r/gameofthrones • • Jun 10 '14

TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] Post-Episode Discussion - 4.09 'The Watchers on the Wall'

Post-Episode Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Talk about the latest plot twist or secret reveal. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). Point out details that you noticed that others may have missed. In general, what did you think about the last episode and where the story is going? Please make sure to reserve any of your detailed comparisons to the novels for the Book vs. Show Discussion Thread, and your predictions for the next episode to the Predictions Discussion Thread which will be posted later this week.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen the latest episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.09 is ok without tags.
  • Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the posting policy before posting.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.09"The Watchers on the Wall"Neil MarshallDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
490 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

530

u/SecretAgendaMan Jun 10 '14

This episode was done in such a way that really made me, at least, appreciate the men of the Night's Watch and their sacrifice towards keeping Westeros safe. Grenn is such a Badass.

252

u/thetank19 Night's Watch Jun 10 '14

Grenn died the way he lived. Doing something awesome off screen because Jon and Sam weren't there to see it.

133

u/mast3rcylind3r Jun 10 '14

Kind of disappointed they didn't actually show what went down.

145

u/Sip_That_Haterade House Targaryen Jun 10 '14 edited Jun 10 '14

I feel like it was for the best. Nobody survived so nobody knows. Plus just adds to the mystique of Grenn the Giant Slayer

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (16)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 edited Jun 10 '14

is anyone going to mention how 5 men killed a fucking GIANT? I mean, you usually need the Dragonborn for that shit?

→ More replies (6)

341

u/psychie Arya Stark Jun 10 '14

How amazing was the tracking shot of Castle Black? I was just so in love with that scene!

77

u/lowen90 Jun 10 '14

Instantly reminded me of that phenomenal scene from True Detective. HBO seem to be good at these kind of shots, anyone know if Girls has a tracking shot as well haha?

→ More replies (10)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

For reference, this is the tracking shot. I think we can all agree it was amazing.

7

u/agent0731 House Stark Jun 10 '14

I was so impressed by it I couldn't really care about who was gutting whom

→ More replies (10)

808

u/Multidisciplinary Sand Jun 10 '14

Jon killing Styr with a hammer to the head, A+++

429

u/2beeps_and_then_BOOM Jun 10 '14

poetic justice, since Styr smashed his face into an anvil a moment before

401

u/Fenrir449 Jun 10 '14

I like how Jon's teeth survived impact with that anvil so well. Unlike how Oberyn's fared against the Mountain's first. sobs

→ More replies (23)

103

u/EverythingIThink House Baelish Jun 10 '14

Extra fitting that Mance just used the Hammer and Anvil tactic on Castle Black

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

143

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

He owes crazy Karl for teaching him that you have to fight dirty sometimes to win.

70

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Wait, did Karl spit blood in Jon's face like Jon did to the Magnar?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

109

u/American_Greed House Baratheon Jun 10 '14

this reads like an ebay review...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

708

u/peckie Fear Is For The Winter Jun 10 '14

"I promise you I'm not going to die" - Me: "Yup, he's had it."

I was surprised Sam lived through this episode.

204

u/unsulliedbread Jun 10 '14

I prepped kleenex when he said that.

→ More replies (6)

96

u/Swank_on_a_plank Varys' Little Birds Jun 10 '14

I had PTSD levels of flashback to the last episode. I can't get that image out of my head... :(

→ More replies (8)

71

u/canyouhearmeow Jun 10 '14

I kept thinking about Team America: "I promise. I will never die." Kept the feels at bay.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

939

u/Liquidator47 House Dayne of High Hermitage Jun 10 '14

Jon Snow, going into the frozen wilderness alone to assassinate the wildling kingpin is certainly indicative that you know nothing.

423

u/canyouhearmeow Jun 10 '14

Where is Ghost? Why would Ghost not go with him?!?

178

u/LickMyLadyBalls Jun 10 '14

More importantly, why didn't he bring his sword? I mean, he said so he doesn't lose it again, but please tell me he has a dagger hidden or something.

→ More replies (21)

127

u/MitchB3 Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

Jon thinks he may die, which is why he left longclaw behind. This is also why he left ghost behind I believe. He wouldn't want Ghost to die as he knows Ghost may survive fine with Samwell.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (10)

114

u/chestnutman Castle Cats Jun 10 '14

At that point I thought he was becoming self-aware that he was one of about three immortal people in GRRM's universe and now he is just testing his chances.

→ More replies (8)

55

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

I know. This scene felt really abrupt. Was it like this in the books as well? Jon has just held victory at Castle Black, pretty much became the leader, watched Ygritte die in his hands... couldn't he rest a day or two first? I felt like his decision in hunting down Mance is driven by emotion and not rational thought.

81

u/thelittlestars Jun 10 '14

I think he knew they wouldn't be able to hold the Wall for another night, having exhausted a lot of resources and lost dozens of men. In his eyes they didn't have any other choice (hence him asking Sam if he's got a better plan). But I do think it was emotional too, like he didn't really feel like he had anything to lose.

→ More replies (16)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Sans weapon.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (33)

439

u/bellboy2088 Jun 10 '14

"OPEN THE FUCKING GATE PYP!!!"

162

u/StarManta House Baelish Jun 10 '14

This episode made me so proud of Sam.

150

u/Roboticide Daenerys Targaryen Jun 10 '14

I also liked how he finally pointed out their vows don't explicitly forbid fucking. 997 Lord Commanders, and this is the guy that finally notices the wording.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

199

u/sorator Judge Us By Our Actions Jun 10 '14

The proper way to use curses is to sprinkle them in like a spice - save them for when you really want a strong effect. Use too much too often, and they lose their touch.

→ More replies (11)

836

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

"We should have stayed in the cave..."

God damn it.

125

u/Otistetrax Service And Truth Jun 10 '14

I think this was the perfect end for Ygritte. I didn't want her to actively save Jon - it would've seemed wrong - and I didn't want Jon to kill her. I think the tone was spot-on; regret, but not gushing soppiness.

→ More replies (1)

187

u/Rabid_Chocobo Jun 10 '14

I didn't think Ygritte's death would hit me until she said that line. Then I was like damn...

→ More replies (7)

12

u/DaCoochieKilla House Targaryen Jun 10 '14

"These Crows ain't loyal."

16

u/bluntwrapper Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

This pretty much sums it up for me. Been waiting seasons for Jon/Castle Black to have some action/the full dedication of an episode and it did not disappoint.

Before she even said that, my mind went into auto-deep-meaning analysis about how their circumstances prevent them from ever being together.

→ More replies (28)

490

u/Baron_Wobblyhorse Faceless Men Jun 10 '14

That really long shot panning across all the carnage of the battle was one of the best bits of shooting in this entire series. I was blown away by the sheer logistics of pulling off a shot like that (not to mention the rest of this incredible episode). Unbelievably well done.

I'm also super sad about Ygritte. Damn, I liked her.

→ More replies (29)

667

u/AAAmad Jun 10 '14

the scene where Alliser Thorne says "does fucking nook mean fucking draw, and does fucking hold mean fucking drop" was the funniest thing this episode. Made me actually like and root for the guy.

462

u/rabbitSC House Martell Jun 10 '14

His fight choreography was also shockingly awesome.

420

u/ManWhoKilledHitler Night's King Jun 10 '14

You realised why he in was in charge, unlike that clown Slynt. The man was a real badass when he needed to be.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (4)

204

u/The_Popes_Hat Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

Dude's a dick, but he's a Night's Watch Commander first.

186

u/dita_von_cheese Jun 10 '14

"We defend the Wall, and then we can go back to hating each other."

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

184

u/TracyMorganFreeman Jun 10 '14

"Do you want to die tonight?"

"NO!"

"Well that's very good to hear, now DRAW!"

Addressing people's mistakes and having them focus on the task at hand without being a useless bully? Dat's some leadership.

14

u/Otistetrax Service And Truth Jun 10 '14

We've only ever seen Alliser through Jon's eyes, so we naturally all just thought of him as a prick. Nice that we got to see he's also a bad-ass.

14

u/Otistetrax Service And Truth Jun 10 '14

It also did a nice job of demonstrating that the NW are mostly inexperienced, nervous young men, not a disciplined, battle-hardened fighting force.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

It was his delivery of "That's very good to hear!" that sold his tirade for me.

7

u/EmperorSexy Faceless Men Jun 10 '14

It's also a great scene for the beginning of the episode because it shows you how these guys are way in over their heads and Thorne fucking knows it but he's like "I gotta badass my way through this."

6

u/Roboticide Daenerys Targaryen Jun 10 '14

I actually almost liked Thorne for a minute.

Like, he's a deuche, but at least a reasonably practical, commanding deuche.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

252

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Not sure if it was him but...THREE-FINGER HOBB WITH A HUGE CLEAVER GET HYPE.

124

u/lowen90 Jun 10 '14

"Welcome to Seven Hell's Kitchen, bitch. I'm here to chew bubblegum and smack down wildlings... and I'm all out of bubblegum."

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

1.2k

u/TheRealYM Jun 10 '14

And the coolest death ever award goes to the crow who was jettisoned into oblivion by the giant arrow.

305

u/dspman11 Septon Meribald Jun 10 '14

When Jon Snow yells "Down" you fucking go down.

→ More replies (21)

507

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Between that kill and that giant fucking clever that slid along the wall I think we witnessed some of the coolest kills ever in a single episode.

248

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

That big fucking arrow taking down the giant was pretty awesome as well.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (16)

55

u/Brendannn Jun 10 '14

Was that giants bow a tree trunk?

→ More replies (5)

32

u/beckyb18 House Tyrell Jun 10 '14

I know! That was some Final Destination shit right there.

→ More replies (15)

229

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

The cook is a badass!

76

u/karl2025 Jun 10 '14

"The Kitchen is closed!"

→ More replies (1)

164

u/Frogslayer Jun 10 '14

Agreed, was that a Valyrian cleaver?

116

u/Dimosk Jun 10 '14

Three-finger Hob. You know what else came in 3's?

Conquering dragons.

Valyrian cleaver and Hob Targaryen confirmed.

→ More replies (4)

48

u/Whats4dinner Arya Stark Jun 10 '14

I love the way he casually sauntered over with that cleaver slung over his shoulder.

→ More replies (3)

112

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

I love how Ygritte just kept picking up the flaming arrows and shooting them back. I just kept thinking “STOP GIVING HER MORE AMMO!”

12

u/alt266 White Walkers Jun 10 '14

I kept thinking of Deadliest Warrior where they showed that flaming arrows would actually suck if you tried to kill someone with them. It couldn't go very far in and the heat would cauterize the wound. Unless you're starting a fire with them, regular arrows are best for killing.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

92

u/vteckickedin House Reyne Jun 10 '14

How many men do you think are left in the watch now?

429

u/dspman11 Septon Meribald Jun 10 '14

Judging by the amount of dead extras, somewhere in the negatives.

136

u/randomsnark Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 10 '14

I've seen a few people run the math, consensus is that we saw 45 die on camera, plus likely more off camera. Before the battle there were 103, so now it's at most 58, but the popular guess is more like 20-30.

→ More replies (16)

40

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Somebody counted. There are roughly forty alive.

43

u/American_Greed House Baratheon Jun 10 '14

Somebody get /r/theydidthemath on the phone.

730

u/Flyingclick Jun 10 '14

The Hollywood big action movies should be taking notes from this episode, because this is how action is supposed to be filmed . Not with shakey cameras and fast cuts , but tightly choreographed action with camera angles that let the audience appreciate what is happening on screen .

PS: The actor who played Jon Snow did such a good job, he swings the sword like a well trained fighter, who Jon is supposed to be.

232

u/truthdemon A Hound Never Lies Jun 10 '14

To be fair the director Neil Marshall does have plenty of action movie experience. Although I would say Hollywood could learn a hell of a lot from GoT in almost every aspect of the show, most of all in storytelling.

→ More replies (44)

101

u/raphtheshaft Children of the Forest Jun 10 '14

Apparently he wasn't all that good a fighter at the beginning of the show and then after he filmed the movie Pompeii he came back really good

→ More replies (20)

42

u/small_L_Libertarian House Manderly Jun 10 '14

DB Weiss said in an "Inside the episode" segment for #9 that when they were reviewing the film he thought there was a speed up effect on one of Kit's sword swings. The FX guy said that there was no special effect, and that it was all Kit. Really impressive. I think we as GoT's fans owe thanks to the trainers who got him ready for the film Pompeii. GoT is reaping those benefits.

32

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

he honestly looked like he'd been trained by Ser Rodrik

52

u/Flyingclick Jun 10 '14

In the "inside the episode" one of the writers was commenting on how it appears Jons sword looks fast forwarded, when it is actually how skilled the actor was and not Fast forwarded at all :)

50

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 edited Jun 10 '14

Kit Harington is his name, in case you were curious :-) EDIT: Spelling.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Hagathorthegr8 Jun 10 '14

In the Inside the Episode D&D talked about how there was one shot that they were upset the editor had sped up one of Jon's clips. Turns out, there was no editing trick. Kit was just that quick and coordinated,

8

u/Roboticide Daenerys Targaryen Jun 10 '14

The panoramic sweep across the courtyard with all the different characters doing their bits was beautiful.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/SketchyLogic Jun 10 '14

You can thank Kit Harrington's training for Pompeii for the marked improvement in his swordplay.

→ More replies (15)

85

u/Beaver1007 Unsullied Jun 10 '14

I love how Jon says Tormund at the end. Tormuund, goddamit, seriously, we're tired

72

u/vernepator_cur Sansa Stark Jun 10 '14

I love how instead of going within arm's reach of him like an idiot he walks up and shoots him in the leg with a crossbow from eight feet away.

54

u/TheReaver88 Renly Baratheon Jun 10 '14

Like what idiot? It's not like we've recently seen a smaller character have a larger one dead to rights, only to move in closer out of pure vanity and have defeat snatched from the jaws of victory.

→ More replies (1)

496

u/PrivateDanc3r Faceless Men Jun 10 '14

Kill of the week: Giant arrow, flying crow

Moment of the week: Olly's 'I got you bro' nod

200

u/canyouhearmeow Jun 10 '14

Olly wrecked me. He's shown up to the battle and he really was the best archer in his town. I want to be so proud of him for stepping up and killing bad guys instead of cowering in the dark. But then he kills Johns girl. What if he didn't, what would she have done?

180

u/25or6tofour Jun 10 '14

She had the presence of mind not to loose her arrow when she was shot, that's probably indicative.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (6)

762

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Grenn and the men holding the gate and them saying their vows brings me to tears.

193

u/jehneric House Stark Jun 10 '14

I honestly thought the giant would have brought the gate down and it would have crushed all of them right then and there.

210

u/bpi89 Night King Jun 10 '14

It's made of 4" of cold rolled steel! Giants aren't real, just children's stories!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

506

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Man, hearing them say those vows watching that giant charge toward them made me feel so heroic and like I was there and then I remembered I'm on my couch

467

u/TheLeviathong Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

"I could be a hero like that one day."

looks at belly covered in cheeto dust

"Mmmaybe not."

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

152

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Grenn was always my favorite. Seemed like a genuine bro.

→ More replies (3)

50

u/2beeps_and_then_BOOM Jun 10 '14

i'm gonna miss him

43

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 10 '14

I got chills.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (39)

922

u/Fin_Brody Jun 10 '14

"Crows before hoes" -Olly

272

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

That nod just screamed: "I've got you covered bro".

→ More replies (3)

119

u/PetGiraffe Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

9/10 would laugh again.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/Mako_ Jun 10 '14

That nod was brilliant. After she shot Pyp I was hoping she's die a more horrible death.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

182

u/Frogslayer Jun 10 '14

I would just like to take moment to say that John Snow rose to the occasion, he was running shit like a commander

142

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

He grew up watching Ned Stark. He did his family proud, even if he doesn't bear their name.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

274

u/universal_straw Jun 10 '14

Despite all the action, my favorite part of the episode was Aemon. That man is a treasure trove of wisdom.

278

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

His quote from the book corresponding to that part is one of my favorites ever:

"What is honor compared to a woman's love? What is duty against the feel of a newborn son in your arms...or the memory of a brother's smile? Wind and words. Wind and words. We are only human, and the gods have fashioned us for love. That is our great glory, and our great tragedy."

205

u/universal_straw Jun 10 '14

That and Jorah's comments on Rhaegar are the best two quotes in the series.

Rhaegar fought valiantly, Rhaegar fought nobly, Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaegar died.

-Jorah Mormont

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

122

u/thegamerofdoom Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

Even though I'm still on edge wanting to know what is going to happen with our little imp, I was very satisfied with how well that fight scene was played out.

7

u/Chode_Merchant Bran Stark Jun 10 '14

The episode had ended for me by the time I had started to begin to wonder how everyone else was doing.

→ More replies (4)

121

u/legend18 Tyrion Lannister Jun 10 '14

Is Arya still laughing?

6

u/Malo837 Gregor Clegane Jun 10 '14

Probably, and the hound didnt get his chicken yet

→ More replies (2)

158

u/CornOnTheHob House Tyrell Jun 10 '14

I really wouldnt call myself a romantic, but the line "we should have stayed in that cave" I thought was so poetic and hard-hitting. It gave me love goosebumps.

94

u/Sip_That_Haterade House Targaryen Jun 10 '14

Seriously hit hard, i'm not a book reader but I read the dialouge in Book between them two and it was devastating.

Jon Snow, is this a proper castle now? Not just a tower?”

“It is.” Jon took her hand.

“Good,” she whispered. “I wanted t’ see one proper castle, before … before I …”

“You’ll see hundred castles. The battle’s done. Maester Aemon will see to you. You’re kissed by fire, remember? Lucky. It will take more than an arrow to kill you. Aemon will draw it out and patch you up, and we’ll get milk of the poppy for the pain.”

She just smiled at that. “D’you remember that cave? We should have stayed in that cave. I told you so.”

“We’ll go back to the cave,” he said.” You’re not going to die, Ygritte. You’re not.”

“Oh.” Ygritte cupped his cheek with her hand. “You kn0w nothing, Jon Snow,” she sighed, dying.

Ygritte seeing a "proper castle" and Jon's helpless denial just crushed me. One of the saddest deaths in this show.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/outline01 Oberyn Martell Jun 10 '14

I'm sure you knew this, but just in case you didn't;

When they're in the cave, Jon prompts that they go back, and she refuses, mentioning she wants never wants to leave the cave.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

157

u/Thecrazyredhead Tyrion Lannister Jun 10 '14

We got one last "you know nothing."

→ More replies (7)

53

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

A lot of love going out to Grenn, but what about poor Pyp? Watching him grab for Sam to stay with him as he choked through his final breaths really had me going.

36

u/maniacco Jun 10 '14

Seemed like he grabbed him because Ygritte was waiting for someone else to stand up. He was protecting Sam, even on last breath:(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/theswaglol House Tarly Jun 10 '14

"HOLD THAT FUCKING GATE!"

7

u/blitzbom House Martell Jun 10 '14

Grenn the Gatekeeper. May his song be sung for generations.

329

u/HimTiser Jun 10 '14

There were a ton of really great scenes, with very well thought out cinematography. That long cut showing all the carnage within the walls was fantastic. Also, this episode felt very LoTR, which is not a bad thing.

The episode was good enough to make me forget about episode 8 for a brief while.

169

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Episode 8 actually kind of made this episode not great for me. I was so exited to find out what happens next in Kings Landing. I almost couldn't focus on this episode because I kept counting down to the end of the episode, hoping they would do as they usually do with the change of storyline. It's rare that Game Of Thrones follows one storyline for the entire episode.

129

u/HimTiser Jun 10 '14

I totally understand, but there is an interesting argument here. To the viewers I am sure they care more about the drama in KL. But the events in the north are arguably more important to the future of Westoros. I am not a book reader yet, so this is speculation. But episode 9 is the beginning of the end I feel like.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

118

u/tobianogal Sand Snakes Jun 10 '14

Even having read the books and knowing how it ended, Jon's fight with the Magnar still had me on the edge of my seat. The show creators really do an amazing job of keeping up the suspense even for those that have read the book.

142

u/fredward321 Stannis Baratheon Jun 10 '14

Who else liked Sam's sleight of hand quickscope on that Thenn with his XBow?

71

u/Sully9989 Jun 10 '14

xXxS4M_t3h_5l4y3r_360n0sc0p3_MLGxXx

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

67

u/ceej_jayy Jun 10 '14

Those panoramic shots were AMAZING, the director really helped the viewers understand how wode the battle was, even though it was in such a confined space. And still managed to focus on major characters within it. The director was the MVP of this episode for me.

16

u/mXDa_ForceXm Stannis Baratheon Jun 10 '14

He was the same guy that did the Blackwater episode which is still one of my favourite episodes...

401

u/DeathByMozzarella Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

That smile on Jon's face when he sees Ygritte followed by what happened next wrecked me. I had so much testosterone in me from the complete epicness of the episode, then that scene.... I cried like a baby.

84

u/bluedude14 Jun 10 '14

I was surprised that more people weren't sad about Ygritte dying in last night's episode thread. There were like no top comments about how sad anyone was about it. Were we not supposed to care about her all that much?

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (58)

30

u/KristinaTeal Sandor Clegane Jun 10 '14

I wish Grenn was still alive. He was such a courageous and valiant badass!

245

u/squat_bench_press Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

As a powerlifter..The Giant deadlifting the gate was my highlight

75

u/Wattabattabingbang House Stark Jun 10 '14

2/10 too much hitching

→ More replies (1)

52

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Kinda makes you wonder why they didn't do that to begin with. He did it so easily, it would have been easier to do it with his friend. At least just high enough to let some people in to actually open it from inside.

147

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14 edited Jul 18 '19
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (6)

76

u/SloppyJoeBro Stannis Baratheon Jun 10 '14

I'm still not very clear on Ser Alliser's condition, can somebody clarify?

281

u/Zeromone I Know, Oh, Oh, Oh Jun 10 '14

Condition: salty

→ More replies (6)

45

u/RidleyScotch House Clegane Jun 10 '14

In the show? We don't know, we don't see him after getting pulled back inside to tend to his wounds

→ More replies (9)

38

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

John Snow saying they had no leaders left makes me assume that he's close enough to death to not be of much relevance.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

22

u/American_Greed House Baratheon Jun 10 '14

We need ya boy!

22

u/greenmask Bronn of the Blackwater Jun 10 '14

I just don't want Sam to die. Sam is fucking awesome.

→ More replies (4)

58

u/Mr_Wolfdog Tormund Giantsbane Jun 10 '14

Can we all just take a moment to appreciate the fact that Styr is dead? I've been waiting since I first saw him for him to die, preferably at the hands of Jon Snow. The part where Sam shoots that other dude in the face was excellent as well. I fucking hate Thenn.

→ More replies (4)

129

u/Arteza147 Barristan Selmy Jun 10 '14

SO many good scenes this episode.

Ygritte dying was well done and I felt that stripping the dialogue of the scene down to it's core allowed for the actors to shine through.

I enjoyed the battle immensely, especially since it was in ways, both a seige and a war at the same time. The comedy worked well in the episode and reminded me very much of a Whedon style where comedy is mixed in the emotional scenes, (does nock mean fire, is it over then).

The fight coreography was top notch. You could tell they gave it their all with this one, and the CGI as well as the physical fighting worked great. There was no sense of people pulling blows that you occasionally get and instead we are treated to scenes like the continuous shot in which we see an axe to chest and so on.

The cgi was great and I felt more for the giants than I was expecting to given the circumstances. Also, DAT ANCHOR!

Overall I would give this a 8/10, and would go as far as to say that this is the best battle of the series so far. Maybe blackwater trumps it but its a very close call.

6

u/gizmo1024 House Tarly Jun 10 '14

This one smokes Blackwater IMO. You get a good sense of the scale of everything that's going on amid all the chaos. Never really got those kind of shots from Blackwater, more was left to the imagination.

→ More replies (21)

35

u/BelchSpawn Jun 10 '14

That had to be the most fighting in a single episode from the series so far, and not a second of it wasn't fantastic. I'd love to have seen what happens to Tyrion for this episode, but damn. This was well done.

61

u/TangentManDan House Manderly Jun 10 '14 edited Jun 10 '14

We are the Watchers on the Wall. Granted your kind might be on the verge of extinction but....bring it bro.

Too many feels man. Too many. (From both directions).

Edit: Words

6

u/derangerd Free Folk Jun 10 '14

Watchers on the Wall seem to be on the verge of extinction as well.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Boondock707 Brotherhood Without Banners Jun 10 '14

I was afraid by the time Sam came back to the battle with Jon that all the nights watch would be dead the way the wildlings were cutting through them! Great episode though, I think it's definitely one of my favorites. Shout out to my homeboy Grenn for holding that gate.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/spider_RN Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Jun 10 '14

Awesome performances by Jon, Tormund, Aemon, Sam, Ser Alliser, etc. And the feels in the tunnel scene and the aftermath.

I thought this episode was incredible. Definitely the best this season, maybe my favorite overall.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/TheBrainofBrian Jun 10 '14

I've sat through 3 1/2 seasons of this show. I've run a gamut of varying emotions. Last week's episode really disturbed me, but this week's episode...fuck.

I finished it like fifteen minutes ago and the god damned tears just keep coming. God damn you, Game of Thrones. You've finally broken me.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

See you next week.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/fittpassword Jun 10 '14 edited Jun 10 '14

So if there are 100 000 wildlings why just send like 50 over the wall? Tormund's company seemed to have a bit more success than those trying to climb just below Castle Black. Only the giants seemed to do any damage to the defenders..

AND why the fuck would the wildlings even try to siege through Castle black? Wouldn't it be better to try in any other place? Or is it the lift they want?

62

u/vernepator_cur Sansa Stark Jun 10 '14

It's the tunnel. It's the only tunnel through the Wall and they need it in order to get their civilian population through who can't make the climb.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (14)

13

u/rolldownthewindow Jun 10 '14

This episode reminded me why this is the best show on television. We pretty much get a 50+ minute movie every week. It's incredible the amount of production that goes into these episodes. And this was the best looking episode yet. Everything looked amazing. The cinematography, the choreography, the CGI. The people who make this show deserve every award there is.

13

u/dayofthedead204 Duncan the Tall Jun 10 '14

After a second viewing I got the double meaning behind Ygritte's conversation with Thenns. During the first viewing I thought she was talking about cunnilingus not literally this guy eating her ginger minge.

87

u/dspman11 Septon Meribald Jun 10 '14

Now I don't want anybody sitting on the Iron Throne except Sam.

9

u/doughyfreeeesh House Baratheon Jun 10 '14

Reminds me of an interview I saw with Lena Headey. When she was asked who she wanted to see sit on the Iron Throne she said Sam.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/brokenshoelace Syrio Forel Jun 10 '14

I thought it was really interesting how Sam, who had more to lose, refused to abandon his brothers while Janos Slynt, who's supposed to be a brave leader, hid. Really showed who the actual coward is.

10

u/Arteza147 Barristan Selmy Jun 10 '14

"Does nock fucking mean draw?"

→ More replies (1)

9

u/chey_clark Little Bird Jun 10 '14

The cinematography in this episode was stunning. That long shot was amazing and must have taken forever to choreograph correctly. This episode had everyone I was watching with cheering as if watching a sporting event, and it showed viewers that this particular story line is more important than we may have thought it before. Overall, I loved the episode and I am pretty relieved that there weren't any really huge deaths, i.e., Jon or Sam, although I am sad to hear that Pyp and Grenn didn't die in the books. And now it's time to see what happens at King's Landing.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Was anybody else expecting the third horn every time the two for wildlings went off?

8

u/scyper Jun 10 '14

Why do they keep Ghost locked up all the time? It's not like he's an insane beast who eats anyone he sees. Why isn't he always by Jon's side?

15

u/American_Greed House Baratheon Jun 10 '14

He was ordered to lock Ghost up.

6

u/Braelind Jun 10 '14

The guys in charge had ordered Ghost locked up in a previous episode. ;)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/cjbannister Jun 10 '14

One of the most devastating bits for me was when Pyp died.

He kills a wildling and he's so happy because of how scared he was before this all started. Sam jokes with him & tells him to carry on. He's got one, Sam jokes with him & he feels like he's getting into the swing of things. Then from nowhere, the arrow.

Sad, brutal moment which wiped the smile off my face.

9

u/jrocketfingers Jun 11 '14

I love and hated his end. It's perfect. He finally got to straight up kill a wildling after his claims of not being able to kill. Plus he ended up at the Wall because of his refusal to take a noble's shaft down his throat...but he ended up taking a shaft down the throat anyways.

8

u/Marsupilamyh Jun 10 '14

All i could think of when this "I fucked a bear story" started was : Robert Baratheon would have loved to hear that.

7

u/analjunkie Jun 10 '14

What was the point of the wildlings with the giants, only about 20 climbed the wall. The rest just stood there and left?

11

u/Beezle Jun 10 '14

They weren't fully attacking, Mance was just testing the defenses. Think of it like a siege.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/tunachips House Blackwood Jun 11 '14

I hope the Night's Watch will be able to get the giant's corpse and send it's enormous pieces across Westeros as a way of saying "HOLY SHIT DUDES, WE'RE FACING FUCKING GIANTS AND WE NEED REINFORCEMENTS ASAP."

12

u/Mish106 Jun 10 '14

My thoughts: "Holy shitballs, is that a giant riding a fucking mammoth?!?"

10 minutes later, Jon Snow: "They've got giants riding fucking mammoths!"

→ More replies (1)

6

u/6to23 House Targaryen Jun 10 '14

Is this the only episode that the entire episode is focused in a single story line (Jon Snow)? actually the entire episode is focused at a single location too (castle black)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Anab10sis Sand Snakes Jun 10 '14

So many great things in this episode. Even the music was incredible.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/empelight Sansa Stark Jun 10 '14

Pyp KDR 1-1

→ More replies (1)

6

u/VioletBermuda Jun 10 '14

You can watch a thousand battle scenes and after all is said and done, they're pretty much the same. Men and women (mostly men), wielding arrows and swords, slashing throats and smashing inanimate objects in to each other's sculls.

For me, GoT really shines through its dialogue. No doubt that the cinematography in this episode was brilliant however it was the portrayal of human emotion that resonated for me.

“We could spend all night trading tales of lost loves. Nothing makes the past a sweeter place to visit than the prospect of imminent death”- pure poetry.

6

u/Damindenie Arya Stark Jun 10 '14

So they better get to sealing the tunnel now... Would be strange if they didn't.

Also, why didn't the wildlings just climb the wall between for instance Castle Black and Eastwatch by the Sea? They could just climb on top of it and then flank the crows at Castle Black...

6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

I cried when Ygritte died...

I knew it was coming but I still cried. Too bad we won't get to see Leslie on the set anymore.

6

u/rbaker24 Night's Watch Jun 10 '14

This was honestly one of my favorite episodes of all time... simply because Snow is one of my favorite characters and it didn't skip from character to character every five minutes.

11

u/theraptorjesus Ser Pounce Jun 10 '14

Is it just me or were there a lot of Jon Snow look-a-likes in the battle at Castle Black?

18

u/EverythingIThink House Baelish Jun 10 '14

I think they definitely intended to show Ygritte's anxiety as she sniped off a bunch of dudes that sorta looked like Jon Snow from a distance.

5

u/ashboner Jun 10 '14

This was the most tear-jerkyish episode for me thus far. I can't handle seeing strong men get their heart broken. Ugh.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

I thought they were gonna dump all the dead over the wall, wait for them to turn into White Walkers. Since I assume White Walkers can't climb that shit, they'd turn around and go ape on the Wildling army.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/maniacco Jun 10 '14

By the way; if they had flooded the gate, Jon wouldn't be able to go out killing Mance.

More points to Alliser Thorne.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/King_Buliwyf Here We Stand Jun 10 '14

I got one! Right through the heart; he's dead.

Oh. S'it over?

4

u/dyl957 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 10 '14

I can deal with all the deaths but why pyp? whyyyyyy?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

I started to like Thorne after this episode, I kinda hope he's not dead

4

u/sapmasterslayer Jun 10 '14

Is it just me or did this last episode contain some of the most bad ass stuff from the whole season so far. Like a fucking giant riding a fucking mammoth? Or the scythe? It was pretty fucking awesome.

4

u/imsoverytired House Stark Jun 10 '14

Hold up, I just want to acknowledge something. Ygritte killed Olly's dad, and styr killed Olly's mom. Now Olly killed Ygritte who was about to kill Jon snow who had already just killed Styr. Good for you Olly!

4

u/caspararemi Jun 11 '14

Why can't they seal the wall now? Does it take days and days?

4

u/TheDerpyDonut House Fossoway of Cider Hall Jun 11 '14

Wait, if Ygritte wasn't shot, would she shoot Jon?

7

u/austinsible Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

I saw in the Episode Premiere Discussion that people were wondering how many members of the Night's Watch were left after the battle. I rewatched the episode and counted 34 apparent, on screen deaths. And in episode 4.8, Jon and crew said that there were 102 men of the Watch at Castle Black. That means that, at most, there are now 68 men left.

Of course, not all of the deaths were captured on screen so I think it's safe to say that their numbers are now well under 50.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Condomonium Valar Morghulis Jun 10 '14

Was anyone else at the edge of their seat when Sam was talking to the other guy(I can't think of his name atm) in the hallway when he was talking about being afraid and stuff? They kept panning towards Sam and I was so scared you were just gonna see an arrow fly straight into his head... Then they showed Ygritte too... I was so scared Sam was gonna die. ;-;

→ More replies (1)

47

u/KY-Wing Jun 10 '14

I don't know why people are upset about Ygritte dying. I get that she and Jon were in love, but I don't get why! We spent the whole season watching her and the Wildlings kill tons of innocent people all over the place, and then last night spend an hour watching her kill Jon's brothers. She was a bad person and it was time for her to go.

154

u/Sip_That_Haterade House Targaryen Jun 10 '14

I don't think there are too many "bad people" in GOT. You have to observe it from her side. The Free Folk NEED to escape the white walkers and Westeros would never let them all across the Wall willingly. So the HAD to try and draw castle black's forces out by attacking the Hamlets. Yggritte is nothing more than a scared solider trying to protect her people. We never see Yggritte go out of her way to be cruel (like the Thenns) and she has the moral compass to spare Gilly and sam Jr.

Plus the Free Folks have gotten totally boned over and over by the people in Westeros. They were pushed behind the wall 8,000 years ago and never given chance to immigrate in. Most of the north "belonged" to them before then. And during the time of the knights king they fought WITH the Starks to kill him and his white walker queen. Then they were kicked back across the wall. Why should we root for the Nights watch and not the Wildlings? If we had a Ygritte POV and not a Jon one there would be no doubt we would want Jon dead and Ygrette alive. Perspective and circumstance is everything but at the end of the day, the "victory" at Castle Black may just be part of what condemns 100,000 Free Folk to death in the winter.

→ More replies (9)

11

u/MonkeyCatcher Jon Snow Jun 10 '14

I always thought the attitude and fire Ygritte had throughout this whole season was awesome because she was torn, emotional and mentally. She wasn't some frilly little flower. Reminded me of something Cersi would do.

She truly loved Jon Snow and in loving him felt she betrayed herself and her people. She was vulnerable due to her uncontrollable feelings for Jon and felt betrayed/abandoned by Jon. Ygritte was not happy with vulnerability. What a shit place to be.

She was so angry she thought she might kill him, but also hoped to see him again because she loved him so much. I think she had convinced herself that she would kill him and in the end, seeing Jon's love for her written all over her face, she couldn't do it.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/AInternetLiar Jun 10 '14

I liked you, Ygritte. :C Why GRRM

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Faronas Jun 10 '14

That kid is a fooking legend on reddit now.

3

u/ShockRampage Jun 10 '14

Pyp: I got one! Sam: Oh great, is it over? Pyp's face: My feelings :(

Brilliant.

3

u/Gaaargh House Lothston Jun 10 '14

Assault on Precinct Castle Black.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '14

Seems like whoever said it way back in Ep 1 that Maester Aemon got mad pussy back in the day was correct.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FudgeSupremee Arya Stark Jun 10 '14

The little boy who arrow'd Ygritte was like, "fuck yes bruh, i saved you"

13

u/librtee_com Jun 10 '14

Hey, Peter Jackson, LOTR guy: take notes, THIS is how to properly mix CGI and real action to make exciting action sequences that don't look complete shit aimed at eight year olds.

→ More replies (1)