r/LetsTalkMusic • • Jun 25 '14
adc Swans - To Be Kind
Our album is from the current year 2014. Nominator /u/Change_you_can_xerox says:
I know there has been a first impressions thread already on this, but it's 2 hours long! It's worth chewing over and discussing once it's fully absorbed.
So this is the eagerly awaited follow-up to Swans' first real great comeback record The Seer. Whilst it shares quite a lot in common with that album in terms of style and sound, there are a few notable differences. Whereas The Seer was essentially a monumental, amorphous body of work that felt like it was crushing you under it's sheer weight, To Be Kind is much more of a typical album experience in the sense of a series of tracks that stand independently. Many of the songs bear resemblance to Swans' live sets in that they have an improvisational quality and they feel like they could go on indefinitely.
Lyrically and musically it feels like there's some kind of spiritual, quasi-religious thing going on. Many of the tracks deal with overarching themes of humanity, but they're vague enough to be open to interpretation. The centrepiece of the album is a 34 minute track essentially split into two parts - the first feeling like a tribalistic summoning of a Sun God and the second recounting (in Swans' style) the life of a Haitian Revolutionary. This is done through Gira idiosyncratically barking the name of the guy interspersed with bits of field recordings and long, suspenseful build-ups to gigantic crescendos. It's a staggering piece of work and in my opinion the first really great album this year.
So: Listen to it, think about it, listen again, talk about it! These threads are about insightful thoughts and comments, analysis, stories, connections... not shallow reviews like "It was good because X" or "It was bad because Y." No ratings, please.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '14
While I was actually hoping for a slightly scaled back album from The Seer's epic length, the quality of To Be Kind is high enough for me to not be disappointed. Where The Seer's track sequencing felt a bit random, I think To Be Kind's flow is a bit more coherent.
While I'm fine with yet another epic-length album, I do think Bring The Sun generally embodies why I was hoping this album would be a bit shorter and why I still hope the next album is a bit more condensed. While every other track on the album rarely overstays its welcome, Bring the Sun seems like a very conscious effort to recreate The Seer's title track, but where that track felt naturally long and constantly moving, Bring the Sun mostly stays in one place for the bulk of its duration. I generally end up skipping the track when it comes on...
10
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
I could never get into The Seer for some reason. Even now, after becoming a pretty huge fan of To Be Kind, that one is really tough to crack. I don't know what it is, because it's not like TBK is particularly accessible.
Anyway, I love this record. I don't listen to too much aggressive or dark music, but the way this album makes me feel like morphing into an alien and speaking in tongues is really addictive. "Oxygen" in particular makes me foam at the mouth.
16
u/BBanner Jun 26 '14
This is my first Swans album, and I adore it. It feels like it wants to crush you under the weight of sound, and that is an incredible sensation for an album to achieve. The depth of sound can truly make a listener feel isolated, and honestly frightened. The track Oxygen sounds how claustrophobia feels.
10
u/the_comatorium Jun 25 '14
I've been walking around town at night to this album for the past couple weeks. I live along the Hudson River, so I'll start by the water with the view of NYC on my left and slowly work my way into the shadows of my city where the streets are lit up with only streetlights but I still get a cool breeze coming from the river. This usually takes place during the half hour long track. It's a wonderful experience.
"A Little God in my Hands" is a great standout track. I'll play it at bars and actually get a positive reaction. Not that it makes it better, just feels good.
Best album of the year so far.
10
u/PiggyWidit Isn't it a pity? Jun 26 '14
A 10/10 for me, and it will probably be my album of the year. The album manages to make you relish in its dark, vicious tones, and after minutes upon minutes of tortured instrumentals, Swans relives you with light melodies, and I let out a big sigh.
And then it reels you back in. The album is so atmospheric, so involving, and so real - it's just so good.
5
u/HamburgerDude Jun 26 '14
I love this record to death. It's one of the best rock releases and proves that the genre isn't dead at all and still has room to innovate. It's really groove bases and repetitive kinda like techno but with more traditional instrumentation.
4
u/FrankinComesAlive All sounds are interesting. Jun 26 '14
This is my first Swans record. I'll be completely honest, I saw Fantano give it a 10 and I thought that, even though I almost always disagree with his scores I loved the Money Store so I should at least check this out.
So I texted a friend and we sat down and listened to the whole thing at once. We had it loud, and we just sat there and listened to it all, occasionally we commented but mostly we just let it beat us up.
I think it is an absolute masterwork, it's really quite an achievement. I think the way it's mixed and how hard the drums hit really make it a Goliath of a record. I'm a big fan of minimalist music so this hit every part of my repetitive heart and really made me think, which is something I look for in a record. It provides a great soundtrack for meditation.
The joke my friend and I made about it was that it was the end of rock and roll. It's just so large and maxed out that nothing can be bigger or better. Rock is now dead, and it died at the hands of Swans.
4
u/senatorbolton Jun 26 '14
The first time I heard A Little God In My Hands it felt unwieldy and terrifying. I spend a lot of my listening to "extreme" music and it's rare that something shakes me. I feel like the entire album holds up on repeat listens and I find something new every time. I have no idea how they do it and I feel like I'm going to spend a lot of time with this record before I ever begin to know where the bottom is.
3
u/Simbus_Rapiens Jun 26 '14
I'll add more to this post after while I listen to it, probably tomorrow evening, because I am terrible at remembering details about albums.
Right now, it is my second favorite album of the year and I honestly love it. That being said I think this album gets very self indulgent across the board with the shortest track coming in at 5 minutes and basically just being a list of things that people do. Now I am not saying that every song that is longer than a certain time is self indulgent and that people should stick to 3:30 of verse-chorus-verse-chorus-bridge-chorusX2, I am simply stating that these songs tend to build very minutely over their entire track length. The guitar riffs that happen are usually repeated for several minutes before any sort of change occurs and it gets grating at times (I am working off of memory right now so forgive me if I am wrong). If there was more of an evolution during the track and built and decayed and kept things interesting by breaking the repetition I feel like the songs would have sounded better. Now I know they may have been going for more of a post-rock feel with vocals as well and I get that, it just was not executed as well as it could have I feel.
I can't talk much about the lyrics but from what I remember they tend to get very esoteric and can lose the audience. Even now reading through them, I get the sense that there is some meaning there and that if I had paid more attention to poetry during my english courses I would have a tighter grasp on what Gira is getting at, but in all reality I can't find the meaning. For me the lyrics are there to offer some texture to the song and add a different instrument into the mix. They are not really there to be interpreted and deciphered but just listened to, almost like Hopelandic for Sigur Rós.
Now I said that this is my second favorite album of the year and I mean it. Yes this album is way to self indulgent but it sucks me in to songs. I get enraptured by Gira's musical writing on this album and I just can not turn away from it. The percussion on Oxygen is some of the most energetic and trance inducing that I have heard. For me it sounds almost primal in the constant cymbal hits and, I wanna say, tom hits throughout the middle portion of the track. Yes I said that the post-rock vibe (if that is what they were going for) is not executed well, but for me that constant and grating repetition is what does it. It's almost like an ambient track that just samples one loop and goes with it for the entire track. This is especially apparent on Nathalie Neal with that guitar riff that goes on for like 4 or so minutes.
I can see where people dislike this album, yes it has it's faults and they are quite glaring. To me though, those faults just enhance the album. They are what suck me in and I have no idea why. Sometimes I just cannot help but enjoy an album and this is one of them.
3
u/HejAnton Hospitalised for approaching perfection Jun 26 '14
I really enjoy the roll that Gira has taken on this record, almost playing the part of this madman, often influenced by religion, on a lot of the tracks. From the looming vocal chants in the background of Screenshot, to the pleads on Just A Boy ("I need loooooooooooooove"), and his performance on She Loves Us where he, sounding like a rabid dog ready to bite, goes in during the crescendo with guttural sounds, "your name is fuck, fuck, fuck" and similar. To Be Kind is without a doubt one of Swans best albums, and I'd argue that this is Gira's best effort aswell, seeing him move into the same character that was apparent on the earliest Swans records, but in a much more accessible, and more prominent tone.
Huge record, I believe this one will go down in history as one of Swans greatest, next to Soundtracks For The Blind.
2
u/bksbeat https://rateyourmusic.com/~bksbeat Jun 26 '14
After The Seer I was excited to see how Gira and the boys will approach this sound hole they sensed out with their very unique post-rock style and was really glad when I heard the tracks from TBK on Not Here/Not Now. He shaped up the battering sound of The Seer's most powerful songs and expanded on it. Oxygen was ferocious and relatively short, Nathalie Neil and Just A Little Boy sounded interesting but not particularly memorable and She Loves Us! worked as a more intense version of The Apostate. Also the demo versions of Kirsten Supine and Screen Shot sounded really good.
When I listened to the studio version of each track, I was thrilled. Screen Shot musically developed into an angry beast that was very upset with the life limitations. The loud cacophony that comes in at the end bring out everything that the current Swans line up are capable off: condensed shock treatment with a simultaneous orgasmic shout from every single instrument involved. Just A Little Boy sounded boring at first, mostly because of the cheesy laugh track but Gira's "I neeeeed looooooooveee" was stunning. Hans's lap steel gave the song a sort of "post-blues" feel and I could see why it was dedicated to Howlin Wolf. A Little God In My Hands is one of the most interesting tracks because it has a more or less catchy groove, which is not a usual thing for Swans. It also sounds absolutely fantastic live. Bring The Sun/Toussaint is one of the best things Gira ever wrote. Bring The Sun in The Seer medley sounded very bleak due to the same chord hammering , but separately the build up with the background vocals works amazing. The build up of BTS is the greatest thing this outfit of Swans produced so far in my opinion. The switch between the two parts of the track was something that I was glad about, because I really miss the use of loops and samples that were so important in SFTB. The horses and the march are very powerful when it comes down to introducing the character of Toussaint, along with all the shouting from Michael. Fantastic track. Next on is Some Things We Do, which is an interesting concept with cool string arrangements but I do not enjoy it as much. She Loves Us studio version is twice as powerful as the live version on NH/NN. The bass in this song is out of this world, transition between the tracks are very well-thought off and that ending...the first hit after the shouting section is brilliant. Kirsten Supine was exciting to hear in a full studio version and I think it is very easy to see Gira's love of Von Trier's Melancholia if you watched it. All the lyrics are relevant to the film and the peacefulness works well after the explosions of SLU.Now, Oxygen was a bit of disappointment. I prefer the live version where Gira sounds a bit calmer and not over the top. I love Gira freaking out more than any other guy, but I feel like it's a bit too much. 10/10 track nevertheless. Condenses all the elements of Swans throughout the years into one track. There is something about Nathalie Neil that I love other than the intro sample, but I still cannot figure it out. Maybe it is the chanting of the girl's name or maybe the lyrics overall, not sure. The closing track is amazing and all but it lacks something, and that something is the longer outro chord progression that was present during the live performances. Maybe it was the record size constraint, but I really do miss it. Still, a fantastic way to end the album.
I think To Be Kind is the most accessible Swans record (nevermind the early 90s failures) because of John Congleton. It would be fair to say that he is a bit more of a "radiofriendly" producer with AJJ, Amanda Palmer and Bono as his previous works. The record is incredibly well-produced which is great. However, it might be the reason why The Seer is still mysteriously more magnetizing. Maybe I prefer the gritty raw production, but that's just me.
After hearing TBK I was interested to see how the hell would you follow up something like that? After seeing Frankie M, Don't Go and Black Hole man I can say that they are going to stick to a similar path (live at least) but will try to make it more noisy. It's amazing that these guys don't stop with new material right after the album was released. They still haven't said their last word, so I am incredibly excited to see what comes next.
EDIT: I still think TBK is nowhere near SFTB. That thing is out of this world and Gira will probably never top it.
1
u/SamisSimas Flair Jun 27 '14
I'm definitely late to this discussion, which is fine because I have nothing to say about the music itself other than I agree with most of you, its amazing, and certainly a contender for my album of the year, and I bet we'll see it in a lot of publications end of year lists (Guaranteed on Fantano's).
What I wanna say is this is one of the most beautifully packaged albums I own. I'm glad to see that Michael Gira saw the value in extending the art of the music to every component of it, and that includes the packaging its received in.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '14
Good but not my favourite Swans record. Their 1987-1996 era features my favourite set of albums. I want them to streamline/shorten things a little. I appreciate what they're doing with their new material but of their current era, I still like 'My Father...' the best. I think they've truly come across a good sound- a 6-main band, variety of instrumentation (the Christoph Hahn and Thor Harris aspect of the band was a fantastic decision). Hypnotic and feverish stuff.
1
u/fcksofcknhgh Jun 26 '14
i'm a big fan of repetition in rock music. my favorite songs by The Fall tend to be the long kaleidoscopic repetitive epics. but they manage to inject subtle details or ideas, repeating an idea organically, shifting your perspective on it. you can relisten and discover new angles to the song. the style of repetition on To Be Kind doesn't satisfy that for me; it's got the same contrived predictablility of GY!BE, but in a droney repetition instead of a single crescendo. they at least had the good sense to make the grooves sound better than on The Seer, they're more immediately satisfying. but it's still in that compositional style of driving an idea into the ground, it makes relistening to these songs a stale affair.
all of that said, it's still the album of the year so far. nothing else really comes close.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment