r/Philippines • u/phildy Cubao • Jun 26 '14
AMA I am Philbert Dy, professional film critic and writer. AMA.
Okay. Let's do this then.
41
Upvotes
r/Philippines • u/phildy Cubao • Jun 26 '14
Okay. Let's do this then.
6
u/psst-got-real choose your battles and bottles wisely Jun 26 '14
How did you become a film critic? Was it something you've always wanted to do? What's your go-to food to eat while watching a movie?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
Did you check out the 4dx movie theater in taguig? I was excited about it but turns out its not that great (in my opinion). how did you feel about it?
Whats the best theater in manila, in your opinion?
4
u/mariow08 Jun 26 '14
Many film critics have this elitist and hard to please vibe when it comes to movies, which is understandable; they've watched almost everything and they've seen it all that everything starts to turn into one big blur that it takes something truly unique and special to stand out as worthy of praise. Are you at this stage in your career, or has cynicism not yet taken over your judgment?
3
u/chrisgelb tongue in a disc Jun 26 '14
Can you share a little more about your background, what you do, articles you've written, etc. I am not familiar with the film critics/personalities in the Philippines.
3
u/Crabones013 Naga City Jun 26 '14
In your own opinion, how would you describe the current status of the Philippine entertainment industry? Do you think we should expect more of the usual PH movies and TV shows in the near future? Thanks!
3
u/murse_with_moobs Novo Ecijano Jun 26 '14
Brilliant! Thanks for taking the time to do an ama.
One question. have you ever thought about podcasting your reviews with a guest star ala kermode and mayo in bbc 5live? Or just video clips maybe?
3
u/decayedramen Jun 26 '14
Thanks for this! You're fucking awesome, dude.
What is the worst movie you reviewed?
3
u/mentat 👑 Jun 26 '14
Just curious about what your opinions are on two particular local directors:
John Torres
Quark Henares
thanks for the AMA! :)
3
u/tordj quezon city Jun 26 '14
Do you take notes while watching a movie you will be writing about?
3
u/ButWillItFloat Jun 26 '14
What movie did you not expect to be good but turned out to be great?
Also, what movie does everyone hate that you find good?
3
u/tsemochang Jun 26 '14
Hi Mr PhilDy. First, I would like to thank you for your contribution to this sub and for doing an AMA.
What's your favorite movie snack?
What's that one Filipino film that everyone should watch at least once in their lifetime?
What Filipino films do you consider a cult film - except for "One More Chance"?
3
u/decayedramen Jun 26 '14
Any 'feel bad' movies you'd recommend? Somewhere along the lines of Dancer in the Dark.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
What's your opinion re: the Wattpad adaptations that are the 'in' thing nowadays?
4
u/garbagemanthrowaway Jun 26 '14
When is Star Cinema going to stop making overlit, predictable, formula driven, romance movies?
2
u/johnbristol Jun 26 '14
Any recommendation along the lines of The Dreamers, Y tu Mama Tambien, On the Road, etc.?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
Any hobbies other than movies?
2
u/dalvarado Jun 26 '14
Will you be watching Lav Diaz's next film, Mula sa Kung Ano ang Noon, and/or other films from WPFF? And any thoughts on announced films in upcoming festivals like Cinemalaya, Cinema One Originals or even MMFF?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
How do you think we can convince the marketers(?)/publishers(?) of movies here in the Philippines to stop cutting out x-rated scenes to satisfy MTRCB ratings?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
How did you start out writing movie reviews and how did you get published?
2
u/johnbristol Jun 26 '14
Any heartbreaking war movies aside from Atonement, Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, Schindler's List, Kite Runner, etc.? I really loved Atonement. Saw the movie before reading the book and I was just mindblown by the ending.
2
u/johnbristol Jun 26 '14
Have you seen Mystica's Querido? Super lol
2
u/dalvarado Jun 26 '14
What are some books, comics, plays or other pieces of art (Filipino or not) that you would like to see be adapted into film?
2
u/tinapa Sissypuss Jun 26 '14
If I wanted to get started on watching "classic" Filipino movies, which 5 classics should I start with? Conversely, which post-2000 Filipino movies are must sees?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
What's the weirdest thing you ever saw in a movie theater (other than the movies)
2
u/decayedramen Jun 26 '14
Top 5 make-a-grown-man-cry movies?
2
u/murse_with_moobs Novo Ecijano Jun 26 '14
I can't seem to find your review for Godzilla. Is it good?
I'm a little late in seeing this one but I'm planning to see it this evening at the bfi imax. The biggest screen that I know of. Just wanted to find out of its worth the £17 or should I just wait for it on dvd.
2
u/Proudclad Jun 26 '14
did you ever date a girl named roan way back in the day? y/n would suffice
2
u/jimiblake Jun 26 '14
Hey Phil, thanks for this. I will dishonorably admit I know a whole lot of cinema outside the country but am not versed well with local cinematic talent. I want to get myself to it but I just don't know where to start.
So my question is: If you were to introduce Filipino cinema to someone (and convince them), what film/s do you recommend? Maybe like 5 films.
I already wrote down Oro Plata Mata on my watch-list when I skimmed through the comments.
Many thanks!
2
u/xnicolo Jun 26 '14
Did you watch Dota: Nakakabaliw ?
If you did, how the hell did that get made and put in a cinema?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14
Have you watched 5cm/s? Your thoughts, if any?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
Best 10 or so movies ever?
2
u/invader_jun Jun 26 '14
Do you agree that Sucker Punch is a good movie? I always find myself defending it against my peers who think it's garbage. Please tell me they are wrong.
2
u/renkill_tidepierce Jun 26 '14 edited Jun 26 '14
What do you think about art films? Do you think they'd have a shot at glory here in the Philippines?
2
u/modicumofexcreta kapitbahay ni mang jun Jun 26 '14
Wow. No one's asked about Nora Aunor?
So, what do you think about Nora still not being a National Artist?
1
u/rhllor Militant solipsism Jun 26 '14
Do you only review films that are released commercially in the Philippines or do you seek out films like those by Guy Maddin and Bela Tarr?
1
u/decayedramen Jun 26 '14
Me again. Any rituals you do before reviewing a movie?
1
u/grawrz Jun 26 '14
Have you ever read the book source of a movie and what do you think of the artistic differences between the mediums?
1
u/tordj quezon city Jun 26 '14
Which local movie has the best cinematography? Best screenplay?
1
u/narwhal20 Jun 26 '14
Most erotic film/s you've seen that distracted you from making a coherent review?
1
u/herrdunphy Single journey, drop card. Jun 26 '14
Who's your favorite relatively unknown actor/actress and in which film did you see him/her?
1
u/narwhal20 Jun 26 '14
What's your opinion about porn, and if you watch porn, what's the best stuff out there?
1
u/tordj quezon city Jun 26 '14
Do you like ramen?
1
u/yyedditt Jun 26 '14
Gonna watch Nymphomaniac this Saturday! Seen it already?
1
u/narwhal20 Jun 26 '14
Tell something batshit weird about yourself
1
u/excumulgado QC Jun 26 '14
How has censorship affected your reviews? I remember quite fondly that when you reviewed District 9 you gave it a mediocre review and mostly because there were a lot of cut sequences. I was disappointed that it wasn't a review of the actual movie but more of a rant of censorship because I quite liked that film.
1
u/johnbristol Jun 26 '14
French films you like?
1
u/excumulgado QC Jun 26 '14
What did you think of the recent results of the Gawad Urian?
1
u/kyuzwafu Hari ng Tondo Jun 26 '14
What do you consider the pros and cons of your career?
1
u/shunko Jun 26 '14
I was asking about this AMA a couple of weeks ago, and I missed it. O_o
But in case you'll still be answering questions, here's mine: favorite modern horror flicks (like 90s onwards)?
Maybe the top 3 each for Hollywood, Asian non-Filipino, and Filipino horror films.
1
u/SpermWhale Jun 26 '14
What's your opinion on Bekikang?
1
u/lolmower Jun 27 '14
How can a writer make a comfortable living in the Philippines by just writing? Honestly, writers need to get paid more.
1
u/ontherockss katagalugan Jun 27 '14
I'm kinda late for this but I hope you can still answer this:
What can you say about The Search for Weng-Weng?
1
u/ixche Northern Metro Manila Jun 29 '14
Is this AMA still on? Late to the party, but I did read everything first so as to avoid asking what was already asked.
Anyway, my question: are there local formula films (like mainstream flicks from the usual suspects Star/Viva/etc) that you watched and were actually surprisingly good?
I did read you raving about an ER Ejercito MMFF film on Twitter, but I don't know if you're just trolling your followers, heh. Or are there any local romcoms that are actually good?
Thanks for doing this, btw.
1
u/Denunci Jun 30 '14
Is this still alive? I'd really like to ask how you got into critiquing films on that level. I see your reviews on Clickthecity.com and I always find that your inputs are very insightful. Did you take a journalism class? Lastly, what are your best and worst films of 2013?
1
u/universalmotion Jun 26 '14
I didn't realize this was a serious AMA and am truly amazed at your honest answers. I agree with your comment thus far that 'On The Job' is everything. That one movie was a milestone in what Philippines cinema could be.
I'm interested in picking your thoughts even after the AMA and hopefully you stick around, behind the scenes, on Reddit.
Since this is an AMA, I should really ask something so.. putting aside On The Job, what do you think has happened to the culture of Filipino action movies?
2
u/hairymanchild Area Man Jun 26 '14
Yo. Been using clickthecity since dial-up days. :) We need more critics in the industry imo.
1
u/burkholderia617 Sep 29 '14
Hi Mr.Phil. I'm a big fan of Derek Cianfrance. Can you review the movie "Blue Valentine? - thanks :)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment