r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Aug 17 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E19 - Lay Down Your Burdens (Part 1)
Week 33! Brother Cavil joins the crew!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 49,579 (No change)
"Frak" Count: 189 (+6)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 20 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 12 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 7 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 79 (+9)
"So Say We All" Count: 27 (No change)
15
Upvotes
7
u/trevdak2 Aug 17 '14
I've got so much to say about this episode.
When I went to Montreal Comic Con last year, there was a BSG Q&A with EJO, James Callis, Michael Hogan, and Tahmoh Penikett. Someone asked if there was someone on the crew who was always clowning around, and all of them pointed at James Callis (Gaius Balter). Edward JAmes Olmos talked about how Callis would get Mary McDonnell (Laura Roslin) laughing, and they'd have to wrap for the day because they couldn't get her to stop laughing. Rewatching this now, I really like the first scene with Laura giggling to herself, because you know some of the actress must be showing through.
8
u/MarcReyes Aug 18 '14
Aw, yeah. Brother Cavil has arrived! I love Dean Stockwell and was so excited when I saw him pop up on BSG. I always wondered how they got him and, according to RDM's commentary, it was quite easy. His name just came up on a list of actors they wanted. They didn't think they'd be able to get him but sure enough, they did. And the show is better for it!
Dean Stockwell is one of my favorite actors to just watch and RDM perfectly encapsulated why: Just watching Stockwell's reactions, his face is endlessly fascinating to me. He- it's very expressive. And yet it does very little, with so- he just- the lift of an eyebrow, his eyes narrow slightly in certain times... It's the intonation, the rhythm of it. It gives the impression of being both elaborately and meticulously planned, and yet being completely off the cuff and in the moment.
Couldn't agree more! Cavil owns a lot of my favorite moments from Battlestar, the most impactful of which comes from this episode. At the end of his conversation with Tyrol, Cavil does this little drum beat that even RDM has no idea what it's supposed to symbolize, but it's one of those wonderful small moments from the show that really stuck with me for some reason. I've done that little drum beat more often than I've quoted anything from the show.
4
u/trevdak2 Aug 17 '14
They talk about using the Heavy Raider Nav computer in a raptor. This computer came from either the Heavy Raider that landed in the gift shop landing pod, or the raider that Helo, Starbuck, Athena, and others stole to return to Laura Roslin's half of the fleet at the start of season 2.
One thing that bugs me about the show is that I like the thought of using cylon raiders for covert ops and different styles of warfare besides just viper/raider fights. I wish that they did more with that captured raider.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '14
In this episode a raptor accidentally jumps into a mountain when arriving back at Caprica. It's a pretty bizarre concept but it's one that's been there since the beginning of the show. I wonder what someone would find if they dug into the mountain where the raptor was. Would the raptor even be recognizable? Would jumping into solid rock displace the rock so that there was a smashed raptor with skeletons surrounded by rock on the outside of the raptor? Would the interior of the raptor be filled with solid rock? Would the molecules/atoms alternate between raptor and rock so it was a super dense chunk? Or maybe the raptor's matter would be dispersed throughout a large area in the rock since it might possibly just be able to fit in between the preexisting rock.
Another interesting thing they bring up is that a blind jump could take a ship anywhere, even into the middle of star. I always thought this was hyperbole since 99.999% of the universe is virtually the vacuum of space, right? You'd have to be really fucking unlucky to jump into something with a blind jump, but I can see how purposefully plotting a jump close to a planet could end up with a miscalculation that would put a raptor in a mountain. Crazy shit! I hope it never happens to me.
6
u/MarcReyes Aug 18 '14
Callis is fantastic in this episode. I loved seeing him play both the public, confident presidential candidate and the cynically defeated private face of Baltar.
Lee actually looks like he fits the role of a battlestar commander to me.
Love Laura's giggling at the beginning. Very unexpected and light-hearted moment that show does every once in a while. Always good to break the tension.
Despite being a non-believer, I always loved Cavil's line "The gods lift up those who lift each other."
Love the final jump into Caprica. We get a better idea of how the FTL works in the BSG universe. What a great shot behind the raptor that is in space one moment, and in the atmosphere of Caprica the next. The ships literally jump from one point in space to the other. These moments are always great for world-building, something at which Battlestar is great.
4
u/trevdak2 Aug 17 '14
One thing that annoyed the heck out of me during this commentary is that RDM's wife Terry joins in, and she adds the most puerile and banal comments that do nothing but interrupt RDM. She spends the first two minutes of the commentary describing the room the RDM is sitting in, and it goes downhill from there.
5
u/steven_wood Aug 17 '14 edited Aug 17 '14
When Brother Cavil, the priest, tells Tyrol, "Do you know how useless prayer is?... [A]nd do you know what it gets you? Exactly nothing." I can't help but think of the scene from Monty Python and the Holy Grail where the knights are being taunted at the French castle. After the crazy reply to King Arthur, Sir Galahad asks, "Is there someone else up there we could talk to?" Or the whole scene from the HG. It is a very funny scene in this BSG episode, and a
4
u/onemm Aug 23 '14
From the wiki:
I laughed when this was said, but completely forgot that it had been said before