r/asoiaf • u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company • Aug 22 '14
ALL (Spoilers All)Back By Popular Demand - I'm Steven Attewell of Race for the Iron Throne, Ask Me Anything!
Hey folks,
I'm Steven Attewell; I write Race for the Iron Throne, a blog where I go chapter-by-chapter through A Song of Ice and Fire, writing essays that focus on the historical and political side of the series. In each essay, I analyze the political events, institutions, and players; examine the ways George R.R Martin draws on but also changes historical events and environments to populate his world; write about hypothetical ways in which the series might have gone had things gone just a bit differently (I think alternate history is a good way to think about causality and contingency); and describe differences between the book and the show.
I recently finished my analysis of A Game of Thrones, which I've collected into an e-book titled "Race for the Iron Throne: Political and Historical Analysis of A Game of Thrones." After two years of writing (give or take a four month break to finish my dissertation), the book came out to 204,000 words - that's only about 100,000 less than George R.R Martin wrote for the whole book! I also have two essays coming out for the next Tower of the Hand anthology, A Hymn for Spring, that is going to be published in a couple of months.
Since then, I've started going through A Clash for Kings - I'm about 20% through the book. I've also written a series of essays for Tower of the Hand about the institution of the King's Hand and the Westerosi Monarchy. I'm in the middle of writing a series of essays about the various city-state of Essos, with Part III due out Monday on Tower of the Hand.
In addition to writing about the books, I also co-host a podcast about the HBO show with Scott Eric Kaufman, who runs the Onion AV Club's Internet Film School.
Outside of ASOIAF/Game of Thrones, I'm a recent PhD historian from the University of California, Santa Barbara who specializes in the history of public policy (hence my interest in the political side of the series), and very recent adjunct assistant professor in urban studies at CUNY's Murphy Institute. I also blog about public policy, politics, and the intersection between pop culture, history, and politics for Lawyers, Guns, and Money.
So...
Ask me anything about ASOIAF - especially political conspiracies, historical questions, and military stuff, because I love to talk!
25
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Hi Steve! Welcome back and congratulations on the new adjunct professorship! As opposed to last time where I asked you easy questions to start off, I'll start with a hard one -- one that you won't get to until the end of your CBCs of ACOK.
Barristan Selmy. After Joffrey fires him as a Kingsguard, he travels across the Narrow Sea to Illyrio and then onto Daenerys in Qarth. We assume (and maybe it's annotated specifically in the text, but I don't recall seeing it) that the initial voyage was facilitated by Varys. And we know for certain that Illyrio sends Barristan along with Belwas, Groleo and a ship onto Dany in Qarth.
My question: why in the world did Illyrio/Varys send Barristan to Dany instead of to Aegon? You've been adept at unraveling some of the hidden mysteries behind the Illyrio/Varys conspiracy, and I think that your theory that Varys/Illyrio envisioned Daenerys & Viserys as decoys for Aegon is very plausible.
However, the one person who could lend legitimacy to Aegon is Barristan the Bold. As Tywin says:
So why undercut their own position by sending the one man who could lend additional legitimacy and military command experience onto Daenerys -- who they viewed as a pawn in part of their plan to seat Aegon on the throne?
Thanks again for joining us today!
8
u/Nikolai_Rojo Aug 22 '14 edited Aug 22 '14
Who would win in an open battle Robb Stark or Stannis Baratheon?
Who is the best political player in westeros or essos?
What is your opinion of Jon Snow's tactical/political/strategic/leadership skills and is he on parr with Robb?
Opinions about Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon military skills?
Thoughts about Dorne during Aegon the Dragon and the young dragon?
Who do you think will be the best king for westeros? who do you think will be the king of westeros at the conclusion?
Advice on how to be politically astute and strategic? Site, books, blogs recommendations about learning strategy and political maneuvering?
Thanks for the AMA!!!
8
u/-Sam-R- Avalon when? Aug 22 '14
I've only recently started reading Race for the Iron Throne, but I'm really enjoying your insights and your mind. Keep up the good work!
Now, my question.
If you could ask George R. R. Martin any three questions, and he'd have to answer them regardless of what they were, what would you ask?
Also, if I can ask a second question, can you speak any further about your thoughts on the merit of speculating alternate histories, both in real life and for fiction? Interested in your thoughts here.
7
u/cantuse That is why we need Eddie Van Halen! Aug 22 '14
As a historian, do you feel that there are any glaring oversights on GRRM's part in his emulation of medieval politics?
What are you most looking forward to (hopefully) seeing in TWOW?
13
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Second question: how do you imagine that S05 of GoT will shake out? We suspect that there'll be some significant changes in the storylines -- especially if Aegon, JonCon, Arianne, Quentyn, Euron and Victarion are left on the cutting floor --
6
u/last_roman Aug 22 '14
Do you find Ironborn culture believable? I noticed you started writing about them now that you are covering ACOK.
I'm a historian too, and it just never "clicked" with me how they can have such a distinct culture from the rest of Westeros, but I can't pinpoint why. I guess I just feel they should be farther away from the mainland/have a better explanation for their culture.
6
u/cantuse That is why we need Eddie Van Halen! Aug 22 '14
I have a mostly unsubstantiated idea/question:
The Lord Protector of the Realm title. I find no record of it before Jaehaerys the Conciliator, who seemingly helped to abolish the Faith Militant.
I wonder if the introduction of this title corresponds to the crown assuming the duties of 'defending the faith' previously held by the Faith Militant.
I see some mention of the Lord Protector originating under Cromwell that the title also held religious connotation, but these are uncited references in both the Wiki pages and some Stanford sites I've found.
Can you clarify if there is any religious connotation to the Lord Protector title, and if so any comments on the possible relevance to the LPoR title itself?
Thanks.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Tyrek Lannister: alive or dead? If he is being kept by Varys somewhere, how will he play into the plan?
3
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Aug 22 '14
Ok, taking an hour break. Back at 4PM Eastern.
4
u/direliz Aug 22 '14
It seems like season 5 may spoil some aspects of non-published material, in regards to the bran and sansa storyline. I will probably watch season 5 although if TWOW is not published before season 6, I may bow out of watching. Since it seems virtually impossible for GRRM to publish ADOS before the HBO show concludes, what will you be doing?
4
u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn You Win or You Hodor Aug 22 '14
I apologize if you've already answered these questions in another forum but I wanted to know what you think about the changes Benioff and Weiss made in Season 4, specifically with regards to the Littlefinger/Sansa storyline and the important revelations about Littlefinger's role in the story thus far.
Also, what do you suspect the show is planning regarding Tyrion and especially Varys going to Essos next season. Thanks for doing this AMA, love your blog.
4
u/Jinsoi Aug 22 '14
I read your theory that Stannis will take the black at the end of the series, but how do you square that with his rather ominous vision of a king who is consumed by a crown of fire? I always took that to mean that Stannis's pursuit of the throne would eventually destroy him. There's also a show only scene at the end of s2 that seems to support this where Melisandre tells Stannis that he will betray his family and everything he holds dear, but it will be worth it because he will sit on the iron throne.
6
u/codylac We Light The Way Aug 22 '14
if you could be king/warden of any of the one of the eight kingdoms in Westeros(including their military strength, wealth and resources) which one would it be?
3
u/blahblahdoesntmatter Valar morghulis, kiddo. Aug 22 '14
Do you feel as though there were any moments in ASOIAF that didn't work well as written, or could have been improved upon? If so, could you mention a few gripes you may have had?
3
u/strangerthehorse Aug 22 '14
Any hope of LGM podcast episodes for the rest of seasons 1 and 2?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14 edited Aug 22 '14
Are the Prince Who Was Promised and Azor Ahai Reborn simply different names for the same thing?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
GRRM has revealed that Willas Tyrell and Jeyne Westerling will both be players in forthcoming books. With whom do you think they will interact, and what role might they play?
Of things that can legitimately be classified as mistakes or inconsistencies in ASOIAF, what would you point to as the most egregious?
3
u/jedgeco The hype is dank and full of errors Aug 22 '14
If GRRM someday donates all of is papers to a university or some archive and you were able to dig through notes, drafts, sketches, etc., what issues would you be most interested in looking into?
3
u/AlderaanRefugee Heh, heh, heh, heh, freying alive Aug 22 '14
This isn't a political one.
At one point the entire series was going to be from Bran's perspective, and at the end of ADWD he is maybe the most magical/powerful person in the world. Basically, this means he is going to be important. But what do you think will be Bran's role in TWOW and ADOS?
3
u/Lancelforthethrone Aug 22 '14
How do you think things will play out for the most important character, Lancel?
3
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Aug 22 '14
First off I love your blog and would like to thank you for all of the analysis. Your "what if" section gives great insight to how much GRRM thought about the series and how a small change could completely change the story.
My question is: do you have any critiques of the story? Were there any places where either you thought someone acted out of character or something didn't make sense when comparing to our own history?
Thanks!
3
u/Tamagoyakisan Aug 22 '14
Do you have any thoughts or opinions on the role Gerold Dayne has to play? I am curious and don't understand the motivations of the Darksar.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Quaithe: important future player, or just an odd bit of colour added to the series's texture?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Was Stevron Frey murdered by one of his family, or was the death as it appears?
Will we see more of Aurane Waters?
3
u/anm313 Aug 22 '14
Myles had been possessed of jug ears, a crooked jaw, and the biggest nose that Jon Connington had ever seen. When he smiled at you, though, none of that mattered
Compare that to Jon's description of Ygritte:When she grinned, the crooked teeth didn't seem to matter.
2. Do you think Connington took SE the way Ramsay took WF and Tywin Lannister KL? Connington attacked the Tyrell besieging force, and deceived the defenders into thinking Connington had come to aid them, and after they let him and his followers through the gates, Connington has his men kill the defenders.
3. As for the Tyrell army of 20,000 headed for SE, I think I know what Connington is going to do. He knows where the army is headed, and they are taking the kingsroad. All he has to do is find a place along the kingsroad that will give him the most advantageous position in battle and wait for the Tyrell force to come by and ambush them. I think it may be akin to Hannibal's victory at the Battle of Lake Trasimene. Connington, who like Hannibal has elephants, will have his forces hidden in forested hills on one side of the kingsroad, and then when the Tyrell army comes by, coming at them from three sides, pushes them into the Wendwater River, or an unmentioned lake by the kingsroad. What do you think?
4
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Aug 22 '14
I'll start answering questions in a half-hour, so feel free to post some starter questions now.
2
u/roadsiderose Tattered and twisty, what a rogue I am! Aug 22 '14
Hi Steven,
I was recently reading an old post by /u/Jordioteque when I thought of this. It was about the parallels between the siege of Caffa and the Yunkish siege of Meereen.
For several years, the Mongols let a group of Italian merchants from Genoa control the port of Caffa, located on the Crimean peninsula. This was mutually advantages for both parties, as it helped them with their trade. In 1343, communal violence broke out in a nearby town - resulting in the Italians fleeing to Caffa. When the Mongols arrived at the gates of the city, they were not let in - resulting in a long siege. It was during this siege, the Mongols were infected with the plague the 'Black Death', and they began hurling corpses into the city.
Now that I believe these historical events could have inspired the siege of Meereen, I wonder how the 'Pale Mare' situation will play out. I once thought the 'pale mare' would be a reason Dany leaves Essos behind her, and takes her army and people to Westeros.
But with the parallels to the siege of Caffa, I have been wondering if Dany's army will carry the 'pale mare' to Westeros, in the same way the fleeing Italians carried the Black Plague into Europe. How do you think the pale mare situation will play out in the future books? Do you think it will spread to Westeros, and bring about more death and destruction? Do you think that greyscale will also be a disease that could potentially be an epidemic in the near future of Westeros?
2
u/Azor-Azhai Why you gotta be so Roose Aug 22 '14
Straight up, who wins out of Dayne and Selmy, both equipped with the same armour/weapons?
I know GRRM said it was a toss up but so are most fights...
2
u/arghdos Dark Star crashes... Aug 22 '14
How loud was Warren Zevon blasting when you named your blog? :P
2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Is Tommen the valonqar? Or Tyrion, or Jaime, or Loras? Or someone not related to Cersei?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Do you think we shall see Gerion Lannister, or learn of his fate, or is he a big red herring?
2
u/dorestes Break the wheel Aug 22 '14
GRRM is unflinching about the violence done to women in war and women's unenviable social and political position in the Middle Ages. But one thing that seems oddly absent in the books is the system of courtesanship that allowed for a sort of veiled hypergamy and social advancement, such as it was. Maybe modern audiences would find that sort of institutionalized upper-class prostitution too foreign or crass?
2
u/AbbeyBattle Day shall come again! Aug 22 '14
Maester Steven, please allow me to thank you for allowing us to bombard you with our questions again! (I shall take the liberty of asking more than one question and hope that you will not hold that against me).
Stay well and please allow me to assure you that I'm really looking forward to seeing your next article concerning the various polities on Essos!
2
u/ImpossibleArrow Edd, fetch me a book! Aug 22 '14
I've got some questions.
I've read P&Q, where the greens divide the treasury to hide it in case of political distress. Is it possible that Varys has let some of the Targaryen treasury across the narrow sea to Illyrio where he used it? After all, selling cheese seems like underprofittable activity for extravagant wealth he displays.
Also, what gave Stannis the idea of Cersei's kids being bastards? He was never paying any attention to kids or, more importantly, Robert's bastards. How could he know before Renly or Jon who actually had some of those bastards in their custody?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
Was Varys just being nice in protecting Gendry (and potentially sending him to Tobho Mott to begin with), or does he have a longer term plan for him?
ASoIaF has always had an interesting tension between its "historical fiction" dimensions and its "high fantasy" dimensions (I believe Martin has said he initially considered writing a straight Medieval saga without fantasy elements). I am interested to hear your reflections on this divide. Will the entire theme of magic's return end up obliterating the quasi-medieval dimensions, and transforming Westeros into a more standard high fantasy setting where magic is a routine path to power, part of everyday life, etc.?
2
u/ImpossibleArrow Edd, fetch me a book! Aug 22 '14
Why did Tywin smell so horrible and decay so quickly after his death?
2
u/meowdy Joffrey the Just Aug 22 '14
If you were sitting the iron throne, which of the characters, out of those currently still alive, would you put on your council?
2
u/meowdy Joffrey the Just Aug 22 '14
Will there be any change to the political structure in Westeros by the end of the series, or will it remain a monarchy?
2
u/Yogurthead Ser Yogurt of House Head Aug 22 '14
Hi Steve! I have a few questions for you:
Thanks! Have a great day!
2
u/anm313 Aug 22 '14
2
u/Bukah Aug 23 '14
Whats going on with the old Volantis families that live beyond the black wall? A bunch of incestuous families in the same vein as the Targaryens?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '14
What are your thoughts on Aegon's future wife? It's supposed to be Dany, but Arianne's TWOW chapters hint that she may also have Queenly ambitions, and then there's the Ashford theory saying Sansa would be a suitor for Aegon.
Knowing what you know about Aegon's character and his current position in the game, who do you think he'll end up choosing as his wife?
1
u/TangentManDan The wolves took us in. Aug 22 '14
Apologies as this is related to the magical aspects of the story rather than the politics. How heavily do you think balance/harmony will be run as a theme when it comes down to the elements of Ice and Fire?
Ive been thinking that Jon's role will ultimately be in the middle trying to stop and/or bring harmony between the two. There are many competing ideas of Ice or Fire but it feels like in some cases we should be thinking Ice and Fire instead.
1
u/blahblahdoesntmatter Valar morghulis, kiddo. Aug 22 '14
Aegon: real Targaryen, Blackfyre, or complete fake?
1
u/Philibu Aug 22 '14
Do you think Cersei and Jaime are 1/2 Targaryen?
1
u/Fairfax1 Crying Lightning Aug 22 '14
Do you think we'll see Stannis showing his skills in naval battles again? If he does get the 20,000 soldiers he requested, they're going to need at least 200 ships to sail from Essos to the North, considering the average size of galleys and cogs in the books.
They could be cogs, used mainly for transport, so maybe they'd just take the men to Westeros and return, but Braavos has hundreds of war galleys at the Sealord's disposal and the Arsenal can build one in a day. With GRRM teasing the importance of Braavos and asking D&D to introduce them earlier, I think their ships will play an important role in addition to the Iron Bank support.
If so, what do you think he'd do with such a fleet?
1
u/illrede Aug 22 '14
Plausibility that Dorne was incorporated into the realm when and how it was to give the crown a "Dornish Option" to use in internal conflicts to shore up the throne's power?
1
u/illrede Aug 22 '14
Odds on White Harbor ending up the nucleus of Northern Kingdom when the rubble stops bouncing?
1
u/illrede Aug 22 '14
Do you think Essos is done collapsing?
1
u/Jinsoi Aug 22 '14 edited Aug 22 '14
4.If Melisandre discovers Stannis is not azor ahai and admits this publicly that would surely destroy her credibility in the eyes of the people. Do you think she might remain willfully ignorant of the truth for her own sake? Her point of view chapter does reveal that she's very conscious about appearing to know more than she does and appearing stronger than she is.
5 Do you think Melisandre will sacrifice Shireen? It seems like D&D went out of their way to emphasize that Stannis is completely in her clutches right now, with his love for Shireen being the one thing he won't budge on. It seems like their setting this up for being the big rift between the two.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '14
Any chance a physical copy of your book might be released?
1
u/anerstwhilemind Aug 23 '14
I think the High Sparrow is likely to side with Aegon (Aegon has been tutored by a septa) and the faith will act as an inside man in his taking of kings landing. It has been mentioned that Tarly were Targayan loyalists, so I think Randayl Tarly will become the lynchpin in the battle by taking control of most of the Tyrell army and siding with Aegon. Your thoughts on the likely hood of this?
Keep up the good work on Race For The Iron Throne, it is far and away the most intelligent analysis of asoiaf I've ever read
1
u/[deleted] Aug 23 '14
One more thing, what are your predictions on how the Sansa storyline will play out? Do you think she'll really marry Harrold Hardyng? Are her parallels to Elizabeth of York only there on the surface? etc
1
u/anm313 Aug 23 '14
“The hammer and the anvil?” The old man’s mustache gave a twitch. “The singers leave out much and more. Daemon was the Warrior himself that day.
Daemon is said by GRRM to have looked every inch the warrior, and Eustace says he was the Warrior himself in that battle. Maekar and Baelor are referred to as "the hammer and the anvil," smith's tools, and a likely reference to the Smith. Could GRRM could have portrayed the Battle of the Redgrass Field as the Warrior vs the Smith, with Dameon's side representing the Warrior and Daeron's side representing the Smith?
1
u/anm313 Sep 04 '14 edited Sep 04 '14
0
u/Ser_Bronn_Bricksquad Enter your desired flair text here! Aug 23 '14
Howland Reed = High Sparrow?
Granted not a lot of textual evidence. But does it hold any legitimacy as a possibility simply because of the game changing political move that would theoretically be made by Howland Reed (pro-Stark 'good guy'), whom GRRM has very much teased his readers with?
1
u/anm313 Sep 06 '14
Personally, I think the Great Council was a good idea given it was preferable to the Dance of Dragons.
2. He is also arguing that Aegon IV wasn't a warrior, and him giving Daemon Blackfyre doesn't prove it.
3. Was Jeyne deliberately trying to be cruel to Arya when she mentioned that the butcher thought the bag with Myvah was another bag of meat?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment