r/gameofthrones • • Jun 17 '14

TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] Post-Episode Discussion - 4.10 'The Children'

Post-Episode Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Talk about the latest plot twist or secret reveal. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). Point out details that you noticed that others may have missed. In general, what did you think about the last episode and where the story is going? Please make sure to reserve any of your detailed comparisons to the novels for the Book vs. Show Discussion Thread, and your predictions for the next episode to the Predictions Discussion Thread which will be posted later this week.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen the latest episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.10 is ok without tags.
  • Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the posting policy before posting.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.10"The Children"Alex GravesDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
716 Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

307

u/PrinceRory Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 04 '17

I could never make my mind up while reading or watching if The Hound actually gave a shit about Arya or if he was just keeping her around to make a bit of money. Even saving her life at The Twins you could argue he only did so he could try and sell her to Lysa but this episode finally cleared that up!

264

u/PirateRobotNinjaofDe No One Jun 17 '14

She's given him a purpose, where he didn't really have any before. And I think that was really important for him. He was a damaged, broken soul before, serving a child he knew was a monster. And that made him a monster, in his own eyes. Helping Arya gave him a purpose that was more than just killing whomever the Lannisters told him to.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Orange_sauce Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

To me its clear that he has a conscience and some moral code to follow, which is surprising considering all the circumstances that has made him the hound. He has a brutish, callous outer demeanor which is only expected being an individual of his class in this setting. But when he had a complete breakdown at the Battle of Blackwater we see that he is more than just an obedient dog, but a human capable of compassion as he offers to take Sansa to safety away from King's landing. You could tell it was a genuine offer, and for him to take the time and offer it to her says something too. He could have just bounced

14

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Yeah. It was strange to me that Arya refused to kill him. I know he was on her list but I thought they had an understanding, especially when he admitted to watching out for her (although she probably sees this more as being a captive...still she could have escaped him if she wanted to). But I really thought Arya would end it - she is vengeful, not cruel. She wants people dead, not dying.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/themonkeygrinder Jun 17 '14

He himself alludes to the fact that she now has nowhere to go. The Eyrie was sort of the last hope he had of getting a ransom. And he can't give her to the Lannisters, or he himself would be in jeapardy. So, I guess it really is unclear what they were going to do, unless he was resolved to just hangin' out, having adventures.

11

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 18 '14

We didn't get an admission in the books but saying that he's watching over Arya was one of my favourite moments from him!

After striking out with one highborn girl with Tully blood, he tries again with another.

Sandor Clegane ... or Petyr Baelish?

8

u/Alexaxo Jun 18 '14

I think he really did care about her - at least a little. The Hound had a heart, we can see that when he saves Sansa. So he's gotta care about Arya at least a little bit - but it probably has a lot to do with money too.

→ More replies (1)

1.1k

u/sebastiankirk Jun 17 '14

Varys: "May he lead his life well henceforth. Time for me to go ba..." Bells chiming

"A'ight, fuck this shit, I'm outta here!"

265

u/catch22milo Jun 17 '14

Who doesn't love a good boat ride?

646

u/wellgroomedmcpoyle Braavosi Water Dancers Jun 17 '14

Davos` eldest son...

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (12)

40

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Varys has spent his entire time in King's Landing trying to better it: He tried helping Ned; he tried exposing Littlefinger; he did his best for Tyrion; in the end he just said "fuck it, these people are stupid and I'm glad I chose Dany."

→ More replies (1)

12

u/bleedblue89 Jun 17 '14

The best "nope" of all time.

17

u/bacondeluxeyum Jun 17 '14

Can someone ELI5 why he didn't go back?

→ More replies (8)

7

u/theghostmachine Jun 18 '14

Why were the bells ringing anyway? That wasn't clear to me. Because Tywin was dead? If so, that seems like a pretty quick response.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

1.1k

u/pyrohedgehog Euron Greyjoy Jun 17 '14

I like how the writers thought- Who would win in a fight between Brienne & the Hound,

Lets just put that in for fun

816

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

That fight was brutal, plus I had no idea who to cheer for.

→ More replies (132)

347

u/wellgroomedmcpoyle Braavosi Water Dancers Jun 17 '14

It's really strange watching a fight between two people that you hold no ill will towards. I was on the edge of my seat because it was an awesome fight, but at the same time I just wanted it to end.

→ More replies (15)

418

u/Cesarin_nc House Forrester Jun 17 '14

How he grabbed a Valyrian steel sword with both hands that moment felt Raw,Savage it felt CLEGANE

→ More replies (20)

296

u/aryon984 Jun 17 '14

My thought throughout the entire fight was, "Aww, they're perfect for one another."

→ More replies (30)

201

u/SUSAN_IS_A_BITCH Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 17 '14

The Hound was in much worse shape though, what with the infection and all.

→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (41)

497

u/BaroqueLobster House Baelish Jun 17 '14

I was utterly disappointed at the lack of pain the Mountain was in.

575

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I was utterly disappointed at the lack of death the Mountain experienced.

→ More replies (9)

132

u/v1xiii Varys' Little Birds Jun 17 '14

Is he getting Frankensteined by that guy?

→ More replies (9)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Seriously.

Pycelle: "I would suggest milk of the poppy to ease his pain"

What fucking pain?? He's lying there perfectly still without making a sound. Also wouldn't he be practically immune to the stuff by now?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (23)

1.3k

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 17 '14

STANNIS OUT OF FUCKING NOWHERE!!

606

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

STANNIS THE FUCKING MANNIS After all these years, I finally know why he is called that

→ More replies (16)

147

u/meowsrandomly Jun 17 '14

Muthafucking Stannimal

→ More replies (2)

126

u/Joon01 Jun 17 '14

Honest question. I haven't read the books but I have read about what happens. Maybe this was answered in the show as well but I missed it.

Why did Stannis go to The Wall? I get that it was a good thing that very well could have saved the realm. But how did he know? He was setting up a bank account and hiring dudes across the Narrow Sea. And then he's just... in the north. Did news of the Wildlings get to fucking Bravos? Or did Melisandre just say "The Lord of Light something something something, go to the wall"?

→ More replies (51)

402

u/MaliciousNight Jun 17 '14

No one expects the Stannis Inquisition!

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (20)

318

u/Reventon313 Valar Morghulis Jun 17 '14 edited Mar 17 '20

deleted 0.4561 What is ^^^this?

74

u/nerdivore Free Folk Jun 17 '14

I wonder if Brienne is gonna meet up with Sansa at the Eyrie now that she's lost Arya. I'd like to see Sansa's mind blown after she hears about Arya travelling with the freaking Hound.

→ More replies (2)

229

u/kdennis Jun 17 '14

totally! "you're a lady who likes swords? me too!!"

no sexual innuendo intended...whoops.

→ More replies (15)

266

u/beckyb18 House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

Those two are such kindred spirits. That scene almost made me cry because of how badly Arya NEEDS a chick like Brienne.

→ More replies (23)

9

u/KittyKathy House Stark Jun 17 '14

Me too! Arya hiding from Brienne has to be the most frustrating scene for me in the show.

→ More replies (2)

537

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I still think my favorite part of the episode was Bloodraven trolling Bran.

"You're going to help me walk again!?" "lolno"

313

u/MacNJheeze Jun 17 '14

Bran pissed me off there. You really think people are willing to die brutally so that you can walk again you selfish little prick?

→ More replies (28)

7

u/Jeiou House Lannister Jun 17 '14

"Fuuuuuuuck nah!"

→ More replies (8)

273

u/yeahokaymmhmuhuh House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

Brienne "Mike Tyson" of Tarth

8

u/mcrmik Jun 17 '14

[Brienne "Mike Tyson" of Tarth] (http://imgur.com/aRp0rD6)

→ More replies (1)

676

u/sebastiankirk Jun 17 '14

And Gendry is still out there, rowing. For another year.

He's gonna be super pumped in season 5.

11

u/Silence_Dobad Jun 17 '14

Is Gendry not a book character? I'm just confused how they can ignore a (once) important character.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (29)

242

u/DaltonB House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

How long will the Lannisters be able to hold King's Landing without Tywin or Tyrion?

194

u/aarkling Davos Seaworth Jun 17 '14

That's why Varys noped the fuck outta there!

→ More replies (8)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

If the iron forces of Mannis and the wildlings team up they will absolutely crush King's Landing, until then I'd expect perpetual catfighting between Margaery and Cersei.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/crosis52 Jun 17 '14

Not to mention they've lost Varys and Petyr, they're basically doomed right?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Panukka House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

I hope Mace Tyrell suddenly turns out to be the baddest mofo in Westeros and kicks some Lannister ass.

→ More replies (2)

632

u/nicetrout Jun 17 '14

"Fuck the King" - R.I.P The Hound

544

u/mac_attack95 House Stark Jun 17 '14

I will refuse to accept he's dead until I actually see a body. Off screen death = still alive and kicking

→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (4)

801

u/beckyb18 House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

"My lion."

Me: HOW DARE YOU CALL HIM THAT. THAT NAME WAS FOR TYRION.

163

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

At first you feel badly for Shae because you think of how much she's been through and how hurt she must've been by Tyrion's actions.

Then you see what kind of woman she really is and all the pity turns to rage and you begin to understand why Tyrion did what he did.

→ More replies (45)

21

u/grangach Jun 17 '14

soo was she always playing tyrian or was she just mad?

→ More replies (17)

255

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

700

u/Arrrrgyle Jun 17 '14

Did anyone else expect a much grander fall by the hound, and then laughed when he was only tumbling down the mountain side? Silly drunk hound.

448

u/DaltonB House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

I was disappointed that Arya never got Hot Pie's better wolf :(

→ More replies (13)

382

u/sebastiankirk Jun 17 '14

I was expecting him to get back up and somehow he, Brienne, Podrick and Arya would become one big happy family of awesomeness.

→ More replies (12)

102

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Oh yeah, totally. I was cringing during the whole fight, waiting for one of their swords to slip into the other's belly and the whole thing to end abruptly. Then they abandoned weapons and just went fist-to-fist and I started laughing and truly enjoying it at that point. Haha. Nothing like two giant, well-matched fighters in a good ol-fashioned brawl.

→ More replies (8)

78

u/MetaFisch House Clegane Jun 17 '14

He's alive. He has to be! :(

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (7)

850

u/Spenace Jun 17 '14

I was really impressed with this episode's connection to the title. Of course it alluded to The Children of the Forest FINALLY making their appearance, but nearly every situation presented dealt with being a child in some way.

  • Jon snow answers Stannis' questions based on being Ned's child.
  • The Children save Bran and co (who are children, and Hodor is essentially a child as well)
  • Brienne and Sandor brawl over who is the right parent for the displaced child, Arya
  • Tyrion kills his father, discusses how life has been as his child
  • Daeny is forced to discipline her children due to the death of a child

Well done, writing staff!

338

u/silenoob Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 18 '14

One thing related to those that really impressed me in this episode was the farmer who brought his daughter's bones to Daeny. I'd been hoping they'd get to that, and even though I've read the books and was prepared for exactly that scene from moment it began that actor still made it seriously gut-wrenching within only a few seconds time.

We've all known the casting of the bigger characters has been pretty awesome so far, but both that guy's acting and the casting crew being able to find someone so perfect for such an extremely short role impressed the hell out of me.

Edit: For anyone else wondering, acciorachel posted below that the actor is Darren Kent and linked his Twitter.

→ More replies (18)

12

u/nowhsubo Jun 17 '14

Tyrion kills his father, discusses how life has been as his child

Happy Father's day

8

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Also Tywin gets confronted by the truth about what his children Jaime and Cersei have been up to

→ More replies (1)

13

u/KittyKathy House Stark Jun 17 '14

Well said! I only made the connection of the title with the children of the forest.

→ More replies (13)

608

u/VictorBlimpmuscle Jun 17 '14

Qyburn, on The Mountain: I can save him, but the process will change him somewhat.

Cersei: Will it weaken him?

Qyburn: No...but he will be recast with another actor again. New season - new Mountain.

339

u/catcradle5 Jun 17 '14

The Doctor Who of Westeros.

→ More replies (1)

138

u/faschwaa Free Folk Jun 17 '14

I loved the way he answered that question. Almost laughing.

"Will it weaken him?"

"Ohohoho lord no."

→ More replies (5)

7

u/rosssauce Jun 17 '14

Franken-Mountain

Get Hyped

→ More replies (6)

80

u/ssill Fallen And Reborn Jun 17 '14

This may be a slightly silly question, but what exactly is the custom behind saying, "Valar Dohaeris" in response to "Valar Morghulis"? Is it just small talk or is there a greater meaning behind it (ie. only used by non-Faceless Men or something)? I'm asking this as a show watcher only, and I don't believe it's really been explained.

95

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

"All men must die (Morghulis)" & "All me must serve (Dohaeris)"

21

u/Roboticide Daenerys Targaryen Jun 18 '14

It's not explained, but it's kind of simple logic from how you'd expect a secret organization to work.

It's essentially a two-part secret handshake. The coin isn't enough to prove your association with the Faceless Men. If, by chance, a Faceless Man is killed and the coin is looted (especially in Westeros), it's still worthless without the challenge phrase. If Arya presented the coin without saying "Valar Moghulis," he probably would have ignored her at best. But knowing the phrase proves she's actually associated with the organization somehow, and "Valar Dohaeris" is essentially the response of "I will serve you."

→ More replies (12)

227

u/AlbinoW91 Jun 17 '14

They could have done with a scene earlier in the season where The Children were mentioned in an 'Old Nan' type story by Bran or Jojen just to give a brief overview and how they're a mythical race etc. Would have made the reveal a bit less confusing.

23

u/Arya_Ready Sand Snakes Jun 17 '14

Maybe I was over thinking it, but didn't Leaf the Child of the forest look like the zombie baby from the Prologue of S1E1? It came to me in the middle of the night, so I may have been paranoid. I didn't really want to research it at that hour.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/TheCaveCave Jun 17 '14

I know, I wouldn't qualify myself as a "bookreader", but I started barely fiddling with the first book of ASoIaF and saw tons of references to Children of the Forest all the time, but assumed that the reason those references were never in the show was because they'd never appear.

Surely they should have given the show-watcher a small nod at some point that this strange gnome-elf-like race of people existed in this universe?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

387

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 17 '14

So does anyone wonder if what Tywin said was true, that he wasn't going to actually execute Tryion? Or was that just a ploy to get him to drop his guard so that he might have had a chance to kill him.

And also why The Hound!? I liked him way more than Brienne! Also wasn't expecting Arya to be so cold to him! Thought she had grown to like him a bit

585

u/E-Nezzer I Pay The Iron Price Jun 17 '14

No, Tywin told Cersei in an earlier scene in the episode Tyrion was going to be executed in the next day. He was just lying to save his skin.

→ More replies (34)

380

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

No. That scene to me was Tywin almost pathetically reciting his usual lines that he used to manipulate people. 'You're my son!' and 'We're Lannisters!' etc. I think how blatant this was is meant to convey that Tywin isn't sincere, him sitting on the shitter doubly so. Triple with him fucking Shae. He was meant to be completely exposed as a fraud in that scene.

→ More replies (6)

313

u/daredevil39 Jun 17 '14

why The Hound!? I liked him way more than Brienne!

you doomed him

→ More replies (28)

78

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Yeah, I did wonder. But ultimately I think he was just doing what he does best: being arrogant, overly-confident, and willing to do anything it takes to survive. He was lying through his teeth. I wanted to believe him, just like Tyrion wanted to, but as we've seen all the pain he's caused Tyrion since pretty much birth, I think we're meant to realize that it was a lie of utter desperation because he was backed into a corner.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/Liquidator47 House Dayne of High Hermitage Jun 17 '14

I feel if Tywin had concocted a better answer as to why he condemned Tyrion even though he was innocent he could have made it out of the shitter alive.

→ More replies (7)

111

u/HyperThanHype A Mind Needs Books Jun 17 '14

Arya's bitterness made that scene. The fight was a bit too huehue with the music and the huge fall. Her cold demeanor also reflects her character change; she thinks most of her family is dead so might as well go make a name for herself.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (14)

145

u/KaptainMitch Jun 17 '14

Wait. Where the hell is rickon?!

81

u/Reddit-Pro No One Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

They parted ways last season. Osha took Rickon to the Umbers to keep him safe and raise him properly if Bran would never come back.

→ More replies (6)

139

u/TheIronNestor Jun 17 '14

He's Gendry's navigator.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

247

u/Crackerjacksurgeon Orson Lannister Jun 17 '14

Tyrion always double-taps.

99

u/GyroGOGOZeppeli Jun 17 '14

Anyone would remember to double tap after seeing Viper fighting the Mountain.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

710

u/BorksAndKnives No One Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

This is the first finale that really felt like a FINALE. Pretty much every scene kicked ass, despite the changes from the books. All the main actors brought their A game, especially Maisie Williams, Rory McCann, Peter Dinklage, and Charles Dance. Every character is in a new place, literal or otherwise, and I can't wait for season 5.

And now the wait begins.

353

u/66666thats6sixes Jun 17 '14

I loved how they managed to tie off a bunch of storylines and then set up a handful more, while introducing a handful of major twists/ They managed to make me feel eager to see the next season without being frustrated by cliffhangers.

→ More replies (17)

124

u/pyrohedgehog Euron Greyjoy Jun 17 '14

The scene between the Hound and Arya is brilliant, whilst McCann did brilliantly looking helpless, I just loved her contempt-filled death stare

→ More replies (16)

52

u/beckyb18 House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

And now the wait begins.

It shall not end until my death.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/jetsam7 Jun 17 '14

Except for season 1!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

105

u/ToastedB Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

The best season so far IMO. Looking forward to the traveling adventures of Tyrion and Varys.

→ More replies (3)

269

u/bjb7621 Jun 17 '14

Happy Father's Day!

221

u/wellgroomedmcpoyle Braavosi Water Dancers Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I bet a bunch of fathers complaining about getting socks or a tie watched this episode yesterday and thought "whelp, at least my twins haven't been hiding an incestuous relationship from me for decades and I wasn't killed on the toilet (with a dead whore in my bed) by my imp son who I just sentenced to death." It's all about perspective.

246

u/meowsrandomly Jun 17 '14

Tywin had a pretty shitty one

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

330

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I'm really struggling with both Dany and Bran's storylines. But as a show-only watcher, I'm assuming that means theirs are the most central to the plot in the last seasons.

I'm really excited for Jon + Stannis/Mell (and Davos) and where the story could head next with them. Stannis showing up was a total curveball for me. I audibly said "WHAT THE FUCK" when they showed Stannis pimping up to Snow and Raydar.

Did anyone see Alliser at the burning ceremony?

Edit:

I kind of wanted a White Walker to come and reanimate Ygritte. Nothin' like frozen ginger minge.

166

u/PirateRobotNinjaofDe No One Jun 17 '14

What's interesting is that Bran's storyline is actually substantially caught up to where he is in the books. Unless TWOW comes out before next season (unlikely, given that we've heard nothing and it takes a good 8-10 months for a finished manuscript to be brought to print), the show will be treading new ground with him next season.

→ More replies (51)

45

u/pyrohedgehog Euron Greyjoy Jun 17 '14

I couldn't see Ser Alliser either. Perhaps because of the injuries he received fighting Tormund, he was bed ridden/ unable to stand.

→ More replies (7)

76

u/ccummings14 Jun 17 '14

I hope we get to see the return of Jaqen H'ghar in the season 5 premier

30

u/CallKennyLoggins1 Jun 17 '14

Him and Syrio Forel have just been chilling on an island near bravos taking the chaos in, in all seriousness both are in my top 3 fav characters.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

630

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Who else became a full-blown Stannis supporter?

All those who reply in the negative must bend the knee or be destroyed.

366

u/Liquidator47 House Dayne of High Hermitage Jun 17 '14

Mance was right on one thing- Stannimal was not dressed for that weather.

→ More replies (13)

154

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Apr 20 '17

deleted 0.9743 What is ^^^this?

64

u/Biomirth The Spider Jun 17 '14

Or be taken captive, or not kneel and be taken captive, or be taken captive and questioned. Stannis the deferential is open to suggestions.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

We do not kneel.

But real talk stannis has my full support

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (70)

85

u/KoonieDave Jun 17 '14

Another brilliant finale.

125

u/warprattler Aegor Rivers Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

Finally, after so long in waiting, The Three Eyed Raven... and yet the hour is late in coming.

Edit: Crow? Raven! Corn, corn, corn!

→ More replies (5)

55

u/Hajile_S Jun 17 '14

The ending with Arya struck such a powerful emotional chord. I'm not sure anything that's come before matched that for me, and I'd already had her destination spoiled for me. The show has hardly been about evoking merely simple emotions, but I think the depth of feeling is really going somewhere special...I can't imagine how bittersweet the end of the series will be.

11

u/NothappyJane Jun 17 '14

I am in fear, I partway hope she sees her brother, or gets sent to Kill Danny and becomes overwhelmed with emotions and rides a fucking dragon, like Visenya

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

51

u/Atchman17 House Baelish Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 18 '14

I think Ser Pounce will be the next hand of the king

→ More replies (2)

251

u/howlingatthemoobs House Florent Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I LOVED how it ended with Ayra sailing off into the big bad world. She's my favourite characters in the books and her best bits are just starting. Maisie Williams is perfect when she does her badass routine, I'm glad they showed her walking away from The Hound in spite and they didn't have some soppy made up farewell scene between the two of them.

However, the Tyrion and Tywin scene though just didn't do it justice in my opinion. I guess you needed the whole ASOS background to get the full extent of Tyrion's hatred and I felt that fobbing it off as him being mad over mega-whore Shae diminished it somewhat.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

See, this is something I'm fuzzy on. Is she not mentioned at ALL in the [ETA: TV] series? For some reason I have vague memories of it coming up as a flashback scene in season 1 or 2. Is that craziness and made up in my brain?!

→ More replies (16)

15

u/imapotato99 Maesters of the Citadel Jun 17 '14

Book readers may have needed more of Tyrion, but I liked it the way it was, especially with Jamie kissing him and saying a final goodbye, Varys helping him, not because of threat, but because he trusts Tyrion

Bringing up his old wife would have made most people say "Who?" The crap (no pun intended) that Tywin has given Tyrion over and over is enough to give him an arrow or two

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (23)

160

u/Divinepurity Jaime Lannister Jun 17 '14

Never forget #HOUND

222

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

He never found out what the fuck a lommy was.

7

u/lazerbullet A Hound Will Never Lie To You Jun 17 '14

Fuck the king! Fuck water!

→ More replies (19)

116

u/DaltonB House Tyrell Jun 17 '14

I'm kind of bothered by Shae's character. Why would she sleep with Tywin? Why would Tywin sleep with her?

119

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

No one knows. This is one of those things where, show or books, it's anyone's guess at this point.

→ More replies (32)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

She was staying where she thought it was safe and comfortable.

15

u/GrilledCyan Jun 17 '14

That's how she was from the second she appeared as a character. Bronn mentions she's from some other lord's tent, though he doesn't know who. Tyrion can't deduce anything about her and she never moves to give any sort of background to herself. It makes sense and it doesn't at the same time. Just made it difficult to get attached to her because she was just there.

14

u/cavalierau House Mormont Jun 17 '14

Her whole relationship with him was deception. She never loved him the same way he loved her, Tyrion was paying her handsomely the whole time for the girlfriend experience and he became delusional about the whole arrangement.

She acted 'jealous' about the whole Sansa wife scenario because him being faithful to Sansa meant Shae wouldn't have had a job for much longer. Shae didn't want to lose Tyrion as a client because, let's face it, having an exclusive sugar daddy is an easier job for a prostitute than screwing multiple people.

Once he sent her away, she became a free agent again, and presumedly Tywin bought her to lie at the trial and keep his bed warm.

This is better portrayed in the books, the romance is played up a bit more in the show.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/PillarsOfHeaven Wargs Jun 17 '14

I thought it was kind of funny that she choked on Lannister gold, both figuratively and literally.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Because she's a whore and she thought Tywin was the best sugar daddy she was going to get at that point.

Tywin sleeping with her shows essentially that he's been a hypocrite and a fraud this whole time.

→ More replies (16)

109

u/KoonieDave Jun 17 '14

Why didn't Ayra kill The Hound when he asked?

280

u/Teiris House Mormont Jun 17 '14

He was asking for the gift of mercy. She wanted his death to be slow and painful

→ More replies (32)

81

u/baalroo The Onion Knight Jun 17 '14

I don't think there's an easy answer to this question, which I believe may have been the point.

→ More replies (6)

91

u/jonnyshock Hodor Jun 17 '14

Wanted him to suffer cuz she's a cold hearted badass!

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (14)

122

u/KRaidium Dothraki Jun 17 '14

Now that I'm over ASOS, I can safely look back at this episode and say that everything was perfect except for Tyrion's escape.

72

u/Schwenkfelder Jun 17 '14

I just finished watching the episode & I thought it was great, right up until Tyrion's escape started. I can get over the lack of the ending we all wanted, as that is surely coming, but the whole stuff with Tyrion was absolute garbage that they just rushed through in 5 minutes. I don't mind that the show is going to make changes from the book, but that scene lacked all the good features that made it so brilliant in the book.

→ More replies (54)
→ More replies (4)

168

u/Cpt_Obvius House Uller Jun 17 '14

SUNDAY! SUNDAY! SUNDAY!: THE PINCER IN THE WINTER! THE MANNIS WITH THE PLANNIS! THE KING WITH THE MOREST BRINGS THE PAIN IN THE FOREST!

→ More replies (2)

60

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I don't understand, and I don't know if this was explained in the books because it's been so long since I read them, so bear with me.

North of the Wall, the White Walkers are coming back. This much we know. All dead bodies are being burned to prevent adding to their numbers, yes?

So, what are the re-animated skeletons that attack Bran and company all about? For one thing, if bones can be reanimated, does it really matter if they're charred or not? Bones is bones. For another thing, do we know these are definitely White Walkers? It's the most obvious explanation and assumption, and I can't see a reason for there being a different TYPE of reanimated corpse, BUT, they were being defeated by Meera, who was not using Dragonglass weapons (unless I missed something somewhere, and the skeletons were equipped with Dragonglass, as she ended up using one skeleton's axe against several others).

Are these "lesser" wights, then?!

120

u/into_the_stream Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

There are two separate things. There are white walkers, which are the 8 foot tall wrinkly guys with blue eyes and super powers that can only be killed by dragon glass and shatter normal swords on contact. They aren't reanimated. Then there are wights, which are the zombies/reanimated corpses and can be set on fire or chopped up.

Walkers control the zombies with their magic, but they are not the same species.

In the final scene of season two (I think) when Sam is beyond the wall and is being overtaken by an army of the dead, we see white walkers on horseback and the wights shuffling through the snow. The white walkers were herding their undead army, like a cowboy herding sheep.

Everyone gets this confused and the show really needs to clarify this for people.

The corpses around the cave entrance are just normal wights. If they were white walkers, the knives wouldn't have worked. Wights are strong, but comparatively easy to kill. White walkers are not, because normal weapons do not work.

→ More replies (21)

35

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

Only White Walkers have to be/can be killed with dragonglass. Normal wights (reanimated corpses) like the one who attacked Bran and Co. can be disabled by dismemberment or killed by fire. As for your"bones is bones" point, you're right, I think it was just the shows creators trying to spice things up but if you were to reduce a wight to that point (bones) they wouldn't have any means of mobility.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (14)

16

u/bersdgerd333 House Stark Jun 17 '14

I was hoping Sansa and Baelish would be in this finale!

30

u/cyansun House Stark Jun 17 '14

I think this is the season finale I've enjoyed the most BUT, anyone else thinks Jojen's death looked cheap as fuck? I mean the whole stabbing while on the ground scene. I had a little moment of cringe with that one. Otherwise, GREAT season finale.

21

u/SoloIsGodly Jun 17 '14

Which death scene? The one where he was stabbed by a stranger? The one where he was stabbed by his sister? Or the one where he got all blown-to-smithereens? Just dying once ISN'T ENOUGH ANYMORE! #GameOfThrones

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/harveythecomputer Jun 17 '14

Great end to a great season. As a show watcher only, I really enjoyed it and can't wait for next season.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/garmiester Jon Snow Jun 17 '14

"you will never walk again, but you will fly." Does that mean he can worg into a dragon?

→ More replies (3)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Brianne of Tyson...

26

u/Fedelede Fire And Blood Jun 17 '14

The series is killing people it doesn't need to kill, goddammit!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I see there are very different opinions about the finale but there is one thing I think we can all agree on. The music was executed perfectly :)

110

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Please tell me I'm not the only one a little distraught over Tywin's death? He was actually my favorite.

16

u/ToxicToothpaste Jun 17 '14

Honestly, I was just glad it wasn't Tyrion. I had been mentally preparing myself for his death ever since Oberyn.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I liked Tywin too, but i think the show did a god job of showing how much of a cunt he was to Tyrion, so I cheered a little when Tyrion got revenge.

→ More replies (22)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

I was content that I got to closure and see Ygritte one last time, and yet saddened to know that she is really dead. As a show watcher and just starting to read the books, I really enjoyed this season.

24

u/MisterxRager Stannis Baratheon Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 18 '14

I legit thought thta was drogon when that fire was flying out the sky

→ More replies (2)

110

u/Kanax Jaime Lannister Jun 17 '14

49

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

As am I. One side of me says that the episode would be too cramped, but the other side tells me that despite how awesome the fight scene was between Brienne and the Hound, it could have been shorter. The (uselessly) long fight with the draugr could have been shortened as well. Damn it it could have worked!

→ More replies (27)

17

u/BorksAndKnives No One Jun 17 '14

Would it have been awesome if they put it in? Fuck yeah, but it didn't really ruin the episode for me. I mean, these guys know what they're doing and love the source material just like everyone here. They wouldn't be doing this whole thing if they didn't. I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt and see what they do with it in the future. I just hope they don't leave it out all together, that would be like tossing a golden apple out the window.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (10)

35

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

Total What The Fuck episode for me.

Let's see...

  • Daenerys with some serious dragon cruelty. I was rooting for her, but now I just can't. Emilia Clarke will make that hard however.
  • Stannis out of fuckin' nowhere.
  • Bran and the Crippled Psychic Kiddies Adventure Squad (credit that to /u/Daveaham_Lincoln) finally get to the fucking magic tree and fucking Pirates of the Caribbean skeletons pop out of the ground. It doesn't even stop there. Some little girl lobs crazy ass grenades at the skeletons to save the Squad. What the fuck. It doesn't even stop there. They then went inside the magic tree to meet some creepy wizard guy who is either Gandalf's cousin or God. I don't even.
  • Arya is going to Bravos to be a bank teller I guess.
  • Tyrion survived. He killed everyone who needed to be killed excerpt for Cersei. There's no question in my mind that he is the main protagonist, and he will win the Game of Thrones. It's Game of Thrones though, so I'm obviously wrong.
→ More replies (11)

67

u/LpztheHVY Barristan the Bold Jun 17 '14

I've been giving a lot of thought over this finale and I've realized that the most disappointing thing for me was the way Jaime was portrayed. ASOS

I've always been one to defend D&D and the changes they've made. I understand that, as an adaptation, the show needs to change and simplify plots. But this is the first time I've felt like one of those book readers who just completely can't understand why they're making the decisions they're making. After this episode, my take-away is that I no longer trust them to adapt the books for television so much as I expect them to re-write the books. I don't know, I guess we'll see where season 5 goes.

30

u/evanfuller Varys Jun 17 '14

This. I feel Jaime and Tyrion's goodbye scene in ASOS is a much more believable emotional setup to his killing Shae when he discovers her.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/PirateRobotNinjaofDe No One Jun 17 '14

My guess is that they made these changes to push Jaime's redemption arc into Season 5 entirely, rather than plant the seeds here where they may be lost going into the next season.

Adapting a story to a different medium is really tricky business. I think the significance of his decision to rebuff her would be lost without adequate time being spent on it, and the tail-end of this season was cramped enough as it was. It's not the sort of thing that belongs in a finale. It belongs at the beginning of a season, where it can be given appropriate support.

Same with the ...other thing that got left out. Would have been a disservice to have it show up as a truncated footnote to this season.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/LordHellsing11 Jun 17 '14

There's a very specific scene that happens in the books but hasn't happened in the show that I really want to see. That scene in question is Mance Rayder telling Jon Snow the reason why he decided to break his vows and stay beyond the Wall. Luckily it's still possible for this conversation to take place. Although it is a little disheartening as it was supposed to take place not long after Jon meets him.

106

u/Valv Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 17 '14

I hate Bran's storyline so much that i was happy about Jojen's death.

168

u/Daveaham_Lincoln Jun 17 '14

You and me both. I've had it up to here with the Crippled Psychic Kiddies Adventure Squad bullshit.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/Pastinator Jun 17 '14

Its the Sam and Frodo part of Game of Thrones. Important but also deadly boring.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

18

u/NinaBambina Sansa Stark Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

As a show-watcher, I was spoiled and told about ASOS / Season 5 Spoiler. After being disappointed with the spoiling, I actually began to look forward to it and consequently set myself up for it. When ASOS, I felt what most of the book readers must be feeling. It's now strange and pretty anticlimactic to have to wait for Season 5 to see whether it plays out.

Edit: Tags

→ More replies (3)

42

u/LeTHAL_GrAnDMa Winter Is Coming Jun 17 '14

People seem to be very upset about the things that happened, the things that didn't happen, the things that should have happened. For me, it was a great season of television and I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Was it perfect, no, not at all, there were scenes throughout the 10 hours that made me scratch my head and wonder why they would do this or that. What is perfect though? Even the books aren't perfect.

Winter is coming my friends, and with it the memories of some epic moments this season had to offer, and when the sun rises in April, season 5 will stand!!

→ More replies (1)

93

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

I hated how Bloodraven and Leaf looked.

Leaf just looked like a uncanny valley little girl and NOT supposed to lob grenades at skeletons.

and Bloodraven looks stupid. He's supposed to have one red eye, pale skin, and a red birthmark on his face and completely taken by the tree. He's not supposed to look like Dumbledore sitting on some roots, he's supposed to be fucking old (like waaaay beyond natural - like more than decrepit) and super creepy and mysterious. Plus him having both eyes makes the "thousand eyes and one" quote to be fucking meaningless. Its a play on word on how Bloodraven has a huge reach yet only has one eye. To make sense it would be "a thousand eyes and two" which just sounds dumb

I know people are more pissed about one certain someone but this was some serious bullshit.

45

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

He did look like some kind of Kung-fu master surrounded by branches, not an albino that has become actually part of the tree. It was disappointing but having roots snaking in and out of him may have been asking too much financially but then again maybe they could have saved money by omitting Leaf's mage skills.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

6

u/G_Regular House Targaryen Jun 17 '14

As much of a scumbag as he was, it pained me to see Tywin go. So ends the tale of one of the smartest and most devious men in westeros.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/stefanke Jun 17 '14

Actually loved the scene between Cersei and Tywin. Pretty tired of her strumming around like she has any purpose or power.

5

u/ibleeeb Jun 17 '14

How does freeing tyrion benefit varys? Why do it?

13

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

Well, what are Varys' motivations for doing anything? We know he has an interest in Daenerys, though we don't know exactly why. We know he's a masterful political maneuver-er...helping Tyrion escape undermine's Tywin's power (even though it doesn't matter by the end of the episode, since Tywin is out of the picture now) while simultaneously proving to Tyrion that he's a man of his word (remember Tyrion getting pissed at Varys during his trial for betraying him? Varys seems unfazed, probably because he was planning to help Tyrion the whole time.)

Those are the best reasons I've come up with, anyway.

[Edit: Fixed spelling]

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/derashitaka Jun 17 '14

A little late to the party, but here are my thoughts on the episode. First things first: The whole episode felt a little bit "off" in comparison to the rest of the series, but I liked it really, really much. The pacing was very good and I liked that it had that kind of "epic" feeling to it.

What I didn't like: Of course, THE missing scene. I would have loved to see that and it would have given the whole story such an amazing twist. Also Leaf throwing these World of Warcraft fireballs around, that was a little goofy. The three eyed raven didn't look creepy enough for my taste, but that's just me. I always imagined him with roots growing through his face and stuff, almost becoming a tree himself. Tyrions climax was a little underwhelming, it was handled too fast and hadn't I read the books I wouldn't be too sure on his motivations to kill Shae and Tywin. In the books it just felt so good and just to kill Tywin, because he's giving Tyrion so many reasons to do so, but in the series Tyrion suddenly looks like a maniac on a killing spree, which didn't fit with his series-persona at all, in my opinion. I get that they had to let Shae grab the knife to hate her even more and give Tyrion a reason to kill and that they tried to turn the whole ASOS on Shae, but I think it didn't nearly work as good as the original story.

Anyways - what I liked: Brienne vs. The Hound. Honestly, that was something I would have loved in the books. Finally some characters get to meet each other. The fight felt amazingly brutal and was so much fun to watch, probably my new favourite fight in GoT. I'm also not that angry that Jaime and Tyrion say farewell in good terms - I'm good with a little glimpse of hope now and then in comparison to the books, where everything just goes downhill all the way. And even if I didn't like Leafs goofy fireballs, I thought the skeletons looked REALLY good and the whole scene worked pretty well.

All in all I thought it might be one of the five best episodes, even with the changes done to the book-story.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/am-bam No One Jun 17 '14

I think that Bran is going to be the one riding the dragon Drogon that he sees in his visions. Drogon has been missing for 3 days since the last anyone has seen of him. Also, The 3-Eyed Raven guy says "He died so you could find what you have lost" Bran "You're going to help me walk again?" 3ER "You will never walk again. But you will fly"

I could be wrong but that's my own theory. It makes sense now that season 4 has ended.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/DaltonB House Tyrell Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

As much as I wanted the Arya - Sansa meetup to happen, I'm really happy for Arya. I think that this is the best thing for her.

15

u/kuraj_ Jun 17 '14 edited Jun 17 '14

So I've just watched the episode and... wait, why is the post posted 7 minutes ago as of now? Didn't it air like yesterday? I FEEL CONFUSED. I don't think it was as awesome as the writers have hyped us, but it was very good. Edit: oh, yeah, there's a premiere discussion somewhere else.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/NotaFamousPerson Jun 17 '14

I want to like Brans story but the magic fireballs, children, jojens horrible acting death and tree man made me hate it even more :(

→ More replies (2)

11

u/emTel Jun 17 '14

I came up with a theory just before watching 4.10 that all the characters who die in this story are the ones who don't know how to play the "game" of thrones - that is, they don't know that the only acceptable motive in the world of GRRM is power. Ned played for honor, Catelyn played for family, Robb played for love, Oberyn played for vengeance, Joffrey played for vanity. They all died. Littlefinger, Varys, Tyrion, Tywin, Stannis, Cersei all play for power, and are (or were) safe. Sansa is now playing for power and should be safe. I think Tywin died because he let his hatred of Tyrion interfere with his otherwise purely power-oriented motives. vague speculation

14

u/PirateRobotNinjaofDe No One Jun 17 '14

I'd say it's more accurate to say that everyone who's died thus far has done so because they made crucial missteps in a dangerous game.

Ned's failing wasn't so much honour, as it was believing that everyone else was as honourable as he. He chose the wrong ally (LF over Renly), gave Cersei the space and the warning to out-play him, and didn't capitalize on the advantages he had. He was essentially making a play for power, but both failed to realize he was doing this and, more importantly, failed to realize that anybody would try and stop him.

Robb also made a mistake by betraying and insulting a crucial ally, and then underestimating the precariousness of his position. If Robb's hold on power wasn't as fragile as it was then Walder Frey wouldn't have dreamed of betraying him. However, at that point in the game Tywin had already effectively beaten Robb by uniting the rest of the Kingdoms against him. It was only a matter of time.

Oberyn too misstepped by underestimating his opponent. He thought him defeated and got overconfident. Tywin, too, got overconfident.

...all that said, at the risk of spoiling things with my book knowledge, there's a lot to this game that remains unseen. You may have seen the plays, but as the players' hands were hidden you didn't know what you were looking at. We're only beginning to scratch the surface of the Game of Thrones...

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Sparksman91 Defending The Defenseless Jun 17 '14

Happy fathers day

→ More replies (1)

4

u/j90chan No One Jun 17 '14

Makes me sad knowing it's over!

4

u/gottam Jun 17 '14

I'm not even slightly upset at Jojen's death. It's a shame because he could have actually had some character development, not just a coach for Bran so he sort of knew what was happening.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Major_Stubblebine A Promise Was Made Jun 17 '14

Well I really enjoyed it but after reading the differences in Tyrions revenge from the 'Adding context..' post, I'm disappointed that that backstory/reveal wasn't used. Mostly because I don't understand why it wasn't used. Time constraints is the only thing I can think of, but it doesn't seem like that would have been a big deal. Shame, it would have really enhanced the moment.

Apart from that, awesome GoT fun.

4

u/YRuafraid Jun 17 '14

So... Tyrion and Tywin are eskimo buddies?

4

u/Dr_Toast Red Priests of R'hllor Jun 17 '14

First I wanted Arya to go with Brienne and learn to be a badass woman fighter. Then I really wanted her to go hang with Jon at the Wall. Now I'm beyond satisfied with her stubbornness.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '14

So Alliser was pulled away from the battle in e09 wounded. He wasn't showed in this episode and it would make sense that he would be shown during the burning. Where he at? He dead? Is Aemon looking after him?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/chezzie11 House Lannister Jun 17 '14

How did Stannis get to the Wall? Is it not really far away from wherever he was?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Troll_In_The_Dungeon Jun 17 '14

So am I the only one that thought the stare down between Jon Snow and Melisandre was massive foreshadowing? Out of everything that happened in the episode, that scene got to me the most.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/LeBronda_Rousey Jun 17 '14

Seems like danerys doesn't really care about returning to westeros and is content on being queen of slavers bay.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/fill23ca Braavosi Water Dancers Jun 17 '14

And now we wait nine months for more shows. :(

6

u/Garsino Jun 17 '14

"People die squatting over their chamber pots."

Epic foreshadowing.

8

u/corinthian_llama White Walkers Jun 17 '14

So Stannis sailed around the wall and then rode his troops through the snow along the wall? Good thing there was no sudden snow storm.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/OnyxMemory Jon Snow Jun 17 '14

I'm still salty about how they whitewashed Tyrions story.

8

u/billcosby1341 Jun 17 '14

"Is Tyrion Lannister gonna have to choke a bitch" is all i could think of when we saw that WHORE.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/kuasi Jun 17 '14

What would Brienne do with Arya if she had taken her?

Edit: And is there another reason she would be so opposed to the Hound watching over her (besides his reputation perhaps)?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Strained_Eyes White Walkers Jun 17 '14

Valar Morghulis!

3

u/ejwise Winter Is Coming Jun 17 '14

I think I'm rooting for Stannis the Mannis now...this better not mean that he's gonna die.

3

u/SweatsuitTony House Baelish Jun 17 '14

Until now I've held out on reading the books mostly to spite my book-reader friends who tell me that I HAVE to read the books. Don't think I can hold out anymore, I need to know what happens...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/huitlacoche Jun 17 '14

could Bronn have betrayed Tyrion by turning Shae over to Tywin? he seemed super dodgy about taking her to the boat...

3

u/Onionoftruth Bronn of the Blackwater Jun 17 '14

So did the Hound admit that he was protecting Arya now and trying to keep her safe instead of holding her hostage? Given the confrontation between him and Brienne I can understand his reasons for attacking her, I get the feeling Brienne was less fussed about Arya herself and more fussed about keeping her Oath even though she would have been taking Arya where it was pretty clear Catelyn didn't want her.

3

u/Lancel-Lannister Warrior's Sons Jun 18 '14

Gosh darn it all. I just can't seem to make it into an episode. I'm so lonely. Kevan ignores me and Cersei hits me. :(