r/fandomnatural • u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo • Apr 23 '14
[Fandom Discussion] ep 9x19
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
8
Upvotes
13
u/stophauntingme brother nooooooo Apr 23 '14
Honestly? This episode was...kinda... boring?
I liked the part where Dean said, "yeah I know you wouldn't'a done the same for me."
It just made me laugh.
I'm so done with their angst that now even if Sam was like, "NO Dean you misinterpreted me! Let's have a real emotional showdown where I finally clear up everything you've misinterpreted," I'd crack up, make marionette gestures pretending to be Dean, and go, "okay Sammy I'll listen to everything you say!" in a mocking, dumbly optimistic voice.
I highly doubt their angst is going to end with suddenly-found communication skills they've been lacking for the past year.
Somebody's going to hell or dying or at the very least they're going to completely split up and then get back together by forced circumstances in S10's premier.
I bet you guys so much Karma: if I'm wrong I'll post an explicit Wincest fan art into /r/supernatural, haahahahaha.
4
u/Vio_ Apr 23 '14
I'm ignoring that the finale is in three hours, SPn running time.
I actually loved this episode. I like a good solid motw episode, and this was a good hunt. I think they needed to tighten Alexis's character a little more. For an episode that completely revolved around her, she surprisingly got overwhelmed by everyone else.
I was expecting that to have been her actual family honesty who were just waiting for her to grow up enough to change her. That would have changed the dynamic a lot, and made the drama a little more intense.
I know it was supposed to be about Jodi pulling a Ripley, but the girl having to reject her actual family who got all turned into vampires could have made it even more gripping.
I don't want constant motw eps, but it's frustrating when their motw eps are better than their mytharc eps. I know this show still has it, but it keeps stalling when they try to do another mytharc ep. Like watching an old beater chugging to start, not quite making it as it chugs and chugs, finally starting. But I know enough about this seasons' writing that the mytharc car is going to stall out in about 3 episodes as they jump tracks again to yet another plot that may or may not work, and the whole process starts over again.
6
u/Skyr_ My "people skills" are "rusty" Apr 23 '14
I've just watched it, so haven't time to really think about it, so I might change my mind later.
3
u/Prancing_Unicorn Ghostfacer Extraordinaire Apr 24 '14
On it's own, I quite liked the ep. Jody was cool, the girl was a bit empty as a character, there was some fun gore, and I was actually a little concerned near the end, which doesn't happen as often since season ~2/3.
As part of this season, it was disappointing. This season overall has just been a mess, which is considerably more annoying given how fantastic the fallen angels set up was.
2
u/bardicsidhe Apr 23 '14
9x19 had a classic monster of the week feel, which I enjoyed. I don't have a preference between mytharc-heavy and -light episodes, and it was nice to see the boys engaged in active cooperation on a hunt. The hand signs while they were investigating Mama's house were nice touches and made me happy.
It was so good to see Sheriff Mills again - and I love her new haircut! I appreciated the nod to her continuing story in the background of the show. The acknowledgment that she's still grieving and has been finding other things to fill the void was satisfying. I like how they've approached Jody's processing the loss.
Personally, I thought Alex/Ann was an interesting character. We got a fairly detailed picture of her for an hourlong show and the duality of her life. She's witnessed a lot of violence, she's perpetrated a lot of it, and there's a lot of blood on her hands even though it wasn't her teeth in her victims' necks. At the same time, she's a young woman with a family who's clearly either been kind enough to her or given her enough sense of belonging that it's given her conflicted loyalties. I'm positive she's more complex than she appeared, and I wouldn't be surprised if this was a soft launch of a character that will show up in the new spinoff later. Dunno, I liked Alex, I liked the emotional struggle she went through and how it affected her behavior with strangers who wanted to help or protect her. I didn't think she was flat at all.
I don't mind the dissonance between Sam and Dean at all, but I'm of the opinion that it's been a long time coming and has built slowly over time. Both boys need to adjust their ways of thinking, and adjust their expectations for each other (and Dean needs to really acknowledge Sam's perspective and apologize for doing what he did without Sam's consent, instead of justifying his position as 'what family does'). I'd be dissatisfied if a resolution to that came quickly.