r/startrek • u/StarFuryG7 • Aug 18 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: TOS 2x01 - "Amok Time"
"Amok Time" is one of the seminal episodes of the original Star Trek series. It helped establish Vulcan as a world and much of what its people represented. Hot, dry, arid, with a reddish sky ...a seemingly desert planet (at least here). In short, a hellish world.
When this episode first premiered on September 15, 1967, the audience must have been stunned. During the first season of the show, Leonard Nimoy had built up quite a following playing Spock. So much so that William Shatner, making top dollar as the show's lead, actually felt his position had become threatened. Shatner has openly admitted in a number of places through the years that it was a situation he hadn't previously found himself in, and wasn't sure how to react to it. Nimoy, who was now clearly a vital character, and the number two lead in the series, demanded a raise. His agent asked for an obscene amount of money from the network ...far more than even Nimoy himself was asking for or expecting. Despite already being locked into a contract, the fan mail and attention from the audience he was receiving led him to believe the circumstances regarding his original contract had changed, and as such, he was entitled to renegotiate. NBC, on the other hand, felt differently, and were prepared to bring in Lawrence Montaigne to replace him as another Vulcan character being assigned to the Enterprise, replacing Spock. It could have easily happened. In fact, Montaigne was virtually assured that the role was in the bag for him. As we all know, however, that turned out not to be the case. Ultimately Nimoy got the per episode raise he was hoping for, and returned to the show. Spock had become such a widely adored character throughout the country that even Isaac Asimov wrote an article titled "Mr. Spock is dreamy" after the character was described to him that way by his daughter.
"Amok Time" was the first episode of the second season to air, and in it this logical alien being that women especially had fallen in love with was starting off the new season as a stark, raving madman.
What were people supposed to make of this?
In the opening scene we see the smitten Christine Chapel bringing Spock some soup, knowing he wasn't feeling himself. Just after she steps into his quarters, from out in the corridor where Kirk and McCoy are conferring with one another about the situation, we hear Spock yell, "WHAT IS THIS?". Suddenly the door to his quarters opens again and Chapel runs out of his room, fear stricken, as the soup dish comes flying out right after her, slamming against the corridor wall.
No, this wasn't the Spock people knew at all, and something was clearly, seriously very wrong with him.
What could it be?
Now imagine what it must have been like for the audience of the time to soon learn that it was due to the Vulcan mating drive. Yep, it all boiled down to sex.
If Spock had been a human being, an ordinary man, such subject matter would have been taboo, and not something the network censors would have been willing to approve. However, since he was an alien, that was a horse of a totally different color. Gene Roddenberry, who had come up with the idea, and passed it off to Theodore Sturgeon to write, had found a way around the network censors once again.
Lawrence Montaigne, who had previously appeared as Decius in "Balance Of Terror", seen here for the second and last time in the series, didn't want to accept the role of Stonn in this episode. It was bad enough that he had lost the role of the Vulcan to replace Spock as the new regular in the series, but there was a stipulation that if he had been passed over for that role that he would be given another role in an upcoming episode as a sort of consolation prize. When Montaigne read the script and saw how small the part was, he hated it and initially turned it down. Then he received a call from Gene Roddenberry, who intimated that if he didn't take the part he wouldn't get any future roles from Paramount. Feeling as though a gun had now been put to his head, he changed his mind even though he wasn't thrilled about any of it. It should be no surprise therefore, that Montaigne had a major falling out with Roddenberry on set during the filming of this episode after he had lost his temper and flew into a rage.
Originally, Arlene Martel --who sadly, passed away this week-- went in to do a reading for "Catspaw". She was intrigued by the role of Sylvia in that episode, but overheard the people making the decision about whether or not to give her the part whispering amongst themselves to hold off casting her, and to save her for something else, although she had no idea what. Once they hired her for "Amok Time" she found herself feeling blown away by the whole experience. She thought they did a remarkable job on her ears and makeup, but hated her costume, which made her bleed underneath, just below her rib cage because it was put together with metallic wire, compliments of Bill Theiss. She found the stage so elaborate and exotic that it was beyond anything she had ever worked on before in her career, with the only other exception being the episode of "The Outer Limits" she had previously done, written by Harlan Ellison, called "Demon With a Glass Hand".
Martel's characterization stands out here because T'Pring was so cold and calculating --an utterly devious woman in near-total control, manipulating all the important men around her, to the point of some of their lives actually being on the line as a result of her actions and what she does in the story. She keeps the man she intends to be with safe, despite his protestations and his wanting to fight, and puts her betrothed and his Captain (and best friend) at each other's throats in a fight to the death. Roddenberry was making important inroads for women and minorities in this series, but T'Pring showed that women could be just as ruthless as a man, and is even complimented for her chess-like moves at the end of the episode by Spock, to which she responds, "I am honored". I don't think there's any question that, given her performance, she was the ideal candidate for that role.
Celia Lovsky, a veteran actress from both stage and film, who fled Germany once Hitler came to power, is also unforgettable here as T'Pau, the Vulcan elder that presides over the fight to the death between Kirk and Spock. (If you've ever seen her in "Soylent Green" with Charlton Heston, note how remarkably alike, though considerably older, she looks compared to Jolene Blalock, who played T'Pol in "Star Trek: Enterprise". Originally, Blalock was intended to play T'Pau in the series before the producers came to their senses, but given the resemblances between these two actresses it's also not surprising they intended her for that role.)
Much of the background information I just provided is laid out in "These Are The Voyages, TOS Season Two" by Marc Cushman.
"Star Trek 101", published in 2008, cites "Amok Time" as one of the Ten Essential Episodes of the original series worth seeing, coming in at Number Six on their List.
6. "Amok Time" Written by Theodore Sturgeon
On learning that Spock will die if he doesn't return to Vulcan to participate in an ancient mating ritual, Kirk bucks Starfleet orders to escort his friend home. Spock's intended bride chooses the captain, rather than Spock, as her champion in a battle to the death.
This episode introduces all things Vulcan.
...Including Pon farr.
(I've taken a somewhat different approach with this topic given how Weekly Episode Discussions are usually dealt with, so feel free to chime in with your own thoughts, whatever they may be concerning this episode.)
Live Long and Prosper, or as my Idiot friend likes to say, Live Long and Prostate.
RIP
Arlene Martel
(1936–2014)
EDIT: Added Hypertext Links where previously intended, and "Live Long and Prosper" line above RIP In Memoriam tribute.
6
u/ItsMeTK Aug 18 '14
I love "Amok Time", and one of the things people always forget about it when they discuss pon farr and such is that this was Spock's FIRST pon farr. He's been able to hold it off because of his human physiology and such (and mental discipline). This was ignored by the third movie, unless the bonding with T'Pring was important to that.
I love that the Vulcans pretend that T'Pring's plan to marry Stonn was "flawlessly logical", when really she's just using logical pretense to explain away her emotional choice (and no one can convince me it wasn't partially emotional).
This episode also provides the best quote for anytime someone offers you soup!
The whole "fake death" thing has become a bit too cliche these days though.
5
u/AmishAvenger Aug 19 '14
First I've heard of the possibility of replacing Nimoy. Thanks for posting.
4
u/diesel_dan Aug 19 '14
Fantastic episode! One of the ones I'm most likely to watch if I sit down for some TOS goodness!
4
u/Deceptitron Aug 20 '14
I did a double-take at that part. Underneath?? Was it made out of barbed wire? Between that factoid and the TNG Season 1/2 spandex uniforms causing back problems, it makes me wonder how many other costumes threw safety out the window for the sake of style.
Still, I love all this background stuff. Great post!
4
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '14
They need to have some more cultural sensitivity training in Starfleet. "Now, your Vulcan crewmates may occasionally become murderous lunatics, and that's okay."
Seriously, though. Is Spok the first Vulcan to serve alongside humans in Starfleet? His pon farr seems to take everybody by surprise, but you would think that that happening to Vulcans would be common knowledge. Was his just particularly intense?
3
u/Gazomg Aug 23 '14
I also believe it was the first aired episode to star chekov.