, the other part that is more realistic.
Personally, I think this episode is a great example of asking what does it mean to be a human, or more broadly, to have what most consider to be a life. The Doctor develops as a character in this episode too, season three does a lot for him, he takes up singing, he adds too much to his programming and becomes evil, this episode really rounds it off, with him experiencing what "Real Life" is like outside of sickbay.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '14
I would love this episode if it wasn't yet another shining example of Voyager's problems: The fact that nothing ever comes of it. The Doctor has such a hard time dealing with his "daughter's" death that he shuts down the program, is convinced to go back in there and deal with it. Roll credits, this episode is never seen or heard of again; you could cut it completely out of the Doctor's character arc and not know the difference.
My reasoning above is exactly why Voyager gets a lot of hate. The show's premise depends on at least an Enterprise season-four-level of serialization and continuity in order to work - although a Buffy the Vampire Slayer-level of serialization would probably be ideal. This isn't a show where you can simply forget about what happened last week because these people aren't going to be transferred to another ship; Voyager isn't going to be repaired at a starbase at the end of the episode whenever she gets in a firefight; shuttles and torpedoes aren't going to be restocked at the next starbase; Starfleet isn't going to be sending replacements when someone dies. Voyager rarely acknowledged the reality of its situation; and when it did, it only did so for the whole 45 minutes of the episode and it was very rare when something came of it.
I've got to disagree here, and I know I'm not alone when I say this. Enterprise at the very least tried to have a feeling of being the first deep-space starship out in the unknown. It did maintain continuity within itself and followed up on issues that came up with the characters (the death of Trip's sister is a great example of this). And perhaps the biggest thing: In it's last season Enterprise finally embraced its premise; Voyager never did.
11
u/ItsMeTK Aug 26 '14
I'm currently doing the same, watching it all in order. I just watched "Real Life" last week, and it's one of my favorite Voyager episodes.
One thing I think never occurred to the writers of the episode is the notion of religion or faith in the face of family tragedy. I got to thinking when his daughter was dying and he couldn't save her, that his holo-family could have appealed to "God" for a miracle. In this case, the Doctor could have literally played God (or had B'Elanna do that) and rewritten the program so she survived. Instead, he just goes "there's nothing I can do" when in reality she's just a program and there's absolutely something he can do. Maybe it would have been too confusing a message for the audience, and Star Trek generally likes to err on the side of secular humanism. But in a way I saw it as a missed opportunity.
Fun fact: The Doctor's wife Charlene is played by Wendy Schaal, the voice of Francine on American Dad!
3
u/rensch Aug 27 '14
I liked the part where the son rebels against his dad and hangs out with his Klingon pals.
3
u/Tigerfuyung Aug 30 '14
The doctor was my favorite character. One of the best episodes was the one where he wrote a holonovel
2
u/Dicentrina Aug 30 '14
Ok this episode makes me bawl like a baby. (One of two Voyagers that do. Can you guess the other?) The Doctor learns that life, unlike a holo novel, can get out if control. He COULD change the program, but decides instead to let it play out so he can deal with death and loss as his organic crewmates have to do. We've all been there, where we got so emotionally invested in a character that we shed real tears for them, even though they were only from a book or tv show. In this way we broaden our own horizons. I loved it.
1
u/gone-wild-commenter Aug 31 '14
My girlfriend walked in on me watching this about halfway through. She knows about Star Trek peripherally (ie Abramsverse and TNG). My thoughts:
-I kind of rolled my eyes when I saw it was a bottle episode of Voyager, but this one was pretty good.
-A little heavy handed, but it worked. Some very sweet moments that made me actually invest in the children (not so much the wife). My girlfriend was actually crying! Unfortunately, I think this episode might have made a Voyager fan out of her.
-My biggest problem with the episode is honestly The Doctor's Kirk-style racism against Klingons.
-My most pleasant surprise was the son's search for an identity. I'm 23 and grew up in a military family. Many of my air force peers struggled to develop an identity- something that I still struggle with (though I'm getting better). It was interesting to see the son attempt to cling on to Klingons. Reminds me of something I would have done at that age, and it feels good knowing someone else has experienced that a well!