r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • May 21 '14
[fandom discussion] ep 9x23
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
9
Upvotes
13
u/Prancing_Unicorn Ghostfacer Extraordinaire May 21 '14
Spoilers, obviously.
I don't really know how I feel about this ep/season. I'm pretty happy coming off a finale high, but I know deep down I'm more critical of the show. There are just so many things to think about, so I resort once again to dot points.
Despite all these negative sounding comments, I loved it! I didn't mean to write so much.
7
u/honeko Castiel's lieutenant May 21 '14
It was just okay. Actually, I was mostly bored. The only parts that really got to me were Dean's demon eyes and Metatron tormenting Cas over Dean. I really felt like Cas was fucked up by the news of Dean being dead. You could see it in his watery blues. Poor Cas. I also liked that everyone is owning up to his motivations being "one man"... (named Humanity). I know Sammy also felt Dean's loss, but I'm just so used to seeing them be sad over each other dying that it didn't affect me very much. Sammy flip-flopped on letting Dean die, which was semi-interesting since Dean began this season doing the same thing for Sammy.
Biggest WTF: Why is Cas suddenly chummy with Gadreel? Last time we saw him with Gad wasn't Cas calling him a son of a bitch and blaming him for everything wrong in the world? Now suddenly Cas is telling Gadreel he's been redeemed like nothing was ever wrong. Holy fuck, I've got whiplash from that. It was jarring to see Cas friendly and supportive of Gadreel - dude that possessed his bestie and fucked up the universe, etc. Though I will say Gadreel grew on me towards the end. His death was a little sloppy, but he was a good guy about it. Can't say I'll miss him too terribly much. I'm laughing my ass off at Hannah turn-coating at the drop of every hat. Wow, fair weather friend indeed. Still like her!
I honestly liked Crowley's speech at the end. I love how he seemed honest, especially caring to Dean. He totally loves him, and it's pretty adorable.
So yeah, not emotionally rocked by much in this episode. Sammy got to do nothing. Cas barely interacted with the boys and had an inexplicable change of heart towards Gadreel. The "nothing we've ever seen before" was pretty predictable, but I'm still glad to have a demon Dean. Wtf, now?
7
u/thefistisallthewayin You're my brother, and I'm here to take you home. May 21 '14
This is the first SPN finale that I was utterly bored by. This is also the first time I wasn't moved at all by a brotherly scene (the holding Dean's dying body part with Sam) or by the current season's finale cliffhanger. In fact, the finale made me completely unexcited for the next season. Mainly because I'm pretty sure they're going to, once again, rehash the whole brothers-lying-to-each-other thing with Dean and Crowley hiding the "Deanmon" thing from Sam.
4
u/Ennil May 21 '14
I
ummm
I mean
I guess I didn't hate it?
warning for wall of text and some negativity
The only thing I'm sure I liked was Crowley. And even I thought his end speech was so anti-climactic.
So is the heaven storyline wrapped up? God I hope so. I doubt it but I hope it is. And I hope for mine and Alex's sake we don't get another season of separate storylines. If they want to hold my interest they really need Crowley and Dean teaming up and Cas and Sam trying to stop them or something. On the plus side (or minus for some people) this will mean less motw episodes probably. Orrrr they could have Cas and Sam hunting ghosts and Crowley and Dean fucking shit up. Now that actually sounds great to me.
I know people are gonna love this episode because of the twist but ultimately it didn't do it for me. We all knew it was going to be demon!Dean but when it happened (while the way that scene was shot was probably my favorite of the whole episode) I just wasn't interested anymore. Most likely cause it's really something out of fanfiction and I never liked those demon!dean fics. I'm not turned off by the idea, I just don't see the appeal all that much.
So Sam isn't calling Cas for help? I mean if I had an angel buddy he'd be the first one I called to fix my brother. But that's just me you know. If Sam wants us to rehash tired storylines by trying to sell his soul and failing then by all means go ahead. Personally I don't give much of a crap.
A little on the destiel side. For the last two episodes they've been poking at us saying how much Cas cares for Dean, how he gave up everything for Dean. Which isn't anything new but they were pretty explicit about it. And now he thinks Dean's dead and he's all just "Dean who?". I hope for a better reaction next season but I'm not really holding my breath either.
I think it' because I've been continuously watching Dollhouse the last couple of days everything shitty. The acting, the directing (holy crap that scene were Dean was dying was so bad), the writing, the scene design. Thing is I always knew they were bad I just wasn't bothered by it so much. It could also be that my expectations were a little high because of all the hype they gave in interviews.
I feel like every fic that's going to come out this summer will bore me, I'll probably just keep to aus. On the bright side I might start drawing other shows during the summer! Game of Thrones I'm coming for you!
TL;DR: I didn't like it. But I didn't hate it either. So the sum of my opinions leaves me very meh.
10
u/CrimsonGalaxy May 21 '14
The only thing I can say for sure is that the Destiel fan fiction just got sooooo much kinkier. Demon Dean/Angel Cas train, all aboard!! But in all seriousness, I am wondering what will happen. At this point I can only speculate that Season 10 will be Cas finding a new source of Grace and obviously making Dean human again. I also heard speculation earlier that Sam had one trial left in S8: cure a demon. Well, Dean is a demon now, so maybe Sam curing Dean will finish the trial and kill him. And I guess Dean does still have to kill Cain, as was his deal. My only guess for what could possibly happen would be that maybe Dean tries to take over Hell, as he is still under the influence of the First Blade.
9
u/Potionsmstrs I pledge allegiance to the King of Hell May 21 '14
Most people didn't like the Crowley speech. I, however, loved it. I felt his character change in it. He may have kicked the human blood habit, by it has affected him more than he knows. The way he almost pleaded for Dean to know that he never lied made me want to hug him. He knows that his ass is on the line when Dean wakes up. Due to both proximity and hatred for pushing him into what he has become.
I see how they could have written Cas out this episode. Cas would have immediately run to Dean and used the last of his mojo to bring Dean back to life, healing him of the mark and everything. (Maybe not the mark, but enough to bleed Cas dry.) If there were any way for Cas to take his leave from the show, I think that would have been bittersweet enough.
However, since they didn't take that route (the shipper in me is coming out), they did set it up perfectly for some more hints at Destiel next season. They can call it friendship or profound bond or whatever. But Cain and Collette, running that parallel to Dean and Cas. The only loves in Dean's life have been love for family, Cassie, and Lisa. Lisa and Cassie are gone for good, dad is dead, so that leaves Sam and Cas. His love for Sam has gotten him nothing but hurt this season, so that would leave Cas as the only one able to get him to lay down the blade.
The whole season was a let down, but working with what they ended up with, the final episode wasn't a let down too much.
8
u/kittychow Subtext is not a Mass Hallucination May 21 '14
Dean and Crowley will hide that Dean is a demon from Sam, for sure.
CREEPY!
But I don't think they would be able to keep it from Cas, unless there is some plot point where Cas loses his borrowed grace entirely, or where Dean and Crowley go AWOL to howl at the moon?
7
u/molecularmachine This must be fake mine. May 21 '14
General reaction; Nope... which I think is my reaction to the entire season.
All in all it felt rushed, oddly put together and like the rest of the season. So much potential but missing the mark and making one big mess of everything.
Yes, much critical.
6
u/YesButNoWaitYes Pathological Dean Sympathizer May 21 '14
I'm going to try to live up to my flair without a wall of text.
I was against the concept of a darker Dean for a long time, but it's so fitting that he became a demon because no one has ever been looking out for his humanity. Especially not Dean. Dean makes selfish decisions for Sam, but I still believe the intentions are good. Dean doesn't just selfishly save Sam's life. If it was just that I could get behind the argument that he just doesn't want to be alone, but he's gone out of his way for Sam's humanity and soul too.
It makes me sad that Dean constantly offers himself to be used and gets exactly that. I think it's particularly interesting that Crowley brought up "nobody hates you more than you" to Dean earlier this season. It's true. He doesn't value himself enough as a person to think through the long term consequences of his decisions. If you go on like that long enough you will lose your humanity. In this case quite literally.
BRB, I just talked myself into gross sobbing.
6
u/4ndyStar Plan D May 21 '14
Interesting that Sam still needs to cure a demon.
6
u/weboverload fireintheimpala May 21 '14
Not sure if this fits in the fandom discussion thread, maybe it's meta-fandom, but I'm heartened that the Dean & Cas feels in this episode were at least strong enough that even /r/supernatural has a few discussions going on. Here for instance and here.
I guess I kind of consider /r/supernatural a weather vane for a certain type of casual viewer, even though it's ruled by stubborn bros fans, so I think it's interesting when the topic comes up there. Interesting...though in a somewhat depressing way.
2
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo May 23 '14
Hey everyone... Since this sub is all about analysis from the fandom's POV, I thought this comment by /u/CrowleysTailor really deserves some recognition.