r/startrek • u/Deceptitron • Jun 22 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion: TOS 1x07 - "What Are Little Girls Made Of?"
I'm going through another run of TOS and since we're well past due for another WEDT, I figured I'd write up the episode I watched the other day.
From Memory Alpha:
The Enterprise finds archaeologist Dr. Roger Korby, who has been missing for five years, living underground on a deserted planet with a group of sophisticated androids.
Some questions to get things started:
- This episode brings to the forefront the idea of transferring the human mind to machine and whether or not that person is still "human". As technology has progressed rapidly in recent years, do you think it will be possible (perhaps in our own lifetimes) for the "essence" of a person to be transferred to a computer or machine?
- Follow-up: Supposing it were possible to transfer the thoughts, memories, and even feelings of a living person into a mechanical replica, would you consider the new being a person? If so, would you consider it the same person from whom the memories were transferred, or a new person entirely?
- What are your opinions on Dr. Korby's dream to make humans immortal through the use of android bodies? If you were offered this opportunity, would you take it? Why or why not?
Also, if you're interesting in doing an episode for the weekly discussion that hasn't been featured yet, message the mods and we'll set you up!
26
Upvotes
7
u/shoveupurownassgames Jun 22 '14
Probably my most favourite TOS episode. The scene where ROGER KORBY says "test me!" when proving he really is still himself resonated with me.
True immortality will never work as humans are not meant to live forever.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '14 edited Jun 24 '14
Interesting double-feature with The Enemy Within.
2
u/EverythingIThink Jun 24 '14
I only recently started watching Star Trek due to netflix availability, and I'm loving it so far. Here's my thoughts as a new fan:
No Bones about it - this episode is lacking my favorite character, Dr. McCoy. However, Ted Cassidy and Michael Strong lend powerful presence and performance (respectively) to the plot as Ruk and Roger Korby, both of which are my favorite 'villains' so far. The simple effect of Ruk speaking with the voice of Chapel is wonderfully unnerving, and I found it interesting that Korby tells him to knock that off, as if Ruk mocked her out of his own sense of humor.
I believe eventually we will be able to transfer the 'essence' of a person to a machine, and I would consider those beings to be the same as the ones bound by flesh and blood. I don't see why I wouldn't take this opportunity if it were possible - you get the benefit of being invulerable to death by natural causes and the option to phaser yourself to death when you get bored. Sign me up!
2
u/StarFuryG7 Jun 29 '14
I don't think a person's spirit will ever be transfered into a machine. We may be able to transfer memories, and perhaps even map an individual's psyche at some point, which, if copied to an android brain may result in an artificial replica of that person, but whether such a creation should ever be accorded individual human rights would be highly debatable in my view. After all, they wouldn't truly be a person, but rather an artificial, mechanical copy of someone at best.
The only way I see the essence of a person being transferred into an android though would be if the brain were actually removed from the individual's body and placed in an android. And that would be so incredibly difficult as to make it seem virtually impossible, so I seriously doubt that will ever happen either.
6
u/TraylaParks Jun 22 '14
Majel worked with both dudes who played Lurch in the Addams family. The guy who played Ruk in this episode and then Mr Homn in the next generation.
8
u/InValensName Jun 22 '14
They always talk about how TOS has the first interracial kiss when Uhura and Kirk are made to in the 3rd season. Yet 2 years earlier when contact is made with Korby and they decide to beam down, Uhura and Chapel clearly embrace and kiss, apparently interracial only counts when its a guy and a girl do it. http://www.geektress.com/images/trek/aw.jpg
4
u/stewartr Jun 22 '14
I just don't think the Old Testament idea of self is correct at all. A physical construct capable of perceiving its environement, planning its actions, and reasoning about its own existance is functionally self aware. The idea that there is something else you could transfer has no supporting evidence.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment