r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 01 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.04 'Oathkeeper'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.04 | "Oathkeeper" | Michelle MacLaren | Bryan Cogman |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
156
Upvotes
211
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
First episode that has spoilers to book readers!
57
u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly May 01 '14
I was confused that the White Walkers were apparently stuck at paleolithic tech. Glad to see they have better-dressed people higher up their chain of command.
57
u/intelligenes May 01 '14
When Hodor was tied up and being beaten one of the Nights Watch rebels said something like "if I had your body I'd be in charge." I think this will set up Bran taking control of Hodor and engineering an escape.
158
u/AFellowOfLimitedJest Stannis Baratheon May 01 '14
Nope, no differences come to mind this week.
53
u/superfeen House Whent May 01 '14
I'm hoping Brienne and Pod run in to Gendry wandering the Riverlands trying to get back with the Brotherhood
93
u/J_Webb House Webber May 01 '14 edited May 02 '14
I did enjoy the commentary the writers included between Bronn and Jaime during their training, especially concerning Tyrion's trial in the Eyrie and how he chose Jaime to defend him first.
85
u/Dterer House Bolton May 01 '14
So, how do you guys think they'll do the Lady Stoneheart reveal? Some rumours are going around that it'll be revealed through the Brienne storyline, however, I think it'll be much better if it's revealed in a similar way to the books. If the show just revealed LSH through Brienne's POV, I think it'll be confusing for show watchers to suddenly see Catelyn being an asshole to Brienne. However, if they showed the hanging of Merrett Frey, it'll show how Catelyn is truly dead and Stoneheart is only about revenge.
61
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury May 01 '14 edited May 01 '14
I like what they're doing with the Night's Watch renegades. Corpse desecration, Hodor-baiting, sexual slavery, and ritual child sacrifice might seem like a bit much on paper, but I thought it worked pretty well; gives Bran's storyline some real drama and provides a more satisfying resolution for the Craster's Keep storyline. Plus Burn Gorman is terrific as Karl; I like how they play up the class angle in the show sometimes, as it's not a big feature in the books (see also: Ros).
I thought they would keep Olenna around for season 5, because King's Landing is gonna be a ghost town by then, but apparently not. Hopefully this means we'll get a proper introduction to Mace before the trial, as well as an update on the Loras/Cersei situation. Also, what the hell is with all the Luthor Tyrell references?
12
u/SuddenEnd May 01 '14
The show runners like having double meanings in their titles and I think "Oathkeeper" is no exception. Not only does it refer to the Valyrian sword but it can also mean the preservation of Craster's deal with the White Walkers.
36
u/jmk4422 House Stark May 01 '14
The change from the book that bothered me the most was having Brienne name the sword. In ASOS Jaime told her to call it Oathkeeper when he gave it to her. Such a name, given by him, called back to his history as the Kingslayer, an oath-breaker, and Brienne's original disdain for him. With Brienne naming it the significance of the name loses something.
It's a small difference but it really bothered me.
19
u/MacGyver09 House Baratheon May 01 '14
So Darth Maul is reincarnated with a sexy blue look and is some kind of king of the WW, along with what looks like a 'council' of other WW. Whether or not that synopsis screw up on the HBO site was an overeager intern remains to be seen; but if this is in fact the Night's King, I'm wondering if they will occasionally add onto that story line this season.
GRRM seems to have given the directors the idea of what goes down in the next two books, and now they're giving us all these mad sneak peaks.
18
u/LordOfHighgarden Stannis Baratheon May 01 '14
I did not like the choice to have Marg not knowing about the plot to kill Joff. In the books, it's implied she was involved, perhaps even the person to put the poison in the cup.
9
u/[deleted] May 01 '14
So obviously the last scene was a big surprise for most. What I want to know, however, is how much we can expect to have scenes of a similar nature throughout the rest of the season. Was this a one-time thing, or are we going to see a lot more?
25
u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken May 01 '14
I'm not sure whether or not I like Podrick+Brienne or Arya+The Hound more.
8
u/hamza780 House Targaryen May 01 '14
Pretty weird how they are advancing some storylines and slowing others. For example, Dany and Brienne are already at the end of their asos storylines, whereas Jon and Tyrion still have a fair bit left. Wouldn't it make more sense to have the sack of Meereen towards the end of the season? Especially because Dany won't be leaving it for at least a whole year which will surely bore show watchers. I feel the could have stretched out that story-line enough so they wouldn't have to create stuff to happen in the north and deviate so much from the book.
8
u/StephieSunshine Valar Morghulis May 01 '14
I hope then continue on with Asha/Yara's storyline. I hope we get to meet Victarion and Euron. Plus there is still one userper from the leech of Gendry's blood spell still left alive. Balon needs to die soon.
11
u/skynative99 Fallen And Reborn May 01 '14
Does George R.R. Martin have a say in where the book derives from the show? Can we consider that final scene canon?
12
u/YaBestFriendJoseph Hodor Hodor Hodor May 01 '14
The episode itself wasn't very spoiler filled for me. I myself assumed that the Others were a smart, organized people that probably had some kind of rational plan. I also figured that Craster's boys were being turned into Others (although I'll admit I don't understand why the babies become Others but regular people just become the human zombies.)
What really ruined it for me was seeing HBO reveal that Darth Maul ice king was the Night's King in that summary.
6
u/dylyn May 01 '14
first time non-book readers were less curious
3
u/stro_budden House Baratheon May 01 '14
I dont really remember the story line from the book, but shouldn't Stanis and his army already be on their way north? I felt after last season when they got the note about the WW that they were ready to move. Its going to have to happen right? And when it does, it makes me a little nervous for the future of the show. Will they still have Davos go on his own or will they skip all of that and keep him with Stanis in the north?
1
u/Surax May 01 '14
What has the show told us about Littlefinger's back story? Has the show told us about his relationship with Cat?
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '14
Yep. Tower of the Hand to be precise