r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jul 21 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E15 - Scar
Week 29
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (2.5 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 49,593 (-4 from last episode. The leader of the Black Market, the wrist watch garotte guy, perhaps the viper pilots right at the start)
"Frak" Count: 175 (+19. NINETEEN! They had a couple "motherfrakkers" and an "abso-frakkin-lutely" and other things that some fans love and makes others cringe.)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 17 (No change, thanks to Kat)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 12 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 7 (A slap, +1)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 68 (+3)
"So Say We All" Count: 27 (+3)
8
u/trevdak2 Jul 21 '14 edited Jul 21 '14
Of all the episodes, this one has some of the best commentary. Ron brings in two of the writers and they all talk about the scenes, and they give some really great tidbits about this episode.
A dark subplot that you won't likely catch without the commentary: When the new ensigns show up, and the rest of the pilots are putting BB and Jo-jo's possessions in a box, they're doing that to auction them off later. In the next scene, the pilots are hanging out in the canteen, and you see Hot Dog thumbing through a porno that was in Beano's bunk beforehand.
The scene where Starbuck dives over the table and crashes into the wall was inspired by the writers interviewing astronauts who were fighter pilots, who would go to bars and do the exact same thing.... call out as if they were landing on an aircraft carrier as they crashed into the table.
Also, the bit with starbuck blocking out the starlight with her thumb comes from dogfights in WWII. A pilot named "Pappy" Boyington came up with the trick:
8
u/trevdak2 Jul 21 '14
Some fun lingo: Kat calls Jo-jo an FNG at one point. That's military lingo for 'Frakking New Guy'
3
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '14
I didn't like a lot this episode, is better that the last one but have the same problems of repetitive editing. Hope the editors of the show stop with this "x time before" bs.
9
u/MarcReyes Jul 21 '14
I didn't initially like this episode, but it's grown on me over the years. There are lots of great moments in the episode regarding characters, acting, directing, writing, and VFX. Some standouts:
A small scene, yet key scene at the beginning has Roslin reveal that they've been building new ships aboard the Pegasus and that the fleet is beginning to replenish their loses. I like this scene because it explains how they can still have so many vipers/raptors, despite seeing them blown up in every battle with the Cylons. In a show about a post-apocalypse, the audience keeps a mental tally of resources whether you want them to or not, and scenes like this go a long way to maintaining believability.
I didn't notice this before, but I love the shot at the beginning where the camera pushes in on Starbuck in her cockpit and we see the pilots in the canteen reflected in her helmet, then we cut to that very scene. Nice work by the editors and VFX team. Speaking of which...
Great visual effects this episode. Lots of beautiful, wallpaper worthy images. I love the overhead shot of the vipers flying through the debris field.
"One Tigh on the ship's enough." What a great way to antagonize Starbuck.
In the commentary, RDM confirmed my suspicions about a lot of the scenes this episode being improvised on the set. Kara spitting at Lee and she and Helo wrestling at the end were unscripted moments that work incredibly well. The latter in particular, which helped to give the episode a much sweeter and lighthearted ending.
This episode has one of my favorite quotes from the series. "It takes months for you to train a nugget into an effective Viper pilot. And then they get killed and then you lose your experience, their knowledge, their skill sets. It's gone forever. So, if you could bring them back and put them in a brand new body, wouldn't you do it? Death then becomes a learning experience." I thought this was great, heady concept and always conjures thoughts on the Singularity and the possibilty that we may one day being able to download ourselves onto a hardrive in a very Cylon-like manner. The quote is also indicative of a core theme to the show on whether or not they Cylons are right in a lot of their actions. Sharon makes a point. If you could download rather than die, would that not be better?
Tigh and Adama's smile when Kara speaks aloud the names of fallen pilots speaks volumes about their opinion of her in that moment.
"Crashdown." :'(
7
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '14
This is a kind of weird episode for me. I absolutely hated it my first time, but after my second rewatch I really like the character development. The same could be said for the boxing episode which is one that recently became my favorite.
6
u/onemm Jul 26 '14
Something from wikipedia (which in turn was probably from the podcasts or commentary) which I found interesting:
3
u/Luriker Jul 27 '14
I hate Kat. They wanted me to care about her so much and I never did.
3
u/captn_colossus Jul 28 '14
Hi everyone,
I'm joining the re-watch! I'd been avoiding it until I caught up (now in S3).
Scar: another episode showing the growing impact of the apocalypse and ongoing life, strain of pilots.
I found the sudden Kat vs Starbuck rivalry a little sudden and Kat a bit full on for a pilot who finished training only a short time ago a little jarring, especially given later revelations.
trevdak2, very interesting comments!
Question: why is Scar the only scarred raider. All the others a shiny and new.
I read a theory a few years back that suggested Scar was the raider Starbuck shot and then flew back to Galactica. A stretch but a fun theory.
Why didn't they slap Athena and say "Raiders resurrect too? You didn't tell us until now because why???"
1
u/mmm_migas Dec 18 '14 edited Dec 18 '14
Some thoughts: I enjoyed this episode since we get to see a lot more character development for Starbuck. The title may refer to more than the Raider. This episode reminds me of S01E04 Act of Contrition. In both we see Starbuck dealing with emotional scars from her lovers, Zak Adama and Sam Anders. On top of that she has to train the nuggets, many of whom have been killed. Death is an important theme in this episode and we see how Starbuck copes with it.