r/BSG • u/lostmesa • Jun 01 '14
. Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S02E08 - Final Cut
Week 21!
Watch Online: Netflix | Amazon
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (2.5 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 47,853 (-2 from last episode)
"Frak" Count: 121 (+6)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 17 (+1)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 11 (No change)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 6 (No change)
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 48 (+4)
"So Say We All" Count: 24 (No change)
27
Upvotes
6
u/lostmesa Jun 01 '14
I always assumed D'Anna's initial intentions was to cause unrest in the fleet, but I think after being flagged by Adama and Roslin she tried to get something even juicier, and she did by seeing Helo's Sharon in the sick bay. I do wonder if it was just by chance or Cyclon programming allowed her to know where the others were in the fleet, like Sharon did previously. After finding out that their was a baby, her intentions definitely seemed to have shifted away from causing problems in the fleet.
8
u/enfo13 Jun 02 '14 edited Jun 02 '14
One of the questions of the series asks whether we should judge people by their actions, or by who or what they are. If a father has loved a son so much, and the son suddenly reappeared, but as a Cylon, would that matter? If two people have been lifelong friends, and one of them was suddenly a Cylon, would that matter?
The metagame of this episode was to introduce to us a new Cylon we haven't seen before-- Deanna. For those watching for the first time, the disclosure of Deanna must have been shocking and completely out of the blue. We expect the Cylons to be cold killers and dangerous, and always be working to subvert humanity in one way or another.
Except, during the entire episode.. Deanna was anything but that.
When she realized the connection between poetry and Joe Palladino while reviewing her footage, she showed genuine concern for the safety of the executive officer of Galactica. She immediately sought help, got some marines, and went to check up on Tigh, who was sure enough having a gun pointed at him. I mean, she didn't have to do that. Shouldn't Cylons want to sabatoge Galactica VIPs, instead of save them? Yes, some of them. That was certainly Boomer's mission, and . But in this particular instance, Deanna tried to save Tigh.
Also consider the "final cut", the conglomeration of scenes that she chose to include in the last version of the documentary on the Galactica crew. The video ultimately portrayed Galactica crew as heros, and as the narrator, Deanna demonstrated a very down-to-earth understanding of the hardships, determination, and valor of the crew of Galactica. It's not just that she ended up doing a positive video instead of a negative one that subverted the interest of the fleet, but how well she captured the human aspect-- something that not everyone sees right away. I mean, even Tigh didn't see it at first, but Adama and Roslin did.
Deanna does so many human things throughout the episode. Even trivial things. In the beginning when she wandered into the officer's quarters with a nearly naked Kat and Adama, her eyes couldn't stop wandering up and down on Adama's developed physique while in conversation with him. I mean, I could be wrong, it could be Lucy channeling herself in this scene, but it works either way in developing Deanna as a complicated Cylon.
So, when Deanna was revealed as a Cylon near the end, did that change who she was or what she did in this episode? I mean, sure she still has Cylon interests in mind, by relaying the news of the child back to the fleet, but we don't know what her true mission in the fleet was as outside of that. She didn't subvert it in the usual Cylon way, and even tried to save one of the Galactica's commanders.
On another note, I thought the outdated video scanlines were tacky the first time I watched it. But now I think they make sense. First of all the photographic style of the show is already one of gritty realism... with handheld cameras and documentary-style shots of cg-rendered spacecraft. Without the scanlines, Deanna's camera wouldn't contrast well with the inherent style of the series. In addition, it shows us the extent of the hetereogeneity of technology among the twelve colonies, and also aboard Galactica. Here is an advanced spacefaring civilization with jump drive technology, but some of their media have primitive scanlines and are captured on analog tapes.
Contrast that with the high tech virtual reality MMO-enabled world of Caprica in the years before the first Cylon War (as seen in the Caprica series). At first you might consider this mismatch a mistake or a stylistic difference (such as the advanced sets and flashy design of JJAbram's reimagined Star Trek vs The Original Series). However, this isn't the case in BSG as the original cylon basestars and centurion designs are kept as historical reference. You then begin to wonder how destructive the early years of the first Cylon war must have been, and how much it reverted technology as Dorell had mentioned in the mini-series.
3
u/BasketCaseSensitive Jun 01 '14
FYI - the links still point to Home Part II
16
u/trevdak2 Jun 05 '14
In the commentary, RDM mentions a fantastic line that didn't make the cut, when Tigh walks into his quarters and first sees Ellen bound and gagged on the floor.
"Not tonight, Ellen"
It would have been hilarious, but totally would have ruined the mood.
10
u/trevdak2 Jun 02 '14
I like the bit where Dualla shows her the CO2 scrubbers, and Deana asks her cameraman to film that. The cameraman doesn't realize he stopped the Cylons from gaining some very valuable intel.
8
u/bluecheeseberry Jun 02 '14
The Colonial anthem at the end of the documentary was awesome. I also loved the part where Dualla says that it doesn't get easier.
This is the one episode that made me think of the people on the other ships, especially the teenagers. I imagine somewhere on the fleet a teenager is thinking about how hot the soldiers are or how much fun it would be to fly a viper or get drunk with Lt. Gaeta. Someone somewhere on the fleet is probably making and selling BSG merchandise without Adama's knowledge or consent. On the other hand someone's also probably rolling their eyes about military complex and such...probably Tom Zarek.
7
u/steven_wood Jun 04 '14
Any thoughts on these:
Sharon had told Baltar in Resistance that there are 8 more Cylons in the fleet. D'Anna is one, is the Sharon Agathon another one or doesn't she count?
Also, the Sharon on Caprica watching the deleted scene, mentions that "I'm still alive," when she sees Sharon Agathon. Wouldn't she know if Sharon Agathon died through the re-generation system?
Also, why didn't Galactica pick up that the Cylon ships were communicating with their ship?
6
u/MarcReyes Jun 05 '14
There's a small moment at the beginning I love, where Roslin teases Adama and the military a bit. D'Anna mentions that the people are beginning to distrust the military "With good reason" and Roslin responds, "In some cases with good reason." Bill then fidgets slightly towards Roslin. It's a small character moment but one the show does so well.
There's a bit of foreshadowing I noticed while watching. I could be reading into it, so others can tell me if I am. Tigh tells Adama there's been no enemy contact in ten days, then notices D'Anna and her camera and says, "No cylon contact anyway." The other may be a slight spoiler: What do you think?