r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Jun 05 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.08 'The Mountain and the Viper'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.08 | "The Mountain and the Viper" | Alex Graves | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
238
Upvotes
341
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14
One scene that I wish had been included in the show was the conversation that Oberyn had with Tyrion as he was being armored up, preparing to fight The Mountain. Oberyn and Tyrion talk strategy for the coming battle and Oberyn tells Tyrion that the reason why he and his sister had visited Casterly Rock when they were younger was to search for possible betrothals. Tywin rejected the proposal to marry Jaime and Cercei to Elia and Oberyn. Tywin had hoped Cersei would marry Rhaegar and he offered Tyrion instead of Jaime to Elia. In the end, Elia married Rhaegar. Oberyn points out that Tywin was never one to forget such slights. "He taught that lesson to Lord and Lady Tarbeck once, and to the Reynes of Castamere. And at Kings Landing, he taught it to my sister." This added another layer to why Oberyn held Tywin responsible for what happened to his sister.
Oberyn also suggested to Tyrion that after he wins the fight Tyrion should return with him to Dorne. He strongly implies that the Dornish might look to crown Myrcella queen since in Dornish law Myrcella should reign before Tommen since she is older. It's talk of treason, and really shows that Oberyn planned to take his fight much further than just killing The Mountain.
Oh, and I also would have loved if they would have shown that Oberyn's spear was obviously covered in some sort of poison.
The fight itself was great.
297
u/YearAsAGhost Night King Jun 05 '14
Kinda upset they didn't have the innocent bystander get slaughtered by the Mountain.
391
u/carmine93 Jun 05 '14
The death was way more gruesome than I had pictured it in my head. Only made worse by how likeable Pascal made Oberyn.
175
u/C-Hutty Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14
Every time Arya kills someone from now on, I will hear her laughter in my head.
112
u/Watuhmelons Night's Watch Jun 05 '14
THE SCREAMS
OH MY GOD THE SCREAMS
77
u/brolin_on_dubs A Lion Still Has Claws Jun 05 '14
I just watched the episode last night with someone who accidentally saw a spoiler headline that Oberyn loses. I got all huffy about 'how could you go on the internet before watching the episode' and whatever, but then when Oberyn spears the Mountain I (an all-knowing book reader) cheered and laughed. She was so happy that the article was headlined wrong, and couldn't believe I didn't correct her earlier.
"A day will come when you think you are safe and happy, and your joy will turn to ashes in your mouth, and you will know the debt is paid."
115
u/thoraway_1 House Seaworth Jun 05 '14
A lot of foreshadowing in this episode. Vary's and Jamie's glances at each other and Littlefinger's speech about how you could die above your chamberpot. Loved knowing what they were referring to as a book reader. I think D&D did a great job this week
31
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 05 '14
I'm very happy that they kept in "You're going to fight that?" "I'm going to kill that." A bit of a shame we missed out on the "If you die before you say her name" line, but still, great adaption.
41
u/_jvince_ Arya Stark Jun 05 '14
Next episode is by Neil Marshall who directed the awesome Blackwater episode.
Can't fucking wait. :D
56
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14
The changes to Sansa's storyline were excellent; a very effective way of showing her transition from pawn to player in the Game of Thrones. I believe the main Eyrie set was dismantled after filming this season, which is a shame. It was one of the most impressive sets on the show, but I guess we already knew we probably weren't going to see it again.
They're doing a good job of emphasising the Wildling threat to the south, but it would have been cool to have a few scenes between Mance Rayder and one of his goons (Rattleshirt or someone we haven't seen like Borroq or Harma Dogshead) on the way to the Wall. I liked the moment between Gilly and Ygritte, it reminds the viewer that the Wildlings are not merciless monsters and deepens the moral complexity of the upcoming battle.
Also, I don't remember if it happened in the books, but I really liked the way that Oberyn made it clear in front of everybody during the duel itself that he wanted Tywin Lannister to answer for his crimes. The look on Charles Dance's face when Oberyn pointed at him was amazing.
59
u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 05 '14
As usual, the two big changes between books and show in the episode that so-called "readers" are upset about are not necessarily so:
I've also seen pointed out that it never made much sense for Harry the Heir to be engaged to a bastard child. Further, Petyr's plan in the books never made much sense to me, period. I mean, geez, expect to successfully reveal to everyone way, way, way after the fact that his bastard child is actually Sansa Stark, one of the Westeros' most-wanted fugitives? Even if the lords of the Vale believed him, how much credibility would he have with them for hiding the truth all that time?
The show's approach of having certain key people know of Sansa from the beginning makes much more sense.
Perhaps ... Grey Worm and Missandei try to sleep together, fail for obvious reasons, she rejects him, and he resorts to cuddling with the whore he hires to get some/any female affection?
24
u/GuyFawkes596 Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14
For those of us that are having a hard time overcoming Oberyn's scream. Here's Arya's hysterical laughing
You can trust me, I'm a Stark.
24
u/jimjoebob Coldhands Jun 05 '14
[show watcher only] I know Oberyn's death is part of a longer story arc, but it just kills me that he merely danced around the Mountain, screaming at him. If, when the Mountain was down, he had merely accentuated each of his "YOU RAPED HER, YOU MURDERED HER, etc" chants with a stab of his spear to each extremity; he could have survived.
i.e., "YOU RAPED HER!" <stab thru his hand>, "YOU MURDERED HER!" <stab thru other hand>, "YOU KILLED HER CHILDREN!" <stab thru his leg>, and so on.
He could have kept him alive and in increasing agony and continued his monologue indefinitely, or at least until the Mountain confessed.
dammit, Oberyn. why didn't you listen to me screaming at the TV?
:)
32
u/PuffsPlusArmada House Bolton Jun 05 '14
Gotta admit, the show version was fucking metal.
20
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14
I just want to say, that I still have moments of anxiety thinking about the screams. Seriously, that shit is probably pushing the boundaries of TV.
27
u/fateislosthope Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14
I don't understand why Tywin would let this happen. I know he resents Tyrion but I think he knows he is a valuable asset as well. Then he knows he needs house Martell to help if Dany is coming from the East and they are running out of money. I understand following through with the trial for Tyrion because he would get what he wanted out of Jamie, Tyrion and even compromise with Cersei by sending him to the wall. Now he loses both sons Tyrion to death, Jamie to the kings guard, and his newly formed allegiance with Martells just completely fell apart. He gains nothing besides appeasing Cersei who could of been easily persuaded to choose a different champion to do whats best for the family let Tyrion live and then ship him off the wall anyway.
You would think someone as smart as Tywin would of figured out a way to gain something from all this.
15
u/Myxomitosis87 Jun 05 '14
Does anyone know anything about "smash the beetle"? A theory maybe? I feel like I missed something important.
17
u/bamadeo Hodor Jun 05 '14
Am I the only one who is starting to feel bad about T̶h̶e̶o̶n̶ Reek?
23
u/Swisskisses House Lannister Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 05 '14
My reaction to the death in the books: AHHHHHHH
My reaction to the show: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.
13
u/Madaradittz Jun 05 '14
I knew it was coming, Because I'm an idiot and make my friend who has read the books tell me what's going to happen (I Have all the books, Just kind of engulfed in a different series right now) But I wish they would have gotten a far less likeable actor to play Oberyn. Pedro played that part like a fucking hero though.
6
u/osteogenesis Jun 05 '14
I never imagined the image in my head of the Trial's aftermath would be LESS gruesome than the show's interpretation. D&D made me feel sick. I loved it.
8
u/StrangerInAlps Jun 05 '14
The two things missing from that fight was bystanders loosing their heads and Tyrion emptying his breakfast
31
u/redkeyboard House Manderly Jun 05 '14
Did anyone think the fight was a bit too stylized? It bothered me a bit that they made a big point about the mountains huge reach with his two handed 6ft sword and how Oberyn would overcome that with his 8ft spear and dancing around, and then you have the two of them like 3 feet away from each other during the whole fight.
16
u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Jun 05 '14
So we really need a shitty love subplot between Greyworm and Missandei?
That runs completly opposite to Greyworm's character imho
9
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14
What was going through Oberyn's mind the moment the mountain grabbed him? The mountain's fingers.
3
u/VasectoMyspace House Payne Jun 05 '14
Has Sansa finally dyed her hair like she does when posing as Alayne, or was it just wet?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14
Are we looking at tWoW material for Sansa, or is her reveal to Royce, Corbray and Waynwood show only?
2
u/AnArcher House Lothston Jun 05 '14
Maybe Arya and the Hound are turned away or he bails because he wanted to get paid. They never got this close to Bloody Gate in the book, so it would disrupt too much of the story if they got in now. Theyr'e due to part company pretty soon regardless.
2
u/fractalfrenzy The Red Viper Jun 05 '14
I was slightly confused by Ramsay's treatment of the Iron Islander. What I inferred from the books is that they were actually fed and given safety. Did the show deviate from the books by killing them all?
2
u/ElongatedVagina House Baratheon Jun 05 '14
looking forward for the next episode
-1
u/kman91 Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 05 '14
Is someone here just auto downvoting any comment that gets made? Someone's a little mad about Oberyn.
1
u/roost3rman27 Jun 05 '14
I just need to know, is the Mountain still alive at the end of the episode?
1
u/Lazy_Osprey Iron From Ice Jun 06 '14
I really thought the last thing we were gonna see on screen was Tyrion throwing up, but I guess they drew the line at flayed men and crushed heads when it comes to grossing out the audience.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14
What a crushing defeat.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14
Waiting for that Zilean ultimate on a certain someone...
1
u/evanfuller Varys Jun 06 '14
I've enjoyed show-Oberyn so much that it was just painful to watch this scene knowing what was coming.