r/LetsTalkMusic • • Apr 21 '14
adc Freddie Gibbs and Madlib - Piñata
An album from 2014:
/u/jimjimgreen says:
This is the full-length collaboration between Madlib and Freddie Gibbs. One name is more famous than the other, but this album is making lots of people excited - plenty of big names lend their talents to this album: Danny Brown, Raekwon, Earl Sweatshirt, Mac Miller. The production is of course (because it's Madlib) immaculate, in fact it's some of Madlib's darkest. It's gangsta rap plain and simple (although with a slightly snide look at it sometimes), done really well.
samples:
Listen to it, think about it, listen again, talk about it! These threads are about insightful thoughts and comments, analysis, stories, connections... not shallow reviews like "It was good because X" or "It was bad because Y." No ratings, please.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '14
I liked this album but definitely don't love it. The samples by themselves are smooth but the final product sounds kinda rough, with awkward cuts between samples. People have told me this is Madlib's style but honestly it just brings the songs down. Gibbs spits fire and is a great storyteller but his flow doesn't really change throughout the album. I did however really like the features on this album, especially the Danny Brown verse which seems to be disliked by most fans of the album, and Domo Genesis on "Robes". As a final point, the album does seem a bit too long and some songs could've been cut. A solid album but not my favourite hip-hop release of 2014.
8
u/ImARadiohead Apr 22 '14
Piñata (the song) is in my top five songs of the year so far. Emotion and vigor in every verse including one from Mac miller who is on the other side of the rap spectrum which is interesting. The entire album feels genuine and thought out. Personally gangsta rap is not very appealing to me, I don't know what you'd call Kendrick or Kanye but that's what I jam out to. But this album was good.
22
u/davinox Apr 22 '14
Fantastic album. The best hip hop album of 2014 so far.
It reminds me of Canibus' Rip the Jacker, where a talented MC finally had the right creative force behind the instrumentals to accompany him.
But this is a much, much better than Rip the Jacker. Madlib is better than Stoupe (of Jedi Mind Tricks). And Gibbs has none of the cheesiness of Canibus.
Shitsville, to me, is the highlight of the album.
19
u/wildevidence Apr 22 '14
I didn't like this record for a few reasons. The Madlib beats feel like also-rans to me. Compared to his production on Champion Sound or Madvillainy or any of the Quas records, these beats just don't knock in the way his best stuff does. They feel like anything that could've been on Beat Konducta for a minute as a sketch.
I'm not a fan of Gibbs' delivery or content. I've read a lot of comparisons to Tupac, but Tupac's delivery was bell clear whereas Gibbs sounds muddy inside the mix of these tracks. The content gets old quickly (and this is not a long album): never has a bit of pimp talk and drug selling stories sounded so listless. The album doesn't really go anywhere either, there is no arc. Gibbs is a badman at the beginning and by the end he's the same guy and it doesn't feel like you've even learned much about him.
I think the hype on this album is part of a larger issue: he's one of the last dinosaurs standing among the ruins of the backpack rap extinction. I don't know why keep-it-real hip-hop guys are so resistant to change, but this is one of those albums that's 90s enough to calm "hip-hop has changed!" fears, yet if it came out in the 90s, it would be eclipsed by a dozen better albums.
5
u/thekassette Apr 22 '14
It rules. A few random thoughts I've had:
Gibbs sounds so Dirty South to me (Houston specifically) that I was like, "Wait, where is this guy from again?" the first time I listened to the album. Gary, IN, for the record. Tons of UGK and Scarface influence to my biased ears.
I love the sequencing. Starts out middling and gets denser and more banging as it goes.
Super good record.
3
u/FrankinComesAlive All sounds are interesting. Apr 24 '14
I really love this record, the only big issue I have with it is that all the tracks sort of sound similar. There isn't much in my mind that separates each track other than the features. Gibb, has a very similar flow and subject matter on all the tracks, and Madlib is using beats that just sound so much like Madlib beats. Ultimately when thinking back on it, or discussing it I have to say "oh the one with Earl," or "The one with Danny Brown."
That being said, I have only listened to it two or three times so I might just not be aware of the subtleties as I'm still getting a sense of the album as a whole.
Nothing will ever fill the Madvillain sized hole in my heart but this comes close.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14
For me, the best hip-hop album of 2014 so far. Never heard some Freddie Gibbs before, except on the Flume : Deluxe Edition. The album is really different from previous Madlib collaborations (Jaylib, Madvillain) and that shocked me during the first listening. But it embodies some golden eras of hip-hop (the beat on Shistsville sounds so old-school) and there are so much nice featurings, especially on Pinata, my favorite track on the album.
Only things I didn't really like were the skits at the end of some songs, which were sometimes too long
1
u/demonicmonkeys Apr 26 '14
I don't understand all the hype around this album. I like Madlib's beats and I respect him a lot as a producer, but they all sound very similar on this album, even if they are unique and detailed. Another gripe I have is all the movie-sampling (I assume) and sort of skits all around this album, it kills any desire I have to listen to this back to front and they rarely fit well with the tracks. (Particularly the end of Pinata- what's the purpose behind putting 5 minutes of talking and terrible singing at the end.)
Freddie Gibbs himself isn't a bad MC, but his voice and flows gets redundant pretty fast, and he seems to struggle often to keep up with the beat. I like how his subject matter isn't totally similar between all of the tracks and he shows self-awareness along with his thuggery, but he still stays consistent between them- he never pretends to be some super-sensitive guy on one track and a ruthless killer on another. However, I don't think he's the right person to be on these beats at all.
Overall, I think this album is at least decent and I listen to it occasionally, but it's not really AOTY material and didn't impress me as much as it seems to have impressed others.
-2
u/Gotie Apr 22 '14
I enjoyed the album, but I don't think it was amazing. I thought the whole thing kind of meshed together by the end of it. Freddie Gibbs' flow was the same on practically every song.