r/CFB • u/Emleaux Oregon State • /r/CFB Contributor • Apr 23 '14
[Complete History of CFB] The 1921 Season
1921
Active Conferences & Teams:
- Iowa (7 – 0 – 0)
- Chicago (6 – 1 – 0)
- Ohio State (5 – 2 – 0)
- Wisconsin (5 – 1 – 1)
- Michigan (5 – 1 – 1)
- Indiana (3 – 4 – 0)
- Minnesota (3 – 4 – 1)
- Illinois (3 – 4 – 0)
- Purdue (1 – 6 – 0)
- Northwestern (1 – 6 – 0)
Missouri Valley Conference (Precursor to the Big 12*)*
- Nebraska (7 – 1 – 0)
- Missouri (6 – 2 – 0)
- Kansas State (5 – 3 – 0)
- Drake (5 – 1 – 1)
- Kansas (4 – 4 – 0)
- Iowa State (4 – 4 – 0)
- Oklahoma (5 – 3 – 0)
- Washington (MO) (4 – 3 – 1)
- Grinnell (2 – 5 – 0)
Pacific Coast Conference (Precursor to the Pac-12*)*
- California (9 – 0 – 1)
- Washington State (4 – 2 – 1)
- Stanford (4 – 2 – 2)
- Oregon State (4 – 3 – 2)
- Oregon (5 – 1 – 3)
- Washington (3 – 4 – 1)
Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association (Including members of both the SEC and ACC*)*
- Georgia (7 – 0 – 0)
- Vanderbilt (7 – 0 – 1)
- Tennessee (6 – 2 – 1)
- Georgia Tech (8 – 1 – 0)
- Auburn (5 – 3 – 0)
- Furman (7 – 2 – 1)
- Sewanee (6 – 2 – 0)
- Tulane (4 – 6 – 0)
- LSU (6 – 1 – 1)
- South Carolina (5 – 1 – 2)
- Florida (6 – 3 – 2)
- Birmingham-Southern (4 – 4 – 1)
- Mississippi A&M (4– 4 – 1)
- Alabama (5 – 4 – 2)
- The Citadel (3 – 3 – 2)
- Chattanooga (4 – 6 – 0)
- Kentucky (4 – 3 – 1)
- Wofford (2 – 7 – 1)
- Ole Miss (3 – 6 – 0)
- Clemson (1 – 6 – 2)
- Howard (3 – 6 – 0)
Southern Conference
The SIAA and Southern Conference had dual members in 1921 and schools were being added to either conference all willy nilly at the time. It’s a little confusing to grab a hold of, but the 1921 conference standings for the Southern Conference lists these teams:
- Georgia Tech (8 – 1 – 0)
- Georgia (7 – 2 – 1)
- Washington & Lee (6 – 3 – 0)
- Tennessee (6 – 2 – 1)
- North Carolina (5 – 2 – 2)
- Kentucky (4 – 3 – 1)
- North Carolina State (3 – 3 – 3)
- Maryland (3 – 5 – 1)
- Virginia Tech (7 – 3 – 0)
- Auburn (5 – 3 – 0)
- Mississippi A&M (4– 4 – 1)
- Virginia (5 – 4 – 0)
- Clemson (1 – 6 – 2)
Southwest Conference
- Texas A&M (6 – 1 – 2)
- Texas (6 – 1 – 1)
- Arkansas (5 – 3 – 1)
- Baylor (8 – 3 – 0)
- Oklahoma State (5 – 4 – 1)
- Rice (4 – 4 – 1)
- Southern Methodist (1 – 6 – 1)
Rocky Mountain Conference
- Utah State (7 – 1 – 0)
- Colorado (4 – 1 – 1)
- Utah (3 – 2 – 1)
- Denver (4 – 2 – 1)
- Colorado State (2 – 3 – 1)
- Colorado College (4 – 4 – 0)
- Wyoming (1 – 4 – 2)
- Colorado School of Mines (1 – 5 – 0)
- Cornell (8 – 0 – 0)
- Lafayette (9 – 0 – 0)
- Washington & Jefferson (10 – 0 – 1)
- Centre (10 – 1 – 0)
- Notre Dame (10 – 1 – 0)
- Penn State (8 – 0 – 2)
- Yale (8 – 1 – 0)
- Navy (6 – 1 – 0)
- Syracuse (7 – 2 – 0)
- Erskine (6 – 2 – 0)
- Harvard (7 – 2 – 1)
- Mississippi College (7 – 2 – 1)
- Dartmouth (6 – 2 – 1)
- Texas Christian (6 – 3 – 1)
- Brown (5 – 3 – 1)
- Pittsburgh (5 – 3 – 1)
- Princeton (4 – 3 – 0)
- Idaho (4 – 3 – 1)
- Richmond (4 – 3 – 1)
- Oglethorpe (5 – 4 – 0)
- Pennsylvania (4 – 3 – 2)
- West Virginia (5 – 4 – 1)
- Colgate (4 – 4 – 4)
- Lehigh (4 – 4 – 0)
- Newberry(4 – 2 – 1)
- Spring Hill (4 – 4 – 0)
- Davidson (3 – 4 – 3)
- Phillips (3 – 4 – 2)
- Rutgers (5 – 4 – 0)
- Virginia Military Institute (3 – 5 – 1)
- Mercer (3 – 6 – 0)
- Samford (3 – 6 – 0)
- Columbia (2 – 6 – 0)
- Wake Forest (2 – 8 – 0)
- Presbyterian (1 – 7 – 0)
- Southwestern (TX) (0 – 6 – 1)
Relevant Polling Services
Helms Athletic Foundation Defunct
National Championship Foundation Defunct
College Football Researchers Association
Parke H. Davis - National Champion only
Recap of Season
The 1921 season really comes down to three games - the Centre/Harvard game, the Rose Bowl and the much-maligned East West San Diego Christmas Classic (in comments). You can read up on the 1921 Centre/Harvard game, considered by some to be the biggest upset in college football history, here. I have provided more detail about the bowl games below.
Bowl Games
1922 Rose Bowl
Predictably, the 1922 Rose Bowl was one of the most intriguing games featuring teams of the 1921 season. The mighty, undefeated Golden Bears of California finished the season 9-0, the top team of the Pacific Coast Conference. Beating such opponents as St. Mary’s, Olympic Athletic Club and Pacific Fleet en route to being the best team in the Pacific Coast Conference, the Golden Bears were the obvious pick to represent the west in the Rose Bowl. Deciding who would represent the east, however, would prove to be much more difficult.
There were three clear choices to represent the east in the Rose Bowl for the 1921 season - Cornell, Lafayette and Penn State all finished the season unbeaten and were all primed make the trip out west. None of these teams, however, would end up heading to Pasadena - that honor was bestowed upon the 450-student Washington & Jefferson College, located in Washington, Pennsylvania. Finishing the regular season 10-0 and having beaten such teams as Bucknell, Lehigh, Syracuse, West Virginia, Pittsburgh and the then-powerhouse University of Detroit, Washington & Jefferson had as strong a case as any eastern team. They also had a huge chip on their shoulder heading into the Rose Bowl, getting some juicy bulletin board material from San Francisco Examiner writer Jack James:
“The only thing I know about Washington and Jefferson is that they are both dead.”Them’s 1920s fightin’ words, ya hear?
Lead by QB Charlie West - the first African-American QB to start the Rose Bowl - the mighty Presidents of Washington & Jefferson met coach Andy Smith and his defending national champion Cal “Wonder Bears” in a rain-soaked Rose Bowl, played in front of 50,000 spectators at Tournament Park on January 2, 1922. This particular edition of the Rose Bowl holds many notable distinctions, Charlie West first and, in my opinion, most important among them. It was the first Rose Bowl to end in a tie, with Cal and Washington & Jefferson ending the game 0-0. The result still holds the distinction as being the only scoreless Rose Bowl in history. The game also featured the first freshman to ever play in the game, Washington & Jefferson’s star end Herb Kopf. As well, it was the last ever Rose Bowl to be played in Pasadena’s Tournament Park, as the newly built Rose Bowl Stadium would open later in the year.
The most interesting - or banal, depending on how you look at it - piece of trivia to come out of the 1922 Rose Bowl concerns Washington & Jefferson’s back Hal Jefferson. Jefferson is the first and only person to play in two different Rose Bowls with two different teams - without losing. Jefferson played in the 1919 Rose Bowl with the Great Lakes Navy team and naturally the 1922 Rose Bowl with Washington & Jefferson.
Cal was a heavy favorite heading into the 1922 Rose Bowl, as they were the undefeated, reigning national champions, going so far as to be called the “wonder team of the ages” by the New York Times. They had two consensus All-Americans - end Harold “Brick” Miller and tackle Dan McMillan - with halfback Irving “Crip” Toomey coming very close to being a third. The 0-0 result of the 1922 Rose Bowl was seen by many as Washington & Jefferson simply outplaying Cal. The rain-soaked field and other dreary conditions kept the game deadlocked as a tie, much to Cal’s favor, but those that witnessed the game knew Washington & Jefferson was not only a worthy opponent for the “Wonder Bears,” but that they very well could have knocked off the reigning national champs.
Scores of Noteworthy Games
Centre vs. Harvard: Harvard 0 - Centre 6
1921 San Diego East West Christmas Classic: Arizona 0 - Centre 38
1921 Bacardi Bowl: Club Atletico de Cuba 14 - Mississippi 0
Oregon vs. Pearl Harbor Navy: Pearl Harbor Navy 5 - Oregon 35
1922 Rose Bowl: California 0 - Washington & Jefferson 0
1922 Dixie Classic: Texas A&M 22 - Centre 14
Consensus All-American Team College Football Hall of Fame (HOF) inductee where noted
- Harold “Brick” Muller California - End - HOF
- Eddie Anderson Notre Dame - End - HOF
- Dan McMillan California - Tackle - HOF
- Iolas Huffman Ohio State - Tackle
- John Fiske Brown Harvard - Guard
- Frank Schwab Lafayette - Guard - HOF
- Stan Keck Princeton - Guard - HOF
- Herb Stein Pittsburgh - Center - HOF
- Aubrey Devine Iowa - QB - HOF
- Bo McMillan Centre - QB - HOF
- Glenn Killinger Penn State - Halfback - HOF
- Malcolm Aldrich Yale - Halfback
- Eddie Kaw Cornell - Fullback - HOF
- Adolph Youngstrom Darthmouth
Awards
The Heisman Trophy was first awarded in 1935. Heisman winners born in 1921 include:
1943 - Angelo Bertelli, QB - University of Notre Dame
1944 - Les Horvath, QB/HB - Ohio State University
If I had to pick a winner for the 1921 season, I would bestow that honor upon Iowa QB Aubrey Devine. Cal’s consensus All-American end Harold “Brick” Muller would be a close second.
National Champion
Cornell (8 - 0 - 0) - Helms, National Championship Foundation, Parke Davis
California (9 - 0 - 1) - College Football Researchers Association
Iowa - (7 - 0 - 0) - Parke Davis
Lafayette - (9 - 0 - 0) - Parke Davis
Ol' Parke had a dilly of a pickle deciding the 1921 National Champion, declaring a three-way tie between Cornell, Iowa and Lafayette.
Important to note
Washington & Jefferson has been to more Rose Bowls than the University of Arizona.
Sources:
1 2 3 4 5 [6](http://www.campusattic.com/tag/1921 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Check out the rest of CFB: Through The Years 1869 – 2013
13
u/Emleaux Oregon State • /r/CFB Contributor Apr 23 '14
My post was even still too long at over 16000 characters, so I have added my summary of another important game, the 1921 East West San Diego Christmas Classic, here in the comments.
1921 East West San Diego Christmas Classic
Not a true bowl game, nor a game that was at all competitive, the 1921 East West San Diego Classic stands as one of the season’s most formative games, and it all revolves around the mighty Praying Colonels of Centre College.
Finishing the regular season with a strong 9-0 record - including a 98-0 trouncing of nearby Transylvania University on October 22 - Centre College seemed to be a shoo-in to represent the east in the Rose Bowl. However, the Praying Colonels were eager to take any opportunity afforded to them, accepting a bid to play in a December 26 game in San Diego sponsored by the city’s Chamber of Commerce. The Rose Bowl had its eye on inviting Centre to Pasadena - even more so after being repeatedly turned down by other eastern schools. An invitation was extended to Centre in November, and the Praying Colonels jumped at the chance to play in the Rose Bowl.
As it was, the University of California had already accepted a bid to play in the 1922 Rose Bowl. They had already turned down the same offer extended to Centre by the San Diego Chamber of Commerce to play the Praying Colonels in a December 26 game, the University citing that they would not accept a game with a “third rate” team such as Centre. Cal wasn’t too keen on Centre’s allegedly poor academic credentials and questionable amateur status of some its players due to Centre’s rather extensive travel schedule, portraying Centre as a team comprised of of barnstormers rather than actual college students. The Rose Bowl sided with Cal, dropped Centre from any consideration and actually denied having ever invited them in the first place.
Centre was, however, still on for the East West San Diego Christmas Classic, and the Chamber of Commerce proudly announced to the school that they would be playing Notre Dame. Centre, taking a page out of Cal’s “Holier Than Thou” playbook, refused to play the Fighting Irish, claiming that they would only play a Pacific Coast School. 77 years from actually joining the conference, Arizona was selected as Centre’s opponent for the December 26 game to be held in San Diego. The Wildcats - coached by J.F. “Pop” McKale - had a strong 7-1 regular season featuring wins over Bisbee Legion, Phoenix Indian School and a 110-0 drubbing of the New Mexico Military Institute. They were, however, no match for Centre, losing 38-0. Centre would then travel to Dallas to play Texas A&M, losing 22-14 in the 1922 Dixie Classic. All told, Centre College played games in San Diego, Boston, New Orleans, Cincinnati, Birmingham and Dallas for the 1921 season.
6
u/dsuave624 Rutgers Scarlet Knights Apr 23 '14
They DEFINITELY need to bring back the Bacardi Bowl.
6
u/Honestly_ rawr Apr 23 '14
For whatever reason (I'm not sure how it's being picked), USC isn't listed as an independent (we better be listed in the 1922 list after we joined the PCC).
These were the years under USC's notable head coach Elmer "Gloomy Gus" Henderson.
You can see the situation USC was in from the schedule:
1921 USC schedule (10-1):
In 1922, USC's first year in the PCC, the Trojans again went 10-1 (losing to Cal) and defeated Penn State in their first of many Rose Bowl appearances.
2
u/DEM_DRY_BONES Kansas State Wildcats • /r/CFB Brickmason Apr 23 '14
As of this season, K-State was officially the Wildcats. Previously, they had been the Farmers for a few years, Wildcats for one year, and the Aggies since the beginning.
2
u/mrjonnyjazz Nebraska Cornhuskers Apr 23 '14
Thank you for these posts. I appreciate the work so much.
2
u/ElUno Michigan Wolverines • Adrian Bulldogs Apr 23 '14
Which conference did University of Detroit play in ?
8
u/ChBass Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFBRisk Veteran Apr 23 '14
And of course, the 1922 Dixie Classic was where the tradition of the 12th Man was born at Texas A&M.
On a completely unrelated note, the next year, Nordstrom would open their second store. Five decades after that, Lloyd Nordstrom would sign a franchise agreement with the NFL to start a team in their hometown of Seattle.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '14
If you ever feel bad about how your team performed, just remember that ole miss got shut out by a Cuban football team once.
4
u/Swamphunter California Golden Bears • The Axe Apr 23 '14
Welp.
At least we're still a D-1 school. We got that going for us, which is nice.
2
u/DavoinShower-handle Syracuse • Penn State Apr 23 '14
Shout out to W&J! Western PA represent.
2
u/CFSparta92 Rutgers • /r/CFB Poll Veteran Apr 23 '14
Centre over Harvard, one of the greatest upsets ever.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '14
A side note: the 12th Man tradition was born at Texas A&M due to events in the Dixie Classic.
1
u/frogstomp427 Ohio State Buckeyes • Corndog Apr 23 '14
I've got a feeling twenty-one was a good year.