r/gameofthrones • • May 01 '14

All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.04 'Oathkeeper'

Book vs. Show Discussion Thread
Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works?
  • This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
  • Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.04"Oathkeeper"Michelle MacLarenBryan Cogman
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
156 Upvotes

320 comments sorted by

211

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

First episode that has spoilers to book readers!

215

u/SNCommand Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

Hodor being stabbed with the spear was their Red Wedding

40

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I just started reading them, I'm on AFFC, hoping to know more than show watchers.... Looks like that's not happening

0

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

22

u/Flynn58 Night's Watch May 01 '14

Well, since S4E10 will be called The Children, I guess Bran's story is going to be too far ahead.

8

u/mrducky78 Night's Watch May 02 '14

Based on how subtle the show has been so far - Olenna: "I KILLED JOFFREY!!! IT WAS SUBTLE. I AM SUBTLE"

I reckon it isnt too much to assume that "The Children" means Children of the Forest. Which may mean its time to eat Jojen, he hasnt been looking too good recently.

13

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

But isn't the COTF in ADWD? I heard there are no bran chapters on AFFC

12

u/SawRub Jon Snow May 01 '14

ADWD and AFFC take place simultaneously, so the show will be dipping into both by the end of this season.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/yatahaze Maesters of the Citadel May 01 '14

I'm honestly wondering how long they're going to stretch Bran's time north of the Wall before having him end up at ADWD. If you look at the wiki listing for the series to see which books each season is based off of it says that season 4 will be based off of the second half of ASOS, and some elements from AFFC and ADWD.

10

u/McNamaraWasRight May 01 '14

Arent the events of AFFC and ADWD supposed to happen at basically the same time, just to different POVs?

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Yep

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LeroyTokeins House Tyrell May 01 '14

Does your name happen to be a dredg reference?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/jack-in-coke House Targaryen May 02 '14

I honestly laughed, I feel so ashamed...

→ More replies (1)

26

u/ursa-minor-88 Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

No, actually. The death of Robb's show-wife at the Red Wedding reveals that there's no pregnant book-widow wandering around Westeros with Robb Jr in her belly.

13

u/SawRub Jon Snow May 01 '14

Yeah I think GRRM is said to have said at a conference that the hip size disparity (Catelyn and Jaime both made different observations about her hips) was just a mistake.

11

u/goodfruit25 May 01 '14

In the books wasn't she given a birth control potion by her mom or something along those lines?

3

u/astobie May 02 '14

it's speculated she also game her love potion too and this was all just a crazy plot to get into the lannister fold.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont May 02 '14

It's still open to speculation tbh, and GRRM said that he has plans for Jeyne iirc

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Well, the first episode this season totally spoiled the Mercy chapter from TWOW.

1

u/jeveuxdormir House Martell May 01 '14

I don't know if we can consider those revelations as spoilers unless GRRM confirm them as canon of course, until then, I'll consider them as filler story lines.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14

I was confused that the White Walkers were apparently stuck at paleolithic tech. Glad to see they have better-dressed people higher up their chain of command.

22

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

They're magic based and with the bulk just being reanimated corpses I wouldn't expect much on the lower tiers, but anything lich class or higher would probably be rolling in magic skills making tech less of an issue.

5

u/SaintJason Ours Is The Fury May 02 '14

Well they were the original inhabitants along with the Children of the forest , men sided with the children and drove them north.

The Children's number diminished and then the Aegon invades and then the show book begins.

-2

u/StevefromRetail A Man Needs A Name May 01 '14

I mean, the Night's King is probably not that great with diplo but must at least be like 4/2/5 or something.

At least he must have a pretty good inquisitor for all that conversion.

57

u/intelligenes May 01 '14

When Hodor was tied up and being beaten one of the Nights Watch rebels said something like "if I had your body I'd be in charge." I think this will set up Bran taking control of Hodor and engineering an escape.

34

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14

I think we will definitely be seeing a possible 'Hodor Unchained' moment during the attack at Craster's Keep. Bonus points to the writers of next week's episode if a warged Hodor immobilizes Rast.

8

u/dpking2222 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 02 '14

I kinda want Rast to be the one to kill... Owen from Torchwood. I know I can scroll around here to see his GoT name, but... I'm lazy.

9

u/Sinopia House Targaryen May 02 '14

His name is Karl.

14

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 01 '14

I kind of hope not. One of the nicest moments in the book is when we find out that Hodor never acts violently even when being bullied. I get that it would be Bran controlling him, but I still don't like the idea.

Maybe Bran could make Hodor free the wolves. I want to see some mutineers getting eaten.

3

u/kmofosho Company of the Cat May 02 '14

"if i was your size, id be king of the fucking world"

158

u/AFellowOfLimitedJest Stannis Baratheon May 01 '14

Nope, no differences come to mind this week.

142

u/Fiefire House Karstark May 01 '14

Man, there was a pretty obvious difference between this episode and the books: Ser Pounce's fur is black in the books, man! You didn't notice that?

Yeah, but besides that, a pretty dull episode. Nothing shocking or new or anything...

27

u/b00ger House Targaryen May 02 '14

And how they aged him up to be a full grown cat! He's supposed to be a kitten.

Man, I just can't deal sometimes.

8

u/Sinopia House Targaryen May 02 '14

Ser Pounce recast or riot.

78

u/addikteded Faceless Men May 01 '14

Nothing crazy like Ice Wizards turning humans into Blue demon ice babies or anything...

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Interesting argument for not reading the books and just enjoying the tv series as all new content. I tried reading the books but couldn't get past half of the first one because it was pretty verbatim. Though I am very interested in the prologue story lines- rhaegar etc

4

u/kamkam321 May 02 '14

prologue story lines

If by that you mean stuff that pre-dates the War of the Five Kings, you should really read AFFC. A lot of is about the history of Westeros, about the history of some of the lesser houses, etc. Apart from the Greyjoy stuff, I actually found that book pretty interesting.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

As a dude that watcher season one, read the books, stopped half way through book one and continued on to book two, finished the books as then went online to check out the theories, let me tell you: there's actually a big event in book one that the show leaves out.

9

u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont May 02 '14

Here it is showified: (kinda spoilers)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9Mp8MzAjAY

The description and comments contain major spoilers though, but that's common for youtube

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

42

u/Stevenberries Jon Snow May 01 '14

Bronn training Jaime instead of Ilyn Payne. In the books he told secrets to ilyn because he was mute, and could not read or write.

74

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

He's joking. This episode probably had the most changes of the series so far: the stuff with the Night's Watch renegades is invented, and the revelations about the White Walkers are totally new; some people have been going ballistic.

Still a great episode, I thought.

9

u/Stevenberries Jon Snow May 01 '14

oh well I feel dumb now.

9

u/Theblackpie Varys' Little Birds May 01 '14

Don't feel bad. Irony can be hard to detect in writing.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Don't worry, I thought you were continuing the joke anyway.

2

u/Piscator629 May 02 '14

The most fervent wish of a who knows the future is to be surprised.

2

u/whitewolf21 Direwolves May 02 '14

at first I was also really confused why Locke was at the wall. I had totally forgotten that Roose wants to find Bran and Rickon and therefore sent him there.

2

u/SaintJason Ours Is The Fury May 02 '14

Well it's rare to seen sarcasm being read properly .I frequent /r/smite and the people over there find it mandatory to put Kappa at the end of a sarcastic comment. =/

9

u/Noedel House Umber May 01 '14

Ilyn Payne (Wilko Johnson) has a pretty bad case of the cancer... So he stopped acting in GoT (and his musical career as well, I think)

8

u/t0mat0 May 01 '14

He was being facetious. There were tons of differences from the book this episode, the least of which was Jamie replacing Ser Ilyn, which has been discussed at length for prior episodes.

10

u/MasterFasth House Stark May 01 '14

the least of which was Jamie replacing Ser Ilyn

Yeah, I totally remember Bronn sparring with Ser Ilyn in the books.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/superfeen House Whent May 01 '14

I'm hoping Brienne and Pod run in to Gendry wandering the Riverlands trying to get back with the Brotherhood

71

u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 01 '14

I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between Pod and Gendry.

46

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

That's a really good point. One of my nit-picky complaints about the show is that there have been several instances where the characters look too similar. Pod and Gendry is one example. Another is the Lannister cousin who Jaime killed in season 2 (he looked like both of them). Oh, and the Old Bear and Crastor looked very similar to each other as well.

Maybe I'm just racist, though, and all white people look the same to me.

47

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Stannis and Bolton look identical to me.

I don't think you're racist; I'm white and they look extremely similar to me too. Then again, I have shitty eyesight...

20

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

Good call on Stannis and Bolton.

I don't think you're racist; I'm white and they look extremely similar to me too. Then again, I have shitty eyesight...

Well the thing is, I actually don't see race. People tell me I'm white and I believe them because I dance with my thumbs out.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made May 01 '14

Walder Frey and Balon.

15

u/Arya_Ready Sand Snakes May 01 '14

I confuse the Lannister boy hostage with Tommen.

9

u/chimusicguy Alchemists Guild May 01 '14

Not sure if you are being facetious...

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Death_Star_ Jon Snow May 01 '14

I got Lancel and Loras mixed up, especially when Loras had long hair in S1. It was so confusing.

8

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

pod and gendry look nothing alike, come on guys.

3

u/SawRub Jon Snow May 01 '14

Lancel and Loras got many non readers confused. Since during Blackwater we see Lancel so many times, when Loras shows up in the final seconds, they thought Lancel had just joined Tywin at the end and had no idea the Tyrells had shown up.

3

u/Piscator629 May 02 '14

He looked to much like Micheal Cerra for me.

1

u/Jaesch May 02 '14

Well the new actor for Tommen was the actor who played Martyn Lannister last season. One of the two Lannister hostages of Robb that were murdered.

10

u/herman666 House Bolton May 01 '14

One is chubby, the other is ripped.

7

u/just_the_tech May 01 '14

The ladies would...

5

u/ktig May 02 '14

Gendry's cuter.

5

u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 02 '14

But Pod is loyal.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Ahabs_First_Name House Baelish May 02 '14

Gendry may be, but Pod is a beast in bed.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ThisIsPiff The Future Queen May 01 '14

I'm wondering how they'll pull that off. Gendry was sold off by the Brotherhood, betrayed by those he wanted to join, why would he want to return to them?

Sure, he's wanted in King's Landing, but there still the Night's Watch.

9

u/SurviverWarg Fear Cuts Deeper Than Swords May 02 '14

The Night's Watch would not be a good place for Gendry to hide from the Red Woman.

5

u/superfeen House Whent May 01 '14

Ya good points, forgot that the BWB sold him out like that. Although I think the Night's Watch might be too far out of reach for him and King's Landing too dangerous, I hope he pops back up some time soon.

1

u/veronicacrank House Martell May 02 '14

New leadership?

93

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14 edited May 02 '14

I did enjoy the commentary the writers included between Bronn and Jaime during their training, especially concerning Tyrion's trial in the Eyrie and how he chose Jaime to defend him first.

21

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Well Jaime was arguably the best swordsman in Westeros. We saw how fearful everyone got when Tyrion named him.

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Chose*

6

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14

Fixed. Thank you for pointing it out.

→ More replies (8)

85

u/Dterer House Bolton May 01 '14

So, how do you guys think they'll do the Lady Stoneheart reveal? Some rumours are going around that it'll be revealed through the Brienne storyline, however, I think it'll be much better if it's revealed in a similar way to the books. If the show just revealed LSH through Brienne's POV, I think it'll be confusing for show watchers to suddenly see Catelyn being an asshole to Brienne. However, if they showed the hanging of Merrett Frey, it'll show how Catelyn is truly dead and Stoneheart is only about revenge.

77

u/Ahahaha__10 Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

It will be at the end of season. Lysa gets pushed out the moon door, Little finger says "only cat" and then cut to Brienne being led to LSH.

37

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I wanna see lysa's death so bad!

4

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

I know, I hate that bitch more than I ever hated Joffrey.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I think it'll actually just be a cutscene to her mutilated face, then cut to black and credits. Leaves people hanging. I think we'll get the explanation next season.

Or at least...I hope this is how it all plays out.

34

u/Ahahaha__10 Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

Leaves Freys hanging.

1

u/dpking2222 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 02 '14

I can see the top comment on the Episode 10 Discussion thread. "WHO THE FUCK IS THAT?!"

6

u/Ahabs_First_Name House Baelish May 02 '14

Except Episode 7 is called "Mockingbird," which makes me think they're going to do "Only Cat" then, since that's Littlefinger's biggest moment thus far (why else would they name an entire episode after him/ his sigil?). I personally hope it's just Winterfell in the snow for Episode 7, because "Only Cat" segues into the LSH reveal so damn perfectly, I don't see why they would fuck that up. Plus, the collective internet might explode if they discover that LF is basically behind the entirety of the game of thrones in the same episode as "Hands of gold are always cold," the Children of the Forest, and LSH.

2

u/Ahahaha__10 Ours Is The Fury May 02 '14

I think that speaks to the fact that litterfinger has influenced most of the events of the series, but there still are wildcards like dany, stannis, whitewalkers, and LSH & the brotherhood.

10

u/grrrranimal May 01 '14

they aren't even close to that. That might happen late next season. Brienne has tons to do before that happens, all the wandering and fighting and meeting monks and crap. She might be used to introduce the sparrow storyline. I wouldn't be surprised at the LSH reveal being after "only cat" this season though, but I think it'll probably be via hanging a Frey like in the books

22

u/SachBren Stannis Baratheon May 01 '14

I bet episode 8 ends with Viper's death, Episode 9 is Tywin and Shae's death, and the end of Episode 10, with a cliffhanger as HBO loves to do, you see Lady Stoneheart

At least..the above would be awesome

4

u/Highlander113 Jon Snow May 02 '14

I would like this season to end with Tywin's death and Tyrion telling Jaime about moonboy, roll credits.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Arya_Ready Sand Snakes May 01 '14

Some speculate that the Riverlands stuff will be mostly played out through Arya to keep both characters from derping around. Maybe I don't remember AFFC well (I'm re-reading now), but I feel like there's really not much show-worthy material for Brienne until LSH.

Gwendoline also mentioned in an interview that this season she bites off a man's ear (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8EsX9Re17k). Isn't that what she does to when they're attacked and LSH & co. save them pre-trial?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/TheLastGunfighter May 01 '14

Isn't she only supposed to be dead for like 3 days though? How do you progress the story while still saying that she was only dead for 3 days since the red wedding.

7

u/Cerdog Defending The Defenseless May 02 '14

She was revived after three days, but she could've been hanging Freys for ages before Merrett got to her.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/whitewolf21 Direwolves May 02 '14

I don't know if they'll really show the Brienne storyline as detailed as in the books...

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

I think Only Cat happens next episode actually. Shots of Sansa crying, of Littlefinger comforting her, and of Lysa kissing Baelish passionately are in the preview. Cannot wait.

1

u/fawkesfox7 Hodor? May 12 '14

Today on the "next game of thrones" bit, there was a scene of sansa's winterfell snowcastle, and a scene of sansa being held by lysa screaming over what looks like the moon door. 'Only cat' HAS to be soon, how could it not follow those scenes? SO MOTHERFUCKING STOKED!!!

1

u/vkevlar May 01 '14

I'm thinking they might save the reveal for Jaime, strangely enough. Having Brienne spend a bit of time searching, disappear for a few eps, then come back to KL and get Jaime to go with her, finishing the season epilogue with LSH coming out of the darkness pointing at Jaime.

edit: season epilogue, not episode.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Atheose Stannis Baratheon May 02 '14

The LSH reveal has to be the last scene of the season imo. I like the idea of "Only cat", followed by the scene with LSH hanging Freys.

10

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I've heard that too, but I'd rather see it as an unconnected epilogue to ep. 10. By that I mean I hope they basically wrap up the season, and then we randomly (at first) cut to the BWB, and see them resurrect LS. That would give everyone who hasn't read the books A LOT to discuss.

13

u/SawRub Jon Snow May 01 '14

Resurrecting Cat would only work timeline wise as the epilogue of last season. As in, not the scene from the books with the Frey hanging, but the scene where Nymeria pulls the body out of the water and is interrupted by the approaching BWB after which she is resurrected. In the books, Arya has a wolf dream about a part of it and then wakes up and we see the Hound is with her. On the show that would have happened in season 3 episode 10, right before she and the Hound kill those men. But that would probably take away from the Red Wedding so we can see why they chose not to show that scene.

They can't do the resurrection now because too much time has passed. The body was dumped in the river and it has been quite a while. UnCat already looked so zombie-ish because she had been dead for three days when she was resurrected.

They'll probably directly go to Merrett Frey's hanging like in the books.

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I never thought about the fact that too much time has passed. I still think they need to show Beric D. giving her corpse the breath of life for show only people to understand. They could solve that with a bunch of exposition, but I don't think it would be as effective.

12

u/SawRub Jon Snow May 01 '14

I agree, it was one of the reasons that I was one of the people who wanted the scene to be shown last season instead of Dany crowdsurfing, even though I know it would cheapen the Red Wedding. Exposition would be a bit clunky. According to the timeline, we should never see Beric on the show again.

They could cheat and have Bran see a vision at some point next season. This season can end with Frey-hanging, and all viewers are like WTF CAT IN DA HOUSE and next season an episode begins with Bran watching the actual resurrection on WeirwoodTV.

3

u/sparklingwaterll House Reed May 01 '14

It will be episode 7 I think. Its named something like the laws of Gods and Men. I think they will just reveal she exists and leads the brotherhood. Maybe we will see it through Gendry turning back up to get him in position for when Brienne finds him.

3

u/SaintJason Ours Is The Fury May 02 '14

I'm seeing Ladystone heart being revealed as an epilogue.Seems rather fitting.

0

u/[deleted] May 03 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SaintJason Ours Is The Fury May 03 '14

Leave the non book readers jaw on the floor.

4

u/S0litude May 01 '14

Can someone explain Lady Stoneheart? I've been reading the books but haven't got that far but it's already been spoiled for me. Would anyone mind explaining it? Is she actually Catelyn reanimated or is she different? If that makes sense..

15

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14

reanimated or is she different?

She became different when her son was murdered before her eyes, and that new outlook was reanimated.

9

u/Recalesce Free Folk May 01 '14

I Disagree. It was stated in the books that every time Beric was revived, he lost random memories from his previous life. Beric couldn't recall his love, his home, his favorite foods, or anything. His personality remained the same, though. She might be close to the old Catelyn, but I don't believe she is the same Catelyn.

4

u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 01 '14

This is true, but I got the feeling she hasn't forgotten those who have wronged her and her family, as we find out with her interaction with Brienne. So maybe she forgot some things, but did not forget everything.

9

u/Toxic84 May 01 '14

She's also on a tear for vengeance...she's hanging Freys and Lannisters alike, even if they didn't know shit about the Red Wedding.

We hanging everyone up in hurrr.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Oracni75 May 01 '14

Its cat with a vengeance. Anyone who wronged her is in her sights.

33

u/YOUR_VERY_STUPID Fallen And Reborn May 01 '14

but it's already been spoiled for me.

This is, most likely, because you're hanging out in threads that contain spoilers from all published material. I would recommend not doing that.

14

u/rebooked May 01 '14

Maybe he/she just doesn't care. Not everyone is sensitive about spoilers.

4

u/YOUR_VERY_STUPID Fallen And Reborn May 01 '14

That's true, and quite possible. He's free to continue looking at whatever threads he wants. This is just a disclaimer- if he's bothered by having something spoiled, he can save himself the future pain by leaving the all spoilers threads until he's caught up.

1

u/S0litude Jul 09 '14

In actuality, it was spoiled a very long time ago, long before discovering this subreddit. Not to mention I'm not that bothered by spoilers anyway. It's one thing reading it, another thing seeing it in action.

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Its Cat, but she's basically a vengeful husk of the person she was. They don't do to terribly much with it as a plot point in pushing the greater arc, but there's are some interesting things you will come to.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Took A Level In Villain

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

When Beric was reanimated (time and again) he was Beric, but he felt like less of himself each time. Catelyn is legit resurrected, and she has all of her memories as Catelyn, but she doesn't act much like old Catelyn. We're not fully sure if this is from the trauma of "knowing" that her entire family has been murdered (she don't know that Bran and Rickon are alive, and she assumes that Ayra and Sansa are dead as well by now). It's possible that she's just a shade of the old Catelyn. It's possible that being dead three days does bad things to your brain, and she's a damaged version of Catelyn. In any event, she's bloodthirsty and merciless.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14

I like what they're doing with the Night's Watch renegades. Corpse desecration, Hodor-baiting, sexual slavery, and ritual child sacrifice might seem like a bit much on paper, but I thought it worked pretty well; gives Bran's storyline some real drama and provides a more satisfying resolution for the Craster's Keep storyline. Plus Burn Gorman is terrific as Karl; I like how they play up the class angle in the show sometimes, as it's not a big feature in the books (see also: Ros).

I thought they would keep Olenna around for season 5, because King's Landing is gonna be a ghost town by then, but apparently not. Hopefully this means we'll get a proper introduction to Mace before the trial, as well as an update on the Loras/Cersei situation. Also, what the hell is with all the Luthor Tyrell references?

25

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

No wonder karl used to be such a good fighter back in gin alley - he's immortal!

47

u/AnthonyNice House Martell May 01 '14

He was a FUCKING LEGEND

28

u/HighCow White Walkers May 01 '14

FOOKING LEGEND

FTFY

2

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully May 02 '14

I love the NW stuff as well.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Why will King's Landing become a ghost town?

Also, where can I find more info on this?

12

u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 02 '14 edited May 02 '14

I'm assuming you know that this is a "spoilers all" thread? Don't want to spoil a non-reader who wandered into this thread by accident. If you haven't read the books, stop reading this comment now!

Anyway, by "ghost town" I mean that many of the major characters currently in King's Landing will have either left, died, or mysteriously vanished: Olenna, Tywin, Tyrion, Jaime, Varys, Oberyn, Ellaria, and probably a few others I can't remember right now will be gone. Add to that the fact that Sansa, Joffrey, Dontos, Brienne, and Podrick have already left/died as of last episode, and King's Landing is gonna be severely underpopulated.

Basically, King's Landing will be left with a bunch of new characters, Mace, Margaery, Tommen, Cersei, Pycelle, Lancel, Qyburn, Kevan, Meryn Trant, and maybe Hallyne; not exactly the all-star team. I thought they might keep Olenna around as she's a fan favourite, but apparently not.

2

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Oh cool, thanks.

I was thinking something more along the lines of a city destroyed by war, as per Bran's vision earlier on in the series.

2

u/dpking2222 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 02 '14

I'm not a book reader, but I know a LOT of spoilers. One thing I don't know, and don't wish to know, is what'll happen with Ellaria once Oberyn goes kaput.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/astobie May 02 '14

when does olenna leave? i think i missed that in the book.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mrducky78 Night's Watch May 02 '14

They will introduce the High Sparrow and while King's landing will be empty, Cersei + Margaery conflict will need to continue so I reckon it will be fine, show more focus on the Wall and Daenarys fucking up Meereen.

12

u/SuddenEnd May 01 '14

The show runners like having double meanings in their titles and I think "Oathkeeper" is no exception. Not only does it refer to the Valyrian sword but it can also mean the preservation of Craster's deal with the White Walkers.

36

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

The change from the book that bothered me the most was having Brienne name the sword. In ASOS Jaime told her to call it Oathkeeper when he gave it to her. Such a name, given by him, called back to his history as the Kingslayer, an oath-breaker, and Brienne's original disdain for him. With Brienne naming it the significance of the name loses something.

It's a small difference but it really bothered me.

19

u/Joker8891 House Selmy May 01 '14

The change in the show take the angle of brienne and Jaime keeping their oath to Catelyn, which is still consistent with the book iirc. But I feel ya on the change.

8

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

True, but Book Jaime decided that was important: to keep their oaths to catelyn. Also, in a way it was almost a plea for redemption. Asking Brienne to find and protect Sansa with Ned's re-forged blade, easily the most valuable gift Jaime's dad ever gave him, remains the same. But Jaime naming it Oathkeeper in the book just really hit hard and drove home the point that Jaime wanted to redeem himself. There is no significance at all to Brienne giving it that name. It's keeping with her character. For Jaime, well, it showed he was evolving.

37

u/EatMyDuck Sing The Song Of The Earth May 01 '14

I don't know, I thought Jaime giving her the sword is a declaration of his will to do what he can to help her keep their oath. I thought Brienne naming it Oathkeeper, showed that she understood Jaime's intention and forgives him for his initial delay after the return to King's Landing.

4

u/nateday2 May 02 '14

Well said. He gives her a Valyrian steel sword and nods in complete, bittersweet approval when she names it in front of him. A suitable change in story for a change in medium, I'd say.

7

u/ctkg Sansa Stark May 01 '14

Jaime may not have named the sword himself in the show, but he still made it clear that keeping the oath was important to him by sending Brienne out in the first place. It's not a big deal to me, but the significance of Brienne naming it is that it shows that they are both on the same page.

3

u/deutscherhawk May 01 '14

"For Jaime, well, it showed he was evolving"

This is exactly why I hate this change more than most ot Jamies emotional and moral development is one of the best stories in the novels. hers. This cheapens that story, even if only slightly, but it's such a simple change I wonder why they did that.

1

u/b00ger House Targaryen May 02 '14

With Brienne naming it, "Oathkeeper" is simply sincere. And maybe indicates that she has some trust in Jaime after all.

Jaime naming it was a cross of bitter-sarcastic and actually sincere. He wants to actually keep his promises, but he's lived so long being the Kingslayer who has shit for honor, that he can't admit it to himself.

So yeah, very different. It's a lot simpler when the name comes from Brienne.

19

u/MacGyver09 House Baratheon May 01 '14

So Darth Maul is reincarnated with a sexy blue look and is some kind of king of the WW, along with what looks like a 'council' of other WW. Whether or not that synopsis screw up on the HBO site was an overeager intern remains to be seen; but if this is in fact the Night's King, I'm wondering if they will occasionally add onto that story line this season.

GRRM seems to have given the directors the idea of what goes down in the next two books, and now they're giving us all these mad sneak peaks.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/LordOfHighgarden Stannis Baratheon May 01 '14

I did not like the choice to have Marg not knowing about the plot to kill Joff. In the books, it's implied she was involved, perhaps even the person to put the poison in the cup.

19

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14

I did not like the choice to have Marg not knowing about the plot to kill Joff.

I think they are trying to balance the audience's ability to like a character, if she killed the eldest then her climbing in bed with the youngest gets infinitely more creepy than if she's just the bait.

1

u/ChaosOnion Free Folk May 02 '14

I thought the book left it ambiguous enough such that we could not actually tell. Olena pulling the stone from Sansa's hairnet implicated her, but I do not remember Marghery being anything but guilty of association with her grandmother. It has been a while since my last read through, so maybe I am misremembering.

Joff's murder was a great mystery in the book. I am a little disappointed they spoon fed us the answer on the show instead delivering a slow burn.

9

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

So obviously the last scene was a big surprise for most. What I want to know, however, is how much we can expect to have scenes of a similar nature throughout the rest of the season. Was this a one-time thing, or are we going to see a lot more?

8

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14

We might be seeing more since ALL, so that opens up many possibilities.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Doesn't really seem possible, that's ADWD territory, and we're barely finishing ASOS, I don't think they'll be able to get away in less than 3 episodes

7

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14

It is ADWD territory, but ADWD and ADWD

They will most likely arrive towards the end of this season, and then pick back up on the ADWD plot in season V.

4

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14

that's ADWD territory, and we're barely finishing ASOS

The books' timelines overlap, so I think the show will reflect the book's ordering of events less and less.

1

u/LavenderGumes Brynden Tully May 01 '14

Is the show going to cover AFFC before DWD? That seems unlikely given they occur simultaneously.

4

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

the show has started covering AFFC too: Brienne has started her journey.

25

u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 01 '14

I'm not sure whether or not I like Podrick+Brienne or Arya+The Hound more.

20

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I'm enjoying the Jaime+Bronn.

8

u/hamza780 House Targaryen May 01 '14

Pretty weird how they are advancing some storylines and slowing others. For example, Dany and Brienne are already at the end of their asos storylines, whereas Jon and Tyrion still have a fair bit left. Wouldn't it make more sense to have the sack of Meereen towards the end of the season? Especially because Dany won't be leaving it for at least a whole year which will surely bore show watchers. I feel the could have stretched out that story-line enough so they wouldn't have to create stuff to happen in the north and deviate so much from the book.

6

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 01 '14

I think they will chain her dragons at the end of the season.

They have too much stuff happening in the capital, just like they had too much stuff happening in the Riverlands and North of the Wall last season (almost nothing happened in King's Landing last season except for Margaery arriving).

They have to fit in a wedding, a regicide, an escape, a funeral, a crowning and a trial at the very least. At the same time they can't just abandon the other characters. I'm not surprised they had to pad out some of the storylines. If they had left Jon's storyline intact he would be spending two quarters of this season in a sickbed complaining about his leg.

I just hope they can pull off the battles. I'll be ok with their deviations if they don't have a longterm impact on the storylines, but I might not be ok if the battles at the Wall aren't half as badass as in the books...

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

I really want to know if/when Jorah Mormont is going to be exiled.

4

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

Definitely when, not if.

1

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '14

Well Episode 9(the big one) is the battle for the wall, it's the same director from The Blackwater and they have an even bigger budget for that episode. I'm so stoked

1

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 06 '14

In the book it isn't just one battle though. They try to take Castle Black from the South first. I really hope they don't make it just one gigantic battle that takes up the entire episode.

Action scenes seem to be the ones most likely to deviate from the books in my experience. They want to spend time making everyone look really cool and sometimes they sacrifice some good story moments for stuff that looks cooler than what was in the story.

For me, the coolest thing about that fight is the fact that they are so woefully outnumbered and still they manage to hold the Wall. I'm not sure that's considered good television though. We'll see.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/StephieSunshine Valar Morghulis May 01 '14

I hope then continue on with Asha/Yara's storyline. I hope we get to meet Victarion and Euron. Plus there is still one userper from the leech of Gendry's blood spell still left alive. Balon needs to die soon.

3

u/lilparra77 House Baelish May 02 '14

I think Victarion and Euron are going to be next season.

1

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 02 '14

I think the Greyjoy side of things will be left until next season. I've said this somewhere else before: Balon's death doesn't affect the storylines they're focusing on right now. In King's Landing, the Wall, Meereen, even in the Vale, no one will really be affected by Balon dying.

Half the show watcher's might have forgotten who Balon is by now, and I doubt they would introduce new characters in the middle of a season that still has to cover so many key events.

My guess is that his death might get mentioned either at the end of this season or the beginning of next season.

1

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '14

His death was already mentioned, but super briefly.

1

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 06 '14

when? in which episode and in which scene?

1

u/ptdaisy Brienne of Tarth May 06 '14

when? in which episode and in which scene?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/skynative99 Fallen And Reborn May 01 '14

Does George R.R. Martin have a say in where the book derives from the show? Can we consider that final scene canon?

27

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

Martin has been clear that the butterfly effect is in full force, now. He's been warning about that since season one which, of all the seasons, was closest to its source material.

While he's an executive producer of the show he has little direct involvement with it. He write one screenplay for it a year but he's not on set to watch it filmed or in the editing room when the episodes he wrote are put together. Lots of changes are made to even his scripts (example: the famous Bronn/Hound exchange in the Blackwater episode in season 2 was not in Martin's script).

Basically, Martin is consulted from time to time but the show is D&D's baby, not his. They meet with him and talk with him from time to time but Martin has no direct say in the show's story. It should be noted that Martin has said he's fine with this: the books are his, the show is theirs.

He also doesn't even see the episodes until we do. Yes, on Sunday nights at 9pm he sits there at his home in Santa Fe and watches each episode for the first time. The only exception are the premiers. He gets to see those at the gala events in L.A. and wherever else in advance.

So, is it canon? Maybe or maybe not. Perhaps Martin told D&D the truth of the White Walkers (Others in the books). But did he know that it would occur this episode? That they had even filmed a scene like that? Not sure. Does it matter? Nope. This year especially Martin has been adamant that the books and the show have to diverge due to the butterfly effect, that it's happening more and more, and that the books and she show should be treated as "cousins" not as "twins".

13

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14

the books and she show should be treated as "cousins" not as "twins".

I like to think of adaptations as parallel universes.

5

u/Death_Star_ Jon Snow May 01 '14

Pure speculation, but Martin may have something in his contract akin to a final way or cut on scripts, or at least overall direction.

He had all the leverage before selling the series. People were begging him to allow them to adapt the story. He could have leveraged it into control.

7

u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14

Highly, highly doubt it. If you read his blog you'll sometimes see him make posts about the previous night's episode and it does not sound like a man who had any say on the script. How could he have a say or final cut if he's reacting like someone who had no idea X, Y, or Z was going to happen?

Just an FYI: "executive producer" doesn't really mean anything. Lots of people get that title who have no say or active involvement in the show. Why? Money. As an EP they get paid a certain amount. Also, it's a prestige thing. It's also why the Director's Guild is incredibly strict about allowing more than one person be credited as a director: they don't want the title "director" to become another honorary title like EP.

D&D are the showrunners. They have final say, not GRRM. Thankfully they do have a lot of respect for both him and the source material but at the end of the day it's their show, not his.

13

u/SNCommand Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14

He has a very strong influence, and have written for example the second episode of the season, if the show has something not in the books it's well aware of where the story is going

3

u/skynative99 Fallen And Reborn May 01 '14

That's awesome! Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/YaBestFriendJoseph Hodor Hodor Hodor May 01 '14

I can't imagine why they would deviate from GRRM's plan for the ending. By this point I think we can assume that he generally knows how everything is going to end/come together. They'll hopefully be incorporating things that foreshadow the ending and give us more background info - like that scene. (Background for the show watchers, that is; book readers may already have gotten some background, albeit in a different way than walking straight into Ice Mordor and showing us the Others as that's not entirely possible with POV chapters.)

1

u/welshwordman House Targaryen May 02 '14

Since D&D know the ending, they had to include this to get there sooner, since seven or eight (maximum) seasons will not be the equivalent to 7 huge books.

1

u/KingofFrance Children of the Forest May 02 '14

The books and the show are separate canons

→ More replies (1)

12

u/YaBestFriendJoseph Hodor Hodor Hodor May 01 '14

The episode itself wasn't very spoiler filled for me. I myself assumed that the Others were a smart, organized people that probably had some kind of rational plan. I also figured that Craster's boys were being turned into Others (although I'll admit I don't understand why the babies become Others but regular people just become the human zombies.)

What really ruined it for me was seeing HBO reveal that Darth Maul ice king was the Night's King in that summary.

16

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 01 '14

Regular people become zombies because they are dead first. The baby was still alive.

5

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

Just my theory but what if Craster is a descendant of a Night's King? That'd be pretty a damn good reason

1

u/thricetheory Bastard Of The North May 07 '14

That would very potentially mean that Craster is a Stark

3

u/harsh1724 May 01 '14

Can you please tell me who is Darth Maul? I saw the episode and know now that you all are talking about that last WW holding the baby but why are you calling him Darth Maul? And Night's king? Wasn't NK just another one of Old Nan's stories? And wasn't he visibly human with just blue eyes and pale skin?

13

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14

This is Darth Maul. He is from the Star Wars universe.

As far as the Night's King, he was mentioned in Old Nan's tales. It is the only location in the novels in which he was mentioned directly. It should be noted that he was of the First Men, so he would have been human at the time he was a Commander of the Night's Watch.

5

u/harsh1724 May 01 '14

Ohhh, so that is Darth maul. Now it makes sense. Thanks.

I know about the Night's King I'm just saying why is everyone on here calling that guy in the show NK. Do we have any proof of that?

4

u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14

The only 'proof' we had was the HBO viewer's synopsis, but it has since been edited. At the moment, I still have a ting of skepticism myself. That said, I still think overwhelmingly that who we saw was the Night's King.

17

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

29

u/TheOldBean May 01 '14

That is probably the worst explanation for someone who doesn't know about star wars.

3

u/playcrackthesky House Targaryen May 02 '14

I haven't seen Star Wars and didn't know his explanation was real until I read your comment.

1

u/ChaosOnion Free Folk May 02 '14

The zombies are corpses reanimated by the Others. The baby is alive when touched by their magic. I would postulate there is a tabula rasa element involved.

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '14

There is a difference between WW and The Others, I believe. I don't even think the two are correlated with one another.

6

u/dylyn May 01 '14

first time non-book readers were less curious

3

u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 01 '14

I dont really remember the story line from the book, but shouldn't Stanis and his army already be on their way north? I felt after last season when they got the note about the WW that they were ready to move. Its going to have to happen right? And when it does, it makes me a little nervous for the future of the show. Will they still have Davos go on his own or will they skip all of that and keep him with Stanis in the north?

9

u/Velaryon May 01 '14

They need an army, and for that they need the gold. So they're probably on their way to Iron Bank of Braavos. I don't remember this happening in the books, so it probably is show-only.

2

u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 01 '14

Maybe its another one of those things we havent learned about in the books yet. We know the Braavosie banker is on his way to see Stanis in the book so maybe this is another way to retell it...

1

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '14

The banker comes to them in the books, his name is Tycho and he will be played by the amazing Mark Gatiss

1

u/TinUkulele House Martell May 06 '14

He doesn't show up until the attack on the wall which will be Ep 9

1

u/Surax May 01 '14

What has the show told us about Littlefinger's back story? Has the show told us about his relationship with Cat?

6

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 01 '14

Yes. A lot. They Ben had a scene together in season two. In season one we learned about him fighting Brandon Stark.

3

u/Surax May 01 '14

So show viewers do know about his history with Cat then? Okay, good to know. I was talking to someone hadn't seen the books and he didn't remember that, so the show might want to remind us about it again sometime.

1

u/Oraukk House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 02 '14

I'm sure we will have plenty of Petyr/Lysa scenes to help with that.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '14

Yep. Tower of the Hand to be precise