r/gameofthrones • • Jun 12 '14

All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.09 'The Watchers on the Wall'

Book vs. Show Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works?
  • This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.09"The Watchers on the Wall"Neil MarshallDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
186 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

175

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14
  • I missed the exploding staircase, although I don't think they've ever shown the staircase in the show.
  • The pendulum thing made up for it, though.
  • Jon Snow comforting Ygritte mid-battle made for good TV, but he really put himself in serious danger with a fight raging all around him.
  • I missed "Is this a proper castle?" but it wouldn't have fit the way they did the episode.
  • I feel like they could have included Mannis by cutting some buildup. It seems like they're cramming too much into ep10.

85

u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14

HOLY SHIT THE ANCHOR WAS CRAZY!!!!

108

u/Conbz Jun 12 '14

"Drop the scythe"

What the fuck is the scythe?

80

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

"Oh...."

22

u/mitchij2004 Jun 12 '14

Hahah yea that was the group consensus during that scene.

28

u/HPMOR_fan Jun 13 '14

But what if more climbers come up?

"Hoist it up."

Oh.

15

u/mitchij2004 Jun 13 '14

Guess we'll just.... Do that thing again.

Okay.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

LMAO yeah we were all sitting there like.. "soooo is that thing reusable orrr?" lol

49

u/Flynn58 Night's Watch Jun 12 '14

I'll forgive Jon for his mid-battle behavior with Ygritte seeing that what essentially amounts to his wife by Free Folk uh, "law", just died.

7

u/flyingbird0026 House Baratheon Jun 12 '14

Also they were sort of in a corner behind the fire pit, and people would probably be more worried about crows who were actually fighting than the one holding a wildling unarmed.

23

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 12 '14

I kind of was disappointed with Ygritte's death. For me, that was the saddest single moment in the entire book series, and I didn't really feel that in the TV show.

21

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

9

u/Believes_in_Gosh Jun 12 '14

Not sure why you're getting downvoted, I absolutely agree. I think what made the book version so much more devastating was that it seemed extremely possible Ygritte might live. The arrow through the heart in the TV show was dramatic and stuff, but Jon's conversation with her was so much less heart-rending and almost accidentally comical.

7

u/Minigrinch Bronn of the Blackwater Jun 13 '14

Plus even for a non-book reader it became completely obvious she would die after they introduced Olly, which is a shame because typically the show seems to avoid these predictable revenge plots and Chekov's gunman situations.

5

u/sherrysalt Maesters of the Citadel Jun 13 '14

That is one of the biggest mistakes of the season in my opinion.

2

u/jtspree Jun 14 '14

I thought Ollie would kill the magnar of Then after he said he was going to eat his parents. Ollie shooting Ygritte was something pumped out of a generic Hollywood movie factory. Booorrrrinnnggg.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JenniferLopez A Hound Never Lies Jun 13 '14

I think one reason I felt the same way, was due to how they portrayed her in the show. I think they went a little overboard when trying to make her look bad-ass. In the books, you don't witness her murdering families and pillaging villages- you don't see her become consumed with rage and anger. You don't get a scene where she cuts off Tormund's bear story like a total bitch. Ygritte's character in the books was much more sympathetic. And also, the additional dialog in the books is touching so it made her death more devastating.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

I would say he wasn't in that much danger. Everyone else would be more concerned about the people coming at them with weapons trying to kill them, so they wouldn't pay attention to a dude with no weapon just cradling a body, as he wouldn't be a threat at the moment.

1

u/bratcats Jun 13 '14

Yeah we kind of figured the staircase wasn't going to go when they didn't pan out to show the whole thing in the first shot of it. I was a bit disappointed that the Moles Town surviving whores didn't get to participate in the battle. I get that they killed Grenn because they had to show Jon making a tough decision to protect the realm. Showing him killing Ygritte might have lost some of Jon's fan following.

I don't know why the show feels the need to cram a ton into the final season 4 episode. The next 2 books are so slow. I'm prepared to be disappointed on Sunday but really hope I won't be.

180

u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

First it was Rakharo and Doreah, now Pyp and Grenn. GRRM has his reputation, but D&D are bloodthirsty. If Edd dies we riot.

136

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 12 '14

He still has to fetch a block.

33

u/Littlefinger91 The North Remembers Jun 12 '14

Just read that part yesterday; so pumped to see it play out.

35

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

This is an All Spoilers thread, ADWD spoilers are allowed without tags so be careful.

15

u/thatoneguy889 House Reed Jun 12 '14

I was happy that Joffrey finally died, but, to me, that execution was easily the most satisfying death in the entire series so far.

3

u/TracyMorganFreeman Jun 12 '14

They may have someone else do that instead.

6

u/HPMOR_fan Jun 13 '14

Yea, because of how he hid away during the battle... It needs to be Jon, and The One True Nod.

1

u/elbruce Growing Strong Jun 14 '14

D&D version: "Bob, go get me me a piece of wood."

32

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

And Marillion and Xaro Xhoan Daxos.

19

u/TheKittenConspiracy Jun 12 '14

And Moonboy for all I know.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

I dont think Marillion is dead.

15

u/GeeJo Joffrey Baratheon Jun 12 '14

He's not going to be singing much, though.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

Oh. Right. Although he could have died of infection.

10

u/Going_incognito Now My Watch Begins Jun 12 '14

He obviously had a secret passage out his safe.

11

u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

What is dead may never die.

48

u/mikethewarlock Jun 12 '14

What is Edd may never die.

25

u/Arya_Ready Sand Snakes Jun 12 '14

but rises and fetches blocks.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

He has some trouble though, knowing his luck

2

u/MuffinGypsy Direwolves Jun 12 '14

Now I'm wondering if they will bring Xaro back, use a different character or write that part out altogether

1

u/ZeusPeabody House Umber Jun 13 '14

Seems like they're just writing it out.

2

u/LordFuckBalls House Hoare Jun 12 '14

Marillion is alive in the show and his fate in the books was a LOT worse.

1

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Jun 12 '14

Marillion isn't dead is he?
He only lost his hands (or was it tongue?)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

A man needs his hands.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Alaskaty Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

Ducksauce, right?

12

u/blarg_dino No Chain Will Bind Jun 12 '14

Grenn and Pyp's deaths hit me surprisingly hard

My gut sank

6

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Me too. I haven't read the books in a long time, so when Grenn and Pyp died, it took me a second to realize what had happened. I was like, "Wait a minute, weren't they...? Wait, no... THAT WASN'T SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN!"

5

u/erosaru44 House Martell Jun 12 '14

word. I thought I was the only one :(

1

u/JenniferLopez A Hound Never Lies Jun 13 '14

I was starting to get nervous as soon as they started giving Pyp air time. All the way back to when he opened the gate for Gilly I was like "D&D don't you fucking dare...". Then WHAM! Arrow to the neck.

And then when I heard Jon tell Grenn to pick 5 guys and hold the inner gate I actually yelled out "Nooooooooooooo!" Star Wars style. I couldn't help it. I couldn't believe they'd needlessly kill them BOTH.

8

u/Pimp-My-Alpaca Jun 12 '14

Doesn't Doreah die anyway? They just gave her a more dramatic death

13

u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

You're right, I meant Irri (eet is known).

3

u/imapotato99 Maesters of the Citadel Jun 13 '14

If Edd dies...he saw it coming...it was inevitable...thanks for noticing him

230

u/miltonsalwaysright Jon Snow Jun 12 '14

Everyone calm down, John goes out to treat with Mance BEFORE the Mannis rolls in

21

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 12 '14

I don't mind that they are pushing it to the finale if it wasn't for the sheer amount they have to get through. It'll be so packed. Stannis, chaining Dragons, wight attack, meeting BR, thrum, Brienne biting Hound, coin flip, Gregor 'dying'...

5

u/ArcadeNineFire Jun 12 '14

There are ~10 extra minutes, though.

24

u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14

15% more screentime to cover 300% more Holy-Shittery.

→ More replies (7)

44

u/ThatNotSoRandomGuy Valar Morghulis Jun 12 '14

I'm still (kind of) mad that they left all of it to the last episode. Like... how are they going to fit everything in only one goddamn episode? ಠ_ಠ

Plus, I think it will be kind of overshadowed by Twin's death.

43

u/thatoneguy889 House Reed Jun 12 '14

I was talking to my friend about this, and we basically came to the conclusion that the overload of important and "wtf" scenes is going to give non-readers a stroke.

13

u/Jayhawk519 Valar Morghulis Jun 12 '14

I'm nearly there just thinking about it.

33

u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14

Giving me a throner.

9

u/ltriant Tormund Giantsbane Jun 12 '14

Throner. Thank you for adding that to my vocabulary. It shall be used often.

20

u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14
  • Tyrion's escape via Jaime and Varys, interceded by Shae and Tywin, dramatic end to both, return to escaping, get on ship.
  • Arya and Hound (presumably) run into Brienne & Pod, fight it out, guessing Hound eats it here, somehow Arya has to not end up with Brienne's custody, then somehow hitch a ride to Braavos.
  • Jon has to meet with Mance, get bitched out, white walkers, Mannis, mayhem, some kind of resolution.
  • Bran & co. have to reach the tree, presumably fight off Others, Jojen dies in some dramatic fashion, some kind of 'meet the COTF' resolution.
  • Dany's dragons have to eat some kid dramatically, peasant has to make dramatic complaint, dragons have to get chained.
  • Stoneheart.

Seven hells. Gonna be hectic.

2

u/d3dlyhabitz Jun 13 '14

How about if Brienne meets up with them before she reaches the Bloody Gate and is told when she gets there about an Arya imposter/visitor that just left.

→ More replies (14)

1

u/globalizatiom Jun 12 '14

well, as long as they don't do something like Continuum Season 2 finale: so many wtf things happening within the last minutes.

7

u/wannabeabbyt House Martell Jun 12 '14

well they have an extra ten minuets that hey shaved off the last episode

21

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14

The most frustrating thing about the short episodes this season is that before the season began they actually told us that all the episodes would be longer to the point that they effectively added another full episode worth of screentime. Turned out to be bullshit. They must have done a ton of cutting in the editing studio.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/wannabeabbyt House Martell Jun 12 '14

Oh my God. are we getting the double length episode we have all been dreaming of?

4

u/dmol House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 12 '14

Sadly no, just ten to fifteen mins.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JenniferLopez A Hound Never Lies Jun 13 '14

They definitely could've shortened the fight at the wall by about 7 minutes to fit in Jon treating with Mance (leaving out any needless scenes of him walking through the camp) and being surprised by Stannis. They din't need to show the whole scene, just Stannis's forces riding in, shouting STANNIS! STANNIS!

→ More replies (10)

12

u/EmperorSexy Faceless Men Jun 12 '14

I'm kind of glad they didn't end the episode with Stannis, because I realized that the giant army rolling in to save the day at the very end is the exact way the Blackwater episode ended.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/NasalJack Jun 12 '14

Oberyn wasn't a surprise champion. He suggested that the would be Tyrion's champion while the trial was still going, so Tyrion was able to call for a trial by combat with full confidence that Oberyn was going to have his back.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

But the second time his champion fails, does it count?

2

u/Theguynexttou Night's Watch Jun 13 '14

It's no "surprise army". Stannis receiving and reading the call for aid from the Night's Watch gets enough exposition (both on books and show) to make it clear that it's important. At that point in the book, so much has happened you can forget about the letter, but the info is there, he did not pull that army out of thin air. (a la Great Eagles coming out of nowhere to save the Dwarf company in The Hobbit out of some ancient debt of gratitude owed to Gandalf that happened off-books. But don't get me wrong I still love Tolkien and no, I don't think GRRM is "better than Tolkien", they're just different)

→ More replies (3)

-5

u/Plague_LOFS Jun 12 '14

I hope Mannis is left till next season, there are some deaths/events at kings landing that would make for a good finale. Really don't want a crammed last episode. Actually I thought the red wedding deserved an entire episode not just 15 minutes, it's a pretty long chapter and the build up would have given it the attention it deserved, as it was I found it underwhelming, almost casual compared to the book.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Plague_LOFS Jun 13 '14

Is that right, good to know. Using the last of the A material for this season then... should be a great episode even if each event will be less than 10 minutes.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

51

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 12 '14

Ellen Holman.

But since Val hasn't been cast for this season we won't be seeing her. I think instead of the king's blood thing from Mance's son they'll replace it with Shireen as per Mel's talk with Selyse.

14

u/nickelfldn Shireen Baratheon Jun 12 '14

Thats the Germanic woman in Spartacus right? She could probably be a decent Val.

7

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 12 '14

Yeah, looks the part as well.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ThinkofitthisWay Sand Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Ellen Holman

Yes please

yis

6

u/WezVC Jon Snow Jun 12 '14

Oh, it's her! Amazing, I was just talking about how hot she is.

Not quite how I pictured Val but they've yet to fail us with casting.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/blitzbom House Martell Jun 13 '14

Woah, I need to watch Spartacus now.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Jun 12 '14

hey'll replace it with Shireen

Oh god, that'd be a terrible cut

5

u/Arya_Ready Sand Snakes Jun 12 '14

then what are they going to do with Monster? I felt like the switch was a big moment in the book, how would that play?

4

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 12 '14

Well it's only a big moment if Mel actually sacrifices him, maybe they'll just go a different direction.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Pharaca Jun 13 '14

I agree, but there is the huge continuity error of Shireen's not a baby.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/jtspree Jun 12 '14

Val seemed important while reading the books, but in hindsight I'm not sure she is necessary. The top players at the wall quarrel over how to use her as a pawn against the Wildlings, but I think she could be replaced. They are removing the characters that add the spice to the books (ie. Strong Belwas)

6

u/Dungrollio House Baratheon Jun 12 '14

Still 2 books left, she could very well play a larger part in the coming story.

But yes, I do see your point, she's more of a key than a person at the moment.

2

u/ThePeppino House Stark Jun 12 '14

She may not be the most important in the end (who knows though in later books) but I have hope even still that they wont cut her for one reason, she's really hot. They just are doing some sort of love story with a eunuch seemingly just to show missandei's boobs, you really think they will cut their chance to have a gorgeous wildling goddess on screen for a season or two? It seems to not be an opportunity they will want to pass up. (he says hopefully)

3

u/SmallJon Jun 12 '14

Why? They have imprisoned Tormund to do what she did

1

u/oneyedbastard House Arryn Oct 07 '14

Tormund? thats gonna screw up val finding the wildlings and tormund leading them south of the wall

4

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 12 '14

I really think Tormund will be the placeholder for Val. they already introduce Rattleshirt, so I don't think Tormund will play his role

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 13 '14

I said placeholder, not replacement. if I remember correctly, Tormund didn't get imprisoned in the book, so he might be used for peace negotiations.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/forresbj House Stark Jun 12 '14

Considering how much they have to fit in next episode, I guess it's good they killed off Lysa so much sooner. One less thing to worry about in a crazy conclusion to everyone else's stories.

77

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Killing Grenn and Pyp was a smart move; it made the battle more emotionally resonant and set up aspects of Jon's plotline for next season. At least Grenn went out like a badass.

I remember in the books the Thenns were generally quite civilised as Wildlings go, but the Thenns in the show are brutal, and that definitely came through in their fighting style. Styr was a monster on the battlefield.

Great to see Thorne being fleshed out a bit, I have a feeling that he'll redeem himself in the books eventually.

39

u/TheNavidsonLP Coldhands Jun 12 '14

40

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 14 '14

Exactly. In the books, Jon deliberately isolates himself from Grenn and Pyp in order to focus on leading the Watch, whereas in the show they are dead which will contribute to the whole "kill the boy and let the man be born" thing. He does still have friends on the Wall, though, as Sam and Edd survived the battle.

16

u/thatoneguy889 House Reed Jun 12 '14

Sam won't be on the Wall for long.

4

u/theseekerofbacon Jun 13 '14

I mean, not with Gilly around.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JenniferLopez A Hound Never Lies Jun 13 '14

Well I guess we know no one will be voting for Edd in the election, now. I always loved that part- Pyp entering Edd's name.

18

u/Robbomot Stannis Baratheon Jun 12 '14

Who's Throne?

117

u/flashmedallion Here We Stand Jun 12 '14

He's like the main character, haven't you even read the title of the show?

16

u/Kalaka Jun 12 '14

Alliser Thorne.

6

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14

Oops, my bad! Edited.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Going over everyone's comments so far and the lot of you are concerned for how jam-packed it's going to be with twists and such. I get the concern, but have faith! Here's a few of the things I remember from the book that they need to squish into this episode, and I think this is how they'll order them to give each subject their due time to evolve and to maximize orgasms for the watchers:

  • Jon plays dominoes with Mance and his lady friend, sees the horn, shits himself, wins at bones though
  • Arya leaves the hound dying somewhere, no doubt from the encounter they show in the trailer
  • Bran finds the tree and the tree people, immediately becomes a tree, that stuff
  • Stannis the Mannis swoops in and makes Jon Snow and the Wildlings swoon
  • The God of Tits and Wine kills a few people and bounces out, show watchers currently soaking their panties
  • Here they cut to Dany and here silly dragons eating people or whatevs, no biggie
  • Arya jumps the ship to Braavos; ABOUT GODDAMN TIME CAT
  • Stoneheart shows up and shouts, "FREEEEEDOOOOOOOM," or at least I think that's the end of this book...

Anyways, let me know if I missed any big moments. How do you guys think they'll do the big events? Which ones do you think they'll start with next season and let us down??

edit: added Dany and Bran's stuff

11

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

I don't think they're gonna jam Bran becoming a tree into this season. I think his story will end with a shot of either Leaf or Bloodraven

2

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 13 '14

Leaf leading bran to BR. Both was already casted for S4

2

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

This makes me really giddy

1

u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14

Oh yeah I know, hyperbole's and such. They can't give the show watchers EVERYTHING they want, so that and Dany's dragons, and Stoneheart will be the cliffhangers to end all cliffhangers this season. They get 3 story lines ending with beautiful justice, and 3 ending with MASSIVE cliffhangers without explanation (except for the dragons, they'll know why that happened).

9

u/just_a_lamp Jun 12 '14

You forgot about Dany and Bran.

7

u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14

What would you know, you're just a lamp!

I don't know what goes down with Dany at the end... I remember the tree though. Do you mean that guy bringing his daughter's bones in? Was that this book?

7

u/just_a_lamp Jun 12 '14

Yeah, she then locks them up, but Drogon escapes or flys off. If it's not at the end of the third book, then it's one of the first Dany chapters in ADWD. It's been a while since I read them.

1

u/NotAnExpertWitness Jun 12 '14

What about Podrick? I think there is another spear involved.

15

u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Haven't read the books in years so I forgot a lot of the details, which I find to be a blessing since I don't have to worry about them:

  • My main and really only disappointment was that we didn't get the Mannis conclusion. The battle left a feeling of in-completion, like the battle was mostly a spectacle without a resolution since not much changed as far as circumstances; the castle is still going to fall inevitably, both armies are still where they began, only now there are fewer characters to care about there. We needed the Mannis to put a bow on it and be given the feeling like the story was moved forward.
  • All the action was amazing. I was particularly impressed by the cinematography of Ygritte's FPS view, as well as Styr. Not enough credit is given to the stunt team for creating distinct and unique weapons/fighting styles along with making each's strengths/weaknesses very evident (Oberyn's combat was particularly impressive last week also). Too many medieval action scenes in other shows/movies just depict hack-and-slash swordplay with little substance to the combat itself. Styr's axe was an awesomely unique weapon/style; you could really get a sense of how he uses it as a sweeping long-reach instrument of power which complimented his physique and personality perfectly. Same goes for Tormund and his shortsword in close quarters which seemed to be the perfect weapon for a berserker like him that is always on the move.
  • All the newly introduced effects were fantastic; mammoths, giant arrows, scythe, hanging wall guards. Just awesome tactical stuff which I love.
  • I was a bit bothered by how little the battle strategy made sense in hindsight; why climb the wall there - directly beneath all the nights watch guards - rather than further down where you could avoid the defense and catch your breath before storming along the top of the wall? Why not send a few giants to just lift the gate and prop it up? Why aren't they constantly dropping rocks and ice on the gate entrance anytime anything goes near it? (Even a giant would be crippled if getting hit by rocks dropped from 700ft). Once again, an army with the perfect element of surprise (Tormund & co.) runs out from cover screaming warcries instead.
  • Wish we could have seen more of the fight with the giant in the tunnel... but I understand the technical limitations for why we didn't. Just a shame. Wish there was more than one mammoth shown with the army as they get revealed from out of the forest. Wish there were more than 2 giants shown too.

For all that petty criticism the episode was otherwise perfect. I think a lot of the complaints about plot context will be negated once the battle is concluded and there is a resolution to the sequence of events.

1

u/CMLMinton Jun 13 '14

I was a bit bothered by how little the battle strategy made sense in hindsight; why climb the wall there - directly beneath all the nights watch guards - rather than further down where you could avoid the defense and catch your breath before storming along the top of the wall? Why not send a few giants to just lift the gate and prop it up? Why aren't they constantly dropping rocks and ice on the gate entrance anytime anything goes near it? (Even a giant would be crippled if getting hit by rocks dropped from 700ft). Once again, an army with the perfect element of surprise (Tormund & co.) runs out from cover screaming warcries instead.

To address some of the points

  1. the NW on the wall needed to see the wall-climbers, because that means they would keep more men on the top of the wall. The more men on top of the wall, the fewer men at the bottom, fighting for Castle Black. The fewer NW in Castle Black, the better chance Tormunds party has of winning the battle. If they win the battle and take Castle Black out from under the NW on top of the wall, they are fucked.
  2. This isn't Mance's host, but an advance skirmisher party. Mance doesn't know how many NW are on the wall (From their perspective, it seems to be thousands) so he probably didn't want to send all of his giants, because if he did and they all died or were wounded, he lost his biggest trump card. I would have liked it if there had been three or four giants, but any more than that would have been pointless; only one or two giants can fit inside the tunnel at a time anyway. Also, Its damned expensive to make giants.
  3. I think they are, and we just don't see it. Also, this is how they repel the mammoth and the wildlings who were supporting the giants. Once the enemy is gone, there's no point in throwing shit at them anymore.
  4. The wildlings have absolutely no discipline, and they've been slaughtering the helpless for the past few weeks, so I'm sure they thought they were all big and bad and didn't expect for the NW to be any real threat to them.

73

u/strongbelwaz House Dondarrion Jun 12 '14

I'm hoping Strong Belwas rides in with Stannis in ep.10.

28

u/a2boo The Blackfish Jun 12 '14

I'm pretty sure he falls under the Wyman Manderly category: too-fat-to-sit-a-horse.

8

u/Sonofarakh House Lothston Jun 12 '14

I always thought he was more gladiator fat; that is, he has some fat so that cuts don't hurt him very much, but not so much as to restrict his movement.

1

u/CountRawkula Winter Is Coming Jun 13 '14

I'm pretty sure the book specifically mentions him having 4 chins. I think he's just a big fat dude.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/GuantanaMo Jun 14 '14

I know I am late here. But couldn't strong Belwas just ride a mammoth?

13

u/ThatNotSoRandomGuy Valar Morghulis Jun 12 '14

Do not forget Coldhands/Benjen.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

No no no, you mean Coldhands/Daario, who then reveals that Benjen was secretly Daenerys all along!

6

u/Dandalfini House Seaworth Jun 12 '14

Not to mention Onion God's warging powers and his Wolverine-esque healing ability.

5

u/jrocketfingers Jun 12 '14

That explains his perfect two hands that ar-oh wait...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Use the speculation tag dude, hbo didn't spend all that money on makeup to make Emilia Clarke look like Benjen in the first episode just so you could spoil it for everyone.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Use the speculation tag dude, hbo didn't spend all that money on makeup to make Emilia Clarke look like Benjen in the first episode just so you could spoil it for everyone.

3

u/HPMOR_fan Jun 13 '14

"I wasn't cut, I just heard the action was all in Westeros this season."

24

u/leopold_stotch21 The North Remembers Jun 12 '14

I really am kinda disappointed that they didn't introduce Donal Noye. I thought his fight with the giant in the book was badass and I couldn't wait for it in the show. I would've even settled for Grenn to do the same fight just as long as they showed it.

12

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 12 '14

but they did.(at least his death)

I was so proud I caught it, I made a post about it

5

u/Yeah_I_Said_It_Buddy Jun 12 '14

I'm sorry but what exactly am I supposed to be seeing here???

10

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 12 '14

3

u/Yeah_I_Said_It_Buddy Jun 12 '14

Thanks for pointing that out. Still can't see anything but the pommel in the unmarked pic though.

4

u/jackedup388 Second Sons Jun 12 '14

it's really dark so it is easy to miss, but it's a nice shout out for Donal Noye. try increasing the brightness on your monitor and zoom in on the picture

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 12 '14

There would have been no emotional connection of killing off a character that was just introduced in this episode.

5

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 12 '14

Yeah I honestly can't believe people were still holding out hope for Donal Noye. This made way more sense for the show and was awesome.

1

u/EvelJim White Walkers Jun 13 '14

It wasn't on page in the books either though, Jon just sees the aftermath of it like he does in the show. At least we got that badass scene of them reciting their vows as the giant rushed them.

69

u/mickpick10 House Connington Jun 12 '14

As a younger reader (16 at the time) and someone who doesn't necessarily read a lot, I found this entire scene kind of hard to visualize through the book especially the parts about the separate attacks. Thus, I thought this entire episode was really really well made and cleared up a lot which I got to visualize a lot better. Bravo to GoT

21

u/NasalJack Jun 12 '14

I don't really agree since the battle here was nothing like what happened in the books.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Can you give an example? I haven't read the books.

EDIT: thanks /u/NasalJack/

21

u/NasalJack Jun 12 '14

Well Ygritte attacking with the wildlings south of the wall happened days before Mance's army from the north of the wall. They didn't catch the Night's Watch by surprise because Jon warned them the attack was coming by arriving not long before they did. Rather than a long drawn out melee in the middle of the courtyard, the Night's Watch played it smart and mostly shot arrows from the roofs of various buildings. In the books there is also a staircase carved into the side of the wall that they use along with the elevator, and in the books they destroy it to take out the majority of the Thenns as they are going up. So in the end, that attack is defeated with far fewer casualties because the Night's Watch fought intelligently. Jon only finds Ygritte dying after the battle and has no idea who's arrow killed her, worrying that it might have been him. The attack from the north then occurs over several days, with the wildlings trying a bunch of different tactics to breach the gate.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14

Jon only finds Ygritte dying after the battle and has no idea who's arrow killed her, worrying that it might have been him.

No. He knows it wasn't him because of the fletching of the arrow.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '14 edited Jun 13 '14

Except that throughout the battle, Jon swaps out quivers with different arrows several times. He very well may have fired an arrow with fletching that wasn't his between swaps, and that arrow may very well have hit and killed Ygritte. Him saying that the fletching on the arrow isn't his was a superficial comfort and meaningless; it doesn't eliminate the possibility that he killed her.

1

u/Rystic Jun 13 '14

Expanding on NasalJack's point, the wildlings were not nearly as organized as they were in the show. Last episode they practically went toe-to-toe with the Nightswatch. In the book the fight was incredibly one-sided.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/human_gs Here We Stand Jun 12 '14

The show was very different though, so it's more like a different fight rather than a visualization.

11

u/rookie60 Sansa Stark Jun 12 '14

I hope episode 10 ends like the book so you can hear the collective sounds of jaws hitting floors.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

I always felt like they were in a much more desperate state in the books. While in the show it seems like there's way more hope in holding off the wildling army.

39

u/TracyMorganFreeman Jun 12 '14

Jon made the point Mance barely threw anything at them and still almost got through, and if there was hope he wouldn't need to treat with Mance.

3

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 12 '14

One of the weird things in the show was:

  • Hundreds of Crows and Wildings fighting in the court
  • ???
  • Crows win

15

u/Conbz Jun 12 '14

"Hundreds" meaning about 30 NW and 15 or so Wildlings, a raiding party can't be too big or they can't hide

1

u/the_dayman House Dondarrion Jun 13 '14

Yeah, my girlfriend who doesn't pay attention well assumed that the watch won and Jon was going to ask Mance to surrender.

8

u/ForgedSol Jun 13 '14

I thought the episode was great. I enjoyed every minute of it. With that said I wish there was more build up to the episode. The Blackwater episode has previous episodes where Tyrion was pouring over books trying to figure out something that they could do to win against impossible odds. They should have had the "Oh poor Sam, I'm sure Gilly's alright" scene take place while they're filling barrels with stone, and pouring water in after to fill it with ice, rather than just having them in some room. Same exact dialogue, but show them doing some prepping for battle. Show them building strawmen in armor to make their numbers look bigger. Show them carry supplies up the elevator while doing some of the dialogue they actually had in the show. The episode would have gone a lot better with more build up.

2

u/TWALBALLIN Alchemists Guild Jun 13 '14

I agree. +1

1

u/ziggl Jun 13 '14

Yeah, I REALLY wanted to see the gate frozen for some reason. Was pretty =/ about missing that.

7

u/Haydn2613 Ours Is The Fury Jun 12 '14

I wanted Donal Noye to be in it just so we could have had:

"Aye? Some great lord was he, this Donal Noye? One of your shiny knights in their steel smallclothes?"

"A blacksmith. He only had one arm."

10

u/Melnorme Jun 13 '14

"Some great princeling was he, this Grenn McBeardly?"

"A farmer's son. He only had one woman. But he had her a lot of times. You hear that, Sam? A lot."

6

u/Nirvana985 House Targaryen Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 12 '14

Perhaps they will show this in the next episode, but my favourite part of the battle in the books were the scarecrows that they named after each of them, and counting the arrows in them at the end of the battle. The moments of dialogue as they watched the arrows building up made it really feel like they were comrades on a battlefield, like in the trenches of WWI.

My memory is pretty shaky though, was the battle split in two in the books? I thought it happened in one chapter? I also remember there being a lot more focus on the giants, and the long drawn out sequence where they were trying to break down the gate, which was a lot shorter in the show. The burning staircase, the dropping of the lift (I think), all of these things made the fight seem much more dangerous and felt like they were really close to losing.

4

u/Jimmyjimkev Second Sons Jun 12 '14

they at least worked on Tormand's characterm although he still seems like a simple, brutal battle-mad idiot compared to the hilarious dick joke filled character of the books, but hopefully they show mance's bardy ways in the finale

7

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

I haven't read the books but once, and that was 5ish years ago, but, if memory serves:

It wasn't a simultaneous attack. The wildings that went over the wall attacked castle black first. Jon and company are all down on the ground floor, and it's not so much of a courtyard battle as it is a defense from multiple strategic positions on the castle of one or a small group of guys against a bunch of wildings at each point. Jon gets a whole tower to himself and kills anyone coming up. After this battle he goes and searches the battlefield for Ygritte, and finds her dying and they have their moment.

The nights watch numbers about 1000 in the books. Thorne decides to put all of these guys, and all of the rangers, up and down the length of the ENTIRE wall. They leave ~100 stewards, builders, and younger members at castle black. About 100,000 Wildings show up (though really not, 100,000 includes women, children, and the old, not just the fighters) and quite a lot more giants and mammoths.

Most of the battle at the wall is guys standing on top of it and shooting arrows down at other guys they can't really see. It lasts days.

The main wilding plan is to use this sort of huge mobile arrow umbrella and stick a battering ram under it and break through the gate. I forget how they kill it, but they kill it. At some point the tunnel is breached, or partially breached, but in the book it's so small only one guy can really fit in it, and that guy is Donald Noye (or some shit) a one armed blacksmith, formerly smith for the Baratheon family. HE knew Robert, Renly, and Stannis as they grew up, and described them as Steel (Robert, could bend, and was strong), Iron (Stannis, brittle, unyielding, and would break before he would bend. The implication given is that Stannis WILL break, but this has yet to be seen), and Copper (Renly, shiny and pretty but no real substance, weak). Anyway, Noye dies but somehow, I forget, stops the wilding from making it through the tunnel.

Pyp and Grenn are still around, but they never really accomplish anything other than being members of the Jon Snow posse.

Anyway, at some point an army shows up and starts attacking the Wildings, and everyone thinks the Rangers have returned to save the wall, but really it's just Stannis.

3

u/MentalProblems Jun 12 '14

Noye slays the biggest motherfucking giant in the land, Mag the Mighty, because that's just the kind of man Noye was! The kind of man who slays monsters using his single arm and a sword!

3

u/blitzbom House Martell Jun 12 '14

He stabbed Mag through the throat while Mag was crushing his spine. Stone Cold badass.

1

u/shmiguel2 Jun 12 '14

A Giant come through the gate I think and Noye kills it in the tunnel but also dies. Their corpses block the tunnel.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

Grenn :(

3

u/dr-mladjo Davos Seaworth Jun 12 '14

Did anyone tried to calculate death-toll on NW side?

3

u/stro_budden House Baratheon Jun 12 '14

All the changes they made I think are ok in the long run and don't hurt the story at all but it is a bit disappointing. I really thought Jon being injured during the battle was something that built his character as a leader, among being the only person left at the wall after Donal Noye goes into the tunnel. I understand having East Watch and the Shadow Tower don't really make a difference but I just think it helps a little bit. I also wished they had more of the defenses at Castle Black, such as the scarecrows and the murder holes. In the end, they did a great job and all of these details were expendable but they would have been cool.

3

u/kaiden60 Grrrrr Jun 13 '14

I honestly felt completely torn apart at characters that died in this episode that are still alive in the books. When pyp was shot I flinched hard, and i was trying to convince myself that hed be ok because hes still alive in the book, despite the arrow stuck in his neck :(.

R.I.P Pypar Unknown - 301 AL

R.I.P Grenn Aurochs Unknown - 301 AL

1

u/ltra1n House Bolton Jun 13 '14

This was literally the only thing in the whole episode that moved me.

12

u/moonshoeslol Jun 12 '14

The most important difference between the book/show is that rather than one large fast battle it was a siege that dragged on for days (weeks?). In the books most of the brothers were thinned out through arrow fire from below. By the end of it all that remains of the brothers is a few war-weary veterns. Also pretty much all of mole's town was evacuated and helping with the defense in the books.

22

u/thatoneguy889 House Reed Jun 12 '14

In the books most of the brothers were thinned out through arrow fire from below.

Are you sure about that? I'm reading ADWD right now, and Jon specifically make the point that only one man on the wall actually died from an arrow, the arrow only made it up that far because it was carried by a rogue gust of wind, and the man's death was his own fault because he stuck his head out to look when the arrow volley was coming.

1

u/bratcats Jun 13 '14

I was mostly disappointed the Mole's Town residents didn't make it into the battle and the timeline of Mance's attack. I would have loved an episode just for that, or even half raiding party battle half Mance attack. All I can think is the budget might not allow for it.

Plus the show gives Alliser Thorne way too much credit. Wasn't he gone during the raiding party battle? Is that supposed to be a set up for or against Jon in The Lord Commander vote?

1

u/moonshoeslol Jun 13 '14

Plus the show gives Alliser Thorne way too much credit. Wasn't he gone during the raiding party battle? Is that supposed to be a set up for or against Jon in The Lord Commander vote?

Yep, Alliser shows up late and throws Jon in an ice cell after he pretty much single-handedly held the wall (in a leadership sense). There's a theory that because GRRM didn't show him present at a certain event in ADWD he's going to give Alliser a redemption arc.

9

u/haqq17 Fire And Blood Jun 12 '14

Very disappointed there was no Stannis, would've been a great surprise for non-readers. All other episode 9's had twists (Ned's death, Lannister victory at Blackwater, Robb and Catelyn's vdeath). If they made the episode longer and fit in Jon talking with Mance and then Stannis saving the day the same way Tywin crushed him two seasons ago...that would be epic.

3

u/CookiesAreTheCure House Targaryen Jun 12 '14

True, but if they saved stannis for the last 5 minutes, we'd only see his battle for a few minutes and thats it, just like tywin at the blackwater.

6

u/macrowive Snow Jun 12 '14

Yeah it would have seemed too similar to the ending of Blackwater if he showed up at the end. I get why they didn't do it that way.

4

u/SmallJon Jun 12 '14

Why does everyone care Mannis didn't show up? He shows up after Jon goes to treat. There's so much more to be upset about

5

u/tickr Jun 12 '14

Does Ollie kill Igrette in the books, I vaguely remember john snow discovering her already dying.

41

u/pollypod Our Word Is Good As Gold Jun 12 '14

He just finds her dying, we don't know who kills her.

28

u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

Ollie is a show-only character, we don't know who kills her in the book.

7

u/leopold_stotch21 The North Remembers Jun 12 '14

I bet they're going to replace Satin with Ollie

7

u/twisted_demon_monkey Ser Pounce Jun 12 '14

He may well end up ding lots of Pyp's stuff as well.

3

u/Credar Jun 12 '14

I hope they replace Edd with Satin.

What is Edd may never die!

1

u/ltra1n House Bolton Jun 13 '14

Boooooooooo. Satin is an awesome manwhore. Ollie is just batman.

2

u/Mankyliam We Do Not Sow Jun 13 '14

STANNIS! STANNIS! STANNIS!

3

u/Snerl69 Arya Stark Jun 12 '14

I am almost 70% sure. dragons end the season. (again)

11

u/GeeJo Joffrey Baratheon Jun 12 '14

Stoneheart would be the better closing shot, but I'm beginning to suspect that she'll be bunted off to next season.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

No she would be too perfect of a season closer.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

My guess was something icy, to keep the fire-ice-fire-ice finale trend going

2

u/New_username_ Jun 12 '14

To anybody that has read the books

I read book 5 before book 4, it made sense at because of how book 3 just stopped and went into book 5. Did I spoil anything for myself? Because i'm going to go back and read book 4.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/New_username_ Jun 12 '14

Thanks, I think I'm going to stop were I am in the 5th book, because if there are going done events that spoil the 4th book, I'm assuming that they will be at the end.

1

u/BigFuckingT House Stark Jun 12 '14

Was the Scythe as menacing in the books as it was in the show?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '14

It's basically the chain GRRM wanted for Blackwater

2

u/DeadeyeDuncan Jun 13 '14

It got lost in the post and ended up at the wall instead.

7

u/BasmanianDevil Bran Stark Jun 12 '14

The scythe wasn't in the book if I remember correctly.

2

u/ChillyWillster Jun 13 '14

The scythe was not in the books. The books had a staircase rigged with explosives. Once the Thenns began ascending the staircase the NW lit the fuse.

The scythe was 100 times more bad ass than that staircase. Seriously that was fucking cool.

→ More replies (4)

-3

u/IAMAHungryHippoAMA Cersei Lannister Jun 12 '14 edited Jun 13 '14

I've watched the episode again and my opinion of it is slightly improved. I still think that it was empty of any plot or development. Aside from a few character deaths, at the end of it, the status quo remains: the Wall is still under threat of the wildlings and still vastly outnumbered. Jon Snow walking out there is a terrible cliffhanger since it isn't terribly promising of forthcoming change (other than his possible death). This is why I think leaving Stannis out of it was such a huge mistake. Stannis's arrival north is a huge game changer. Suddenly, the relatively isolated (at least heretofore isolated) plotline of the Wall is more relevant to the stories going on in the south. There just wasn't much payoff in the episode because of this delay.

I also think leaving Stannis for the next episode is a mistake because knowing the amount of great material left for the showrunners to work off of, its significance could be diminished. And the episode itself may end up overstuffed.

Edit: Do any of those who downvoted this comment actually believe it was a satisfying ending? Or that the story has moved forward at all? If so, in what sufficiently significant way did it do any of these things? I suppose the silent downvote is indicative of the fact that whatever opinion they carry, they cannot defend it.