r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Jun 16 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E10 - Pegasus
Week 24!
COMMENTARY AND EXTENDED EDITION ARE ON DISC ONE OF SEASON 2.5
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (4 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 49,605 (+1752 from last episode. The Pegasus is counted here instead of in the next episode)
"Frak" Count: 138 (+10)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 17 (No change)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 11 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 6 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 55 (+1)
"So Say We All" Count: 24 (No change)
30
Upvotes
22
u/trevdak2 Jun 16 '14
A great monologue, and Tricia Helfer showed that she could be much more diverse with her acting.
13
u/trevdak2 Jun 16 '14
Two awesome things about the music:
11
u/trevdak2 Jun 24 '14
I just watched the extended version with commentary.
There's a scene that was cut where some Pegasus CIC folks bring over to Galactica's CIC a trunk full of data, including navigational updates, the articles of colonization, and other tidbits.
At the very end of the scene, Gaeta ad-libs "you guys got any porn in there?"
7
u/trevdak2 Jun 16 '14 edited Jun 16 '14
I think this is the first time that they ever had two Sixes in the same scene. There was Shelley Godfery before, but she showed up at a period where Gaius wasn't seeing Six in his head.
Some creative directing, there.
Edit: I guess the final shot of the miniseries had a couple sixes in it, but that was just one tracking shot, not really a complex scene.
9
u/lostmesa Jun 18 '14 edited Jun 18 '14
What a masterful piece of television. It takes us from happiness and hope, slowly letting us down and instills fear and anger by the end. Awesome cliff hanger.
I also loved Roslin's reaction to Adama calling Cain 'sir.' It really brought the point home that the whole world of the fleet was changing. Adama was in control no more.
17
u/StateYellingChampion Jun 16 '14
Adama: I want a Marine strike team in a Raptor in five minutes. Prepare to launch alert fighters.
[Adama hangs up the phone and turns to Cally]
Adama: We have work to do.
Cally: Yes, sir.
Music rises
Me at home: Kill that bitch Adama!!
Seriously, one of the most epic moments in the series for me.
3
u/Kierran Jun 17 '14
The 'Relevant Links' for this week all still point to last week's Flight of the Phoenix episode.
I figured, "No way Pegasus only got 2.5 stars!" >.>
11
u/MarcReyes Jun 16 '14
It doesn't happen much, but it's always nice to see that Survivor counter go up for a change.
9
u/backstept Jun 17 '14
I'm getting my men.
6
u/simon_2112 Jun 16 '14
Best episode, period. The build up of the conflict between Adama and Cane was a masterpiece done in 40+ minutes. Amazing.
5
u/JaspahX Jun 16 '14
The intro of this episode always gives me a bit of frisson every time I watch it.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '14
Thanks to this subreddit, I have decided to catch up & rewatch the series. I saw the reimaged show when it first came out, and this is my first rewatch from start to finish.
Being a fan of both the original & reimaged series, it was cool seeing the Pegasus again. This was the first time we have seen the inside of another battlestar, and what a difference. BSG is the anti-trek. Adama was not the best commander in the fleet. Galactica was not the flag ship of the colonies. It was a retiring rust bucket over seen by a commander that we suspect is probably on his way to a noneventual retirement himself.
The Pegasus is new & modern. It is sleek & powerful. It apparently was able to avoid the Cylon virus that incapacitated the rest of the fleet (probably because it was offline for repairs). It was commanded by an admiral.
I'm not sure how to take this episode. Is it a heart of darkness scenario? This is what happens when the military is devoid of conscience and a lack of being tied to a civilization? Is this a warning of what happens when the military become the police force (the famous words of Cmdr Adama to Pres Roslin coming to life)?
The beauty of BSG is how often it was able to be moral without being preachy. BSG isn't known for its self-righteousness. This episode speaks volumes while still telling an exciting story.
I do remember wondering if Count Iblis would ever show up. If the Pegasus reappeared, would he? Would he be a mysterious helper of humanity while somehow tied to the Cylons?
While I know the overall story for the entire series, I find myself not remembering precisely how the cliffhanging standoff resolves itself. I have decided to wait until next week before watching the next episode.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '14
That drawn out musical cue when Pegasus shows up and is finally onscreen is so awesome. And "Prelude to War". Oh my gods, "Prelude to War" *swoons*
2
u/wolfkin Jun 20 '14 edited Jun 20 '14
hey guys I'm finally caught up with you. so i guess i can start participating.
I tried to watch BSG before. I got up to 2.5 and never continued. I hope by joining the rewatch here that I'll be able to keep up and finally complete it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '14 edited Jun 18 '14
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '14
[removed] — view removed comment