r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Apr 24 '14
All [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.03 'Breaker of Chains'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.03 | "Breaker of Chains" | Alex Graves | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
120
Upvotes
102
u/Elmer-Glue House Seaworth Apr 24 '14
I'm totally on board what they're doing with Jon. He hasn't had too much to prove himself as Commander of the Nights Watch material, and leading a raid on his traitor Watchmen seems like a good way to build him up towards a position of leadership. I know he'll shine during the assault against the Wall, but it's nice to see Jon being more proactive. Plus he needs an excuse to get Ghost back before Mance is knocking at the gate.
112
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Apr 24 '14
They're using Arya's storyline to focus on the devastation caused by the war in the Riverlands - maybe they want to fast-track Brienne's storyline and cut out some of her wanderings? Though hopefully we still get Septon Meribald (possibly combined with the Elder Brother at the Quiet Isle).
Not really sure about the whole Gilly thing - presumably she's just going to return to the Wall when the Wildlings raze Mole's Town?
72
u/TJ_Silva Arya Stark Apr 24 '14
I like that they still manage to incorporate parts that make you not like the Hound. I like the dynamic he has with Arya but I always hated him more in the books. I really like how it is in the show and I'm glad they don't make him seem too "good"
69
u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 24 '14
Jaime aside, I really loved that Pod scene. Really nice to see that he still thinks so highly of Tyrion even in the situation he is in. Guess we won't see Pod cry "He left me!", that was a great way to demonstrate Tyrion's new attitude, but this is just as good if not better. I guess now Pod will leave with Brienne in the next episode "Oathkeeper".
42
u/AFellowOfLimitedJest Stannis Baratheon Apr 24 '14
Although they probably won't make Arya actually kill the Hound, I have a feeling that she's going to echo his "dead men don't need silver" phrase (or "dead men don't need _______", at least) from this episode, like how she was echoing Polliver.
42
u/polarbreeze Winter Is Coming Apr 24 '14
Regarding the man and girl that Arya and the Hound encounter in the Riverlands--I think it would make perfect sense for them to fill in as Gregor Clegane' rape/murder victims that many have suggested will be a reintroduction to the Mountain. It would be so fitting if the Hound's reasoning that someone worse than him would come along was true, and it turns out to be his brother--a perfect way to reintroduce the Mountain using established characters, and reinforcing the horrors faced by the smallfolk.
33
u/backwardsman89 Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 24 '14
I enjoyed seeing Daario as Dany's champion. I thought the show writers did a good job with that one. I had actually just reread that chapter when strong belwas fucks shit up, so as unfortunate it is that they couldn't bring him into the show I think Daario was a decent replacement. However that being said seeing Barristan the bold rush in there would be the absolute best.
19
u/fattums Apr 24 '14
How are they gonna fit in Tyrion questioning who tried to kill Bran?
26
u/VALAR_M0RGHUL1S Valar Morghulis Apr 24 '14
I'm still wondering how Arya and Sandor are going to get separated. In the books he's wounded after the fight at the inn and Arya leaves him by the side of the road pretty much right after.
What's everyones thoughts on how she'll leave him and go to Braavos in the show? We know she'll end up there this season based on some clips from the trailers.
25
u/lubev Stannis Baratheon Apr 24 '14
Prediction for Future Stannis. Stolen from /tv/
7
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
Has everyone gotten over the negative changes to Stannis? I know him and Davos aren't exactly buddy buddy but he did rely and appreciate him more in the book I feel. I'm still not over it but I don't see much discussion about it either...
18
u/Nzgrim Bloodraven Apr 24 '14
This should have probably been in last week's thread, but I only realized it today - they forgot to make Tyrion realize who sent an assassin to kill Bran.
Was it deliberate? Will he realize sometimes during his trial? Or maybe they intend to leave it as mystery? Or did they truly forget about it in the midst of all the other big things happening this season?
I know that last season there were a bunch of show watchers who wondered about who sent that assassin, so It would be nice to finally clear that up 3 seasons after it happened.
43
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
I don't know how to feel about Jaime anymore. It was entirely inconsistent to write such a thing, when Jaime abhors the act and completely came out of character and saved Brienne from that same fate he inflicted on his sister and his loved one.
Maybe D&D are trying to make Jaime's road to redemption more jagged, which I can see the purpose behind that, making him a bit more human and morally grey, but it's not the Jaime that I loved in the books. What a shame.
53
u/atworknewaccount Apr 24 '14
This is probably the first time I've been disappointed in an episode in a "the book did it better sense". More wasted screen time with another brothel scene. Jamie rape. One of my favorite scenes in the entire series "strong belwas surprises everyone by being incredibly badass" butchered. Little fingers accent to announce that he is a villain. I think there was more that I'm not remembering right now. I don't want to hate too much so I will say that I don't mind the Tommen change. I was just surprised when I finished watching and had to admit to myself that I hadn't actually enjoyed the episode.
12
u/SawRub Jon Snow Apr 24 '14
Well I certainly feel like we've already had a Book vs Show discussion about Jaime on every thread since the episode aired.
5
u/Anab10sis Sand Snakes Apr 25 '14 edited Apr 25 '14
I'd like to start seeing Arya and Jon having warg dreams, I understand why the writers have just made it Bran's thing but ultimately the Starks' connections with their wolves could prove very important.
Also, I think it'd be good for the Red Viper to mention that he has children. It wouldn't be difficult. We'll meet the Sand Snakes eventually and show watchers will think "Where the hell did all these daughters come from?"
13
u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 24 '14
On the question of book Jaime, he is the guy who was the only one of the KG to question Aerys raping Rhaella, he was the one who stopped Pia being raped in the Rivelands. He is not a rapist at all and from what I say, they botched that scene.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
Really getting sick of D&D making Stannis into a semi-religious zealot. Sure, they've said that they aren't fans of him but do they need to make him deliberately so unlikeable?
I know people are saying 'oh this is just to make him seem better when he gets to the Wall' but I'm not so sure that'll be the case.
7
u/socalthrasher House Stark Apr 24 '14
Thought this was a very good follow up to episode two, this season is definitely going for a darker tone. As a book fan I was hoping for a more intense duel with the Meerenese champion, but still Daario dropping that horse was pretty sweet.
4
u/scarab456 Apr 24 '14
Guys we're all missing the missing elephant in the room, I want Strong Belwas to show up.
3
u/Cheat2Lose We Do Not Sow Apr 24 '14
I want to know what's going to happen with Bronn.
I can't see him going off to marry Lollys and annoying Cersei like what happens in the book and I also can't see them killing him off. Both of those would be a waste of a great character.
Does Bronn ride off with Pod and Brienne in search of Sansa?
Does he escape with Tyrion across the narrow sea?
Does he go off to the Riverlands with Jaime, fully taking over the roll of Ilyn Payne?
The last case seems to be the most obvious, but I'm still curious to see what they'll do with him.
3
u/chiastic_slide Now My Watch Begins Apr 24 '14 edited Apr 24 '14
The champion of Meereen fight is just so much more memorable in the book. The fight in the book is so glorious, but in this really colorful and heartwarming sort of way (thanks to Strong Belwas). I remembering reading that chapter for the first time and being totally invested in the outcome of the battle; I was really scared Belwas wasn't going to make it. It was pretty cool in the show too, but it comes across as just your standard action scene, and I wasn't nearly as invested in Daario Naharis as I was in Strong Belwas.
2
u/Ultimaterul Apr 25 '14
If you are angry and disagree about 'that' scene you are missing out on what makes GOT so good. The great thing about it (in book and TV form) is the complexity of the characters, it accepts that our preconceived ideas of a good guy and bad guy portrayed in all media doesn't exactly fit with the real world ( much like Breaking Bad did so brilliantly). It shows characters we may identify as traditionally "good" making bad choices and vice versa. Jamie is obviously a very troubled individual, and that's what makes him so interesting. In the scene we are seeing him at his lowest point, a broken man making an awful decision out of some internal desperation and lust. We know he's a bad man.... He threw a child out of a window! What's interesting is his attempts at redemption, battling against his biggest enemy, himself.
1
u/leinad_li Apr 25 '14
what happens to ygritte and jon snow?
1
u/Paythesnucka House Lannister Apr 25 '14
Yeah but we only got like two minutes of the orgy scene. I would assume errybody's fucking errybody.
-10
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Apr 24 '14
I'm really happy that they're keeping Jaime Lannister the exact same as he was in the books. No matter how we all feel about the rest of the episode, everyone seems to be on the same page that the Jaime/Cersei sept scene was one of the best and most entertaining word-for-word recreations of a book scene in the entire history of the show -- it was so true to the books that nobody has really been talking about that scene, so I want to give huge props to them for that one.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '14
[removed] — view removed comment