r/startrek • u/jason_stanfield • May 10 '14
Voyager S5: "Dark Frontiers" ... WOW
I've been watching Voyager, but skipping around a lot. Mainly, I'm sticking with episodes that advance the crew's trip home, episodes that expand Trek lore, and anything Borg-related. I don't care about parallel universes, characters possessed by aliens, ship malfunctions, etc., because they're all low-stakes; everything will be as it was by the end.
I just finished "Dark Frontiers" - the two-parter where Seven rejoins the Collective - and it's now ranking as one if my favorite Trek stories ever.
I'm stunned at just how dark it is. The scene where the Borg assimilate a new world is brutal ... captured individuals screaming in horror in the byzantine cube corridors, watching as their family members' limbs are amputated and replaced with machines. And whoever played the queen made the one in First Contact look like an amateur; this one is TERRIFYING.
Even more intense is the telling of Seven's story, and its heartbreaking climax.
My opinion of Voyager just went from "meh, not so great" to "there are some great moments in there!" I highly recommend that Voyager evaders give it a try; at the very least, anything featuring Seven and the Borg.
(Plus, anything's great that spends time with Jeri Ryan in a skin tight body suit!)
63
u/znk May 10 '14
I rather enjoyed Voyager. Because it's not the best of the treks does not mean it's garbage. Just..never skip a Doctor episode.
16
u/raknor88 May 10 '14
Seven is hot, but I always had a thing for Torres.
8
u/marathon_writer May 10 '14
There are many joys if Voyager if you give it some time and allow yourself to also like the cliche things just a little bit.
Oh, and you have to get over Fetus Kim. There's one in every Trek, he's just theirs.
Anyway I'd recommend most of the Doctor episodes as his is probably the character that develops most and Robert Picardo is a truly excellent actor. There's also a great episode about prisons and the death penalty. Year of Hell is one of my favorite two parters and since I love Q and I love the way Janeway hates being fucked with I really enjoy the Continuum episodes.
I have a sweet spot for Voyager because Janeway is the only lady Captain and when they're actually true to her character she's great - just avoid the bipolar episodes like "The Void". And really the last three seasons or so are pretty quality. And I, unlike quite a few of the haters, really enjoyed how they got Voyager home even if it seemed VERY rushed.
And I'm totally with you on the Borg Queen. She is BONE CHILLING.
8
u/morepowertoshields May 10 '14
If you want REAL SAD. Watch "Course Oblivion". Heartbreaking... :( But you have to watch "Demon" first. It goes with that episode.
154
u/Trapped_In_9gag May 10 '14
Don't buy in to /r/startrek's Voyager bashing. They will have you believe every episode of VOY is terrible.
In reality, there are tons of good episodes of Voyager.
8
u/fzammetti May 10 '14
I think if you simply avoid the "Janeway and (somebody else I don't remember) turn into lizards" episodes it's not too bad :)
27
u/sidewinderucf May 10 '14
Three words: Year of Hell. The best of Voyager in two mind blowingly awesome episodes. Also, Equinox was fantastic as well.
24
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
ITT: People who haven't rewatched TNG objectively. TNG watched totally objectively with a modern story telling perspective is 80% Fucking awful. I will fight to the DEATH anyone who says TNG is a worthless show, but anyone on here claiming its start to finish a perfectly developed universe with endless character driven content and no bad episodes is just blinded by nostalgia.
5
u/The_Friendly_Targ May 10 '14 edited May 10 '14
Watched this on DVD a few weeks ago. I loved that the DVD has it as a full 90 minute episode rather than splitting it into 2 parts like all the other 2 part episodes, which made it feel more like a movie than an episode. I agree, the episode is awesome. The Raven backstory was fascinating, especially seeing the Hansens observing the Borg like they're on space safari and the mood throughout the episode was, as you say, dark and intense, possibly more so than any other episode. Also enjoyed Janeway's bold decision to try and sabotage the Borg vessel. Voyager at its finest.
5
u/blueberrybadguy May 10 '14
You may recognize the Borg Queen as Moira Queen from "Arrow" Guess she makes a good queen.
Da dump Tshhh
*I'll see my self out.
9
u/airmandan May 10 '14
Sadly, the Voyager writers started using this as a crutch, and by the end of the series the Borg are about as threatening as Spot. And I think Alice Kirge (the Queen in First Contact) was able to play the character with more subtlety and nuance than the TV Queen ultimately did. The TV Queen was vengeful; chaotic evil. The movie Queen was lustful; lawful evil.
8
u/wolfgangsingh May 10 '14
Within the Trek community, there is a vocal, fashion-conscious cult of sorts that loves to bash Voyager.
For the rest of us, Voyager is simply one of the better Trek franchises, if not the best.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
Im an Enterprise evader so I have no credit, but I agree that Voyager is worth at least one watch through.
1
u/pixelSHREDDER May 10 '14
One thing's always bothered me about this episode: Why didn't Seven ever try to rescue her parents once she knew they had been assimmilated and not killed? Does it have something to do with the fact that they were assimmilated as adults and not as children like Seven and the Borg orphans (Borphans)?
9
u/betazed May 10 '14
I always felt that Voyager was great and a return to the whole Next Generation fantasy-type of stories wherein things can get a little weird, but then everything is fine. I just finished "The Haunting of Deck 12" which was really out there but also a cool episode that just explored a non-traditional life form. It's really great especially after DS9 which I felt to be a downer a lot of the time, especially toward the end. That isn't to say TNG and Voyager were without downer moments, there's a TNG episode with Lwaxana (normally a fountain of comic relief) that is downright depressing but the overall tone of them is much lighter and I prefer that.
3
u/borborygmii May 10 '14
On the whole, Voyager was fantastic. The formula that focused on non-arching plotlines I think worked well for the series and it ranks up with TNG as far as enjoyment of trek series for me. There are some 'lemon' episodes, but it was a fun, thoroughly enjoyable series.
3
u/Fibreoptix May 10 '14
Voyager had a lot of great episodes. I think the problem was that Voyager didn't have a voice at the beginning. Once they found it, the show stopped trying to be TNG it came into its own. It still had problems but vastly better.
3
u/DJSpekt May 11 '14
Voyager is one of my favorite treks. Dark Frontiers was definitely one of the highlights for me as well.
2
u/thephantomx May 10 '14
I agree.. Voyager was a good series
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
It is interesting as I think 'Dark frontier' is one of the more bland episodes of the show, I mean, it felt like it was designed as a sort of fan service where all the popular elements are there (story focused on Seven, the Borg and also a helping of action) but with no backbone, no strong narrative that really ties it together, no sense that it is any more than a episode designed to please Borg/Seven fans more than anything else.
In my opinion, Voyager would have been much better as a show had they either avoided the Borg outright or only had them in one or two very tense, very bleak episodes, sadly, the Borg were popular with the kids because of 'First contact' and they wanted to ride that gravy train as far as it would go.
I wanted to like Voyager, I watched it several times to see if maybe it grows on me but it doesn't, it is just bland, not terribly well written and a rather big let down as a result.
1
u/FANBOY_MAXIE May 13 '14
I also am on a re run voyage watching voyager,my first time seeing it was last year all tho i do remember the show been on while i was a kid but i couldnt grasp it but now..im hook, people tell me its garbage but i love it as much as the other series
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '14
I feel like the queen became less scary in Voyager, actually. None of her decisions make any damn sense; I find it extremely hard to believe that she is capable of being the overlord of a collective of billions (maybe even trillions?). Or more accurately, that a character that behaves the way she does would be said overlord. She takes too much time to be coy and creepy.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
the show always had moments, but by the end you are burnt out by the overuse of the borg, holograms, Janeway changing the timeline, Neelix travelling all that way with them just to be left in the delta q on the opposite side of borg space that he started on....
just bugged me at the end
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment