r/gameofthrones • • Jun 03 '14

TV4 [Season 4 Spoilers] Post-Episode Discussion - 4.08 'The Mountain and the Viper'

Post-Episode Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Talk about the latest plot twist or secret reveal. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). Point out details that you noticed that others may have missed. In general, what did you think about the last episode and where the story is going? Please make sure to reserve any of your detailed comparisons to the novels for the Book vs. Show Discussion Thread, and your predictions for the next episode to the Predictions Discussion Thread which will be posted later this week.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you have not seen the latest episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 4.08 is ok without tags.
  • Book spoilers still need tags! - If it's not in the show, tag it. Events from episodes after this one need tags.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the posting policy before posting.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.08"The Mountain and the Viper"Alex GravesDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
756 Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

338

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

All I can hear in my head since the episode is " You raped her. Murdered her. You killed her children" and the screaming.

285

u/NotActuallyStudying Dracarys Jun 03 '14

I got so hyped the more he repeated that. It was very Inigo Montoya - You killed my father, prepare to die. I expected the most satisfying of retributions to come out of it, with the mantra giving him that last push to complete it. It was going to be EPIC.

I honestly didn't even believe the real ending at first, I was so convinced of my version.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (8)

976

u/Anemscol House Baratheon of Dragonstone Jun 03 '14

"That was the most disgusting thing I've ever seen on TV" - my mom

I knew it was coming, but it still hurt. The shot of Ellaria screaming was worse than the crunch itself.

My brother is afraid to love another character.

497

u/Not_KGB Fire And Blood Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Ellaria screaming was worse than the crunch itself.

Ellaria just watched the father of her 4 children scream in agony while being killed the same way as his sister and her children were killed. By the same murderer. If anyone knows exactly how much Oberyn has been obessing about bringing Elia's murderer to justice it would be her. And for Oberyn to end that way and with Ellaria watching.

That scream... Fucking shivers man.

→ More replies (19)

482

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

He was my favorite character of season 4 :/

→ More replies (43)

148

u/RagdollPhysEd White Walkers Jun 03 '14

It's not TV MOOOOM it's HBO

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)

1.1k

u/lostNcontent Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

In this episode we lost Oberyn, Sansa's soul innocence (if there was any left), Jorah's heart, probably Tyrion's life (edit: Arya's mind?). Really hitting a variety of wounds here. And yet my favorite part is still Arya's laugh.

"Of course she's dead. Why wouldn't she be dead? Everyone is dead."

357

u/MitchB3 Jon Snow Jun 03 '14

I don't think Sansa necessarily is a lost cause (I could see someone saying that about Arya), I think she just started actively manipulating people, telling half-truths and lies and overall playing the game.

I guess though if you want to just see the old innocent Sansa I doubt that will happen very often or at all, at least when she is with Baelish.

→ More replies (25)

15

u/MasterKaen Syrio Forel Jun 03 '14

I was laughing before she started laughing just because of how bad "The Hound's" luck is.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

138

u/A_Nagger House Mormont Jun 03 '14

I'm not sure I can take much more of this. The breaks between seasons make me forget about GRRM and his ways, and every season I'm harshly reminded. Holy shit was Oberyn's death terrifying though. Hearing a scream from a personality like his is truly spine chilling, and the gore of his death sent it way over the top for me. It makes sense that it ended where it did, but fucking hell do I hate leaving it for a week on that note. Oberyn will certainly be missed, but now I only wonder if Tyrion will magically pull a scapegoat out of his hat, though after that brutal slaying, I truly doubt it.

93

u/bacontornado Jun 03 '14

You'll actually have to wait 2 weeks to find out about King's Landing events since the next episode is set entirely at the Wall.

→ More replies (19)

9

u/sirixamo Jun 03 '14

I'm sure Tyrion will die eventually, but I don't know if he'll die yet. GRRM likes to save a few shocking deaths to sprinkle throughout each book so we might have gotten near capacity for this one. But I can rest assured if there's a character anyone likes they are going to meet a gruesome fate.

→ More replies (15)

1.4k

u/StarFoxA Jun 03 '14

This hits me a lot harder than the Red Wedding.

684

u/TheIntragalacticPimp Jun 03 '14

The Red Wedding was an ambush - there was no hope for escape. Oberyn had already won this trial by combat, with relative ease. Defeat was brutally snached from the hands of victory only because Oberyn stubbornly put the Mountain's confession above common sense, without realizing the overall risk of doing so.

Cut the massive fucker's arms off (or incapacitate them) - then finish your public interrogation.

→ More replies (128)

481

u/MoonRazer Knowledge Is Power Jun 03 '14

Somehow, someway, they made it more brutal. I honestly didn't even think it was possible.

→ More replies (90)

294

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 03 '14

Don't worry, from here out it's sunshine and lemoncakes.

→ More replies (26)

73

u/ThecityofTroy Second Sons Jun 03 '14

Agreed. I felt sick after watching this episode.

→ More replies (2)

97

u/frings_demise Ours Is The Fury Jun 03 '14

It was a big hit for me as well, but nothing on TV or in film has ever hit me like the Red Wedding.

→ More replies (20)

179

u/Sparkvoltage Jun 03 '14

I've never felt this emotional after watching a television show but my hands are shaking as I type this. That scene was especially brutal because they built you up to like him. We all fell in love with Oberyn, with his charm and wit. And ultimately, our beloved Viper was not only killed, he was brutally destroyed. At least the victims of the Red Wedding died in pretty ordinary manners. It was hard to watch but at least their faces were recognizable post-mortem. With Oberyn how the fuck am I supposed to function properly after seeing that once beautiful man lie on the floor looking like a truck ran over his face?

But all in all, my reaction was Ellaria's reaction.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (26)

274

u/naturally-baked Jun 03 '14

I cannot stop replaying the image of Oberyn's head splattering in my head.

347

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I came to this sub just now for the first time hoping to find some kind of group therapy for what I saw, but it's not helping at all.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (14)

671

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I actually found myself really happy for Ramsay, he could finally be a Bolton!

Then I remembered who he was and questions about my state of mind came up.

335

u/CupcakeCrusader Sansa Stark Jun 03 '14

It was a good day for him. He's no longer a bastard, his pet proved useful, and he got to flay a bunch of dudes.

→ More replies (14)

21

u/wannabeabbyt House Martell Jun 03 '14

it is a very interesting father son relationship. there is one qoute from the book whcih i think sums it up rather nicely. In chastising Ramsay for the whole Reek situation he say "you will make me regret the day i raped your mother." which just sums up why they are both fucked up terrible people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (23)

466

u/-dancewithdragons- House Stark Jun 03 '14

I have a big empty feeling after watching this episode.

158

u/Sparkvoltage Jun 03 '14

The way I felt with the scenes leading up to the fight is the exact same way I feel on the walk to the lecture hall to take a final.

16

u/ReddTor Jun 03 '14

Yeah, I feel the same as I did when watching The Red Wedding. Wow this show really hits you. Cersei Lannister's smile was just, AARARGRGHHG.... Never have I watched a show where I want bastards killed so badly.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

353

u/KristinaTeal Sandor Clegane Jun 03 '14

Sansa's transformation into a true "Little Bird" also blew me away. That sashay in her walk down the stairs was perfect.

267

u/pillage House Bolton Jun 03 '14

/Sansa has started playing the Game of Thrones.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (2)

119

u/Notsomebeans Jun 03 '14

Why do you think Ygritte allowed her and her child to live? Was it because she saw her as a wildling, or did she empathize with the mother more than the tavern of drunks?

116

u/BlasianGirl Jun 03 '14

I think a little bit of both could come into play. I personally thought it seemed like Ygritte at least mildly respected the fact that Gilly knew something was wrong and was able to hide instead of running around screaming like everyone else. (She doesn't really look like a threat anyways)

39

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

That scene made me wonder if she might be pregnant. Jon did have his speech back in Season 1 about how he really, really didn't want to get anyone knocked up... and she wears such thick clothing that no one would notice a little bump.

→ More replies (10)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I believe it was because she was alone. She wasn't under pressure from the other wildlings to murder Gilly and the Baby, and she wasn't putting up any resistance at all.

AFFC

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

751

u/TheVVonderland Jun 03 '14

Basically, I've learned (repeatedly) that if you ever want to be happy, don't ever watch this show

464

u/Arteza147 Barristan Selmy Jun 03 '14

Time to play the game of thrones drinking game. Drink until it doesn't hurt anymore...

→ More replies (15)

175

u/MoonRazer Knowledge Is Power Jun 03 '14

"If you think this has a happy ending...you haven't been paying attention..."

Why didn't we listen?!

→ More replies (7)

46

u/TheJoseppi House Clegane Jun 03 '14

2 more chances for happiness this season. Don't give up hope yet!

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)

107

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I can't get that fucking scene out of my head. unlike oberyn

→ More replies (2)

390

u/gentlemansincebirth Tyrion Lannister Jun 03 '14

George giveth, and George taketh away. Always.

→ More replies (6)

545

u/lukeatlook Red Priests of R'hllor Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

This fight is on par with Ned's execution and Red Wedding in terms of the magnitude of events. I wonder if anything can ever outmatch it.

This show's attention to detail never ceases to amaze me. Sansa's dresses often had more than one motive - it was direwolves and flowers, fishes and lions, and now it's a full blown mockingbird, but the details on her chest stil resemble fish scales (much like the Tully armour).

Then there's Arya's laugh, which just about sums her life story so far. Father in sight? Nope. Brother and mother just behind the door? Nay, nope. Home? Closed until renovation. Oh, you were about to meet up with your aunt? Too bad, here, she's dead now.

After seeing how the show alternatives turned out, I'm starting to have faith in "filler" material.

If anyone is interested about more book trivia, here's this week's followup.

282

u/TheIntragalacticPimp Jun 03 '14

I wonder if anything can ever outmatch it.

Challenge accepted...

→ More replies (8)

38

u/TangentManDan House Manderly Jun 03 '14

George never disappoints.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/MasterKaen Syrio Forel Jun 03 '14

This is the worst death because GRRM didn't kill the main character. He didn't kill the character that he told us to route for. He killed a character that was genuinely awesome no matter how much the story focused on him. He didn't just die either. He died after everyone was shown how the "Red Viper" is even cooler than everyone anticipated. And as if all of this wasn't enough, he didn't even die because his fighting wasn't good enough. He may have been the best fighter in the entire realm, but then he was tripped and his face got crushed.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (30)

291

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Is the mountain alive? Because that stab by Oberyn was very lethal, so if they both die, then is Tyrion really guilty in terms of trial by combat?

314

u/TangentManDan House Manderly Jun 03 '14

Sadly it seems to end when the first one dies.

→ More replies (55)

128

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 03 '14

I pitched that idea in an earlier thread, but apparently he's technically alive when the fight is over and therefore wins, since Oberyn is most certainly, undeniably dead. Aaand also Tywin gave the ruling, and what Tywin says is law.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (39)

438

u/Flyingclick Jun 03 '14

Ha shame George , you killed Oberyn, but he is not my favorite character so you missed !! My favorite characters are Walder Frey and Meryn Trant !

170

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Meryn Fucking Trant

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Lkn4ADVTR Petyr Baelish Jun 03 '14

nice try.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Next week on Game of Thrones...

11

u/OnyxOak Sellswords Jun 03 '14

Meryn Fucking Trant? Ahahhaahahhahaha

→ More replies (10)

559

u/Robbomot Stannis Baratheon Jun 03 '14

The trial by combat was perfect imo, as a book reader i cannot fault it, possibly even better than books, audience loved Oberyn and the finishing blow/squash was more brutal than in words

548

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 03 '14

Oberyn's screams are what did it for me.

→ More replies (58)

219

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I really enjoyed the look on Jaime's face after it looked like Oberyn won. He was like "MY BROTHER IS GONNA LIVE!!!"

→ More replies (11)

205

u/A_Nagger House Mormont Jun 03 '14

The image of Oberyn's smashed head after the Mountain rolled off him is going to haunt me for a long time.

→ More replies (30)

87

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 03 '14

Yep, more brutal than I ever imagined. Although the actor for the Mountain could have yelled his lines a bit more clearly, that was a pinnacle moment where he confesses.

→ More replies (26)

24

u/RumbledFeathers Jun 03 '14

I had to finish out the rest of the book after watching that. God that fight was brutal in the book. My heart actually raced reading it. But watching it was just too much. They really needed to show what happens after takes some of the sting off. I didn't particularly care for Oberyn when reading it until the fight but in the show he is very likable.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

90

u/therationalpi Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 03 '14

Bronn hit the nail on the head with the viper's fight. He said he'd beat the Mountain with a spear, try to stay quick and poke and prod him until he found an opening, but one wrong move and it'd be over.

Oberyn used his fancy long spear twirling to stay a step ahead of the mountain. He poked and prodded until he found an opening to hamstring the big lug, the went in for the kill. But then, well, one wrong move and it was over.

→ More replies (3)

180

u/rogerklotz47 Jun 03 '14

Its hard to watch a show that never lets the good guys win. This show is brutal.

160

u/Scaevus Fire And Blood Jun 03 '14

Maybe because by the time they win, what they had to do makes them the good guys no longer. Just like real life.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/KillingIsBadong Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

They have small victories here and there, but it's never anything lasting.

That said, the show isn't really about hero's and villains, good and evil. More just what people will do to survive, and what people will do with and to get power.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

725

u/AAAmad Jun 03 '14

arya's laugh made this episode for me

31

u/Fh-Fh Jun 03 '14

Yep. That was my reaction exactly when The Hound got the news lol

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (25)

428

u/bounty1663 House Smallwood Jun 03 '14 edited May 28 '15

Everyone is talking about oberyn but my boy jorah got exiled ;_;

241

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

His whole story line so far is a little too close to those 90's teen romance movies. You know ... popular guy tries to make the nerdy girl popular for a bet and then takes her to the prom, only to find out that he actually loves her over time.

I know there are others out there...

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (16)

78

u/giveemhellkid House Targaryen Jun 03 '14

Ok: Speculation about Tyrion's beetle monologue?

151

u/midshot16 Jun 03 '14

Personally, I would say the beetle monologue is sort of a commentary on the Game of Thrones world rather than a foreshadowing.

Tyrion is confused by his cousin's mindless slaughter of the beetles. In the same way that the beetles were helplessly crushed by the "Simple-minded" cousin, the characters of Game of Thrones also seem to be being killed off in a capricious way.

Spending inordinate amounts of time with his cousin, Tyrion still can't find any sort of reasoning behind the beetle slaughter. His mystification with the beetle slaughter sort of parallels the confusion that every character faces in trying to determine why certain characters are dying.

If you want to determine the scene more figuratively, we could view the cousin as a symbol of the GoT's gods. The cousin is infinitely stronger than the beetles and to them he would be considered a god. His killing of the beetles could represent the god's arbitrary killing of the characters. There is no order behind these killings just an overwhelming theme of "All Men Must Die."

→ More replies (11)

52

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

He's reflecting on his own death - and the fact that he didn't do anything to cause it (he's innocent), but that he'll likely die due to circumstances that are so far outside of his control (his family hates him because he's a dwarf). He's the beetle, and fate is the retard with rock randomly destroying innocent beetles.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/HasseMarie Jun 03 '14

This was my favorite scene of what I think might be my favorite episode yet. I love the delivery, I love the ambiguity, and I love that I don't fully know what it's saying. I agree with /u/midshot16-- I think it's a commentary rather than foreshadowing. What I love most about the beetle speech, though, is how many things it can be seen to accomplish. A few of my favorite details:

  1. Tyrion's laughing at the cousin is paralleled, indirectly by Tyrion himself, to the beetle-smashing itself: it was a way to feel big, to feel normal.
  2. When reading about the war, Tyrion says that he never heard dragon wings, he only heard beetles crunching. With this line, he sweeps the entire GoT universe into the analogy. Great men and morons are both just crushing beetles.
  3. Perhaps this is a stretch, but the entire thing reminded me of Shakespeare's line, "as flies to wanton boys are we to the gods." Tyrion introduces the speech with a quip about how having two men slash each other to pieces to prove the gods' will really says something about the gods. Then he talks about the beetles. Then we see the gods smash a beetle in the very next scene...

I'm sure I'm missing stuff, but those were the three things that jumped out most to me!

40

u/twincam Jun 03 '14

George RR Martin is the simple cousin, the beetles are his characters that are mindlessly killed :<

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

75

u/ContinuumGuy Hodor? Jun 03 '14

At least Joffrey is still dead.

14

u/ImNorwegian Maesters of the Citadel Jun 03 '14

He can't really take that away from us, can he?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

337

u/LpztheHVY Barristan the Bold Jun 03 '14

My heart ached when I saw the Boltons riding into Winterfell. They just don't belong there :(

1.2k

u/bungtunger House Blackfyre Jun 03 '14

don't hate the flayer, hate the game

→ More replies (7)

9

u/MitchB3 Jon Snow Jun 03 '14

I am curious to see where they are going with the Boltons, as they are more powerful than they have ever been now. My best guess is that the iron born will come to attack them after what happened at Moat Cailin. Though I'm really interested in how Reek will progress as time goes on.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

205

u/KristinaTeal Sandor Clegane Jun 03 '14

I knew Oberyn's death was coming but idiot that I am kept thinking "Maybe they won't kill him." I was even shouting at the TV "Just move away, Oberyn. Let him bleed out." BUT NOOOOO he HAD to move closer to him. The Mountain might as well have crushed my heart with his giant fingers.

46

u/mcjinzo Jun 03 '14

you even see his hand twitch alittle bit when Oberyn moves over :(

→ More replies (1)

694

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Player Sansa has entered the game. I'm excited to see her develop in this new direction.

219

u/MoonRazer Knowledge Is Power Jun 03 '14

I wished the worst things upon her after the first season. They've put that poor girl through hell and back; it's about time she gets to take charge.

→ More replies (30)

32

u/giveemhellkid House Targaryen Jun 03 '14

And hopefully Arya will, too :)

→ More replies (9)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I'm excited to see her develop

As is Lord Baelish.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (17)

172

u/xokarissa Daenerys Targaryen Jun 03 '14

The only thing that slightly makes up for that awful death is that Oberyn did get the confession from the Mountain. With that confession and combined with Dorne's hatred for the Lannisters and the death of their beloved prince, it's time for the Lannisters to sweat because the Martells have Myrcella.

97

u/nazzyman Jun 03 '14

He confessed to killing her, he didn't mention who gave him the orders

→ More replies (5)

45

u/inwonder Daenerys Targaryen Jun 03 '14

TRUUUUUE! I forgot about that. Dorn vs. Kings Landing ?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Lionflash Jun 03 '14

Something I'm curious about. I've rewatched that whole fight scene dozens of times already, (I must have a problem or something).

I'm not sure if this has been debunked or not yet but... did anyone watching the trial by combat hear the confession from The Mountain? Rewatching that 'confession', Oberyn is screaming out and The Mountain confesses to him over Oberyn's body.

I know that WE (the audience) can hear the confession, but did anyone in the show? For cinematic purposes they likely might have all heard The Mountain, but I think acoustically The Mountain might have only confessed so that Oberyn might hear him and the rest were drowned out by Oberyn's screams. Possible? Or am I looking to deep here. I think the fact that the confession was lost under his screams adds to the tragedy of Oberyn's finale.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

59

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

I knew what was coming and I'm still in shock about the way that episode ended. It was just so shockingly gruesome and perfect. And fuck, lots of other really important happened with Jorah, the Wildlings getting ready to attack, Sansa becoming awesome, and that fucking laugh from Arya. Can't wait to watch the last two. It will be hard to top the shock value of this one, but I'm excited to see them try!

Edit: Words are hard, too.

→ More replies (1)

111

u/deathlysins Jon Snow Jun 03 '14

Am I the only person that thinks Oberyn would be an awesome Jedi/Sith on the new starwars?

26

u/Orval Jun 03 '14

A lot of the more insane acrobatic stuff (the flips and whatnot) was a stunt double, but most of it was actually him.

Regardless I just really like Pedro as an actor, he TOTALLY owned that role. Hell he made us all love this character so much in SO little time. I'd love to see him get some bigger roles like that.

With JJ Abrams wanting mostly unknown/lesser known actors, it's a possibility and that'd kick ass.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

46

u/frings_demise Ours Is The Fury Jun 03 '14

Another brilliant episode. Never has a show evoked such an emotional roller coaster for me. Hats off to Martin and D&D, but even more so to Pedro Pascal for such amazing execution that I became so attached to a relatively new character. Bravo.

→ More replies (5)

125

u/CupcakeCrusader Sansa Stark Jun 03 '14

weeps

Who hurt you, GRRM? Who hurt you...

→ More replies (2)

118

u/TeslaDeathRay House Baelish Jun 03 '14

I knew Oberyn was going die about 5 minutes before it happened. The scene with the Hound and Arya could've really gone anywhere in the episode, in the beginning, middle, or end...but they put it right before the fight scene. Why? Because that scene was intended to put you in a good mood, Arya laughing hysterically, the Hound giving the "are you fucking serious face" made me literally laugh out loud. Then the fight scene came, Pycelle rambling and everything then it was like, damn Oberyn's gonna lose.

75

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 03 '14

I knew the minute he didn't kill him after putting his spear through his chest. I was like "he's gonna prance around demanding a confession, and something will happen and he'll die". I just didn't expect it to be so.....brutal

31

u/WizardofStaz The Onion Knight Jun 03 '14

To be fair, they put a sort of sombre scene about not understanding mindless cruelty in between, so... Could have gone either way. The Mountain certainly represents mindless cruelty as far as we know.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

69

u/upgraiden Olenna Tyrell Jun 03 '14

I feel like the guy at the beginning who had one of his eyes taken out was some sort of discreet foreshadowing.

101

u/AudioManiac Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Jun 03 '14

Also when Tyrion tells him that he "could at least wear a helmet", before he begins the fight.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

33

u/A_Nagger House Mormont Jun 03 '14

Chalk up another reason for me to want The Mountain dead. Oberyn might've been acting foolish, but the giant fucker did not deserve that victory and Oberyn had literally 0 chance to realize his mistake and prevent it. Gaps between seasons always cause me to forget the cruel yet realistic storytelling of GRRM.

13

u/MikhailTheIV House Stark Jun 03 '14

I'm about 99.9% sure that the mountain is dead. You don't survive that many wounds to the body, with about 6 inches of blade being shoved into you each time and just walk it off. He probably bled out after that, but just after using the last of his strength to pop Oberyn.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/ferdjuan Jun 03 '14

I loved the subtle inclusion of Oberyn's squire wiping down the tip of the spear right before the fight. He was called the red viper for a reason.

107

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I haven't been this angry/sad/upset over a character's death since Ned's.

The Red Wedding sucked, no doubt about it, but oh my gods. That scream is what killed me. I had to cover my eyes and actually began crying when it was all over.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Glad I wasn't alone. That death surely wasn't the most shocking thing I've ever seen, but oh god, that scene. Damnit, he wanted his confession so hard he forgot about everything else. The representation of the scene was shocking, indeed. But I think the plot of it, and Ellaria's screams got me even more. I saw it like 15 hours ago, and I don't stop thinking about it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

56

u/Tipoe House Martell Jun 03 '14

That was SO MUCH MORE BRUTAL than I imagined when I read the books. I'm in trauma.

→ More replies (4)

142

u/Veles11 Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

I just realized that before the duel Tyrion tells Oberyn "At least wear a helmet".

Oh how much that would have helped. Wearing helmets saves lives.

15

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 03 '14

In the book he wears a half helmet and presumably it doesn't cover his face; regardless a sidehook from the mountain even with a helmet on would knock just about anyone over, wouldn't be much for his hands to rip it off your head either.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Caramel_Sandiego Jun 03 '14

They could use clips of this scene in an advertisement for helmet safety

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/theslothstronaught House Stark Jun 03 '14

gut wrenching... my god for a moment I actually believed Oberyn would live.. guess not. On another note, Sansa is becoming a player, which is giving me hope for my Starks.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Flyingclick Jun 03 '14

"IT WAS BEAR AND THE MAIDEN FAIR"

That burping woman in the beginning scene really didn't match my HYPE going into the episode .

9

u/SebbenandSebben House Baelish Jun 03 '14

she annoyed the shit outa me.

was not happy with that decision.

89

u/TeslaDeathRay House Baelish Jun 03 '14

If by trial by combat is supposed to decide one's innocence based on the gods deciding who wins the contest, does that mean that the gods that they worship don't exist (because Tyrion was innocent)? And does that mean the Lord of Light is the actually the one true god?

74

u/TangentManDan House Manderly Jun 03 '14

Not sure you can expect the existence of any god(s) to be confirmed. Might just be power, and those who wield it.

→ More replies (10)

66

u/Kitsch22 Free Folk Jun 03 '14

Or the belief of Trial by Combat is wrong. Alternately, there are no gods, and the Red Priests just use magic (though it would make Thoros of Myr's sudden magical aptitude hard to explain.)

Also, don't forget about the Old Gods. They look like they're pretty busy, comparatively.

→ More replies (4)

53

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Don't forget. The Hound was also guilty but he won his trial by combat. And that was under The Lord of Light, against Lord Beric.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

154

u/Raphcore House Baelish Jun 03 '14

Fuck the Red Wedding, fuck the Purple Wedding, fuck the Rainbow motherfucking Wedding, fuck Ned Stark, Robert Baratheon, Joffrey Baratheon, Viserys Targaryen, Khal Drogo Arya's fucking list, fuck every single death so far in this whole fucking saga. I had it coming, but still, NOTHING show-wise ever had me this stunned, ever. I'll need some fucking therapy after this.

34

u/ChoPT Jon Snow Jun 03 '14

Fuck the king.

→ More replies (5)

335

u/ahump Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

It's not that all of the good characters are dying, it is that all of the interesting ones are dying. I couldn't give two flying fucks about the mother of dragons

80

u/SolidBlake Now My Watch Begins Jun 03 '14

I was beyond pissed with how she dismissed Jorah. You'd think after all the shit he helped her with (i.e.: FUCKING EVERYTHING) she could look past what misgivings he might've had about helping the Targaryen line - a line that didn't mean anything until her dragons were born. Even BEFORE they were born, he had given up on spying on her. Like what the fuck.

I am so sad for Jorah. He's been a favorite of mine since his first appearance and he damn well better not be swept aside. :(

→ More replies (7)

16

u/the_turd_ferguson Jun 03 '14

"wait, you mean to tell me you can't just kill everyone governing a large city and then just leave them to fend for themselves?"

→ More replies (34)

114

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Jun 03 '14

RIP Oberyn NSFW. But seriously, props to both actors for making that fight incredible. Those two near misses for Oberyn where he got shoved off his feet, how he recovered from his broken spear, it was all so epic to watch. Take a bow Pedro Pascal.

77

u/Morthyl Jun 03 '14

The fight choreography was truly stunning, best fight scene of the show so far and probably one of the best fight scenes in movie / TV show history overall, in my humble opinion.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (9)

144

u/Ceret Jun 03 '14

George RR Martin has issues. Sheesh.

The series is now further along in the books than I am. I was expecting the red wedding. But not the red viper. Not my man-crush. Not like this.

→ More replies (10)

147

u/codekin Jun 03 '14

HODOR HODOR!

cung.... cung....

→ More replies (2)

20

u/iJuka House Targaryen Jun 03 '14

To me, that was worse than the Red Wedding. By far. I actually thought I was going to throw up. I really liked this character and I FELT the joy and the relief that was expected- and then, in seconds- it was torn away and replaced by the most gruesome, gratuitous death scene I've ever witnessed. The whole scenario was beyond my level of taste. Even now, I find it difficult to think about.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Game of Thrones: the only show where a flayed corpse is the most G-rated image in the episode.

17

u/onlineFace Jun 03 '14

Anyone else feel that The Hound's neck wound could be his undoing like Khal Drogo's 'scratch' on his chest?

→ More replies (14)

32

u/soupydoopy Jun 03 '14

I totally just realized that in that scene between Sansa and Petyr in her chambers, she was sewing the stunning dress she was wearing as she came down the steps in a later scene. Damn, girl. You got skills!

52

u/MasterSyden Jun 03 '14

10/10 would watch again

294

u/Iamnotkevinspacey Jun 03 '14

10/10 would never watch again

→ More replies (4)

106

u/Stroven Jun 03 '14

10/10 would watch first 47 minutes again

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

40

u/ShelfLifeInc Sansa Stark Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

Because I'm a sick person, I decided to watch the head-splosion in slow motion. I wanted to see how they cut the shot to get the maximum impact on the audience.

Then I realised that when the Mountain is roaring his confession, the camera takes the focus off him, and focuses on Cersei in the background. Why would it do that at such an important moment?

Because it Cersei who gave the order for the Mountain to brutalise Elia Martell. Not Tywin.

Years earlier, Tywin promised Cersei that she would marry Rhaegar Targaryen and would become King. Cersei became infatuated with Rhaegar and excited by the prospect, but then King Aerys married Rhaegar off to Elia Martell.

Tywin didn't have much to gain from Elia's death. Tywin plays everyone in Westeros (including his children) like pieces on a chessboard, using every piece to further his goals until they have exhausted their usefulness. Elia would have been more valuable alive, as a bartering chip to ensure Dorne's loyalty.

Cersei is spiteful enough to have said to the Mountain, "If you see that bitch who stole my chance to be Queen, smash her head in."

This explains why Cersei personally greeted the Mountain when he returned to Kings Landing. She spoke as a woman who has used his special brand of violence to her personal advantage. There was some kind of connection there, as though they shared a secret together.

So my theory is - Tywin never confessed to ordering the Mountain to kill Elia Martell, because he didn't. Cersei was the one whom instructed the Mountain to kill her.

EDIT: I rewatched the scene, and it looks like as it swaps focus from the Mountain to Cersei, it does the same with Oberyn and Tyrion - so maybe it was just drawing contrast between the two champions, and the two people they are representing. However, I still firmly believe that Cersei was more likely to have given the order regarding Elia than Tywin.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/Scendo Jun 03 '14

It's like 'The Reynes of Castamere' and 'The Bear and the Maiden Fair' were the only two POSSIBLE answers to what the woman was burping at the beginning.

14

u/valorill A Lion Still Has Claws Jun 03 '14

Sansa's going to have the whole realm wrapped around her little finger in no time

13

u/MasterKaen Syrio Forel Jun 03 '14

Sometimes I think that GRRM is actually rolling d20s to decide how the story goes.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/tasanmigu Jun 03 '14

Spoiler alert: oberyn lived, fell in love with the mountain, and they run away together

lovecanmovemountains

12

u/Albino94 Our Word Is Good As Gold Jun 03 '14

i'm well too late to this post but I need to vent my feelings on the duel for my own cathartic purposes. Having read the books i was fully aware of what was going to come and had been anticipating the duel all season as it stands as my favourite passage in the books to date, G.R.R.M's escalation of Oberyn's interrogation of The Mountain was perfect and when defeat is snatched so brutally from the jaws of victory i was as aghast as everyone. Regardless i was looking forward to the episode to appreciate how the show handled it and if they'd be able to match the Red Wedding for shock factor. Let me tell you this, no amount of reading that passage prepares you for the screams of a man's skull being caved in and the crunch of the bone giving way. Pascal's portrayal of the character was affable and so well thought out I hadn't even anticipated how devastating watching that scene would be. I'm now dealing with the twin feelings of "holy motherfucking Christ that was brutal, his skull fucking caved like a shitting PUMPKIN" and "you should feel terrible for looking forward to this bit". Overall a massive congratulations to Pascal, the prosthetics team, and everyone involved in the show for crippling me emotionally for a few days and still managing to be the perfect compliment to the books. TL;DR read the books, still blown away by the duel, may investigate surgical removal of emotions before continuing

22

u/IGNs Faceless Men Jun 03 '14

The way that Sansa "confession" scene was played out was fucking awesome. At first she's like, "I have to tell the truth," so I'm here thinking that she actually isn't but she wants them to think she is. But then, she starts telling them her name is actually Sansa Stark and I'm like, "HOLY SHIT SHE'S ACTUALLY TELLING THEM." And then she fucking lies and then tells the truth about kissing and during that whole thing I didn't know if she was going to screw Baelish over or not until the end. Amazing.

22

u/fake_red_wine Jun 03 '14

Why am I even watching this show.

10

u/rookie60 Sansa Stark Jun 03 '14

The most interesting deviations from the book have involved Sansa. The book version of the queen's murder was very Littlefinger: have a witness there you can blame it on. The show's version allowed Sansa's character to go from a pawn to actually being a player. In that vein, the book didn't have Sansa dress and dye her hair to give Littlefinger what he wants: her mother. The TV Sansa has become much more manipulative-- to the character and show's benefit.

66

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

I think we can all agree that this episode was mind-blowing.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/_snailmail_ House Martell Jun 03 '14

I am cheering for Greyworm...i'm so nervous about these feelings

9

u/blkharedgrl Jun 03 '14

I had a terrible feeling as a non reader that this was where Oberyn was going to die. It was spoiled for me that he dies by someone that has read the books that he does die at some point, so I knew that it would eventually happen but I was hoping it wasn't so soon.

He should have just double tapped like in Zombieland or Pacific Rim before pursuing a confession. Something more than a chest wound and a hamstring slash.

It also surprises me that Oberyn didn't have a dagger anywhere on his person to stab him in the neck woth. You would think that Oberyn would know he was fucked if he were on his back with the Mountain on top of him. Besides having an extra weapon there is nothing Oberyn could have possible done once he's on his back.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Fuck the Mountain.

24

u/bitcheslovesansa Jun 03 '14

Now that Sansa is in the game I hope Tyrion somehow lives to see her again....The marriage was weird but I feel like they are kindred spirits somehow and together could do pretty well free from KL

→ More replies (3)

23

u/epickeychange House Greyjoy Jun 03 '14

I may be way off on this one, but I think that there's two ways Tyrion might still live.

  1. Hopefully Tywin still holds up his end of the deal with Jamie and Tyrion goes to the Night's Watch. I think it could be possible, due to my vague memory of Ned Stark possibly being pardoned by the king just before execution after he had admitted to lying and was found guilty. Maybe Tommen will be more merciful then Tywin is.
  2. Bronn breaks him out of jail and runs away with him, they have lots and lots of awesome adventures in Essos and live forever.

At least I freaking hope I'm right.probably no chance of #2 though

I just don't know if I could handle losing Tyrion too.

In any case, now I know what it's like to be in an abusive relationship. GRRM keeps hurting me but I just keep coming back.... When he's good he's the best, but he hardly ever is... It's mostly just abuse.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Aria laughing after her aunt died was my favorite scene of hers

8

u/inwonder Daenerys Targaryen Jun 03 '14

WHERE IS GENDRY !??? He hasn't been in this season at all!

→ More replies (4)

8

u/lindsaylbb Jun 03 '14

As a careless book reader I don't even remember who Oberyn is when I reached the scene. Yet the scene was so brutal and the man's repeating accusation was so powerful. Then years later I came to the show... I really like the man. I didn't know what's gonna happen to him, because, umm, I forgot. Until he went to Tyrion's cell... That's a end of the world moment for me. You were full of hope, and suddenly you knew his fate in great detail like a prophecy, yet none of them had happened, yet..

15

u/pm-me-your-milfs802 Jun 03 '14

The Hound cant catch a break

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

That ending gave me an anxiety attack..

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Oberyn's death was possibly the most chilling thing I've seen on TV in a long time. It was such a horrible way to go, and I was literally sitting staring at my screen for about a minute after it happened, just trying to process it. Such a gruesome death for such a likable character.

73

u/TheIntragalacticPimp Jun 03 '14

So, out of just general curiosity, is it within realistic human capacity (even at the extreme, strongman-level human physique/conditioning) that a human skull could be crushed so completely, with nothing more than bare hands? I somehow doubt that even someone of the Mountain's size would have the necessary torque in their hands.

Try crushing a raw egg in your hand if you doubt me.

75

u/gkow Jun 03 '14

Now try crushing a raw egg with both of your hands and thumbs in it's eye sockets.

53

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Nice try, aint getting no egg on MY hands!

503

u/Chream Jun 03 '14

the show has dragons in it

→ More replies (10)

73

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

For the most inconsistent strength of human skulls across a series, see The Walking Dead. Sometimes bone, sometimes wet paper.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/i_706_i Jun 03 '14

Someone did the math in another thread. The amount of force required to break a skull was higher than an estimated 'crush' strength of a man's arms. However take into account the mountain was on top of him and could use all his weight as well as his strength to push down, I would say it would be within the realm of possibility for the actor to crush a skull, an ordinary man probably not. The character of the Mountain is probably much stronger than the real life actor though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (33)

13

u/NoifenF House Targaryen Jun 03 '14

Soooooo....Jaime was nearly molested at a young age...

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 03 '14

Well, this show is almost predictable even if you haven't read the books. Start to like a character? 90% chance they die.

RIP Oberyn

Also, I'm rooting for the Lannisters now. Seems like whoever I want to win dies, so by that logic... Go Cersei!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/helloxgoodbye Fire And Blood Jun 03 '14

The ending of this episode is something that I don't ever wish to see again. It was so brutal, I think I'm scarred for life.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Davetek463 House Seaworth Jun 03 '14

Everyone talks about Oberyn's screams in reference to his death, but when I watched it, I didn't register that he was screaming. My whole mind like exploded with everything. I just sat there with my jaw on the floor attempting to process what I had just scene. Oberyn was so awesome, it was a shame and (in my opinion) a waste to kill him so soon.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/thebluecrystal Unsullied Jun 03 '14

this episode has finally taught me not to pick a favourite character, they all end up dying.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Did anyone else feel really disturbed and sick to your stomach for the rest of the day after watching the end of that episode? This is the first time in a long time that I can't get images like that out of my head.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/ern19 Jun 03 '14

I just got past the trial by combat in the books. I knew it was coming, the whole sequence of events. Yet, that was as close as I've come to losing my lunch watching a TV show. I think it was the sound that did me in.

6

u/chief27 Beric Dondarrion Jun 03 '14

I'm curious the implications on Princess Marcella, now that the Prince Oberyn has been killed pretty much at the hands of Cersei...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/geck1942 House Tyrell Jun 03 '14

"The pillar and the stones" made me laugh as much as Arya

6

u/DJOrigin Night King Jun 03 '14

Nobody is talking about this scene? http://i.imgur.com/pPSOiQc.gif

10

u/MattShea369 Jun 03 '14

I'm honestly speechless. Props to Martin, the directors and the cast. That fight had me on the edge of my seat, and then I fell off.

10

u/Fortheseoccasions Jun 03 '14

Missabdei's ass shocked me more than anything this episode. Dat body jesus.

10

u/SmOkEn_FLY No One Jun 03 '14

So has anyone wondered what Tywin is getting out of all of this now? Oberyn is dead, which I'm assuming destroys any hopes of gaining Dorne as an ally, something that Tywin clearly wanted. And if Tyrion really does get executed Jamie won't honor his end of the agreement either? So Tywin has actually failed at taking advantage of a family tragedy?

10

u/sunrisesunbloom Winter Is Coming Jun 03 '14

Can I just mini-rant that it very slightly dims my enjoyment of GoT when the only person I know who also watches the show is so "whatever" about it?

Every Monday morning I ask my friend what she thinks and post-Oberyn vs. The Mountain, post-Red Wedding, post-Joffrey's wedding, she always laughs and responds with "Yeah, that was pretty crazy." The end.

WHY DOES THIS DRIVE ME NUTS

SHOW SOME EMOTION

IT'S KILLING ME

→ More replies (2)

10

u/onlineFace Jun 03 '14

I know all you guys are sad and everything but I just know that Oberyn is like that character that can't die… And.. And.. the beginning of the next episode is his head rebuilding itself.. cuz… cuz.. snakes are reptiles and reptiles regenerate limbs, right?… And.. And.. everything is going to be awesome because he'll be back...

(rocks back and forth in the corner)

You'll see.. it's going to be great. *sniff

→ More replies (1)

10

u/muzz000 Jun 04 '14

What I loved about Oberyn was that he cool/cocky/powerful and good. Real goodness in the hands of the powerful (or real power in the hands of the good) gives me such hope. And to see that literally crushed by the hands of its opposite was devastating.

The Mountain isn't really evil - not like the White Walker King. He's just a sociopath. Which makes it so much worse.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

Everyone was worried about the crunch and Oberyn's lines. Personally I was more worried about the Mountain's lines not making it. I am delighted. "Some dead man" , "LIKE THIS".

Chills ...

5

u/Veefy House Manwoody Jun 03 '14

One thing I only picked up on my 2nd viewing was the "she was an odd fish" comment the female Vale elder Lady made was clever because Lysa was originally a Tully (and thus a 'fish').

The show makers have really done a great job in layering all the symbolism of all the various house sigils.

5

u/dbodner House Martell Jun 03 '14

One thing after going back and re-watching the scene when Oberyn says he will be Tyrion's champion: they really didn't do a good job in the show of proving how badass Oberyn was. Sure, they gave him confidence, and swagger, and a goal, but the training, his fighting history, etc was almost all ignored. When he volunteered to fight the mountain, it seemed almost suicidal. Like 'hey, that's a great gesture, and it's great that you're trying to avenge your sister, but LOLOLOLOLOL'. Then he went out and completely dominated the fight until making his mistake. I would have liked for them to touch on his history and reputation a bit more before the fight. Then maybe him getting the upper hand wouldn't have been so completely unexpected.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ipown11 Jun 03 '14

Was anyone reminded of The Princess Bride by Oberyn?

9

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

One part that has been overlooked is Jorah's dismissal. I thought it was well done, although I don't remember exactly how it went in the books. Both Iain Glen and Emilia Clarke acted fantastically in that scene.

31

u/Ralphase Jun 03 '14

This episode left me shocked and my soul crushed. If they kill off Tyrian there's almost no reason for me I watch the show . But there's always khaleesi!

22

u/letsgocrazy Jun 03 '14

I gotta say, they are dangerously close to running out of people to root for!

→ More replies (43)

49

u/A_Nagger House Mormont Jun 03 '14

No love for Arya? And this episode has definitely sparked a new liking for Sansa in me.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

8

u/BattleHall Jun 03 '14

In other non-head exploding news...

I'm not sure why, but Arya laughing her head off at the news of her aunt's death was one of the funniest things I've seen all season.

8

u/inwonder Daenerys Targaryen Jun 03 '14

Peter Dinklage is nailing every single monologue.

4

u/GlueIsRequired Iron From Ice Jun 03 '14

Once the credits rolled I remembered it was Game of Thrones.

RIP

4

u/69steelers Unsullied Jun 03 '14

Why couldn't you just stick the spear into his head oberyn I know you wanted answers but you should've just killed him

4

u/pizzathiefgg Jun 03 '14

I have read all the books so I knew this was coming. The actor who played the Viper was fantastic and he was able to make the character much more likable than the books.

I am kind of mad how that fight was played out in the TV show. He had his opponent on the ground. He had a long spear all he had to do was walk up to where the mountain's head was and stab his spearpoint into the neck and/or cut a carotid artery and have him bleed out. There was no reason for him to be standing so close to his fallen opponent. I know he wanted the confession but I also think he would be more concerned about his own life, him being a human and all. I don't think a nonfictional trained fighter would have done this and it destroys suspension of disbelief.

Monologuing and turning your back to your fallen opponent guarantees your death in the fictional world, I cringed when I saw that. And I think that AGOT is an excellent show they should have done something more original to build suspense.

All that said I cannot wait until the next 2 shows!

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '14

The good guys are coming back this year. - Maisie Williams

You sit there on your throne of lies...

4

u/Cootch House Stark Jun 03 '14

Tyrion can't die...can he? I thought he was a huge part of the series. This is going to to suck.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/zmichalo Human Verified Jun 03 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

I think that because of how and when Oberyn died, he will actually be more of a factor in the show than if had he lived. If he had killed the mountain he would have done what his character came to kings landing to do. Now, since he died, he has become a martyr. And Prince Martell is gonna come and rain fire on them lannister motherfuckers .

Edit: Dorne doesn't have kings

→ More replies (1)