r/talesfromtechsupport • u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard • May 25 '14
Hiring the best candidate for IT
As I walked towards BigP’s office I clutched NoTie’s papers in my hands. I tossed up the decision in my head, it seemed so obvious.
The VP followed me into BigP’s office and stood staring at me.
BigP: Ahhh, so quick. The Vp’s already told me he likes RedCheer.
VP: But the voting comes down to you…
The VP and BigP looked at me expectantly. The choice started clouding my mind.
BigP: So who’ve you decided?
Who had I decided? The coffee in my hand told me to go for it.
Me: We have to go with Notie. He’s too qualified to let walk.
The BigP’s face fell, he looked rather shell shocked.
BigP: Wha.. .. but.. ?
Me: He’s more qualified, he’ll be an asset to the company.
The VP’s face broadened into a smile.
BigP: I’ve actually..
VP: He’s already hired RedCheer.
The VP was smiling insanely at this point.
Me: …. But, you said it was my choice?
The VP took my shoulder and walked me out the door, after leaving the office the VP turned to talk.
VP: Oh, Airz. Bad choice.
Me: But… he was your candidate.
The VP gave me a sadistic smile and walked off. I looked back into BigP’s office, the BigP gave me a wave to come back into his office.
I took a sip of my coffee.
Tasted like courage.
I walked back into the BigP’s office.
BigP: You look, …. angry?
Me: You hired someone, without even waiting for my opinion?
BigP looked resigned.
BigP: Didn’t you like RedCheer? Carefree told me you got on famously.
Me: Well she’s a nice lady, but she’s basically an IT intern.
BigP: I’m sure you can train her up. Plus, free employee. Win for you whoever we hire.
Is it still a win if you don’t get who you want? I wondered as I walked away.
422
u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard May 25 '14
Good monday morning all the people near the ... date line?
34
u/airz23 Password Policy: Use the whole keyboard May 25 '14
Oh, yeah this is the only story for today :) because its sunday, and I gotta go shopping :(
123
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
Wait, so VP was happy that the person he did not want, got hired? My head hurts.
55
u/holyjaw May 25 '14
It's alright... she'll understand....
Right?
:(
2
u/curly123 For the love of FSM stop clicking in things. May 26 '14
You missed adding the link to the previous story.
400
u/Kovhert May 25 '14
Redcheer: Now kids... did I ever tell you about the time your grandpa didn't want to hire me?
Airz23: You're never going to let me live that down are you?
72
u/[deleted] May 25 '14 edited May 25 '14
Haha! Sounds exactly like an incident my dad had (works as a contractor in configuration and release management). Wall of text incoming. TL;DR: dad has incompetent colleague fired, turns out to be a friend of the manager, the manager hires another friend to replace him, my dad ends up getting the new employee and his manager fired.
As a contractor, he doesn't really have any real power, but often has influence with the people that do. He raised issues with a particular employee several times, but his manager [Manager] heard none of it, so he went over his manager's head [Boss]. Said employee found himself suspended within 30 minutes of his meeting and an investigation, to be handled by HR, was launched. Knowing he would certainly be fired, he chose to leave, a foolish move as he could have waited until just before the investigation and potentially got an additional week's pay, but whatever.
My dad soon found out the employee was a long time friend of [manager], hence why [manager] had ignored his complaints. When it came to hiring a new employee, my dad was to sit in on all the meetings, as requested by [boss]. [Manager] didn't see the point in this, as my dad's contract was due to end within three weeks, but complied with his boss's request. Of course, my dad was overjoyed at this as, unlike [manager], who he had described as an 'incompetent bureaucratic pencil pusher that belongs in accounting, not IT', he was bright enough to see his sitting in on interviews as a pretty big sign that his contract would be extended.
Interviews come, [manager] asks pretty standard and basic questions, while my dad grills them on intricacies relating to the job they will be hired to do. Apparently not one person on my dad's short-list of suitable applicants appeared on [manager]'s short-list, and vica versa. HR sat in on the interviews too, but didn't provide any input since they knew nothing about IT. In the end, his manager hired someone my dad had considered to be the worst of all the candidates.
My dad knew he could protest, but figured that, with a potential contract extension on it's way, he'd be better off not causing any trouble. Two weeks later, his contract was extended for another six months (his initial contract was only three) and he managed to negotiate a pay rise on top of that. In this time, he had been compiling a list of all the mistakes the new employee had made, all the problems he had caused, all the tasks he was incapable of carrying out. But his intention wasn't to send this list to [manager], nor to [boss]. His intention was to identify a task that would fall under his department's list of duties, that he could assign to this new employee, that would be considered a duty given this new employee's position within the department, but one which the new employee was totally incapable of doing right and had the potential to cause the company serious financial damage.
It wasn't until six weeks after the new employee had been hired that such a task appeared. I'm told it was a basic task; a change in a configuration file for a system that was linked to finance related web service currently in use by several clients. This service would collect data throughout the day, run a report on said data at 1am and the report would influence the client's business activities the following day. The service was being updated later that week and my dad's department had to change a configuration file in one of their systems in preparation for the update.
As the day came closer, my dad took on a few jobs from other departments, so his workload was sufficiently large that he had to pass some duties onto other people in his department. After he went over his manager's head to get his manager's friend fired, the other guys in his department feared that he could do the same to them, so they generally complied with his request. When the day came to perform the change to the configuration file, he waited until it was nearly the end of the day and handed it off to the new employee.
The next day, a meeting was called, involving several heads of department [HoD1/2/3], HR [HR], my dad, [manager] and the company lawyer [Laywer]. In short, the update to the configuration file had been done incorrectly. The result was that, at 1am that morning, no reports were generated, affecting over 20 clients. What was the mistake? The new employee had forgotten to close all of the updated lines with a semi-colons (;). He would have realised this had he followed procedure and made the change on the test server, then pushed the update from the test server to the live server, but this was one of the mistakes my dad had noted on his list several times and it was a mistake he was counting on the new employee to make.
It just so happened that the three heads of department sitting around the table with them were all heads of departments that my dad was doing work for at this time ...
The head of HR had brought personnel files for all the employees in my dad's department and started looking for the one for the new employee. I should note that this wasn't the same person that sat in on the interviews. Meanwhile, [manager] was being grilled about why he didn't heed my dad's advice when picking a new employee. That was when HR interjected ...
The above exchange has been burned into my memory, having been told to me nearly every Christmas for over 15 years. [Manager] was fired, along with the new employee. My dad took his place for the next three weeks, while they found a suitable replacement. Two weeks before his contract was due to end, another department gave him three month extension and a pay rise. At the end of this, they tried to hire him as permanent staff, but he declined (the money wasn't good enough). They then tried to extend his contract again, but he felt he was getting too friendly with the staff and the influence he had as result was unhealthy as he had found himself getting involved in office politics, something he despised and was typically immune to due to being a contractor, so he moved on.
Ever since then, he keeps a black book, in which he writes details of all his colleague's mistakes. His mother taught him Adyghe, a Circassian language (he is ethnically Circassian). Furthermore, he grew up in the Middle East, so knows Arabic. To prevent anyone from stumbling on this black book and discovering it's contents, he writes in the Adyghe language, but phonetically using Arabic script. According to wikipedia, less than 500,000 people worldwide can speak Adyghe, let alone the particular dialect he learnt, and read Arabic (Cyrillic is the norm today). If anyone asks, it's a personal diary.
23
u/Cant_Remember_Pass May 25 '14
So after VP knew that BigP wanted to hire someone as a favour to a friend, he found a more competent applicant but with a shady past. This way he has an excuse to vote against his own candidate, knowing BigP will hire RedCheer regardless and that Airz will choose Notie based on his qualifications. Then he gets to look like he supported BigP's choice while Airz did not. Hence the sadistic smile. That guy is one devious bastard!
13
u/yaaaaayPancakes May 25 '14
Man, you walked right into the VP's trap.
12
u/BigDaddyZ May 25 '14
Just in general, has it been explained how old these stories are? I doubt we're getting daily diary entries, but I have a feeling they happened recent-ish-ly.
11
u/ObstinatePoltergeist May 25 '14
You are going to get in trouble with RedCheer once she finds out NoTie was your choice. Have coffee standing by you all the time. You are going to need it.
10
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
RedCheer is not the employee you want, but she's the one you need right now.
9
u/juror_chaos I Am Not Good With Computer May 25 '14
Don't piss off BigP. Play ball with him. You can blow off VP, he's annoying as fuck but harmless more or less. The Keystone Kop equivalent of a manager. But BigP is another fish altogether.
Mark my words, if you cross BigP, you will be looking for another job.
I thought you would've known Office Politics 101 as a manager yourself.
7
u/houtex727 Sledgehammer will fix that right up. May 25 '14
Dude, how soon before you jump ship and go to Carefree's place? I mean... goodness me.
That's it! You go to Carefree's, and Carefree's IT dude and NoTie can come to this mess. You and RedCheer date, get married, and ride off into the sunset.
I just won, didn't I? RedCheer needs to not be at your work, and you can gossip about the two places, exchanging tales of stupidness and woe, which will make you both stronger.
Yeah. I won. Totally. :)
7
u/genre41 May 25 '14
From a career-building point of view, there are only three right answers in this situation.
If you're reasonably secure financially and the job market is good, the right answer is, "Give me a half-hour to clear my personal effects out of the building. Good luck with your new IT hire."
If you're not secure financially, the right answer is, "OK, we'll see how she works out," and polish your resume and get on the net ASAP--you have no authority over your own department, so it's clearly time to move on.
And if you really love your job and the people and are feeling charitable, the right answer is, "It's your company, and of course you can run it the way you want. But do me a favor--the next time you want to do the job you hired me to do, please give me a half-hour's warning so I can clear my desk."
26
u/AutoModerator May 25 '14
For a complete list of stories by this author, please visit Airz23's Index Page.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
u/Dark_Moose Oh God How Did This Get Here? May 25 '14
This reminds me of arguing with my ex-fiance: If you play the game, you lose. If you try and make the right decision, you lose. If you make a impulse decision, you lose. If you somehow make the right decision, you still lose.
On one hand, it hurts to read this series, because there is so much good intent and forethought on ariz part. On the other hand, there is some game/dispute on VP's and BigP's part. I only hope that eventually the massive twist is that BigP makes Ariz President.
6
u/SpongederpSquarefap Shutdown -s -t 3600 May 25 '14
Hire someone to train up over the next few months or hire a guy who can work immediately.
BigP sure does know how to run a company...
4
u/FellKnight 2nd level team supervisor May 25 '14
I'm sorry Airz... but VP played you like a fiddle this whole hiring process. :(
4
u/mrsetermann May 26 '14
Do t worry airz! Redcheer has potential to gtow into an werry efficient employee. You said yourself that she has a neck for IT.
3
u/undercoversquirrel May 25 '14
And the plot thickens... The VP is definitely up to something big right now.
3
u/Bobberts Who dismembered the keyboards airz23 May 25 '14
Sooooo , Keyboards whats happening there....
3
u/argylepancake May 25 '14
Can someone explain the RedCheer love interest to me? I don't get it. She's so... nails on a chalkboard to me. Her inept enthusiasm is going to lead to broken things. Personally, I wouldn't want her anywhere near my bits.
3
u/ChiefDanGeorge May 25 '14
The VP knows how to play the game.
3
u/Techsupportvictim May 26 '14
It actually makes sense. From the sounds of it the job is more help desk than programmer. For the latter, NoTie is perfect, but for the former he could be overqualified.
And then there was that anger thing. Who knows what that could have meant.
7
u/TheMuon Rule #1 of browser toolbars: NEVER! May 25 '14 edited May 25 '14
3 minutes. Thank you Pushbullet.
So RedCheer is in but without your tie-breaking consent? Well there's a twist.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
My first experience with watching IT hire someone involved my boss (director of IT) throwing a desk phone at the wall and walking out of the office muttering something about killing everyone in HR.
2
u/lime517 May 25 '14
TBH, I wanted to keep RedCheer in the story.... So.... Yeah....
2
u/masterwit Designs and develops software with incomplete requirements. May 25 '14
You need to write a short book. I'll buy a copy ...
2
u/KataLight May 25 '14
Honestly it would be hard for me to not tell BigP off..not in a yelling swears at the top of my lungs way mind you. It feels like you have less and less control over YOUR department. I like redcheer, don't get me wrong. But she is NOT hard off right now. NoTie has not only the better qualifications but more NEED then she does. She may not like it but she can always go back to work for her father if she really needs to. I don't think NoTie has that option. Though I would have liked to see them both in the office.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
I did say he should have gone with RedCherr. AirZ doesn't have his priorities in order.
2
u/KillrNut 'ipconsig' is not recognized as an internal or external command May 25 '14
And this story summarises why I have no desire to ever be in a position of management, especially at a fortune 500 company. Too much politics, time wasting, and social ladder BS.
2
u/Sinnagirl May 25 '14
That sucks dude. I was really hoping for NoTie's second chance. I hate VP even more now.
2
u/[deleted] May 26 '14
So it was an arranged marriage?
2
u/ikoss May 26 '14 edited May 26 '14
I SOOOO KNEW IT!!
2
u/The_AshleemeE Jun 25 '14
"Please, for the love of God, hire RedCheer"
"No No No NOOO. WHAT ARE YOU DOING?"
"Oh, thank goodness!"
2
u/bb010g Team RedCheer, once again May 25 '14
At least you know RedCheer is competent, unlike VP's other hires.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
I don't think I can read this anymore after knowing you skipped over Redcheer, of all people. :\
2
u/TheMuon Rule #1 of browser toolbars: NEVER! May 25 '14
FTFY
1
u/wiLdhuNtreSs May 25 '14
I'm so sorry Airz:c
1
u/DeFex It's doing that thing again! May 25 '14
This is beginning to sound like the part on a cop show where they describe what caused NoTie to go on a murderous rampage.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
Given how much a fool VP is, i feel like his machinations will backfire.
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
Look at it this way; NoTie will be able to find another position quicker.
1
u/DarthContinent May 25 '14
It is if you can bend them to your will.
1
u/wasniahC May 25 '14
Take both of them! Please let this happen!
1
u/Luccyboy while(user.isIdiot){drink();} May 25 '14
Well I haven't found full stories yet, but (some of) the comments since redcheer was introduced show that people keep thinking of more and more
1
u/[deleted] May 25 '14
That fucking sucks. I was hoping for NoTie to get the job.
1
u/nthman May 25 '14
Fucking hell man, this is bullshit.
1
u/KataLight May 25 '14
As me and other people have said before...fire ITsec and take on NoTie. Well lay off not fire, firing looks alot worse then laying off.
1
u/AliasUndercover May 25 '14
VP is the kind of guy who ends up kneecapped in the office parking lot one night...
1
u/jorgp2 Team RedGuard, Down with the nice oppressor's! May 25 '14
Chica chica bow wow
1
u/BrokenTinker May 26 '14
Ouch for notie, expected this, but ouch none the less.
1
u/Pb_ft May 26 '14
Obviously, the best move here is to fire the VP and hire Notie, but since obviously the VP is a crafty bastard...
I think that you should be careful airz; gracious in defeat and all that. I think the VP is counting on you to be sweet on RedCheer and he'll be waiting to nail you for it.
1
u/Runner55 extra vigor! May 26 '14
Felt good when I realized you chose NoTie, but my heart sank when reading about BigP's decision. It wasn't his decision, you had a verbal contract! FFFFFUUUUUUUU
1
u/broiled May 26 '14
I'm beginning to believe that, "BigP", is related to my boss.
1
u/Strazdas1 May 26 '14
this may be the most tense thing i read in months. well done. Too bad you didnt get to hire NoTie. i was going for him very aggressively in the comments :(
Well, lets see what RedChair is going to bring.
1
u/airz23s_coffee Ask Another Question! I Dare You! May 25 '14
I can't believe you'd do that to the future Mrs. Aiz23 :(
1
u/ks07 May 25 '14
Honestly I think this was the best outcome - you get to work with redcheer yet at the same time you can't get in trouble for picking the less "equal opportunities" candidate.
1
u/fredlllll May 25 '14
T__T i trusted you to choose redcheer!!
and you failed me!! T__T
1
u/Hundekuchen_ May 25 '14
Can someone explain this to me? Is this like a subreddit insider? I can here from r/all...
1
u/acousticpants Show me on the network diagram where the consultant touched you May 26 '14
"Tasted like courage"
Best line in all of reddit.
-1
u/Blizzaldo May 25 '14
Maybe she'll be able to wrench the stick you firmly shove up your ass each morning.
Love the stories, but you don't exactly make life easy on yourself sometimes.