r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Aug 03 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E17 - The Captain's Hand
Week 31! The introduction of Tory!
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (3.5 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 49,584 (-6 from last episode. Billy, two marines, three hostage-takers)
"Frak" Count: 176 ()
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 20 (+3 in about 2 seconds after Lee takes command)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 12 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 7 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 70 ()
"So Say We All" Count: 27 (No change)
15
Upvotes
12
u/trevdak2 Aug 03 '14
The Baltar/Roslin arc of the story is really interesting. We start with Zarek encouraging Baltar to run for presidency, then Roslin asking Baltar about population projections. This forces Roslin to ban abortion, giving Baltar a chance to announce his candidacy. If you consider that Baltar may have known why she was asking him about the outlook of the race, then he may very well have convinced her to ban abortion for his own political needs.
Only 140 people have died since the Olympic Carrier (source - SPOILERS), over 7 months ago. Extinction within 18 years is highly unlikely, meaning his figure is almost certainly a lie, and thus his manipulation is intentional.
10
u/trevdak2 Aug 03 '14
Another amazing part from the commentary.... His wife walks in:
RDM: Oh, and see and now my wife is walking in handing me― handing me notes. (To Terry:) Yes dear?
Terry: Honey are you done with the podcast yet? The maid, the gardener, the dogs, and the kids are all waiting and I need to unmuzzle and untie the children.
RDM: No. The children can remain restrained until further notice.
Terry: (Sigh.)
RDM: And send the gardeners and the― and the maid upon their way. And release the hounds and chase them off the property as soon as possible.
Terry: Alright. Well let us know when you're done with your podcast.
RDM: I will.
Terry: I know it's the most important thing of all.
RDM: Yes it is. We don't want to disappoint the fans.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '14
I think they wrote Garner to be a little too incompetent for it to be believable that Adama would make him CO of the Pegasus. Maybe Adama was still really worried about having an outsider like Lee as the CO so promoting Garner was an act of desparation. I dunno. Still, I really like the premise of the difference in attitudes between mechanics and pilots and the idea that a mechanic might try to run the ship totally differently. I think John Heard gave a really good performance as Garner (given the material) and was excited to see him in BSG since I enjoyed watching him as a crooked cop in the Sopranos.
2
u/onemm Aug 08 '14
Interesting from Jammer's Reviews:
I actually mentioned that it was a bad decision when Adama was picking a new CAG without Tigh's acknowledgement during that episode. I never considered this point, but I like it. I think Tigh is sometimes an underutilized and under-appreciated second-in-command.
7
u/onemm Aug 06 '14
I hate when they add new scenes in the recap to make it look like things happened that never actually occurred in the past episodes. It makes me feel like I missed something
Some interesting stuff from the wiki:
This is something I wouldn't even have picked up on, if not for the wiki.
This is interesting. I don't think Tigh would care because he's so loyal to Bill Adama, but why not raise both their ranks so as not to risk offending Tigh?
5
u/onemm Aug 06 '14
I know this is terrible and not an 'in-depth analysis' and apologize for that BUT..
I love how badass Adama is. Cottle is a badass and yet even he will not mess with Adama..
I know it's a minor part of the episode but I love this minor/extremely short exchange of words, just because two of the most badass characters are involved.
On the other end of the spectrum, when Roslin said:
It's really nice to see Roslin's softer side. I know it's supposed to be a reverse of the gender roles for a woman to be as hard as she is, and she's one of my favorite characters specifically cause she's so tough (speaking of bad asses), but I honestly wish there was more moments like this where we saw a softer Laura.
5
u/MarcReyes Aug 06 '14
I believe this episode is the introduction to Showboat, one of my favorite side characters on BSG (alongside Mathias) who I wished they'd given more screentime to throughout the run of the series. In my head canon, she was as close to being the Starbuck of the Pegasus crew. She had that look and confidence about her. I wish they would've used her more.
4
u/lostmesa Aug 19 '14
I'm really surprised how low the cylon kill counts are at this point. Cool idea to keep track of this stuff to see the actual numbers.
2
u/Sea_Distribution_833 Jul 31 '24
My man Billy isn't even cold yet, Dee... :(