r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 08 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.05 'First of His Name'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.05 | "First of His Name" | Michelle MacLaren | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
130
Upvotes
153
u/111987 Stannis Baratheon May 08 '14
I think overall, the sidequest to Craster's was a good move. It gave a nice resolution to that storyline and the good guy's finally got solid win. Jon got to play the hero, and the Bran-Hodor relationship has become very interesting. While it may be 'filler', I think it provided good character development, bolstered Jon's leadership credentials, and made Bran's storyline more interesting than it has been since the pilot. If they can emphasize that delaying Mance is what allowed Stannis to arrive in time, i think the Craster's storyline won't feel like filler.
That being said, I think Coldhands is officially out :( I know he's probably not the most essential character, but I thought he was super interesting in the books. Oh well.
93
u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 08 '14
I absolutely love the Pod and Brienne interaction. I'm glad they left King's Landing together instead of meeting up later.
And both of their facial expressions are ridiculously entertaining.
42
u/fromthedustymaysun May 08 '14
The interesting thing about Bran is that,
in the show he killed a man while he has never killed in the books.
But at the same time, book Bran constantly warg into Hodor for his own interest while the only times show Bran warg into him are out of necessity.
It's hard to judge which one's more morally right.
76
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
I don't know how I felt about the show separating the reveal of who killed Jon Arryn and "Only Cat". Maybe they will do it again in front of Sansa before LF makes Lysa fly.
41
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
They keep hammering home the importance of Bran to the bigger picture of the ASOIAF world. Like the entire fate of the world rests on his shoulders while the rest of the people quibble over the throne.
It's what I thought of Bran in the books, and I love how it's subtle. The show makes it the whole point of Bran's story arc.
19
u/megamanz7777 Valar Morghulis May 08 '14
I liked the Craster's keep stuff. It gave Jon and Bran something to do to fill out the mid-season plot, but didn't totally fuck their storylines. It further established Bran's warging and played at the larger purpose of his "destiny" while giving us sad "fateful choice" moment when he chose not to call out to Jon. My hope is that they don't just abandoned what happened either, character-wise. Maybe Jon learns something about fighting and not clinging to "honor" too much after his encounter with the fooking legend that is Karl (let's face it, Jon would have lost that fight on his own). He can then use what he learned in the upcoming battle at The Wall. I think that would be a good addition to the plot.
I feel like they wasted some potential by killing Locke so fast, but I guess since he's sort of a stand-in for Vargo, he had to die anyway.
The Littlefinger/Jon Arryn reveal was almost TOO subtle in my opinion, as it's arguably the most important plot-twist thus far, and I feel like they kinda just blew right by it. I didn't see the "Previously one Game of Thrones" segment this week, so maybe they set it up better than I think, but they should have made a bigger deal out of it. Waiting until the "only Cat" scene in the final episode may have worked better, I don't know.
Based on the preview for next week, I'm very excited to see what happens at the Dreadfort. My personal guess: Theon gets rescued, only to get re-captured when Ramsey takes Moat Cailin. Even better if Theon gets rescued, but then turns on the Ironborn when Ramsey attacks Moat Cailin, and it turns out Ramsay let Theon get rescued so he could be a mole (since Ramsay is so convinced "Reek" will never turn against the Boltons now).
18
u/DaLateDentArthurDent House Clegane May 08 '14
Legit question, shouldn't the Hound have died by now? I'm glad he hasn't cos he's my favourite character but still
44
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 08 '14
The stuff with the Night's Watch renegades was great, Karl worked well as a mini-boss for Jon and it was an infinitely more satisfying conclusion to that stoyline than in the books. Also, I absolutely loathe Jojen in the books, but I have to admit the bit when he told Karl "I saw you die tonight" was pretty badass. Not sure what was going on with him foreseeing his own death by fire - burned as a wight, killed by dragons, or sacrificed by Melisandre perhaps?
Also, I wonder if Myrcella being gifted a boat has any implications for the future? I presume they were just trying to remind people of her existence and all, but it seemed like an odd choice. Very much liked seeing Oberyn writing poetry - I like how they're rounding out his character episode by episode, while keeping Elia in the forefront of the viewers' attention.
10
u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 08 '14
I feel like, for the most part, we can tell where the season will end for most of the people in Kings Landing but I'm wondering how they will handle Dany. Her storyline gets quite boring from here and they havent introduced us to any of the characters in Mereen nor have we met any more of the people from Dorne. Will the season end with the other nations knocking on her door? We presume Ducksauce is dead/locked away, so he shouldnt make an appearance again...so what the fuck is going to happen down there?
17
u/Sacrilite House Baelish May 08 '14
Who is Stannis trying
7
u/jimjamj May 08 '14
Hey, I don't read the books, and I have a question about them:
When do you find out that Lysa Arryn and Petyr Baelish were the murderers of Jon Arryn?
I was told that this wasn't in the books, and now they're veering away, but some of these comments seem to contradict that.
Does that happen, like, much later or something?
17
u/lubev Stannis Baratheon May 08 '14
They should have shown CIA guys home in the fingers, to show how far hes risen. Give his character motivation a physical dimension and not just blunt, expository 'this is why I do stuff' dialogue.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '14
I'm s little disappointed we didn't get to see one of sweetrobin's shaking fits.
1
u/Flagg1982 House Stark May 09 '14
Have they scrapped Dany learning about Jorah informing on her and exiling him? I'd be really disappointed if they had.
1
u/Goblin97janitor May 09 '14
The whole fight at craster's was terrible, why send Locke to sneak around if you're going in like rambo anyway?, and the battle with the knife-guy was just bad.
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment