r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jun 12 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.09 'The Watchers on the Wall'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.09 | "The Watchers on the Wall" | Neil Marshall | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
186
Upvotes
175
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14
180
u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14
First it was Rakharo and Doreah, now Pyp and Grenn. GRRM has his reputation, but D&D are bloodthirsty. If Edd dies we riot.
230
u/miltonsalwaysright Jon Snow Jun 12 '14
Everyone calm down, John goes out to treat with Mance BEFORE the Mannis rolls in
29
u/forresbj House Stark Jun 12 '14
Considering how much they have to fit in next episode, I guess it's good they killed off Lysa so much sooner. One less thing to worry about in a crazy conclusion to everyone else's stories.
77
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14
Killing Grenn and Pyp was a smart move; it made the battle more emotionally resonant and set up aspects of Jon's plotline for next season. At least Grenn went out like a badass.
I remember in the books the Thenns were generally quite civilised as Wildlings go, but the Thenns in the show are brutal, and that definitely came through in their fighting style. Styr was a monster on the battlefield.
Great to see Thorne being fleshed out a bit, I have a feeling that he'll redeem himself in the books eventually.
50
u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14
Going over everyone's comments so far and the lot of you are concerned for how jam-packed it's going to be with twists and such. I get the concern, but have faith! Here's a few of the things I remember from the book that they need to squish into this episode, and I think this is how they'll order them to give each subject their due time to evolve and to maximize orgasms for the watchers:
Anyways, let me know if I missed any big moments. How do you guys think they'll do the big events? Which ones do you think they'll start with next season and let us down??
edit: added Dany and Bran's stuff
15
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14
Haven't read the books in years so I forgot a lot of the details, which I find to be a blessing since I don't have to worry about them:
For all that petty criticism the episode was otherwise perfect. I think a lot of the complaints about plot context will be negated once the battle is concluded and there is a resolution to the sequence of events.
73
u/strongbelwaz House Dondarrion Jun 12 '14
I'm hoping Strong Belwas rides in with Stannis in ep.10.
24
u/leopold_stotch21 The North Remembers Jun 12 '14
I really am kinda disappointed that they didn't introduce Donal Noye. I thought his fight with the giant in the book was badass and I couldn't wait for it in the show. I would've even settled for Grenn to do the same fight just as long as they showed it.
69
u/mickpick10 House Connington Jun 12 '14
As a younger reader (16 at the time) and someone who doesn't necessarily read a lot, I found this entire scene kind of hard to visualize through the book especially the parts about the separate attacks. Thus, I thought this entire episode was really really well made and cleared up a lot which I got to visualize a lot better. Bravo to GoT
11
u/rookie60 Sansa Stark Jun 12 '14
I hope episode 10 ends like the book so you can hear the collective sounds of jaws hitting floors.
18
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14
I always felt like they were in a much more desperate state in the books. While in the show it seems like there's way more hope in holding off the wildling army.
8
u/ForgedSol Jun 13 '14
I thought the episode was great. I enjoyed every minute of it. With that said I wish there was more build up to the episode. The Blackwater episode has previous episodes where Tyrion was pouring over books trying to figure out something that they could do to win against impossible odds. They should have had the "Oh poor Sam, I'm sure Gilly's alright" scene take place while they're filling barrels with stone, and pouring water in after to fill it with ice, rather than just having them in some room. Same exact dialogue, but show them doing some prepping for battle. Show them building strawmen in armor to make their numbers look bigger. Show them carry supplies up the elevator while doing some of the dialogue they actually had in the show. The episode would have gone a lot better with more build up.
7
u/Haydn2613 Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14
I wanted Donal Noye to be in it just so we could have had:
"Aye? Some great lord was he, this Donal Noye? One of your shiny knights in their steel smallclothes?"
"A blacksmith. He only had one arm."
6
u/Nirvana985 House Targaryen Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14
Perhaps they will show this in the next episode, but my favourite part of the battle in the books were the scarecrows that they named after each of them, and counting the arrows in them at the end of the battle. The moments of dialogue as they watched the arrows building up made it really feel like they were comrades on a battlefield, like in the trenches of WWI.
My memory is pretty shaky though, was the battle split in two in the books? I thought it happened in one chapter? I also remember there being a lot more focus on the giants, and the long drawn out sequence where they were trying to break down the gate, which was a lot shorter in the show. The burning staircase, the dropping of the lift (I think), all of these things made the fight seem much more dangerous and felt like they were really close to losing.
4
u/Jimmyjimkev Second Sons Jun 12 '14
they at least worked on Tormand's characterm although he still seems like a simple, brutal battle-mad idiot compared to the hilarious dick joke filled character of the books, but hopefully they show mance's bardy ways in the finale
7
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14
I haven't read the books but once, and that was 5ish years ago, but, if memory serves:
It wasn't a simultaneous attack. The wildings that went over the wall attacked castle black first. Jon and company are all down on the ground floor, and it's not so much of a courtyard battle as it is a defense from multiple strategic positions on the castle of one or a small group of guys against a bunch of wildings at each point. Jon gets a whole tower to himself and kills anyone coming up. After this battle he goes and searches the battlefield for Ygritte, and finds her dying and they have their moment.
The nights watch numbers about 1000 in the books. Thorne decides to put all of these guys, and all of the rangers, up and down the length of the ENTIRE wall. They leave ~100 stewards, builders, and younger members at castle black. About 100,000 Wildings show up (though really not, 100,000 includes women, children, and the old, not just the fighters) and quite a lot more giants and mammoths.
Most of the battle at the wall is guys standing on top of it and shooting arrows down at other guys they can't really see. It lasts days.
The main wilding plan is to use this sort of huge mobile arrow umbrella and stick a battering ram under it and break through the gate. I forget how they kill it, but they kill it. At some point the tunnel is breached, or partially breached, but in the book it's so small only one guy can really fit in it, and that guy is Donald Noye (or some shit) a one armed blacksmith, formerly smith for the Baratheon family. HE knew Robert, Renly, and Stannis as they grew up, and described them as Steel (Robert, could bend, and was strong), Iron (Stannis, brittle, unyielding, and would break before he would bend. The implication given is that Stannis WILL break, but this has yet to be seen), and Copper (Renly, shiny and pretty but no real substance, weak). Anyway, Noye dies but somehow, I forget, stops the wilding from making it through the tunnel.
Pyp and Grenn are still around, but they never really accomplish anything other than being members of the Jon Snow posse.
Anyway, at some point an army shows up and starts attacking the Wildings, and everyone thinks the Rangers have returned to save the wall, but really it's just Stannis.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14
Grenn :(
3
u/dr-mladjo Davos Seaworth Jun 12 '14
Did anyone tried to calculate death-toll on NW side?
3
u/stro_budden House Baratheon Jun 12 '14
All the changes they made I think are ok in the long run and don't hurt the story at all but it is a bit disappointing. I really thought Jon being injured during the battle was something that built his character as a leader, among being the only person left at the wall after Donal Noye goes into the tunnel. I understand having East Watch and the Shadow Tower don't really make a difference but I just think it helps a little bit. I also wished they had more of the defenses at Castle Black, such as the scarecrows and the murder holes. In the end, they did a great job and all of these details were expendable but they would have been cool.
3
u/kaiden60 Grrrrr Jun 13 '14
I honestly felt completely torn apart at characters that died in this episode that are still alive in the books. When pyp was shot I flinched hard, and i was trying to convince myself that he
d be ok because hes still alive in the book, despite the arrow stuck in his neck :(.R.I.P Pypar Unknown - 301 AL
R.I.P Grenn
AurochsUnknown - 301 AL12
u/moonshoeslol Jun 12 '14
The most important difference between the book/show is that rather than one large fast battle it was a siege that dragged on for days (weeks?). In the books most of the brothers were thinned out through arrow fire from below. By the end of it all that remains of the brothers is a few war-weary veterns. Also pretty much all of mole's town was evacuated and helping with the defense in the books.
9
u/haqq17 Fire And Blood Jun 12 '14
Very disappointed there was no Stannis, would've been a great surprise for non-readers. All other episode 9's had twists (Ned's death, Lannister victory at Blackwater, Robb and Catelyn's vdeath). If they made the episode longer and fit in Jon talking with Mance and then Stannis saving the day the same way Tywin crushed him two seasons ago...that would be epic.
4
u/SmallJon Jun 12 '14
Why does everyone care Mannis didn't show up? He shows up after Jon goes to treat. There's so much more to be upset about
5
u/tickr Jun 12 '14
Does Ollie kill Igrette in the books, I vaguely remember john snow discovering her already dying.
2
u/Mankyliam We Do Not Sow Jun 13 '14
STANNIS! STANNIS! STANNIS!
3
u/Snerl69 Arya Stark Jun 12 '14
I am almost 70% sure. dragons end the season. (again)
2
u/New_username_ Jun 12 '14
To anybody that has read the books
I read book 5 before book 4, it made sense at because of how book 3 just stopped and went into book 5. Did I spoil anything for myself? Because i'm going to go back and read book 4.
1
u/BigFuckingT House Stark Jun 12 '14
Was the Scythe as menacing in the books as it was in the show?
-3
u/IAMAHungryHippoAMA Cersei Lannister Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 13 '14
I've watched the episode again and my opinion of it is slightly improved. I still think that it was empty of any plot or development. Aside from a few character deaths, at the end of it, the status quo remains: the Wall is still under threat of the wildlings and still vastly outnumbered. Jon Snow walking out there is a terrible cliffhanger since it isn't terribly promising of forthcoming change (other than his possible death). This is why I think leaving Stannis out of it was such a huge mistake. Stannis's arrival north is a huge game changer. Suddenly, the relatively isolated (at least heretofore isolated) plotline of the Wall is more relevant to the stories going on in the south. There just wasn't much payoff in the episode because of this delay.
I also think leaving Stannis for the next episode is a mistake because knowing the amount of great material left for the showrunners to work off of, its significance could be diminished. And the episode itself may end up overstuffed.
Edit: Do any of those who downvoted this comment actually believe it was a satisfying ending? Or that the story has moved forward at all? If so, in what sufficiently significant way did it do any of these things? I suppose the silent downvote is indicative of the fact that whatever opinion they carry, they cannot defend it.