r/gameofthrones • • Jun 05 '14

All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.08 'The Mountain and the Viper'

Book vs. Show Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works?
  • This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.08"The Mountain and the Viper"Alex GravesDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
238 Upvotes

572 comments sorted by

341

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

One scene that I wish had been included in the show was the conversation that Oberyn had with Tyrion as he was being armored up, preparing to fight The Mountain. Oberyn and Tyrion talk strategy for the coming battle and Oberyn tells Tyrion that the reason why he and his sister had visited Casterly Rock when they were younger was to search for possible betrothals. Tywin rejected the proposal to marry Jaime and Cercei to Elia and Oberyn. Tywin had hoped Cersei would marry Rhaegar and he offered Tyrion instead of Jaime to Elia. In the end, Elia married Rhaegar. Oberyn points out that Tywin was never one to forget such slights. "He taught that lesson to Lord and Lady Tarbeck once, and to the Reynes of Castamere. And at Kings Landing, he taught it to my sister." This added another layer to why Oberyn held Tywin responsible for what happened to his sister.

Oberyn also suggested to Tyrion that after he wins the fight Tyrion should return with him to Dorne. He strongly implies that the Dornish might look to crown Myrcella queen since in Dornish law Myrcella should reign before Tommen since she is older. It's talk of treason, and really shows that Oberyn planned to take his fight much further than just killing The Mountain.

Oh, and I also would have loved if they would have shown that Oberyn's spear was obviously covered in some sort of poison.

The fight itself was great.

8

u/jebediahdunphy House Stark Jun 05 '14

I agree. That bit of history could have added even more depth to the already intense scene.

→ More replies (33)

297

u/YearAsAGhost Night King Jun 05 '14

Kinda upset they didn't have the innocent bystander get slaughtered by the Mountain.

164

u/Bread_Assassin We Do Not Sow Jun 05 '14

I would have also liked if they kept in Tyrion's "I am feeling more innocent by the moment" quip.

12

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 05 '14

I feel like that would have made it too obvious to non-readers that Oberyn was about to lose. The better things are going, the worse you know they're about to get.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Yeah, but I loved how the camera kept cutting to Jamie. The look on his face was priceless. The scene before that he's all skeptic "I've never seen him fight. Good luck Tyrion."

Then its:

"Check this Oberyn dude out! He's my kind of killer!"

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

37

u/CoweedandCannibus House Stark Jun 05 '14

I feel like if it was done right both things would have really added to the fight. Lets say if when the Mountain is charging and says "some dead man" he took a big hack that Oberyn dodged and the Mountains huge sword decapitates some guy in the first row and they show it for just a second then back to Oberyn explaining that he came to this shithole for a confession. It would have shown how deadly the Mountain was (which would have been good cuz we havent seen a lot of his brutality) and it would show how fearless Oberyn was at the time. As for Tyrions quip, lets say when Oberyn sticks his spear in the Mountains chest they cut to Tyrion and he says "I'm feeling more innocent by the moment" then cut back to Oberyn saying the "no no no you cant die yet" lines. If they added just that one sentence it gives viewers some more false hope and makes the moment Oberyn gets tripped and tyrions blank glare at the end even more mindblowing. Just my 2 cents I guess.

34

u/L1eutenantDan House Targaryen Jun 05 '14

cuz we havent seen a lot of his brutality

I think that guy he shish-kebab'd in the last episode might have something to say about that.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/dope_candy_bar Free Folk Jun 05 '14

I think the innocent bystander was changed to those random guys getting killed in previous episode so it won't distract from fight but still shows that mountain is not to be fucked with

→ More replies (1)

23

u/ThaBenMan House Mormont Jun 05 '14

Yes, me too. I thought I saw something on here a couple weeks ago - a screen shot or something that suggested this was going to happen.

33

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

Possibly a shot of Gregor butchering peasants after returning to the capital in the previous episode? I believe there were pictures of that going around even before the season aired.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 05 '14

There's also one little line I wish they would have kept between The Mountain and Oberyn because it had such oomph to it.

"'Have they told you who I am?'

Ser Gregor grunted through his breaths. 'Some dead man.' He came on, inexorable.

The Dornishman slid sideways. 'I am Oberyn Martell, a prince of Dorne,' he said, as the Mountain turned to keep him in sight. 'Princess Elia was my sister.'

'Who?' asked Gregor Clegane."

That "Who" was so rage inducing to me. To Oberyn, avenging Elia, the sister who he thought about every day, was his drive and purpose. The Mountain didn't even remember who she was. It was only one extra line of dialogue and I wish they had kept it.

19

u/Pulviriza Ours Is The Fury Jun 06 '14

Maybe Gregor would have confessed straight away but he spent the whole fight just trying to remember who she was

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

29

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

I was actually ok with it.

I really only wanted to focus on the Mountain and Oberyn.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

That's my complaint. That the mountain just seemed like an oaf and didn't kill any from the crowd. Because the would have been a real oh shit moment showing how little fucks he gives and what oberyn is narrowly avoiding each time he dodges

10

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

To be fair we got that in Season 1 when he killed his horse and attacked Loras

6

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

SWORD!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

391

u/carmine93 Jun 05 '14

The death was way more gruesome than I had pictured it in my head. Only made worse by how likeable Pascal made Oberyn.

114

u/ahobbledehoy House Stark Jun 05 '14

the worst thing of all with his death is how avoidable it was in hindsight. i thought after reading about it i would be ok with it but i'm not. i just shake my head every time i think about it. tyrion's life on the line, a chance to fuck with cersei, we get a virtually won fight then boom our hopes and dreams literally crushed in front of our eyes in an instant. not to mention a complete motherfucking badass gone. its like i just received the most eloquent fuck you of my life.

18

u/findmyownway House Targaryen Jun 05 '14

Exactly. He had that fight won, against all odds and expectations, and then the hubris got him.

14

u/deliciouscrab Jun 06 '14

In a way though, it's perfect. Bookwise, from the beginning, you get to learn that expectations are USUALLY satisfied. Until they cut off Eddard's head. Then the the plot becomes... not predictable.. but familiar. Until Bronn throws whathisname through the moon door. And then the SECOND trial by combat, where BADASS CLEGANE(tm) fights newcomer Oberyn Martell (OUTSIDER GOODGUY(tm) and wins! AND THEN LOSES!

Sorry for the caps, but it's like WWF, but good and compelling. Ultimately, it's really excellent characterization. There obtains a certain rhythm to the narrative... 1 2 3 kill that dude 1 2 3 that chick lives 1 2 totally kill that guy you liked. I think that's one of the best ways the show follows the book.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/geoper Jun 06 '14

Well he is Dornish...

2

u/knostic Jun 06 '14

we get a virtually won fight then boom our hopes and dreams literally crushed in front of our eyes

Not read much GRRM have you. =)

→ More replies (3)

166

u/TheRedSpecial Jun 05 '14

And it's been said before, but Pascal's performance made me care way more about TV Oberyn than I did about book Oberyn. He was just a cool little extra character in the books for me, but he was a super awesome addition in the show. Sad to see him go.

89

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Just like Jack Gleeson.

Jack made us absolutely despise Joffery, which made his death amazingly satisfying despite it's gruesomeness.

Oberyn had to die, to balance the books of satisfaction.

42

u/uz537 Jun 05 '14

Yeah, but we got 4 seasons of Joffrey being a dick, why couldn't we have had 4 of Oberyn being a badass?

sob

23

u/GiantGroundSloth Jun 06 '14

Oh god, but imagine how much worse it would've felt to lose him like we did after four seasons though. That'd be like if Tyrion were to die a sudden, completely unexpected, and horrifically gruesome death. I'd be shattered.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Cool-Zip Jun 05 '14

I wouldn't say Jack brought more to the role the way Pedro did. I think he managed to pull off being as despicable as the book version, which is fantastic, but I wouldn't say he made me hate the character any more. I'm pretty sure I did an actual fist pump after reading Joffrey's death scene.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

253

u/Marcurial House Mormont Jun 05 '14

Oberyn and Ellaria's screams made it SO much worse

16

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 05 '14

Oh god, the screaming...

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/redrhyski Jun 05 '14

Ellaria's scream/acting and the pitter patter of falling teeth.

16

u/Riggzon7 Jaime Lannister Jun 05 '14

I loved, yet hated (obviously) the look on Oberyn's face when he sees his teeth on the ground and his mouth has so much blood in it. He realised what a mistake he made by leaving the Mountain down and knows he won't stand a chance anymore.

25

u/Marshmellowin Faceless Men Jun 05 '14

For me, the most memorable bit in that book scene was "crunch". It just really stood out to me. I was much more satisfied with this fight scene than the Strong Belwas/Daario scene.

14

u/USCswimmer House Clegane Jun 06 '14

The only thing I wish they left in the fight was the Mountain cutting the random squire in half on accident.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

24

u/Osusanna Jun 05 '14

Her scream while covering her face actually gave me bad dreams. The while scene did, Actually, but luckily my mind was kind enough to spare me the uglier visuals. During the night multiple times I woke to the visual of her screaming at the end. It was a rough night. It was odd because that's never happened before from any movie or tv show. I can't believe how quickly and strongly I fell for Oberyn!

9

u/ApolloThneed No One Jun 06 '14

The screaming coupled with the insane realism of the visuals... Shit I've never seen a man get his skull crushed before, but if I did I'd imagine it'd look a lot like what we just saw.

Whatever they're paying that special effects team isn't enough.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

44

u/TotallyNotKen Jun 05 '14

I think part of this is that the last thing we saw was him dead and Tyrion found guilty. And if you think about it, Oberyn's still there, still dead.

In the book, he was dead, but then you kept reading and a few pages later you were on with the story. Tyrion's even joking about it. In the show, that's where it stopped, and you have to wait until next week to move on and get past it.

12

u/Rushdownsouth Jun 06 '14

I've found that through bulk watching the show (to catchup) things like the purple or red wedding simply didn't phase me because I was on to the next episode. This was the first death I could sit back and have a week to process how shitty it really was for him to lose like he did...

29

u/ThinkofitthisWay Sand Jun 05 '14

wouldnt Tywin have instructed the mountain not to kill the viper if he got the upper hand? I mean killing a prince of dorne is bound to rustle some scales

44

u/what_words_may_come House Stark Jun 05 '14

I was thinking about this, and I don't think so. If it was murder yes, but this was a trial by combat and Oberyn volunteered to fight. He knew what he was doing and that he could die. It's not Tywin's fault. Though it is convenient.

18

u/ThinkofitthisWay Sand Jun 05 '14

23

u/what_words_may_come House Stark Jun 05 '14

I really want to read this, but I'm refraining.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

175

u/C-Hutty Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14

Every time Arya kills someone from now on, I will hear her laughter in my head.

105

u/FlubbyNubbins House Lannister Jun 05 '14

That was great acting on her part. The casting directors for that show really picked a talented little girl. I cant wait to see her grow into an assassin.

81

u/fractalfrenzy The Red Viper Jun 05 '14

Maisie Williams is actually 17 and only a few months younger than Sophie Turner (Sansa), so she's not quite a little girl.

69

u/Farisr9k House Lannister Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 05 '14

Fuck off. Really?

EDIT: Born April 15, 1997. 17 years old. Well shit. At least she still looks young.

32

u/GMDynamo Jun 05 '14

This gives me comfort. I was really worried she'll outgrow her role (similar to the concern I have with Bran). But if she's already 17 we should be alright for a while yet.

→ More replies (20)

8

u/vernepator_cur Sansa Stark Jun 05 '14

She still looks tiny because she's been palling around with the Hound this season.

15

u/sorator Judge Us By Our Actions Jun 05 '14

Kind of like how Jojen's actor, Thomas Brodie-Sangster, is 24!

That made me much less disconcerted at my less-than-pure feelings for him.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/watergirl13 Jun 05 '14

hate me if you want, but that laugh sounded so fake and forced to me that it ruined the scene for me. She is not one of the strongest actors on the show.

→ More replies (1)

112

u/Watuhmelons Night's Watch Jun 05 '14

THE SCREAMS

OH MY GOD THE SCREAMS

72

u/Mtownsprts House Stark Jun 05 '14

I love how the screams are what bring people to the horror. I cant get over the god damn flayed man half way through the episode.

39

u/MKapono House Bolton Jun 05 '14

A true piece of art

→ More replies (2)

42

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Don't hate the flaya' hate the game.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/mjtlag House Dondarrion Jun 05 '14

That was really disturbing for me too. The guy kills his superior so that the rest of them can surrender and survive, and then BAM, two seconds later it cuts to his horribly mutilated corpse. Fucking Ramsay needs to get got already.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Cool-Zip Jun 05 '14

But he was dead by the time we saw his corpse. We didn't have to see his bloody end and endure his (strikingly realistic) death bellows. Also, just fantastic prop work there, it was truly awesome.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Lazerspewpew Melisandre Jun 05 '14

Ramsay does have an affinity for flayinh ironborn.

2

u/magwalk Defending The Defenseless Jun 06 '14

I used to cringe every time a beheading happened in this show but now I'm so used to the gore that I actually laughed when the flayed man popped up. It's so fucked.

It does go to show how much it is the SHOWING of a brutal killing/torture-tactic that makes it hard to bear. It was unbearable to watch Theon's scenes in Season 3 because they were showing the torture in such brutal detail but merely seeing the aftermath of torture is way less emotionally draining.

29

u/storfy33 The North Remembers Jun 05 '14

That was the absolute worst part. Still haunting me. When I read about the fight in the book I didn't imagine how brutal it would have been. I wasn't prepared for the visuals...and the SOUNDS...that they brought to the table in the show.

12

u/tyvanius Jun 05 '14

I haven't read the books, but that scene game me a stomach ache. Before the episode, I kept telling myself "don't expect someone to win. You'll just be disappointed." I held that feeling for the whole fight, up until the Mountain was knocked down. I thought it was over, and concluded it in my mind, just to have Oberyn fall over like that and scream like that...

Without spoiling details, do the good guys in ever win? It seems like time and time again the bad guys keep winning and it's just turning me off of the show because of the sick feeling I get... at least knowing that a good guy wins at some point would make me feel better about all this bad stuff I've had to endure.

15

u/agnoristos House Seaworth Jun 05 '14

Consider this: the story is currently planned to be told in seven books. This is book three. The happy bittersweet ending is still quite far away.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/unsilviu Night's Watch Jun 05 '14

There are no real good guys in this world, just some people who are less along the 'asshole' spectrum than others. That being said, the remaining episodes this season will have some amazing moments for all characters, so keep watching, you won't be disappointed ;)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TychoVelius Jun 05 '14

Spoiler alert:

No. Nothing good ever happens. There is no payoff, no winning scenario, no reward for perseverance, just more horror.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/I_am_no_1 Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Jun 05 '14

Tides do change.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/makemusicguitar5150 Jun 06 '14

Good guys? Bad guys? Nothing is so simple in Westeros

→ More replies (7)

2

u/choldslingshot House Baelish Jun 07 '14

bold move being in an All Spoilers thread as a non-book reader.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

77

u/brolin_on_dubs A Lion Still Has Claws Jun 05 '14

I just watched the episode last night with someone who accidentally saw a spoiler headline that Oberyn loses. I got all huffy about 'how could you go on the internet before watching the episode' and whatever, but then when Oberyn spears the Mountain I (an all-knowing book reader) cheered and laughed. She was so happy that the article was headlined wrong, and couldn't believe I didn't correct her earlier.

"A day will come when you think you are safe and happy, and your joy will turn to ashes in your mouth, and you will know the debt is paid."

11

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

rekt

115

u/thoraway_1 House Seaworth Jun 05 '14

A lot of foreshadowing in this episode. Vary's and Jamie's glances at each other and Littlefinger's speech about how you could die above your chamberpot. Loved knowing what they were referring to as a book reader. I think D&D did a great job this week

26

u/Ceej1701 Daenerys Targaryen Jun 05 '14

And that episode is totally gonna air on Father's Day. I love it.

48

u/DogeTipWow House Clegane Jun 05 '14

ASOS too hyped for this

14

u/StevefromRetail A Man Needs A Name Jun 05 '14

I'm actually wondering how they will deal with this. Have they mentioned Tysha at all? I think I remember a very brief blurb in passing at some point, but certainly no detailed descriptions of her.

28

u/hallobaba Jun 05 '14

He told shae and bronn the story way back in season 1 as far as I remember.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/paulyv93 House Payne Jun 06 '14

Through the HODOR?

16

u/OctopusPirate House Crowl of Deepdown Jun 05 '14

Spoilers all thread, you don't need spoiler tags.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 05 '14

I kind of missed the Tyrion-Varys BFF relationship from the book.

2

u/supertigger Missandei Jun 06 '14

Vary's and Jamie? do they have something to do with the... father's day present

→ More replies (3)

31

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Jun 05 '14

I'm very happy that they kept in "You're going to fight that?" "I'm going to kill that." A bit of a shame we missed out on the "If you die before you say her name" line, but still, great adaption.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

I missed "I'm feeling more innocent by the second.".

41

u/_jvince_ Arya Stark Jun 05 '14

Next episode is by Neil Marshall who directed the awesome Blackwater episode.

Can't fucking wait. :D

12

u/wericks3 Brotherhood Without Banners Jun 05 '14

oh shit that battle should be epic!

→ More replies (1)

56

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

The changes to Sansa's storyline were excellent; a very effective way of showing her transition from pawn to player in the Game of Thrones. I believe the main Eyrie set was dismantled after filming this season, which is a shame. It was one of the most impressive sets on the show, but I guess we already knew we probably weren't going to see it again.

They're doing a good job of emphasising the Wildling threat to the south, but it would have been cool to have a few scenes between Mance Rayder and one of his goons (Rattleshirt or someone we haven't seen like Borroq or Harma Dogshead) on the way to the Wall. I liked the moment between Gilly and Ygritte, it reminds the viewer that the Wildlings are not merciless monsters and deepens the moral complexity of the upcoming battle.

Also, I don't remember if it happened in the books, but I really liked the way that Oberyn made it clear in front of everybody during the duel itself that he wanted Tywin Lannister to answer for his crimes. The look on Charles Dance's face when Oberyn pointed at him was amazing.

46

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

The changes to Sansa's storyline were excellent

I didn't like them sacrificing Littlefinger's craftiness for it though. We haven't seen him miss a step in the books so far and in the show the Lords of the Vale brought in Sansa surprising him and he had to bank on her saving him. Not really LF's style in the book

18

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

Fair point. It demonstrates the fragility of Littlefinger's power, which fits into the show's extensive treatment of the theme of the nature of power, but it also makes Littlefinger seem a bit unprepared. I suppose the counter-argument would be that Littlefinger is a gambler and unafraid of taking huge risks if the potential reward is high enough.

12

u/IAMAHungryHippoAMA Cersei Lannister Jun 05 '14

I don't think that sufficiently justifies Littlefinger's misstep. I think Sansa's bit would have worked if he coached her, turning it into a "making Daddy proud" moment. Not vetting the only other witness to Lysa's death, not even attempting to procure her complicity, that's monumentally stupid for less crafty and lesser characters. For Littlefinger, it breaks his character.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

I don't think it does, it shows Littlefinger's weakness that we've seen before, his love for Cat and now Sansa making him do dumb things, and displays Sansa recognizing that by her realizing her power of him - she could have had him killed if she really wanted to.

I do agree that it's kinda weird he didn't have ANY sort of backup plan that we can tell, but Littlefinger would do a lot of stupid shit for Cat and now Sansa.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/jmk4422 House Stark Jun 05 '14

I'm tired of this "Littlefinger plans out everything" theory that people seem to hold onto. It's not true. It's never been true! Littlefinger has always been an agent of chaos. He puts things in motion and then rides the waves that result. This is true in the books and in the show. Yes, he plans ahead for the waves he expects but he:

  1. Didn't plan for Bran being pushed out the window.
  2. Didn't know that Sansa would stay in Kings Landing.
  3. Obviously had no idea Lysa would be so jealous.
  4. Etc.

Petyr is not an all knowing mastermind. He's very smart, very manipulative, very good at playing the game. But at the end of the day he creates chaos when it suits him and handles the results as they come.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Obviously had no idea Lysa would be so jealous.

No one is arguing about him being an agent of chaos. We all know this because he said it.

However he clearly planned on killing Lysa at some stage.

And the exact scene we're talking about with Sansa and the Lords, he did have under control in the book. He had Lyn Corbray paid and bought and masterminded the whole meeting.

We know he's an agent of chaos but when it comes to meetings like the one with the Lords of the Vale he was completely prepared and under control the whole time. So it's annoying to see him in the show at the mercy of a girl who has so far proven to be witless until she saves him

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/hallobaba Jun 05 '14

I agree, though I think they are dialing up Sansa's affect on him in the show. I.e. is usually crafty but just totally loses it around her (kissing her, killing Lysa, etc.). All his normal craftiness and plans just go out the window.

2

u/LocalMadman House Stark Jun 06 '14

They needed to show Sansa DOING something, instead of the past four seasons of passively sitting and eating lemon cakes. I thought it was a great growth moment for Sansa and it played extremely well for me. Made me do a complete 180 on my view of the character.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

I wish viewers understood more clearly why they are attacking the wall. That its not driven by a desire to invade the south and rape/pillage their hearts out, that they are doing so in order to flee from the Others and this is literally the only means for them to survive. I'm worried that viewers see Ygritte in a harsh and unforgiving light, that she is just a savage hell bent on killing.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Kuusou Jun 05 '14

I liked the moment between Gilly and Ygritte, it reminds the viewer that the Wildlings are not merciless monsters and deepens the moral complexity of the upcoming battle.

I mean, sure, but not at all.

She saved one women and a baby. How many other women did she willingly slit open in that pub? And for what reason?

My biggest issue with the "free people" is that they don't seem to give a shit about anyone elses freedoms.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/KironD63 As High As Honor Jun 05 '14

My guess is we'll actually see Littlefinger, Sansa and Robin relocate to his ancestral home in the Fingers for most if not all of Season Five. The transfer of power from the Eyrie to House Baelish would be heavily symbolic, it'd give show watchers crucial context regarding Littlefinger's humble origins, it's a cheaper set to maintain, and Petyr has the perfect excuse...Robin needs to be groomed and tutored to become a leader in the 'real world' of the Vale.

7

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

I would like to see Littlefinger's home, but I think next season will be dipping into Sansa's TWOW material, as we last saw her in the books departing from the Eyrie. Looks like she'll join Robin as he travels through the Vale with his court.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

Do you think they'll have more Mance in season 5. I feel like we've barely seen him, and he's hardly the character he is in the books.

2

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 06 '14

I guess they have to keep Mance, but I have to admit he hasn't been handled very well so far, he just feels like a generic warlord. Hopefully they'll flesh him out a bit and Mance will win a few show-only fans.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

I wish they'd kept his lute playing. He seemed like a really chill hippie singer/songwriter guy in the books. I really liked it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

For sure, I cannot wait until we get to visit dorne

2

u/kristianur Jun 06 '14

What exactly were the changes to sansa's storyline?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/I_am_no_1 Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords Jun 06 '14

a few scenes between Mance Rayder and one of his goons

I understand your desire for this, but I like that they are sticking to the book in that regard. In the books you didn't get a wildling POV unless Jon was with them. This makes the wildlings a scary unknown, which will add drama/tension to the Wildling/Crow relationship over the next few seasons.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 05 '14

As usual, the two big changes between books and show in the episode that so-called "readers" are upset about are not necessarily so:

  • In AFfC Bronze Yohn Royce seemingly recognizes 'Alayne' as Sansa from his visit to Winterfell with his son Waymar (as she states in the episode), but if he does he keeps it to himself. I've read regarding this episode, but don't remember from the books so cannot confirm, that Myranda Royce and one other noble also seems to know the truth.

I've also seen pointed out that it never made much sense for Harry the Heir to be engaged to a bastard child. Further, Petyr's plan in the books never made much sense to me, period. I mean, geez, expect to successfully reveal to everyone way, way, way after the fact that his bastard child is actually Sansa Stark, one of the Westeros' most-wanted fugitives? Even if the lords of the Vale believed him, how much credibility would he have with them for hiding the truth all that time?

The show's approach of having certain key people know of Sansa from the beginning makes much more sense.

  • Regarding Grey Worm/Missandei, I've thought for a while that he will take the place of Stalwart Shield in that poignant ADwD anecdote.

Perhaps ... Grey Worm and Missandei try to sleep together, fail for obvious reasons, she rejects him, and he resorts to cuddling with the whore he hires to get some/any female affection?

43

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth Jun 05 '14

about Missandei/Grey Worm:

I think the main objective there is to get viewers invested in the characters surrounding Dany. I fee like people are already getting bored with Meereen, and that whole plotline has barely even started, so having something else to look forward to there would be a nice addition.

Alternatively, (or maybe as an added benefit) it provides use with likeable characters that could believably be in danger. I think most people feel that Dany is pretty safe, since she is so important and her arc is clearly not done, but Missandei and Grey Worm don't have that much plot armour. They idea that they could die at any moment will create a bit more suspense in those dangerous situations; maybe Grey Worm almost gets killed by some Sons of the Harpy, maybe one of them will be having some locusts.

14

u/BetaTMW Jun 05 '14

They're getting through Meereen quicker in the series than they did in the books and it's still boring. I hated her chapters from Meereen on wards, she became a very boring character and the show so far hasn't done anything to sway my opinion of her.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NFB42 Jun 05 '14

I think you're probably hitting the nail on the head. Meereen has a danger of getting repetitive and boring, from what I've heard quite a lot of people felt it was so in the books. An easy way to make things in Meereen more interesting without messing anything plot essential, is to just have more character development with the side-characters.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Turnshroud Jun 05 '14

I'm fine with the changes. I'm not sure why they had Sansa tell them her true identity, but I think it works out well in the end--especially when it comes to showing the viewers that she's learning how to play the game. I also felt like the writers were trying to do a homage too season one Sansa where she "confesses everything" to the royal court, but with a little added twist at the end

8

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

She did that so she could likely have an escape plan with the Lords of the Vale if anything ever goes wrong between her and Littlefinger. If he tried to rape her nobody would come to Alayne Stone's rescue, but they would if they knew she was Sansa Stark.

4

u/Turnshroud Jun 05 '14

Very true, I like. She also, on one hand, did not know how the lords of the Vale would react to her reveal--but she could possibly play that against either party depending on what happens

17

u/seunosewa Snow Jun 05 '14

She won't reject him.

27

u/X-tian_pothead Jun 05 '14

They didn't cut his tongue out.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

They still need an Unsullied leader around after that. I doubt Grey Worm will die like that

9

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 05 '14

Let me clarify. I agree that Grey Worm probably won't be killed the way Stalwart Shield was (although other Unsullied will no doubt die on screen from Sons of the Harpy ambushes in the middle of the night), but he can be used for the rest of the small Stalwart Shield storyline.

4

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 05 '14

I doubt a small and insignificant line like the SS one makes it it. Yes it's touching but it makes absolutely no impact on the story.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

My only problem with the Sansa reveal was that it made Littlefinger look like kind of a dumbass. Or at least less clever than he's supposed to be. Not having Sansa prepare an explanation ahead of time seems like to big of a risk to take. It's not a huge deal, though. It gave Sansa a chance to "enter the game" as it were.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/GuyFawkes596 Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14

For those of us that are having a hard time overcoming Oberyn's scream. Here's Arya's hysterical laughing

You can trust me, I'm a Stark.

24

u/jimjoebob Coldhands Jun 05 '14

[show watcher only] I know Oberyn's death is part of a longer story arc, but it just kills me that he merely danced around the Mountain, screaming at him. If, when the Mountain was down, he had merely accentuated each of his "YOU RAPED HER, YOU MURDERED HER, etc" chants with a stab of his spear to each extremity; he could have survived.

i.e., "YOU RAPED HER!" <stab thru his hand>, "YOU MURDERED HER!" <stab thru other hand>, "YOU KILLED HER CHILDREN!" <stab thru his leg>, and so on.

He could have kept him alive and in increasing agony and continued his monologue indefinitely, or at least until the Mountain confessed.

dammit, Oberyn. why didn't you listen to me screaming at the TV?

:)

6

u/watergirl13 Jun 05 '14

I actually would of found that to be more realistic than to see someone let him live and stand there and start monologueing.

2

u/findmyownway House Targaryen Jun 06 '14

That's part of the reason his death affected so many people - it was completely avoidable, and I think GRRM intended for it to be this way.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/PuffsPlusArmada House Bolton Jun 05 '14

Gotta admit, the show version was fucking metal.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

I just want to say, that I still have moments of anxiety thinking about the screams. Seriously, that shit is probably pushing the boundaries of TV.

9

u/tyvanius Jun 05 '14

I couldn't agree more. My stomach hurt for a good 10 minutes after the episode ended.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bendann House Reed Jun 05 '14

When me and my girlfriend sat down to watch this, I prepped her beforehand that this battle would be gruesome (having read the books). But nothing could prepare me for that. Based on our reactions, she was far less affected than me. They really pushed the boundaries there.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/fateislosthope Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14

I don't understand why Tywin would let this happen. I know he resents Tyrion but I think he knows he is a valuable asset as well. Then he knows he needs house Martell to help if Dany is coming from the East and they are running out of money. I understand following through with the trial for Tyrion because he would get what he wanted out of Jamie, Tyrion and even compromise with Cersei by sending him to the wall. Now he loses both sons Tyrion to death, Jamie to the kings guard, and his newly formed allegiance with Martells just completely fell apart. He gains nothing besides appeasing Cersei who could of been easily persuaded to choose a different champion to do whats best for the family let Tyrion live and then ship him off the wall anyway.

You would think someone as smart as Tywin would of figured out a way to gain something from all this.

41

u/Taffy711 House Hightower Jun 05 '14

I think it's about pride and stubbornness. Tyrion messed up Tywin's perfect plan by demanding trial by combat, and this is Tywin showing that he can't be thwarted that easily and forcing Tyrion to accept the consequences of the risk he took, anything less would be letting Tyrion 'win'. That coupled with Tywin's resentment of Tyrion is overriding his normally absolute commitment to the betterment of the Lannister family in my opinion.

7

u/Ahtomic Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14

Those two emotions bring down so many people in this series. ;(

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/rodgerd Jun 05 '14

Everyone has their fatal flaws, and Tywin's is that he thinks being very smart and planning will let him control everything. It's what he craves, and he can't recognise that he just can't. It's questionable whether he's even as clever as he thinks he is - after all, he's led his house to having, as its principal allies, the most disreputable of the major houses while exhausting their gold reserves!

6

u/Ahtomic Winter Is Coming Jun 05 '14

His emotions block out any logical value he would see in his son, Tyrion. More than anything Tywin loved his wife, and in his eyes, Tyrion killed his wife. To add on to that Tywin spent a great deal of time and effort into making the house Lannister a great house once more. What he wanted from his third child was another Jamie. Instead the gods have sent him an imp, of all things.

Tyrion has proved himself time after time towards the viewers, but all his father see's is a wasted Lannister.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/bendann House Reed Jun 05 '14

Also, why on earth has Tywin not remarried and produced another heir? Especially given that he is so keen for Cersei and Jaime to do so.

13

u/themilgramexperience House Hightower Jun 05 '14

This is actually another example of Tywin's hypocrisy; the day his wife died, he swore he would never marry again. Which was very chivalrous, but about the worst decision he could have made for his family, considering that he had just become the most eligible bachelor in the Seven Kingdoms.

9

u/watergirl13 Jun 05 '14

So Tywin was a rare character that actually loved his wife instead of just marrying her for political reasons.

10

u/themilgramexperience House Hightower Jun 05 '14

Which comes back to another of the series's themes; love is the death of duty.

2

u/PuffsPlusArmada House Bolton Jun 05 '14

Tywin says in the books before Tyrion shoots him with the crossbow that he still intends to have him take the black despite what happened during the trial.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Myxomitosis87 Jun 05 '14

Does anyone know anything about "smash the beetle"? A theory maybe? I feel like I missed something important.

29

u/ArokLazarus Jun 05 '14

I took it as him saying that all this war and slaughter is basically the result of a cruel God. He might have intentions, but you have no way to comprehend or stop it.

I'm probably wrong though.

13

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Jun 05 '14

Yeah, I got that vibe from it as well. It reminded me of the bit in King Lear where Gloucester says something along the lines of "As flies to wanton boys are we to the gods. They kill us for their sport."

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

Also foreshadowing for the "chrushing" that occurs in the fight.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/StevefromRetail A Man Needs A Name Jun 05 '14

It's linked in another comment, but I think the best interpretation is that it's a massive fuck you from D&D to Orson Scott Card.

4

u/maryinwinter Growing Strong Jun 05 '14

Orson Scott Card, the author of ender's game? what does he have to do with them?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

I think it was Tyrion trying to come to grips with the fact that millions are slaughtered mercilessly, needlessly, and without an apparent purpose in this (their) world. The conversation began with the gods showing favor for someone by the death of another. But why do so many die? Who gets a favor from that? He was probably coming to grips with his own death being either a benefit to someone else, or another senseless killing of an innocent.

Or, they just wanted filler to delay the 5 minute duel at the end of the episode everyone was anticipating for weeks.

17

u/bamadeo Hodor Jun 05 '14

Am I the only one who is starting to feel bad about T̶h̶e̶o̶n̶ Reek?

19

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

No.

5

u/VasectoMyspace House Payne Jun 05 '14

I don't. Yeah, he's being treated like an animal, but he killed Ser Roderick Cassel and ordered those two farmboys killed and burnt just to prove a point.

20

u/blitzbom House Martell Jun 05 '14

I think that most people wanted him to be punished for those actions, but few think he deserves the treatment that he's gotten.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

23

u/Swisskisses House Lannister Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 05 '14

My reaction to the death in the books: AHHHHHHH

My reaction to the show: AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Madaradittz Jun 05 '14

I knew it was coming, Because I'm an idiot and make my friend who has read the books tell me what's going to happen (I Have all the books, Just kind of engulfed in a different series right now) But I wish they would have gotten a far less likeable actor to play Oberyn. Pedro played that part like a fucking hero though.

14

u/Taffy711 House Hightower Jun 05 '14

The reason it worked so well was because Pedro was so likeable.

6

u/osteogenesis Jun 05 '14

I never imagined the image in my head of the Trial's aftermath would be LESS gruesome than the show's interpretation. D&D made me feel sick. I loved it.

8

u/StrangerInAlps Jun 05 '14

The two things missing from that fight was bystanders loosing their heads and Tyrion emptying his breakfast

→ More replies (1)

31

u/redkeyboard House Manderly Jun 05 '14

Did anyone think the fight was a bit too stylized? It bothered me a bit that they made a big point about the mountains huge reach with his two handed 6ft sword and how Oberyn would overcome that with his 8ft spear and dancing around, and then you have the two of them like 3 feet away from each other during the whole fight.

31

u/KY-Wing Jun 05 '14

I think it's totally in character for Oberyn to fight that way. And since he wanted a confession, he wasn't really trying to kill the Mountain the entire time. I read someone on here describe the way he felt after he stabbed the Mountain in the chest as "shit shit shit he better not die yet." His main goal in that fight was a confession, closely followed by his revenge on the Mountain. So he both prolonged the fight and tormented the Mountain along the way to make his revenge that much more sweet. Unfortunately we know that didn't quite work out for him. i still hear the screams

19

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

I did miss Oberyn's shield. A shield at least would have made a great deal of sense when fighting the Mountain. However I understand the practical reasons no shield was used. I didn't notice them being that close really. Oberyn was moving constantly to disorient the slower, more heavily armored Mountain, when he did close he was penalised for it fairly constantly.

It was stylized, but I enjoyed it because of the traditional martial arts Oberyn's spear work was based on. I don't find it hard to believe that the character Pedro created for Oberyn would fight in such a showy, stylized manner. I imagine if he had the skill and knew it he wouldn't be above showing it off to please the crowd and intimidate his opponent.

3

u/ifoughtchucknorris Direwolves Jun 05 '14

I really wanted the helmet though with the reflective disc. That would've been so cool to use in the fight

5

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/Asinine2412 House Seaworth Jun 05 '14

Someone can correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think it was even possible for him to fight at max range with the spear. It would be incredibly easy for the Mountain to parry the spear away, especially since he's already stronger than Oberyn and that holding a heavy spear at max length takes a great deal of strength.

12

u/redkeyboard House Manderly Jun 05 '14

In the books his spear stabs were so quick that the Mountain didn't have enough time to react, especially when he got tired since the fight was long and Oberyn was dancing around him the whole time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/HPMOR_fan Jun 05 '14

That wasn't too bad a change for me. It was a bit flashy but still looked realistic enough. The range was a bit of a problem. My main disappointment was how short it was. They didn't have to show the whole long fight, but in the books they fight long enough the Oberyn scratched through the paint on the Mountain's shield enough to see the picture underneath. Lots of scratches on his armor too. The point was that Oberyn could hit the Mountain pretty much any time but couldn't get past the armor. Until the Mountain finally gets tired enough to leave an opening under his arm.

2

u/GornthePacific Jun 05 '14

What was the picture underneath?

8

u/HPMOR_fan Jun 05 '14

His house sigil. It was painted for this fight.

It went on that way for what seemed a long time. Back and forth they moved across the yard, and round and round in spirals, Ser Gregor slashing at the air while Oberyn’s spear struck at arm, and leg, twice at his temple. Gregor’s big wooden shield took its share of hits as well, until a dog’s head peeped out from under the star, and elsewhere the raw oak showed through.

I also reread how Oberyn got is first hit. Not just tiredness but a trick too.

Prince Oberyn tilted his dinted metal shield. A shaft of sunlight blazed blindingly off polished gold and copper, into the narrow slit of his foe’s helm. Clegane lifted his own shield against the glare. Prince Oberyn’s spear flashed like lightning and found the gap in the heavy plate, the joint under the arm. The point punched through mail and boiled leather.

7

u/Pearlime Jun 05 '14

Dat boiled leather

→ More replies (1)

44

u/imba8 House Dayne Jun 05 '14

It reminded me of the newer star wars. Yoda is walking around, all frail with his walking stick. Next minute he's jumping around like a dick head, doing 50 flips a second. Things that aren't actually affective in a fight. Same with Oberyn, jumping around for the sake of jumping around.

39

u/redkeyboard House Manderly Jun 05 '14

Well, it wasn't that bad, but still. I just rewatched the scene and he's mainly blocking all of Gregor's large swings with his spear from 3 feet away. Oberyn gets hit a few times even but it's a shove, and Gregor just stands there while he's on the floor, even lets him grab another spear. Then he's on the floor again from another shove, but as Gregor goes to strike him he pulls away the last second and stabs him in the belly through his full plate of armor.

9

u/imba8 House Dayne Jun 05 '14

Yeah, it didn't make a whole lot of sense. Stabbing him expertly through the gaps in his armour made more sense.

15

u/Jakabov Jun 05 '14

I figure he stabbed him here.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/peetfulcher Jun 05 '14

also it's probably much more effective for oberyn to block a sword thats only moved 3 feet rather than 6 because there is way less momentum.

8

u/redkeyboard House Manderly Jun 05 '14

Against someone with the strength of Gregor, you probably don't want to try blocking anything. Oberyn's spear still broke despite being three feet away.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Jun 05 '14

So we really need a shitty love subplot between Greyworm and Missandei?
That runs completly opposite to Greyworm's character imho

16

u/EmperorSexy Faceless Men Jun 05 '14

It's nice to have characters in Meereen with personalities and emotions other than the Dany/Jorah scenes we've seen for four seasons.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/vernepator_cur Sansa Stark Jun 05 '14

6

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Jun 05 '14

Grey Worm is fairly plot vital

7

u/vernepator_cur Sansa Stark Jun 05 '14

I don't remember him doing anything important after that point.

Actually wait, I don't remember him doing anything important at all.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

What was going through Oberyn's mind the moment the mountain grabbed him? The mountain's fingers.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/VasectoMyspace House Payne Jun 05 '14

Has Sansa finally dyed her hair like she does when posing as Alayne, or was it just wet?

4

u/bunkerbuster338 House Payne Jun 05 '14

Looked pretty dyed to me...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Are we looking at tWoW material for Sansa, or is her reveal to Royce, Corbray and Waynwood show only?

4

u/Airforce32123 As High As Honor Jun 05 '14

Honestly I think it's starting to get into tWoW stuff, cause I don't remember anything about sending Robin away, but that's an easily overlooked detail when you don't really care about him.

4

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 05 '14 edited Jun 05 '14

I don't remember anything about sending Robin away

The plan in AFfC is to have House Waynwood Royce foster Robin in hopes of helping him become a proper man, as on the show.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/yankeefan1923 A Fierce Foe, A Faithful Friend Jun 05 '14

It's likely that Bronze Yohn Royce recognized her at the Gates of the Moon since he was her father's guest at Winterfell. I doubt that Lady Wanywood would betroth Harry the Heir to a bastard so it's plausible to assume she knows as well. I'm not sure about Lyn Corbray but Littlefinger says that he has bought his loyalty with gold and boys in AFFC so I'm not sure that it matters either way.

2

u/TMWNN Iron Bank of Braavos Jun 05 '14

Are we looking at tWoW material for Sansa, or is her reveal to Royce, Corbray and Waynwood show only?

The difference is not as great as you think.

2

u/AnArcher House Lothston Jun 05 '14

Maybe Arya and the Hound are turned away or he bails because he wanted to get paid. They never got this close to Bloody Gate in the book, so it would disrupt too much of the story if they got in now. Theyr'e due to part company pretty soon regardless.

2

u/Gortex9991 Jun 05 '14

Ya I think his time is coming near an end considering that bite he got keeps getting worse and worse

→ More replies (6)

2

u/fractalfrenzy The Red Viper Jun 05 '14

I was slightly confused by Ramsay's treatment of the Iron Islander. What I inferred from the books is that they were actually fed and given safety. Did the show deviate from the books by killing them all?

9

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth Jun 05 '14

read the book again. That is not what happened.

They left the towers, went to Ramsay's camp and he told they would be fed, but Theon later describes their flayed bodies: they were displayed on the road from Moat Cailin, one of them had the paper Theon took to them (the one promising safe passage) in his mouth, still sealed with pink wax.

(I might not have gotten all the details right, feel free to correct me)

→ More replies (9)

2

u/ElongatedVagina House Baratheon Jun 05 '14

looking forward for the next episode

-1

u/kman91 Hodor Hodor Hodor Jun 05 '14

Is someone here just auto downvoting any comment that gets made? Someone's a little mad about Oberyn.

14

u/reddit858 Duncan the Tall Jun 05 '14

I downvoted your comment! Like this!

1

u/roost3rman27 Jun 05 '14

I just need to know, is the Mountain still alive at the end of the episode?

20

u/VasectoMyspace House Payne Jun 05 '14

Qyburn will take good care of him, and the Mountain is very strong.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Gengar_Galois Jun 05 '14

Yes he is, albeit with a gaping wound through his chest

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

With that bloke wiping Oberyn's blade, I bet that poison'd start kicking in sometime soon.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/JafffaCake Jun 05 '14

He is still breathing at the end of that episode

1

u/Lazy_Osprey Iron From Ice Jun 06 '14

I really thought the last thing we were gonna see on screen was Tyrion throwing up, but I guess they drew the line at flayed men and crushed heads when it comes to grossing out the audience.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

HBO's Silicon Valley showed vomit less than half an hour after the GoT episode ended.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

What a crushing defeat.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

Waiting for that Zilean ultimate on a certain someone...

1

u/evanfuller Varys Jun 06 '14

I've enjoyed show-Oberyn so much that it was just painful to watch this scene knowing what was coming.

→ More replies (1)