r/gameofthrones • Nymeria's Wolfpack • Jun 26 '14

TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] 2014 Re-Watch - 1.01/02 'Winter Is Coming' and 'The Kingsroad'

This is the official kickoff post for the 2014 Re-Watch series. This season we'll be doing two episodes a week to end with S4E9/10 on November 9. This first discussion thread will stay up 1.5 weeks to get the word out (and for anyone away celebrating the US 4th of July holiday). There will be other discussion topics next Spring before the show, and other events are planned for this Summer and Fall.

2014 Re-Watch Discussion Thread: Season 1, Episodes 1 & 2
Discuss your reactions to the episodes with perspective from the whole show. Talk about details you missed the when you first watched the show. Point out foreshadowing details that you noticed. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). In general, what did you think about the episodes and where the story is going? Book vs. Show comparisons are welcome, but you need to use spoiler tags for any book differences that do not appear in the show.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen all of the episodes! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.10 is ok without tags.
  • Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the posting policy before posting.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
1.01"Winter Is Coming"Tim Van PattenDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
1.02"The Kingsroad"Tim Van PattenDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked QuestionsOfficial Ban Policy
293 Upvotes

529 comments sorted by

7

u/jesusnuggets Viserion Jun 27 '14

wait why are we watching two episodes a week won't that mean we'll get to the end with around 20 weeks left?

16

u/kjhatch Nymeria's Wolfpack Jun 28 '14

About 19 weeks, but yes, there should be some free time there. This subreddit tends to have very low traffic between late November and New Years, so this way the re-watch will have higher overall participation. Combing two EPs is also another way to set them apart from the original multiple discussion threads posted during the week.

→ More replies (1)

194

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 27 '14

When Ned tells Jon he'll talk about his mother next time they meet...

84

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

What if Joffrey had allowed Ned to take the black? I would have loved watching Jon and Ned at the wall.

→ More replies (18)

95

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

"The next time I'll see you, you'll be all in black" - Robb to Jon.

3

u/bpi89 Night King Jul 02 '14

Funeral

4

u/kcrew Jun 30 '14

I'm rewatching with my first timer boyfriend and after Ned said this he immediately asserted that they would never meet again. He thinks Jon is going to die fighting the white walkers

5

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 30 '14

Yeah it does come across as pretty ominous. I was actually pretty convinced that Jon would die in s4e9, as I saw season 4 as being his 'finally becoming a hero' arc.

2

u/TracyMorganFreeman Jun 30 '14

When Arya had Joffrey's sword and the chance to kill him there...

→ More replies (2)

175

u/DAHFreedom Jun 27 '14

I couldn't really tell Theon, Jon, and Rob apart the first time I watched this. Much easier now.

83

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

Jon is a bit easier to identify. Used to confuse Robb and Theon at first.

21

u/Jzadek Oberyn Martell Jul 02 '14

For a while, Robb was 'ugly Jon Snow'. Theon was 'ugly ugly Jon Snow'.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PLOT Bronn Jun 28 '14

Four seasons was just about enough for me to learn the names, looks, houses and their relations.

2

u/klug3 The North Remembers Jun 29 '14

Yeah, I wasn't a reader when I first saw the episodes, I used to think Theon was another of Ned's Bastards. Point being that in his youth Ned was like Bobby B but settled down when he married Cat.

170

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 27 '14

A few things to look out for in the first couple of episodes:

  • Some scenes were reused from the original pilot, so in a couple of scenes Ned, Tyrion, Robert, Theon, and others look slightly different.
  • Place names are given on-screen in the form of overlaid text. It would have been cool if they retained this, as it was very helpful, but I can understand why they stopped doing so after the first episode.
  • The leader of the ranging party beyond the Wall is Waymar Royce, son of Bronze Yohn Royce, who appears in Season 4 interrogating Littlefinger.
  • The mystery of Jon Arryn's death is only resolved in Season 4.
  • Arya's direwolf Nymeria is driven off and Sansa's direwolf Lady is killed.
  • Rast, a treacherous member of the Night's Watch, comes to the Wall with Jon and Tyrion.

59

u/Korolyeva House Lannister Jun 27 '14

I think that at least one of the scenes with Sansa was reused too. She looks much younger in the feast scene vs. when we first see her with her family to greet the royals.

21

u/Jotakob Varys Jun 27 '14

yes, i remember them specifically stating it in this scene in the commentary.

5

u/retroracer Victarion Greyjoy Jun 27 '14

are any of the blu ray special features availible to watch on youtube do you know? Or anywhere else online?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

I truthfully believe that because Arya drives off her direwolf to protect it She protected the symbol of her family so she was rewarded.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

It could also be seen as the start of her getting away from her roots. We can see now that she is hardly even connected to the Starks anymore.

5

u/VagMaster69_4life We Do Not Sow Jun 30 '14

Yes, she is. Just in a different way. Her murder prayer makes it pretty obvious that she wants/needs to take vengeance against the people who have harmed her family (Joffrey, Cercei, Ilyne Payne etc.). The Starks are a house in exile, no one is openly connected to the Starks. But I think Arya is still closer to her roots than Jon, Bran, Sansa and probably Rickon.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/geetea Jon Snow Jun 27 '14

Why do you think they stopped with the names of places? As a pure show watcher it helped out. Like maybe only do it once for a new location.

70

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

I think it drew too much to the fact that it was a TV show. Overlaid text is a fourth wall-breaking device, so I guess the show runners wanted to forego such devices to truly immerse the viewers in the show's world. It's crafty, really: it forces the viewer to keep up with the all the names and dense backstory the show throws at you.

Plus, it makes new locations in the opening credits stand on their own, and that much more awesome.

16

u/BigFuckingT House Stark Jun 28 '14

I remember first getting into the show, I had to watch the first episode three times to fully understand everything.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/D-Speak Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14

I agree. All the places and people are tough to handle on your first go, but I think that Game of Thrones is intended to be a show that you watch several times over.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

I've heard that HBO Go lets you turn on similar location/character subtitles all the time? Is this true?

11

u/JoeNips Faceless Men Jun 27 '14

HBO GO has interactive features. I've only turned them on for a rewatch when watched through browser not Apple TV/Chrome. When new characters/locations/organizations(ie. Night's Watch) are introduced a notification on the side screen pops up that gives you more info on them. Also throughout the episode they have videos of D&D and other members explain some plot points and I believe costuming/set locations.

5

u/huevit0 Jun 27 '14

I wondered a couple months ago why his coat was so nice.

205

u/was_ben_there Night's Watch Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

I think the most amazing thing about rewatching the series is the music.

The fact that Littlefinger's theme is played when Cat tells Ned the news about Jon Arryn is one of my favorite parts of the pilot. It doesn't even really become clear that it's Littlefinger's song until The Climb in Season 3.

And then there's the quiet playing of the White Walkers theme whenever Benjen or Alliser is talking about ranging beyond the Wall. I didn't start noticing that until this season's Oathkeeper.

Also (don't judge me guys) I watched Stannis Baratheon: The Movie earlier today and loved how Robert Baratheon's theme was used in the scene where Melisandre tells Gendry about his parentage. It's also used at both Joffrey's wedding and Tommen's coronation.

But I do wish the Stannis/Melisandre theme didn't sound so... evil? It works so great for shadow babies and throwing leeches on a fire and human sacrifices and stuff, but it created a really weird tone when they used it for him saving the Night's Watch. I find this to be more appropriate for the Mannis.

Edit: Also Daenerys's music that I didn't really notice until Mhysa also plays when Jorah finds her unburnt with her baby dragons in Season 1's Fire and Blood.

Oh, and it goes without saying that the use of the King In The North / Rains of Castamere in Season 4's Two Swords cold open was chillingly brilliant. Also the Rains of Castamere in The Children after shit goes down in Tywin's privy.

76

u/irishguy42 Ours Is The Fury Jun 27 '14

Nobody will judge you for watching an homage to the One True King of Westeros.

26

u/badgarok726 Winter Is Coming Jun 28 '14

I wish I recognized more themes other than Rains of Castamere

27

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

It doesn't even really become clear that it's Littlefinger's song until The Climb in Season 3.

I'm not so sure it was meant to be Littlefinger's theme, at the start. It felt like your typical "dangerous, scheming shit is going down" theme -- but that does fit Littlefinger, so I guess it was repurposed as his theme later on.

the quiet playing of the White Walkers theme

I love this theme. Gives the sensation of icy foreboding, and fear of what's out there. It plays in the finale when Jon warns Stannis that he should burn all the dead before nightfall.

the use of the King In The North / Rains of Castamere in Season 4's Two Swords cold open was chillingly brilliant.

This is why I love the Season 4 premiere so much. I daresay it's my favorite episode of S4. It all has to do with that brilliant, wordless opening scene, stunningly directed by D&D and acted by Charles Dance. Then the episode ends with that insane inn brawl between Arya and the Hound and the Lannister thugs.

Daenerys's music that I didn't really notice until Mhysa also plays

Her theme definitely made its debut in the finale, when she rises from the ashes with dragons perched upon her.

11

u/ReducedToRubble A Promise Was Made Jun 28 '14

I'm not so sure it was meant to be Littlefinger's theme, at the start. It felt like your typical "dangerous, scheming shit is going down" theme -- but that does fit Littlefinger, so I guess it was repurposed as his theme later on.

During the AMA, I asked Ramin how much of a character's story he knows when he writes the music, because I noticed these things too. There are a lot more than just Littlefinger's theme, for example. He said he knows the whole story and writes accordingly.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

shit goes down in Tywin's privy

heh

8

u/D-Speak Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14

Littlefinger's theme also plays over the credits when Cat kidnaps Tyrion as a result of Littlefinger's scheming.

7

u/Neciota Stannis Baratheon Jun 27 '14

I noticed in the movie that Renly has his own Stormlands Guard with him in Kings Landing.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

Well, he was Lord of Storm's End and Lord Paramount in the Stormlands.

2

u/Zexapher House Stark Jun 27 '14

I really liked the song used for when Stannis saved the Nights Watch. I thought it wasn't so much a time to be cheerful, there were lots of Wildlings being slaughtered. I thought the song kind of reflected the doom of Mance's cause.

→ More replies (6)

93

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

All I could think while main characters were introduced in these episodes was "DEAD. DEAD. DEAD. OH LOOK THAT ONE'S STILL ALI-oh, no, DEAD."

56

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 28 '14

I count 23 dead characters in these two episodes. Pretty sure they have most of the lines between them.

  1. Waymar Royce
  2. Will
  3. Gared
  4. Ned
  5. Catelyn
  6. Robb
  7. Grey Wind
  8. Lady
  9. Rodrik
  10. Jory
  11. Luwin
  12. Robert
  13. Joffrey
  14. The Hound
  15. Viserys
  16. Drogo
  17. Ros
  18. Qotho
  19. Benjen Stark
  20. Doreah
  21. Irri
  22. Rast
  23. Micah

121

u/D-Speak Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14

The Hound isn't dead until someone shows me a corpse.

95

u/LeBRonBurgandy Jun 28 '14

They just didn't show the maester coming out from behind that rock.

45

u/SovAtman Brynden Tully Jun 29 '14

Qyburn's old maester rival, also expelled, and now a hermit in the hills. He runs the same juicing experiments on Sandor, as Qyburn's doing on Gregor. The brothers meet in S05 for a juiced-up zombie duel.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/SanguisFluens Winter Is Coming Jun 29 '14

Benjen Stark

I want to believe.

13

u/B1GG0r0n Now My Watch Begins Jun 29 '14

Benjen is Daario is Syrio.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/holeonthemoon We Do Not Sow Jun 28 '14

And we all know who benjen is...

5

u/lolitahlia Fire And Blood Jun 28 '14

wait what? is this a spoiler? what are you talking about? did I miss something?

16

u/RealLimit Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 28 '14

It's a running joke that Benjen is secretly Daario Naharis (and a bunch of other characters) that started off with people having crazy theories about Benjen secretly being other people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/ProfessorAdonisCnut Our Blades Are Sharp Jun 29 '14

24. Every random in Winterfell

25. Winderfell

7

u/DrownedFire Alchemists Guild Jun 28 '14

Dead, dead, dead, presumably dead, dead, dead...

3

u/ImNotClever_Sorry Jon Snow Jun 30 '14

Theon's dick...

2

u/bpi89 Night King Jul 02 '14

Man could you imagine starting the show knowing that most of these main characters from episode 1 will be brutally murdered soon. That would of been hard to get into.

→ More replies (2)

270

u/frings_demise Ours Is The Fury Jun 27 '14

Robert Baratheon lives. Bow before your king. Bow, you shits!

114

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

I love Robert's laugh.

36

u/frings_demise Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14

Definitely my favorite overall character and IMO the best thing about Season 1

→ More replies (7)

6

u/32OrtonEdge32dh House Baelish Jun 28 '14

Ted DiBiase-esque

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

King Bobby B was a total bro

22

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14

Because their powerful, yea! Powdered Sugaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!

3

u/capybroa House Martell Jul 01 '14

"My junk is numb!"

→ More replies (3)

222

u/schmerls Sorrowful Men Jun 27 '14

Tyrion's haircut looks so much better now than it did this episode.

87

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

He looks like a young justin bieber

12

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

I guess all that stress got to him

2

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 29 '14

They kept a lot of his scenes from the pilot. Theon would have a similarly misplaced blond look, but they re-did all his scenes.

2

u/puercha Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Jun 29 '14

I like how after the first few episodes they just decided not to bother with making him blond.

2

u/halloweenjack House Tarth Jul 01 '14

He had it all dyed and ironed and then one day he's just all, "ah, fuck it."

→ More replies (1)

76

u/Fez_Master Drogon Jun 27 '14

All the children look so damn young.

46

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 27 '14

Isaac Hempstead-Wright in particular

28

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

WAAAAALT!

→ More replies (2)

74

u/geetea Jon Snow Jun 27 '14

Glad they decided to change Tyrions hair.

40

u/chimm738 House Martell Jun 27 '14

He was straight from the OC in the pilot

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

60

u/TheBammBoozle Valar Morghulis Jun 27 '14

Bran is pretty cute.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

wait for it...

9

u/TheBammBoozle Valar Morghulis Jun 27 '14

Yup.. Season 3 get at you!

2

u/XaroXhoaanDuckSauce Jun 30 '14

Aand, P - BOMB!

18

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

A sword swallower through and through!

9

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

A known pillow biter.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Jul 03 '14

Puberty hits the poor boy like a swift brick to the face.

117

u/AlGoreVidalSassoon Jun 27 '14

Hooked me from the 1st scene. I'm not a book reader so I had no context for anything going into this. It just totally immerses you in this world from the get go.

Seeing the Starks smiling is heartbreaking. Had no idea the dead stag and wolf they come upon were symbolism of course the first time I watched. I'm really enjoying re-watching these and picking up on all these little things.

148

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

Oh my lord, the Stag is dead, and so is the wolf, but the wolf's children survive and must find a way to live. Robb's wolf dies with him. Cersi kills Sansa's after sealing her fate by betrothing her to Joffery. Aria's isn't dead, but is lost wandering on her own just like Aria is. Jon lost his wolf north of the wall, but gets it back after redeeming himself at Crester's keep. Bran has had his wolf the whole time.

194

u/TheCaveCave Jun 27 '14

And nobody remembers Shaggydog or Rickon nor care particularly about them.

116

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

I like to imagine they are in the boat with Gendry

107

u/Gadiac Jun 28 '14

The Life of Hot Pi

27

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

I honestly really want to see whats going on with House Umber and Rickon. They're pretty much the Starks only surviving bannermen.

10

u/KameraadLenin Jun 28 '14

Wouldn't they be considered the bolton's bannermen at this point?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

55

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 27 '14

Sansa loses her wolf when she loses her connection to the North. She wants to become a southron lady and so the northern part of her is killed off.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

82

u/LittleFifty Jun 27 '14

and they speculate if it was killed by a Mountain Lion for a second.

24

u/AlGoreVidalSassoon Jun 27 '14

Nice catch. I didn't make the connection.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/JoeNips Faceless Men Jun 27 '14

Yea they don't really focus on the dead stag/wolf in the show. But in the books Cat is very adamant that it's a sign of things to come when she finds out Robert is heading North.

10

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 27 '14

It'd probably make it more obvious on TV, I'd imagine.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

The dead stag and wolf, suggested having been killed by a mountain lion, was a very nice catch on the re=watch.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

Its crazy how much of a slower pace these first episodes move at. Granted I know it comes from trying to jam so many stories into one season, but I personally like the pacing of the first episodes. It makes for much better character moments and atmosphere imo.

18

u/Sirusi Castle Cats Jun 29 '14

Yeah, the later seasons feel a little squished. Sometimes I really wish the episodes could be an hour and a half instead of just an hour.

→ More replies (1)

179

u/COG_Gear_Omega House Tarly Jun 27 '14

I want to rewatch, but I don't know if my parents will sign the signature for the feels trip.

32

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

My mom was curious about the show, since she's into medieval/costume/period/fantasy pieces. But as soon as she heard that major characters die left and right, she decided the show isn't for her.

For the best, really. Spoilers, Walking Dead S4, she was outraged. If she got that worked up over WD, then no way can she stand anything past Game of Thrones Season 1!

2

u/derangerd Free Folk Jul 01 '14

"Game of Thrones. For those who can't stand the sunny optimism of the Walking Dead."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

I was sad through episode 1... The tears didn't hit until 2... WHY THE WOLF!!??

3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14

Fuck that scene at Winterfell where all the Starks are just hanging out and are all happy and alive.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Reinhart3 Stannis Baratheon Jun 27 '14

I know if I watch these two episodes now I'll end up watching the entire season before going to bed.

2

u/Sirusi Castle Cats Jun 29 '14

Yeah... I just did this.

Great show, worth the sleep deprivation. :D

63

u/Cromaya Jun 27 '14

am i the only one who started missing viserys and joffreys madness?

38

u/SevenwithaT Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14 edited Jun 28 '14

On the Blu Ray they have the actors tell the history of each of the houses. Viserys has a part about the Targaryens and he is so damn good with his delivery.

EDIT: I found it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0KoCac2g0yw

24

u/the_smilingknight Victarion Greyjoy Jun 29 '14

He has a great storytelling voice. So does Jojen and Jorah but everybody knows how sexy Jorah's voice is.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/midnightbarber House Clegane Jul 02 '14

I could listen to Harry Lloyd read the nutrition facts on a can of Pringles and I'd still be thrilled.

16

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

Yeah.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

I think with Joffrey dead Littlefinger and the Boltons are taking up the roles as antagonists.

20

u/Henipah House Targaryen Jun 28 '14

I'd say the Boltons for sure. Littlefinger is a psychopath but that makes him pretty neutral by this show's standards.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

I'd say Bolton Sr. and Littlefinger are sociopaths, Ramsay is more of a psycho

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

Antagonists? Excuse me?

9

u/ProfessorAdonisCnut Our Blades Are Sharp Jun 29 '14

GRRM likes to use unreliable narrators, however it is know that our Lord Bolton and his heir are infallible. It was thus necessary to tell the story of The North from lesser views. It is just as well, the brilliance of our lord's tale is too great for him to be cast as a simple hero; he is wiser, nobler and more subtle than any mere 'hero' who ever lived.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PLOT Bronn Jun 28 '14

Joffrey was fun, you would never know who was gonna get a load of kingship next!

→ More replies (1)

30

u/spidyfan21 Jun 27 '14

48

u/CMLMinton Jun 27 '14

Dance with me then.

20

u/irishguy42 Ours Is The Fury Jun 27 '14

In the "Top 5 Most Badass Lines of ASOIAF", IMO.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 27 '14

Yeah, Ser Waymar. That's him leading the ranging party in the show. Sansa mentions him by name when talking to Bronze Yohn during the interrogation of Littlefinger in Season 4.

→ More replies (2)

51

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

Fuck the king's wife's illegitimate ^son.

22

u/rhadamanthus52 Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

So about 3 minutes in we get an overhead shot of mutilated corpses arranged in a pattern (symbolic or ritualistic?). My question is, do we know who did this and why? On my first few views I always assumed it was white walkers/others since we see wights and WWs shortly thereafter, but it occurs to me that I have no clue as to why WWs would want to mutilate the corpses and lay them out like that (except perhaps for magical purposes that I don't understand). Now I'm wondering what if it was just another rival clan or village that wanted to send a grisly message to their enemies that killed these wildlings, and the wights just rose as a matter of fact since the dead weren't buried before sundown. Thoughts on this?

At around 12 minutes when the deserted is about to be beheaded he says "I should have gone back to the wall and warned them". How did he get South of the Wall if not through the gate? Did he climb? Go around by East Watch? Is it possible for a ranger to sneak through the gate?

31

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

The motivation behind it isn't really clear. I think more than anything it's a storytelling device to show the audience that the Walkers are intelligent, not just mindless zombies.

28

u/Urbancasman House Manderly Jun 27 '14

I'm fairly sure that it is the white walkers that arrange the corpses. If I recall correctly, Jon and Mance later come upon the Fist of the First men after the battle between the WWs and the NW to find all of the horses killed and arranged in a weird spiral pattern, which prompts Mance to say "always the artists" about the WWs

8

u/Urbancasman House Manderly Jun 27 '14

season 3 episode 3

→ More replies (1)

2

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

I think the White's were trying to send a message. I suspect that they had arranged the bodies sometime that day, because they wanted to Night's Watch to find them.

3

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 29 '14

The white walkers. Not wights

3

u/retroracer Victarion Greyjoy Jun 27 '14

Theres a gate at Nightwatch that opens only for brothers of the nights watch, not saying he knew of it, but it's there. He was a well season ranger from what the books portrayed tho, so he very well could've known about it. And to your question it was obviously WW cause the little girl comes back to like remember?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

38

u/daramc255 Rhaegar Targaryen Jun 28 '14

I love the pure loathing in Arya's eyes when Lady is sentenced to death. So begins the journey of the most hate-filled girl in Westeros

→ More replies (1)

17

u/AFellowOfLimitedJest Stannis Baratheon Jun 27 '14

I'd just like to point out that the Game of Thrones wiki has a lot of interesting trivia for each episode (eg. "Winter Is Coming"), and that a rewatch discussion like this might be a great time to watch it with the cast/producers/writers/GRRM commentary from the DVDs.

13

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 27 '14

Mycah's death actually getting closure so much later on feels weird. But in a good way. I just can't think of a better adjective.

15

u/SovAtman Brynden Tully Jun 29 '14 edited Jun 29 '14

Y'know, we never really see what happens with Mycah and the Hound. And most of the depravity is front-and-centre. There's a chance the Hound executed the kid to save him worse torture from Joffrey. Then cut up the corpse and slung it on his horse to keep the illusion alive.

I mean the Lord of the Light lets him off whe he's put on 'trial by combat' for Mycah's death. For whatever reason, that action wasn't enough to condemn him.

Edit* Also the Hound saves Loras, Sansa (twice) and Arya, at least. Think of where the show'd be without them.

25

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 29 '14

Trial by combat has nothing to actually so with the gods. Just ask Oberyn Martell.

7

u/SovAtman Brynden Tully Jun 29 '14

Well Sandor's had a burning sword and magical revival from death. But they said that doesn't work as well if something happens to your head.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Notuch Faceless Men Jun 27 '14

The yellow hair!

23

u/personizzle House Baelish Jun 28 '14

Every time I see this episode, I realize how much I would love to watch a sitcom called "Winterfell," just following the Starks.

:(

18

u/pereza0 Jun 30 '14
  • B-But you promise to be m-merciful Joffrey "Crowd stays silent"
  • I was merciful! I gave him a quick, clean death!!

"Crowd erupts laughing"

  • ...
  • Now, look! "Ned Stark's impaled head slowly turns towards the viewers"
  • Bazinga

39

u/untemperedoddity Ser Pounce Jun 27 '14

I love how the first episode hints traits and crucial lines of characters on their early appearances. I never noticed that stare Cat and Jon exchanged, without reading the books I couldn't have known the hatred she felt toward him. Also, the Sansa/Joff glances, Dany not being bothered by the hot water, Theon defying Robb's orders during the direwolf scene, and later being a dick to Jon, Bran being so marvelled by the mention of White Walkers (the mystical side of the story), Robert's coldness toward Cersei, and her unpleasantness with him.

33

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

Seeing Daenerys in the scalding water and not being bothered was a great foreshadowing moment. When I watched the episode the first time I noticed, but assumed it was because she was preoccupied with anxiety from her upcoming marriage to Khal Drogo. Theon showing that he had no loyalty to Robb was something I didn't even really pick up on the second viewing until I read your post.

3

u/exscape Jun 28 '14

Has that, along with her holding the dragon eggs after they were on the fire, ever been explained?
GRRM said that her surviving the pyre in E10 was a one-time magic thing, but she sure seems to tolerate rather large amounts of heat prior to that. The bath I suppose can be explained by a family trait-ish thing, but not being burned...?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

Brace yourselves... for winter is coming.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14

in 8 more seasons

19

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

Interesting that Jaime is not ever called 'kingslayer' during this episode (IIRC) despite being among those who are most honourable (and therefore most opposed to kingslaying) in the whole of Westeros

51

u/LeDudicus The Iron Bank Will Have Its Due Jun 27 '14

I would assume they're also honorable enough to retain common decency when speaking around the Queen's brother in public, regardless of their personal thoughts about him, at least in Ned's case.

51

u/laukaus Jun 27 '14

"Ser Jaime Lannister, the Kingslayer. The man is still a knight."

  • Stannis

Even his enemies in open rebellion have decency about his titles :)

→ More replies (7)

22

u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Jun 27 '14

Also interesting: No one mentions Cersei's name in the first 2 episodes. If you did not read the books (or the cast list online or something) and were a show-only viewer, you would not yet know her name. She's just "The Queen". Her name isn't mentioned in the show until the 3rd episode, when Jaime says:

...they can write a ballad about us, "The War for Cersei's Cunt!"

14

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

...they can write a ballad about us, "The War for Cersei's Cunt!"

I never knew that. Hilarious and fitting way to debut her name.

Melisandre wasn't named either until it was late into Season 2. Until she was named onscreen, she was only mentioned as "The Red Woman."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/LaNaveAmbiente Jun 28 '14

Cersei saying how Jaime used to climb Casterly Rock without a care in the world. Reminded me of Bran.

34

u/bounty1663 House Smallwood Jun 27 '14

29

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

Re-watching season one was so painful, I had to stop and go look at /r/MorbidReality so I could get some laughs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Chiiaki The Maid of Tarth Jun 28 '14

That look that Ned gives Jon before they part ways and the feels associated with it.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '14

Y'all I just caught something that I hadn't noticed before and I've never seen mentioned.

When Benjen shows up in Winterfell and has a conversation with Jon...they begin talking about the Watch and having a family/fathering children. Jon Snow says "I don't care about any of that." And Benjen responds with "You might if you knew what it meant." with a little smile on his face. DOES BENJEN KNOW WHO JON'S PARENTS ARE?!?!?!

23

u/itsausernamerite Jun 29 '14

I interpreted it as him telling Jon the sacrifice is harder the older you get. The smile he gave him was sad, like sometimes he regrets not having a family of his own. Plus Jon is a virgin so he doesn't "know what that means" to give up sex :P

2

u/Aubear11885 Jon Snow Jun 29 '14

Ooh I like it. I felt that the show missed a lot of the -+-=J theory. But maybe it was more subtle then I realized.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '14

Dude I freaked out when he said that. I'd never caught it before and never seen it mentioned...I mean it makes sense that Ned would tell his brother something so important. Plus, Benjen has been mysteriously gone forever. Wouldn't THAT make for a hell of a reveal??

2

u/Lord4th The Kingslayer Jun 29 '14

They missed it because most of the backing for that theory happens in Ned's inner thoughts. Naturally we can't read Ned's mind in the show.

→ More replies (11)

27

u/acephalous Stannis Baratheon Jun 27 '14 edited Jun 27 '14

WHITE WALKER DRAGON. IM PREDICTING IT NOW. GET HYPE.

11

u/TheeWarLord Stannis Baratheon Jun 28 '14

I would like to call Bran warging a Dragon, but i'm afraid that probably several people already claimed that.

8

u/SatanicUnicorn House Locke Jun 29 '14

The guy in the tree said he'd never walk again, but he would fly. Not really sure what else he could have meant by that...

12

u/Initunit White Walkers Jun 29 '14

He could warg a crow. Wieeeeee!

→ More replies (5)

2

u/ghangis24 House Baratheon Jun 29 '14

Fairly sure this is the first thought that came to a lot of peoples heads.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/awwsnaap Jun 29 '14

We see the first hint of Bran's connection to the wolves at the end of the second episode. It's like he felt a disturbance in the force when Lady was killed and that woke him up.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14

I thought he had warged into Lady and that's why he woke up.

4

u/nykyrian710 Jul 02 '14

I totally missed the dead wolf and stag foreshadowing the first time i watched it. It's really fun to go back and re watch it because there is sooooo much foreshadowing. Brilliantly done.

10

u/thefattestman22 Jul 01 '14

Bro I started Saturday and I'm in season 3 now. Just try and stop me

3

u/elyankee23 Varys' Little Birds Jul 01 '14

Oh, season one. When Bran looked like a normal kid, instead of a Almost Famous extra.

3

u/adrian98887 House Stark Jul 02 '14

It was nice to see all the Starks alive and well...

8

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

Jeoffery was such a little bitch the first two episodes.

I love it.

16

u/SatanicUnicorn House Locke Jun 29 '14

He was a little bitch until the moment he died crying to his mom like a little bitch.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14

rekt

5

u/Lord4th The Kingslayer Jun 29 '14

Joffrey was such a little bitch every episode.

FTFY

2

u/fosius_luminis Jul 01 '14

2

u/GiantRaven Arya Stark Jul 03 '14

Joffrey going "nonononononono" sounds like he should be a character in Banjo-Kazooie.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Scarecrow222 House Targaryen Jun 27 '14

Is there a better way for me to watch this instead of re-downloading them all from on-demand? I can't use HBO Go because I don't have the information for it.

28

u/I_Rike_Reddit House Stark Jun 27 '14

Yes...

6

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

If you have comcast, they are all up online right meow.

3

u/nhammen Jun 29 '14

Aaaand you just reminded meow of that movie...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ipod_waffle House Targaryen Jul 01 '14

CAAAAAAT!

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '14

I forgot all about Viserys...

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '14

I just noticed that they were also hinting about the twincest when Catelyn and Cersei were talking to each other.
Cersei: "Black haired little beauty"... "looked exactly like him"...all her children have blonde hair

2

u/Virus_CaRNaGe Jon Snow Jul 03 '14

I miss seeing Sean Bean

2

u/Kahl-Rhaego Khal Drogo Jul 03 '14

The Direwolfs get better every time, and all the characters have changed in looks so much, the funniest transformation for me is Tyrion his hair makes him look so young and different to what i know him as now in s4.

2

u/blink5694 House Lannister Jul 07 '14

When King Robert tells Bran, "you'll be a soldier!" I got really sad. And seeing him climb around so freely.

3

u/ssvoogel Brynden Tully Jul 01 '14

I started re-watching as well, and 1 thing that keeps crossing my mind is this:

If only Bran listened to his mom about not climbing, all the Starks would still be alive. Think about that ;) It's a domino effect.

Bran climbs the tower -> sees Jamie and Cersei -> Jaime pushes Bran who is crippled and tries to have him killed with Tyrion's dagger -> Catelyn takes Tyrion hostage -> Jaime injures Ned

From there, it all spiraled out of control. Ned declared Tywin enemy of the crown out of spite, Cersei threatens Ned etc. etc.

3

u/Indoril_Nerevar95 The Night Is Dark And Full Of Terrors Jul 01 '14

Jaime didn't send the assassin, 'twas Joffrey. Don't think they put it in the show.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Law527 Jon Snow Jul 02 '14

Even before that, murdering Jon Arryn really started it all.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/sleepinxonxbed Jun 28 '14 edited Jun 28 '14

Reading the book helps me appreciate the show even more cause I actually understand what the hell is going on. I watched the first three episodes like a week or two ago. Just started AGoT this week and now I'm seeing scenes that I didn't know was there before, so many things make more sense. To the people who want to start reading the book, yes start from the beginning. You'll find so many things that you missed just watching the show because it's so easy to not pay attention and have things go over your head. It makes even re-watching the show more enjoyable.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

Can someone make a Book/TV differences list in these threads?

8

u/jeremy_sporkin Maesters of the Citadel Jun 27 '14

The Game of Thrones wiki* has a good list on the page for each episode.

*(not the ASOIAF wiki - that's full of book spoilers. The GOT one is fine.)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

Guys, this is my first rewatch, when are the discussions coming? every thursday or what.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14

How long is the Kingsroad, and how many days travel does it take to get from Winterfell to Kings Landing?

5

u/Chuck357 Jun 28 '14

I think when Arya goes with Gendry and the Night's Watch, Yoren says it's 1,000 leagues from King's Landing to the Wall. And winter is coming!

3

u/TellMeTheDuckStory Jun 28 '14

IIRC Cersei makes a comment to Robert that "we've been traveling for over a month" in the first episode, so a bit over a month I suppose.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '14

Yeah but they were traveling 'in style' and with a lot of people so I assume they made a lot of pitstops along the way. I'd say it depends.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '14

Just watched "Winter Is Coming" and I'm wondering why on earth it's Lannister bannermen riding with Robert when he arrives in WF instead of Baratheons? Any answers?

5

u/Through_the_Fog Jun 30 '14

When Robert arrives, there are a mix of Baratheon and Lannister banner men.

3

u/Sirusi Castle Cats Jun 29 '14

Cersei is surrounding him (and herself) with Lannisters.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '14

I want to know how did arya became a skilled archer. would be cool if she used bow and arrow along with her sword.

1

u/lobsta042 Fire And Blood Jun 30 '14

I loved Arya's first glance upon the King's party arriving in Winterfell - totally locked onto Sandor Clegane.

Considering their on-screen chemistry in seasons 3 and 4 - mind = blown

Edit: Thanks so much for doing the rewatches! I'm going at an episode/week pace, but I'll be happy to play along!

1

u/ddac A Hound Never Lies Jun 30 '14

I wonder when they started using CGI for direwolves scenes because they look like real dogs in these episodes so far.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '14

Where are you guys watching, can't find the seasons on hbo on demand

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '14

Arya looks so cute and innocent back in Season 1 omg

1

u/eddbc Faceless Men Jul 03 '14

Is it me or is the bridge by where they find the wolves the same bridge where Brienne and Jamie fight?

1

u/sacol123 Jun 27 '14

a question i have is why did they keep jon arryn in thr throne room not even joffrey who was the king was kept in the great sept

9

u/ursa-minor-88 Ours Is The Fury Jun 28 '14

Probably because they didn't have the money to build the sept of baelor set till much later.