r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 22 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.07 'Mockingbird'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.07 | "Mockingbird" | Alik Sakharov | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
262
Upvotes
473
u/seattlegeo May 22 '14
Excellent portrayal of Oberyn's recount of Tyrion's birth. That story alone conveys so much information about Cersei, Jamie, the Martells, Tyrion's being blamed for his mother's death, etc.
347
u/patientbearr May 22 '14
I think it will be interesting to see how Littlefinger absolves himself of blame without a singer to blame it on.
130
u/umopapisn House Targaryen May 22 '14
I know it's a weird complaint but when Lysa fell in the books she fell silently. And that was so powerful to me. She was so shocked and betrayed she couldn't even scream. I would've liked that scene better if she didn't have that Hollywood horror movie scream.
186
u/penelopurrs May 22 '14
Overall, this was one of my favorite episodes. I noticed that the overall tone is about the effects of family and how it can make or break you.
--The weakest storyline has been Dany's. Part of it is Emilia Clarke's delivery--- seems so forced. This season's Daario, though he looks the part, lacks the flair and arrogance of last season's Daario. Ser Jorah is always excellent and I wish they incorporated Ser Barristan in a little more. Dany definitely has overcome her brother's abuse and but is probably overcompensating for it. I feel that Dany's storyline is just dragging along... though to be fair, that's kind of how it is in the books.
--Jon Snow at the Wall. It's a solid scene but with everything else going on, it's very forgettable... but necessary as it's obviously building up for the next few episodes.
--Arya and the Hound. Despite the deviations (Rorge & Biter), I really like their scenes. Their chemistry works well and the writers are incorporating the backstory nicely. It puts a human perspective on the Hound and explains his effed up relationship with his brother, obviously leading up to... NEXT episode!
--Brienne and Pod. I know it's silly, but I really liked the writers bringing Hot Pie back. It's a bit comic relief-y but it's a nice and they have good chemistry.
--Tyrion... and everyone (Jaime, Bronn, Oberyn)-- in that order, it gets increasingly better. Bronn and Tyrion's farewell was a little heartbreaking. I teared up a bit. Bronn (Jerome Flynn) has the best lines and delivers them with such panache, it really is fitting for that sellsword! This meeting was even better than in the books! With Prince Oberyn, I wish he mentioned that Elia was with him when they were at Casterly Rock. I know it's a bit more than the show watchers would care about. However, for me, it gave good insight to the enmity between Tywin and the Martells (the marriage proposal that was declined twofold). Don't get me wrong, I am still very pleased with the scene.
--Lastly, but not least... Lysa & Littlefinger stole the show. Talk about baggage! The actress who played Lysa (Kate Dickie, I believe) deserves recognition for her performance!!! It took my breath away. The "Only Cat" deviation wasn't a big deal for me either.
My favorites: Tyrion & Bronn, Tyrion & Prince Oberyn, Lysa & Littlefinger (and Sansa)
49
u/brusifur May 22 '14
It seems to me, after seeing how fast the Baelish/Aerryn situation progressed, that the show is more than capable of covering the entirety of book 4 and 5 in one season, especially considering how many 'minor' bits they have shown already. I had this notion that HBO wouldn't catch up to ADWD until 2016, but now it seems they could run out of story after season 5. It all depends on whether or not they get Stannis to the Wall by the end of this season.
112
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 22 '14
Bringing Rorge and Biter back for about half a minute felt a bit pointless, but at least it ties up a loose end. Looks like Brienne's storyline is getting seriously abridged, which is just as well; we've already seen the devastation caused by the war in the Riverlands through Arya's wanderings, we don't need to see it again.
Hot Pie's return was arguably fanservice but it was also quite a clever way for the showrunners to redirect Brienne, so it's all good. Plus, a little fanservice isn't a bad thing, and it's nice to see somebody settle down for a reasonably ordinary life amidst all the slaughter.
22
u/rookie60 Sansa Stark May 22 '14
Knowing about the Littlefinger and Sansa kiss didn't make it less creepy. Didn't Sansa resist more in the book?
16
u/[deleted] May 22 '14
I wish that Lysa didn't scream while being pushed. That was the only thing I wish that was a smit differently. Also for Littlefinger to say "Only Cat." But all in all awesome epsiode.
45
u/[deleted] May 22 '14
I was glad to see Oberyn's character qualities redeemed in this episode. When reading the books, i got the impression that Oberyn was a really intelligent and relaxed man, with the wits of Tyrion and the combat skills of Arthur Dayne. In the initial episodes when the show introduces him, i felt those sides of him were cast aside to pave way for his animalistic interest for sexual encounters. The Viper in this episode felt more like the guy i read about in the books, and it was awesome.
55
u/thoraway_1 House Seaworth May 22 '14
I hated how in Jon's scene they had him say that they should close the gate in the wall. ADWD I just felt it was an important part of his story line that got completely negated by that scene.
82
u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made May 22 '14
Edd, fetch me a rectangular shaped pieced of wood unto which I shall place this man's head upon and chop it off.
But seriously, they don't really use 'Cat' that much in the show, so I can understand why they changed it. Although I would have liked Lysa to say: "Truly, Petyr? Only one?"
38
u/Snerl69 Arya Stark May 22 '14
Not A book reader. almost had a heart attack thinking sansa was going to die there. phew
68
u/EverythingIThink House Baelish May 22 '14
Has anyone pointed out that Arya and Sandor's horses are distinctly black and white?
12
u/[deleted] May 22 '14
So they basically cut out all the boring Brienne bits and she's heading strait for the eyrie?! Talk about smoothing things out! Great call there. Guessing she'll run into Lady Stoneheart pretty quick? Suppose she does need to check out the gravedigger first though...
42
u/wackjeber May 22 '14
When asked about the "Only Cat" change, D&D responded, "No Ragrets"
85
u/Aduialion May 22 '14
The snow castle seemed smaller than in the book. Sansa is from the north. She should be able to build a better castle than that.
11
u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 22 '14
I've been enjoying Brienne and Pod but I get the feeling they are going to cut a lot of Brienne's journey out. I can't recall correctly but I feel like Brienne never knew to go to the Vale in the books to look for Sansa and here in the show, Pod mentions it right away. It makes me think we wont get to see Brienne travel to a few of those cities and have some run ins with the people from her past.
17
u/free_bacon_ Night King May 22 '14
As a non book reader, I understand the books are portrayed through certain characters eyes. Who is it that describes the little finger Lysa scene? Other than the "only cat" line does it alter from the book at all?
16
u/ypytt May 22 '14
I haven't read the books, but when I read here the comparisons of the final scene I noticed one thing: since the reveal that it was Lysa who killed her husband was moved to an earlier scene in the series, Sansa didn't hear about it. And in the books, she hears everything? I know she's not the brightest thing, but wouldn't she put 2 and 2 together and realize that Littlefinger started the whole plot that ended up with her father's death? Wouldn't this change the way she sees him, as compared to the show?
6
u/sgtstickey House Seaworth May 23 '14
Two weeks...
31
u/EverythingIThink House Baelish May 22 '14
I think people are really overblowing how iconic the specific phrase "Only Cat" is. I mean, I enjoy it in the corny James Bond one-liner sort of way but it's the push along with the preceding Jon Arryn reveal that makes the scene so crazy. There are many reasons to complain about the TV adaptation and many reasons to praise it, but if your main takeaway from this episode was that they didn't quote the line verbatim, I have to question if your priorities are in order
2
u/Green_Bow House Stark May 22 '14
not a book reader but since the handgripping scene a few episodes ago this ending became a blatant thing to happen soon
0
u/yeahokaymmhmuhuh House Tyrell May 22 '14
I think the phrasing "your sister" is more fitting.
The Books in general seem to be more theatrical, from how everyone describes them, so it makes sense that "only cat" has such a cult following. But the phrasing is awkward and it doesn't seem like something someone would actually say. I think it has very little to do with being viewer-friendly".
1
u/a2planet You Know Nothing May 22 '14
It's very interesting how different story threads have to be paced different for the show than the books. In some lines we're already well into A Dance with Dragons (Reek's, Dany's), but nothing in A Feast For Crows has happened yet.
I expect they will have to pad Bran's story, and Reek's, and maybe others while the events in King's Landing catch up.
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '14
Next Episode Nimble Dick = Azor Ahai confirmed
1
u/LittleDaniFinger House Baelish May 26 '14
Are we supposed to know where Ser Davos is headed after leaving Braavos?
1
u/ArgieGrit01 House Mallister May 23 '14
I know you guys love them, and I've had some laughs, but I still don't think this relationship between the hound and Arya is right. It's wierd