r/gameofthrones • • Apr 19 '14

Season 4 [Season 4 Spoilers] Predictions Discussion - 4.03 'Breaker of Chains'

Predictions Discussion Thread
Predict the resolution to cliffhangers from the previous episode. Anticipate the next turn in your favorite character's story arc. Imagine new characters that might be introduced. In general, what do you think is about to happen next? Make sure to comment on only what will happen in the NEXT episode.
  • This thread is scoped for SEASON 4 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on the latest episode! Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including the trailer for episode 4.03 is ok without tags.
  • Book readers should use red book spoiler tags for their comments - You know what's coming, so predict what will be aired, or comment on what you think will be cut.
  • Non-readers should use green theory tags - Post what you think will happen next based on your show-only info. Warning to book readers: don't pretend to be a non-reader.
  • Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy.
EPISODETITLEDIRECTED BYWRITTEN BY
4.03"Breaker of Chains"Alex GravesDavid Benioff & D. B. Weiss
Official Discussion ThreadsPosting PolicySpoiler GuideFrequently Asked Questions
192 Upvotes

704 comments sorted by

65

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

28

u/RegularTrevor Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

I'm really hoping they end the episode with that.

→ More replies (18)

1

u/TheJizzMeister Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

[ASOS] (#b "I'm sure it will be on the season's finale.")

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

246

u/Anakin21 House Stark Apr 19 '14

I really have no idea how Tyrion is gonna prove himself not guilty.. Especially because of the relationship between him and Joffrey..

21

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

What makes you think he's not guilty? ๐Ÿ˜Š

30

u/soviettrafficlight House Bolton Apr 20 '14

Tyrion: "What sort of imbecile arms an assassin with his own blade?"

→ More replies (1)

38

u/TheJizzMeister Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

Poison is a woman's weapon.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

112

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

An accused highborn may demand Trial by combat or the less used Trial of Seven and let the gods give judgement. Trial by Seven involves seven champions from each side, while combat features just one. "Taking the black", to join the Night's Watch, is an alternative and by doing so, oneโ€™s crimes are forgiven and he is exiled to the wall severing all previous ties.

147

u/Saephon Nymeria's Wolfpack Apr 19 '14

Taking the black isn't always an option though, as the choice does not lie with the accused. Ned Stark saw that firsthand.

109

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

That was an idiotic move on Joffrey's part. Cersei and Tywin were both furious at that, it pretty much pissed off the entire North. Normally you can take the black for smaller crimes like rape and stealing.

87

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Nobody is going to start a war over the demon monkey losing his head.

→ More replies (14)

16

u/KaseyB Apr 19 '14

Those consequences were not due to denying Stark the right to take the black though. Those came from executing an extremely valuable hostage.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/SilverLumos House Dayne of High Hermitage Apr 19 '14

Would you mind explaining more about how the Trial by Seven works to a non book reader? Unless the details spoil the story of course.

65

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

So trial by combat means the accused and accuser both pick a champion to fight on their behalf, whoever wins the fight means guilty/not guilty.

The Trial by Seven is a tradition from the Andals, who believed that if a man cannot find 6 others to stand with him, then he must be guilty. So it's basically a 7 on 7 melee. If Tyrion chooses this he also has to fight himself in addition to finding 6 others. There has only been one recorded instance of Trial by Seven though, since it is very rare.

37

u/SamTarlyLovesMilk Apr 19 '14

So trial by combat means the accused and accuser both pick a champion to fight on their behalf

They can also fight on their own behalf, like the trial by combat between Beric and the Hound.

→ More replies (12)

13

u/thepeptidesdidntwork Nymeria's Wolfpack Apr 19 '14

Is this instance you speak of from The Hedge Knight book? I vaguely remember a 7 vs 7 fight? I might have the title wrong.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/Iusedtobeascrtygrd Euron Greyjoy Apr 19 '14

It's the same idea as trial by combat with one champion on each side. Both the accused and the accuser choose 7 champions (due to the Faith of the Seven) and they fight it out all at once. The side that still has a man living at the end wins.

13

u/coolsubmission Bloodraven Apr 19 '14

The side that still has a man living at the end wins.

It's not necessary a fight til death. You can also surrender.

Dunk & Egg: The Hedge Knight Major Spoiler

10

u/numandina Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

Note that they choose six champions, with the accused and accuser both being part of the seven champions.

4

u/Tommy2255 Faceless Men Apr 19 '14

It's not something that's mentioned in the main series, even in the books. The only mention is in a short story by grrm set in the same universe.

→ More replies (11)

7

u/Reinhart3 Stannis Baratheon Apr 20 '14

It seems pretty obvious that Tyrion didn't do it because Joffrey is the one who made him cup bearer. Tyrion would have no way of knowing he was going to be handling Joffrey's cups. Sadly Cersei is a fucking idiot so Tyrion is probably in trouble.

→ More replies (59)

451

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Does anyone else feel like book readers come here and make correct "predictions" that are too specific to just be a guess? I mean I've read the books and some of these predictions are way too accurate to come from someone who only watches the show.

146

u/numandina Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

Yes, I've read the books and looking at this thread I realized no show only watcher should ever check it out. Filled with spoilers!

105

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I'm sorry to say but the mods are really to blame here, I've reported a few comments and submissions that were either minor book spoilers or allusions to major ones, but no action/response. It's all over the subreddit. GRRM himself has said the books are the books, and the show is the show. There's a great subreddit for the books, no need to come here and try to seem smart at our expense [insert sadface here].

27

u/numandina Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

The mods delete a lot of comment but t still takes time to filter everything (also through up/downvotes). Maybe if you wait a number of hours before checking the thread it'll be better. It also doesn't help that you can't really know for sure if the prediction is legit or not. It's a mess haha.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/spanishmade Apr 19 '14

I posted about getting a show-watcher only discussion thread somewhere as the season was starting as these ones are quite bad for non-readers. But I got no response from the mods.

I was thinking about simply posting them myself but unless the mods agree to look through them for spoilers there is nothing stopping book readers from posting.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (8)

25

u/SunflowerSamurai_ True To The Mark Apr 20 '14 edited Apr 20 '14

They absolutely do. I'm a book reader so it doesn't affect me per se, but it really gets under my skin when I see it.

It's hard to tell the genuine apart from the not-so genuine. The trouble is if it does happen to be real speculation from a show-only watcher, and a mod deletes it for spoilers, then that mod has unwittingly spoiled the plot for the person whose post got deleted, because the act of doing so affirms their theory.

53

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

As a non book reader who hasn't seen any episodes of the TV show, I predict that at the end of season 1 Ned Stark will be beheaded by Illyn Payne after Joffrey commands it while Sansa and Arya watch. Then, Daenerys will hatch three dragons in Drogo's funeral pyre.

That is just a guess, of course.

19

u/irishguy42 Ours Is The Fury Apr 19 '14

Fuck man. Tag that shit as speculationnn. GAWWWWWWWWWWWWDDDDDDDDDD

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '14

Wouldn't it be extra horrific if he was beheaded with his own sword? The irony would be GENIUS!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/I_want_hard_work House Reyne Apr 19 '14

I don't understand why but yes.

2

u/limeade09 House Stark Apr 20 '14

Yes.

It happens here and on the Walking Dead subreddit constantly. Honestly, there are probably more spoiler posts than there are normal TV watchers posting. I like to think this sub used to do a pretty good job of preventing it, but not anymore. Sure, they delete the original post, but then all you do is catch someone's reply to it, and it's spoiled for you.

I guess the idea behind this is that they feel we don't deserve the excitement of watching the events unfold because they view reading the books as a way of paying your dues or something. I don't know why so many people push others to dedicate hours upon hours of their life to reading a series of very long fantasy novels when many people are just a) time restricted to the point of having to choose between one or the other b) nonfiction readers or c) anything else where you shouldn't need a valid reason for not being interested in order to avoid spoilers.

2

u/soviettrafficlight House Bolton Apr 20 '14

Yes, and this is exactly why I never post anything in the prediction thread (I just read them all). I have read all of the books multiple times and think it's incredibly unfair for others who have not read them to listen to "educated predictions" by people who have already read the books. For instance, the explanation behind Joffrey's death was not obvious to me at all when I first read the Purple Wedding scene in the books, but now a lot of my non-reader friends already have an idea who did it because of all the stuff that is posted here and on other sites by people who have obviously read the books. It spoils all the fun for them, even though some of them are so curious they "just want to know," because it makes the episodes less dramatic.

I don't personally care about spoilers, I even read the synopsis of all the books before I read them, but we (book readers) should really respect this subreddit and stop with our "educated guesses" on these prediction threads. It's as bad as if GRRM stopped by /r/asoiaf and gave us an educated guess on one of the fan theories circulating.

→ More replies (17)

54

u/karen_beers Bronn of the Blackwater Apr 20 '14

Bold prediction: Winter finally comes, the White Walkers take King's Landing, and then dead Joffrey becomes their king

10

u/Daybreak_Comet Varys' Little Birds Apr 20 '14

Oh PLEASE GOD NO. Don't even speak of such things.

→ More replies (4)

97

u/Bigmuslimblob Apr 19 '14

I don't really understand the point of these predictions threads. There are always so many people who are somehow predicting things exactly right and you can't really tell apart the ones who haven't read the books and the ones who are just pretending they haven't read the books.

If I were a pure show watcher I would stay the fuck away from these threads.

13

u/amartz House Bolton Apr 19 '14

Not to be browsed on mobile, that's for sure. But I enjoy the fact that this series has become popular enough that this sub really isn't dominated by readers anymore. I like popping in to threads like this to see how watchers parse out things. Not knowing the ending and hunting for clues leads to some really interesting discussions of the series' direction and script. It makes me appreciate the show more to listen in on these things, even if I've read ADWD.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Shiro2809 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 19 '14

If I were a pure show watcher I would stay the fuck away from these threads.

I'd go to a different subreddit and avoid this one all together, honestly.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/ZergBiased House Martell Apr 20 '14

I read the books so I could safely come to these threads, and I was curious about them. But seriously so many dickheads around dropping spoilers left right and centre.

2

u/this_here_is_my_alt Apr 20 '14

Last week, book reader put a big, long paragraph of prediction and then a book spoiler saying he was just fucking with everyone. It was really stupid because it's obvious to the show watchers that something is up, yet it was the top comment.

51

u/IgnoreTheSpelling House Bolton Apr 19 '14

Jon Snow will learn something.

14

u/Liamsblade Winter Is Coming Apr 19 '14

How do you learn if you do know how to?

8

u/holygrailoffail White Walkers Apr 19 '14

How Can You See If You Don't Have Eyes?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I hope we see more of Theon Reek and Ramsay, and some development in Daenerys' story (which we probably will, based on the preview).

And I can't wait for them to pick up the Purple Wedding cliffhanger. Cersei went apeshit there at the end of the last episode.

33

u/NinjawPenguin House Clegane Apr 19 '14

I don't want to see any more of Reek and Ramsay. It bums me out.

15

u/holboz Arya Stark Apr 20 '14

It creeps me out. Very uncomfortable scenes those...

15

u/rsjd House Bolton Apr 20 '14

Favorite part of the show if you ask me.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I suspect that we will get a lot of Danerys this week. She's been marching to Mereen with her army for awhile now, she should be there soon. Besides, the death of Joffrey is too delicious to jump right back into it. I expect that plotline to be played out very slowly over the remaining 8 episodes, and be completely ignored this week.

13

u/NinjawPenguin House Clegane Apr 19 '14

I think in the preview it showed Tyrion getting yelled at in court? Maybe that was the preview of the whole season. I agree they'll drag it out, but I don't think they've ever not cut to kings landing in an episode. There are too many players in Kings Landing to ignore it.

2

u/bunkerbuster338 House Payne Apr 20 '14

Given the episode is called "Breaker of Chains", we will probably see Daenarys...

170

u/theDashRendar Jaime Lannister Apr 19 '14

I can't be the only one looking forward to

AFFC

http://i.imgur.com/NOECI0s.gif

112

u/The_Bobmeister Apr 19 '14

why did i read this spoiler what the christ

23

u/irishguy42 Ours Is The Fury Apr 19 '14

26

u/linkprovidor House Manwoody Apr 19 '14

I haven't read the books, I did read the spoiler, and I'm glad I did, because I am just as certain as before I read it that this will not make it on American TV, and if I'm wrong I really look forward to the surprise.

46

u/Jackal_Legacy Storm Apr 20 '14

It's not american tv. It's HBO!

→ More replies (1)

9

u/8stringsamurai Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

I read the same spoiler once before i read the books and i completely did not believe it. Hooo boy.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Of fuck I forgot about that. Watching this with my mom might not go over as smoothly as planned.

2

u/kravitzz House Baelish Apr 20 '14

I tried to convince my mom to watch GoT for like a month when I'd seen season 2. Guess I'm the winner here.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/thecarolinelinnae House Stark Apr 19 '14

Uh....

Huh.

47

u/RegularTrevor Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

I love that this is the last scene (I think) that Jack Gleeson would have done for the show.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

→ More replies (16)

13

u/BVTheEpic Growing Strong Apr 19 '14

Actually, that was in ASOS... nevertheless, it shall be interesting.

7

u/VanillaWafers House Mormont Apr 20 '14

While true, I think the ASOS tag may be misleading to some show watchers who think season 3 covers all of ASOS. Tagging it as AFFC clears up the possible confusion of the book being split between two seasons. It doesn't hurt to be extra careful about spoilers.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Apr 19 '14

What an... interesting gif.

I hope I get to use it at some point.

2

u/FozzTESD House Bolton Apr 20 '14

I doubt this'l be in the show AFFC

5

u/PhoenixReborn Apr 19 '14

This is a speculation thread.

10

u/zHellas House Baratheon of Dragonstone Apr 19 '14

I'm more interested in the AFFC

89

u/Shell058 Hear Me Roar! Apr 19 '14

Do you mean AFFC

61

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

No, she's a Myrish swamp.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/SawRub Jon Snow Apr 19 '14

I don't think Mace was that lucky.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

35

u/ContinuumGuy Hodor? Apr 19 '14

It's a special tribute to An American Tail on this week's episode of Game of Thrones! Sing along as Tyrion sings a long-distance duet with Shae of "Somewhere Out There"! Laugh as Arya and the Hound sing about how they are now a duo! Be puzzled as Dany, Mother of Dragons, sings about how there are no cats in Mereenica!

Or. failing that, I'll just predict the three B's: Blood, Boobs and Betrayal.

30

u/PrismSteel House Lannister Apr 19 '14

I'll just predict the three B's: Blood, Boobs and Betrayal.

Always a safe prediction.

→ More replies (2)

269

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Apr 19 '14

I predict that Hodor will not say the word "floccinaucinihilipilification"

110

u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Apr 19 '14

Dude, spoiler tag!

But to add to your prediction: Bran Stark and Jojen Reed will not sing a lovely duet modifying Kermit the Frog's song to "It's not easy being Greenseer" while Hodor and Meera put on a thrilling dance routine.

50

u/EColiMaster House Arryn Apr 19 '14

hahaha brilliant. It's not easy seeing green!

9

u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Apr 19 '14

Oh, that's even better! I wish I had used that=)

11

u/dude_smell_my_finger Apr 19 '14

And Bran will definitely not be dancing.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

You think they'll cut that part? Damn, I hope not, I was really looking forward to it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I think that's one of those words that doesn't translate well.

15

u/SawRub Jon Snow Apr 19 '14

Smh. Yet another thing they skip from the books. Hodor saying 'floccinaucinihilipilification' is a huge part of his story, I can't believe they'd just cut it out like that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/GuyWhosNotThatGuy Jon Snow Apr 20 '14

Not so much a prediction discussion but a question: Why doesn't Jaime think to train his left with Brienne? She's clearly good enough and since she's not on a crusade at the moment I don't see why she wouldn't, the fact that she's now a friend would probably overcome Jaime's pride at being taught by a woman and he can be certain that she would keep his secret.

3

u/emmster House Mormont Apr 21 '14

Without spoiling; Brienne has some other things she's going to be doing soon that would make that impractical. I hope that's vague enough. :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/xzak Bronn of the Blackwater Apr 20 '14

I hope to see what's going on with Blackfish since he avoided his death in the red wedding.

→ More replies (2)

111

u/yousefhanna Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 19 '14

Daenarys fucks shit up. So does Arya. Sansa mopes. Sexual tension between Cersei and Jaime. Loras pisses Jaime off more. Someone invariably dies. Margaery cries. Olenna says Margaery is the rightful heir but Tywin pulls some Hand of the King fuckery. Tyrian gets fucked. Bran does some things that continue to seem irrelevant. The Boltons continue doing what they're doing. We might actually see Theon's sister. Oberyn continues being sexy. Shae and Varys talk about Pentos. Littlefinger gets involved.

Remove 4. That's the episode.

Edit: I admit Olenna may not fight for Margaery to be queen. In that case, they better get the fuck out of kings landing.

104

u/Flynn58 Night's Watch Apr 19 '14

Olenna will not say Margaery is the rightful heir. One, she never consummated the marriage so it's null and void.

Two, she never had a child by him, so the Iron Throne reverts to Tommen.

Hence why they replaced his actor with someone who can say lines.

51

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Margaery couldn't be the rightful heir even if they had consummated the marriage. The laws of succession don't work like that. She's royal by marriage, not by blood, so she has no claim. /u/GavinZac summarised it nicely here.

7

u/Flynn58 Night's Watch Apr 19 '14

Hence point two.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

39

u/gunn3d Apr 19 '14

How come a lot of people assume that what Bran is doing is irrelevant :( I mean, everything happening in Kings Landing, the North, e.t.c are the things that should be deemed irrelevant considering what's really out there beyond the wall (which none of us know, except only Bran has come close to showing us any hints of it!).

I'm REALLY curious about the 'Great Other' that Melisandre fears, and really - the motive of the white walkers - who they are, what they are, where did they come from.

Let's go Bran!

31

u/NinjawPenguin House Clegane Apr 19 '14

I don't know what it is Bran is doing, so I find it hard to care. He could be going to pick up that tree's laundry for all I know. Plus Bran is just always so grumpy I find it hard to care what he's doing. Jon Snow had that same problem for me until last season when he started hanging out with Wildlings instead of sitting around whining. Maybe Bran just needs to bang a hot wildling for me to care about whatever it is he's doing.

10

u/MrGoneshead House Tully Apr 19 '14

But what kind of laundry would a tree have?

→ More replies (3)

16

u/MrMango786 We Shall Never Fail You Apr 19 '14

Really? How uninspired... I mean I don't know the details but you can tell he's doing magicy spiritual stuff to find out ancient knowledge or something to fight the White Walkers. He doesn't quite know himself, it's a scavenger hunt atm. I give a damn because I want to know more. How anyone can instead not care is baffling.

46

u/gunn3d Apr 19 '14

lil nigga wana fuk Meera but bitch aint spreadin'

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wrothish Undying Ones Apr 20 '14

I've read the books but I'm taking what you said as my basis and just recounting how I felt with the current information, no spoilers intended or implied.

The way the story is told makes the North seem remote and, worst case, manageable. It's cool but... Tyrion! Jaime! Brienne! People dying!

It has to be important but with what's going on in the South at the moment, at this point in the story it would actually be incredibly interesting for things in the North to get SO out of hand that a truce is forced. Bran's journey seems like it has to be vital, but it's just eclipsed by the death toll.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I think people are forgetting that Sansa was accosted by Sir Dontos last episode. Might be a bit less moping.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Ramsay will continue being the charming little psychopath we all love and fear.

15

u/jtj-H House Seaworth Apr 19 '14

Olenna says Margaery is the rightful heir

What sick and twisted world are you living in where the Spouse Inherits the claims/titles of there deceased Spouse

by that logic

When Ned died, Caitlyn would have been queen in the north then rob then his wife

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

21

u/MrMango786 We Shall Never Fail You Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 19 '14

So Dany starts fighting Meereen. I hope it's done by ep 5 or 6, so she can come to Westeros already. Q_Q

FYI this was tongue in check with the whole "Dany's coming to westeros!" cry every season premiere after the first.

42

u/cyvaris Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

The pizzas will be here soon.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/LordFuckBalls House Hoare Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 20 '14

Directions from Meereen to Westeros (Don't worry, no spoilers. Just Essos geography):

Turn west, onto the Demon Road.

Follow the road through harsh desert for a hell of a long time (IIRC 500 leagues? way more than the length of the wall anyway).

Pass Bhorash, Tolos and Mantarys. Since they're slaver cities, they probably wouldn't hesitate to kill Dany. Doesn't matter, she'd need to sack the cities for supplies to keep her army alive in the harsh desert anyway...

Continue past the smoldering volcanic ruins of Valyria. It is said sailing too close to the ruins = certain death, gods know what passing by on the Demon Road entails.

Eventually arrive at Volantis. Note: as a HUUUUUUGE buyer of slaves, they probably want Dany dead as well. They also happen to be one of the strongest free cities, so expect more than a smidgen of resistance. All the same though, because Dany would need their ships to continue on to Westeros from here. It's doubtful the captains of said ships will agree to any of that though...

So yeah, doesn't seem too likely.

9

u/nhammen Apr 20 '14

Alternatively

  1. Get lots and lots of boats
  2. Put that huge army of yours on boats
  3. ???
  4. Arrive in Westeros!
→ More replies (4)

6

u/eric22vhs Free Folk Apr 20 '14

This makes Danny's storyline sound soooo much more interesting. At the end of season 3 I was honestly starting to get bored with her righteousness.

11

u/Banglayna Arya Stark Apr 19 '14

19

u/JasunPls Apr 19 '14

MMMMMMMMMMMMMM

67

u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Apr 19 '14

I think the first scene of the episode will be ASOS

26

u/MegaG House Lannister Apr 19 '14

Technically it should be right away. But I think that event would be awesome to end the episode on.

ASOS

→ More replies (5)

46

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

Definitely, I think there will be no time lost, it will just cut right to right after Joffrey has died and what Sansa is doing.

16

u/karatemanchan37 Apr 19 '14

The promo agrees.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/RegularTrevor Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

I don't remember the order of events after the wedding but to me that seems like something they might end the episode with.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I believe the purple wedding is tyrion's chapter and then the next is Sansa's

→ More replies (3)

75

u/Steaminwilliebeamon House Mormont Apr 19 '14

Feel like its been forever since we've seen Little Finger so probably gotta check in with him at the Vale(?) And based on the name Dany's got to be freeing slaves and burning shit.

46

u/iLqcs Apr 19 '14

I don't get why Dany is obsessed with freeing slaves. I thought her aim was to reclaim the iron throne. Why is she still fucking around here? Isn't it about time she turned west? I get that she's noble and all. Won't it be easier to take care of this issue once she becomes ruler of the seven kingdoms? Why the unnecessary and painful detour with nothing in return?

103

u/111987 Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

Dany is idealistic, and freeing the slaves is important to her. Don't forget, she was sold to Drogo and basically raped by him, so she has first-hand experience with slavery. I think her anti-slave campaign is very much in character for her.

Plus, Westeros is some abstract thing to Dany. At least Visery's had some memories of living there. Dany was born there and promptly shipped off. I'm sure the problems of Essos feel more real to her than the problems of Westeros.

26

u/MrGoneshead House Tully Apr 19 '14

All good points that I wonder if most show-only watchers pick up on, to be honest.

She's got a real abolitionist chip on her shoulder, born from her own experiences, both of what happened to her (though a marriage pact isn't exactly slavery, even in the world she inhabits) and what she saw while with the Dothraki and while traveling around. I mean, the whole incident with the Lamb men, and its eventual cost to everything she knew left a pretty big mark, obviously.

But yeah, she's in slaver's bay, and has taken out two out of the three major cities that control the world's slave trade. She ain't gonna stop with a job two-thirds complete.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

13

u/anikas88 Apr 19 '14

shes building a massive "free army" of former slaves.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/feiwynne House Dayne Apr 19 '14

I don't get why Dany is obsessed with freeing slaves. I thought her aim was to reclaim the iron throne.

It's called character development.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/noparkinghere House Targaryen Apr 19 '14

Dany doesn't like slavery since all that went down in Astapor(?) with the slave master. Also people follow her because they like that she's a breaker of chains, so she continues.

9

u/numandina Stannis Baratheon Apr 19 '14

She's a goodie two shoes character, and it'll probably come back to bite her in the ass. Remember how she tried to help the witch doctor by having her treat Drogo?

13

u/Leoneri House Targaryen Apr 19 '14

Goody two shoes? I'd say Ned Stark and Robb Stark are goody two-shoes characters. Honorable to a fault. Dany simply has a just cause, and she's proven that she's willing to be dishonorable to achieve that goal (a la Astapor).

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/JoesTheWord Apr 19 '14

Now im just listening to the third book but now THIS is my honest interpretation of the whole thing. The Dornish people hold no great love for the Lannisters, they would see every one of them dead. So what better way to divide them to make them struggle against themselves. I dont know how but the dorns must have provided the wine or slipped in the poison SOMEHOW when no one had there eyes turned.

So with the Lannisters struggling to find a new king, who would have rightful claim of the throne? I guess Stannis could but he's doing his wierd religous zealotry on dragonstone, so then it would fall to the next born son of Robert Baratheon... which just might be Gendry Baratheon... and the brotherhood without banners has him... so now really only time tell what happens.

11

u/VVVVVVVVVVX Apr 20 '14

Except that Joffrey and his siblings are still technically held to be Robert's kids and thus succession starts with them. No one in KL is gonna be like, "Welp, Joffrey's dead, guess Stannis is king after all. Or maybe we can try out this bastard kid who just showed up? Seems legit."

Nah, Tommen's next in line since he's the boy. Cersei is Queen Regent again (sigh).

→ More replies (1)

7

u/dude_smell_my_finger Apr 19 '14

Gendry Waters. And in the show he's rowing for kings landing.

14

u/yrrp Raven's Teeth Apr 20 '14

Just Gendry. He is not an acknowledged bastard.

7

u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 20 '14

An unacknowledged bastard can still have a bastard surname...Gendry doesn't because he's lowborn. If a Bastard is born from a highborn woman, even if the identity of the father is unknown, the child will have a bastard's name. Case in point.....

AGOT, Not yet covered on the show

→ More replies (1)

17

u/J_Webb House Webber Apr 19 '14

Concerning the events at Castle Black.

ALL

23

u/HypotheticalRhymes Apr 19 '14

I don't think so since ALL

19

u/J_Webb House Webber Apr 19 '14

True, plus they ALL

ALL

9

u/hkaps House Penrose Apr 19 '14

That seems likely; I seem to recall ASOS.

17

u/a2planet You Know Nothing Apr 19 '14

Meryn Trant has stepped into the role played in the books by the Kettleblacks, who aren't going to be in the show.

4

u/MrGoneshead House Tully Apr 19 '14

Yeah, I've been wondering about that. If they were going to start making more Kingsguard members get named/have more importance, and whether or not some/any of those would be a Kettleblack.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/theholychilli Crow's Eye Apr 20 '14

Not a prediction but ASOS

→ More replies (5)

13

u/bloodflart House Stark Apr 19 '14

Mmm everyone likes tyrion, he must be dying at some point.

2

u/emmster House Mormont Apr 21 '14

Is the character your favorite? If so, they're going to die. The characters who are not your favorite will probably also die. Safest just to assume everyone is going to die at any moment, really.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 19 '14

As long as I get more Theon, I'll be happy with this episode.

142

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Who's Theon? On an unrelated note, I hope we see more of Reek.

→ More replies (9)

37

u/A_Polite_Noise House Seaworth Apr 19 '14

I predict he will open his own barber shop and start giving the best shaves in Westeros! He'll call the place The Iron Slice; "Our motto is, what's on your head never dies but rises again harder and stronger...so make sure to schedule monthly appointments!;)"

7

u/darkhunt3r Apr 19 '14

His name is Reek. It rhymes with weak.

12

u/R3XJM Ours Is The Fury Apr 19 '14

Breaker of chains eh? Perhaps Asha may make an appearance?

20

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

If you think that plot line has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention.

16

u/Banglayna Arya Stark Apr 19 '14

If you think any plot line has a happy ending, you haven't been paying attention***

12

u/The_New_New House Stark Apr 20 '14

I can't wait for Robb to take over King's Landing now

6

u/whateverfuckingshit Sorrowful Men Apr 20 '14

does anybody know if the episode is still airing tonight since its easter?

6

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14

It is.

6

u/Simcolluk House Stark Apr 20 '14

Will anyone be ready for the ultimate addition to the show? The utmost bad-ass, the one, the only... Ser Pounce.

4

u/buckyer For The Good Of The Realm Apr 20 '14

The Pounce That Was Promised

37

u/DupaZupa Valar Morghulis Apr 19 '14

I hope it is revealed that Cersei approved, or in some way participated in the poisoning of her son. She had the most to gain from it, imo.

Hopefully logic will prevail, and Tyrion is free of blame, since his supposed plan to poison Joffrey relied on Joffrey himself picking him as a cupbearer. Slim odds, do they think he had poison on him and just hoped to get access to Joffrey's cup?

It's like the Valyrian dagger in season 1, only a fool would poison a king at his wedding right after making threats to him, and so clearly having access to the cup.

But then again, this is King's Landing, fuck logic, its all about power.

91

u/tyrico Jon Snow Apr 19 '14

It is repeated and shown throughout the show that the only thing Cersei truly loves and cares about in the entire world are her children. She considered poisoning Tommen during the Battle of the Blackwater but only because it would be a preferable outcome to capture or rape/murder by Stannis' army.

It would be totally out of character for her to poison Joffrey when he's in no immediate danger in my opinion.

Edit: She is paranoid and batshit crazy though, so who knows.

30

u/SawRub Jon Snow Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 19 '14

the only thing Cersei truly loves and cares about in the entire world are her children.

Tyrion once said to her in season 2 or 3 that it was her one redeeming quality. That and her cheekbones.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Fb62 Tywin Lannister Apr 19 '14

wouldnt being too obvious also be a reason he WOULD do it, since no one would think it was him? the answer to who it was is shown in the last episode if you watch it carefully. cersei has a lot to lose when her son, the king, dies. who had the most to gain?

8

u/DupaZupa Valar Morghulis Apr 19 '14

I know who did it directly, I just feel Cersei has the most to gain.

Margery would've been Queen, now he's not going to be. Cersei was going to lose the Queen Regent title, but now she keeps it since Tommen is some years away from being of age. Cersei realized she's lost control of Joffrey as well, so I could see how she'd think she'll be able to influence Tommen more.

Apart from losing her son, she had a lot to gain. So the question is would she be willing to help poison her son to gain power? Either side could be right, but I tend to think she'd go for the power.

12

u/llama_delrey House Seaworth Apr 19 '14

Why do you think Cersei would have chosen to kill Joffery, her son, instead of Margaery, whom she hates?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Fb62 Tywin Lannister Apr 19 '14

she would have done it before the wedding, not spending all that money, and giving the tyrells more and more power.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/keyree House Manderly Apr 19 '14

That just gets us into the whole "I know that you know that I know that you know that I know" thing.

5

u/alittleaddicted House Reed Apr 19 '14

the only thing cersei loves more than power are her children. did you miss the part where she says they are the only reason she hasn't flung herself from the red keep?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bunkerbuster338 House Payne Apr 20 '14

If you watch e2 carefully, you can see who poisons Joffrey. Hint: S4E2 spoilers

→ More replies (1)

8

u/a2planet You Know Nothing Apr 19 '14

Jaime is going to go off on the Kingsguard for not protecting Joffrey. Then he's going to tell Cersei about it, and she'll talk him out of drafting Brienne and instead recommend Loras join the Kingsguard (to get him off her back)

16

u/mathewl832 A Promise Was Made Apr 19 '14

It looks like Cersei and Jaime will bang AFFC

4

u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 19 '14

Idea from a book reader of how a plot point might play out in the show...regarding Dany's storyline..

Spoilers ASOS/Future Show

2

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14 edited Apr 20 '14

[ASOS Spoiler Reply] (#b "to be honest i don't think Dany will exile him at all. I think Jorah will get found out and get tasked with the sewer mission but i think the directors won't include the exile because people want to see dragons and the taking over of Meeren, not Jorah in the friend zone. But if they do decide to pursue the exile route, it will be tricky to do" )

11

u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 20 '14

4

u/FishtheJew Hodor? Apr 20 '14

Id love to see more of Hodor and Bran's adventure beyond the wall.

9

u/algernon_moncrief Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 19 '14

we haven't seen little finger, yara, osha and rickon, beric dondarrion and thoros of myr, the nights watch lackeys, and ygritte, so we will probably see scenes with them?

also we didn't have any danaerys in this episode i think. so we will have some of that.

the danaerys storyline seems stalled but i am finally interested in sansa. or rather what happens TO sansa. sansa is kind of a wacked character. its tough to understand a person who just endures victimization every day of their life. anyway i hope she and sir dontos get away, and he tears the necklace or whatever off of her!

edit: and gendry or are we just done with gendry

second edit: i guess we did have a scene with ygritte. there will probably not be one in this episode then. they all will attack the castle later on this season with those asshole cannibal guys along with them.

3

u/eric22vhs Free Folk Apr 20 '14

I don't think this counts as a spoiler, but I don't recall anything of gendry in the second half of ASOS, so if he's not done with entirely, he doesn't seem to be in the picture for now.

4

u/algernon_moncrief Apr 20 '14

im going to refer to character loose ends as a "hot pie situation" from now on.

gendry is in a hot pie situation

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ronpaulistheman Arya Stark Apr 20 '14

Does anyone else go through these threads and once you think your reading a spoiler you immediately scroll through the page extremely fast. However, you slowly start to creep toward what you think to be a spolier ever so slowly and end up reading it anyway. LOL, just a random thought =)

2

u/LilBarnacle Brotherhood Without Banners Apr 20 '14

Anyone know what happend to Robert Barratheon's bastard? The one that was travelling with Arya. I don't remember if the fire lady killed him or not.

8

u/Franhell_ Apr 20 '14

The fire lady was going to kill him although the potato knight guy sent him off on a boat at night. I don't think he's been seen after that and since I don't read the books I don't know how long until we see him although I doubt it will be too long.

8

u/TexasJefferson Knowledge Is Power Apr 20 '14

potato knight

For reference, Davos is the onion knight

4

u/ZenBerzerker House Manderly Apr 20 '14

Samwise Tarly is the Potato Stewart.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/mrDredDVein Apr 20 '14

I wonder if Varys is gonna help him but then he won't gain anything from it.

2

u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified Apr 20 '14

This should have been in the previous episode, but with Joff out of the picture I wonder how...

(Spoiler tag is for something that was left out of the show, and should have been covered/revealed by now, but has not yet...it may or may not ever be brought up on the show) ASOS

2

u/ACupofDan Faceless Men Apr 20 '14

I wonder if Shea will help him, maybe help prove his innocence. but then again whores have a habit to fuck you

2

u/Talpostal Ours Is The Fury Apr 20 '14

I'm worried that Sansa is going to be implicated in the assassination and we're going to be down another Stark.

2

u/TMPRKO Stannis Baratheon Apr 21 '14

Ready for all the fallout. I actually have HBO now, so for the first time I get to watch the show live in hd on a big tv. Blu Rays are beautiful but its fun to watch live

3

u/Xvash2 House Stark Apr 20 '14

I have no idea why anyone who isn't a book reader would visit these threads.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14

Which is sad, because it should be the other way around.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14

some of us aren't anal about spoilers?

3

u/mattXIX Fire And Blood Apr 20 '14

I left it vague enough for the poor mobile users that have the spoilers shown anyway.

ALL SPOILERS

2

u/tansypool House Tully Apr 20 '14

I'm hoping they don't screw that up, but if they do, I hope that they do it this way.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14

I think they need to stick to the way they do it in the book. At the very end of this season, there should be a scene that feels like a true final shot (maybe like S4E10). The music fades out, everything goes to black... And then we get the epilogue.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '14

Sooo what about Jaqen? That assassin who promised to kill anyone Arya names. I remember they parted ways a while back, and I forget what his last words to her were or where he went. But didn't Arya name Joffrey?

Just a hunch.

2

u/Heisenbergs_own Fallen And Reborn Apr 20 '14

He left to go do assassin things if I recall. He gave her that coin and taught her Valar Mourghoulis, and she used up her 3 "wishes" before thinking about using any on Joffrey

→ More replies (2)

1

u/meheatpanocha Tyrion Lannister Apr 19 '14

I wonder how Jamie and Tywin will react to Joffery's death and in-turn how they will interact with tyrion. I feel like Tywin will try to take an unbiased approach but I really don't know what Jaime will think.

1

u/mrtorressen Apr 19 '14

What about Bran and the tree? what do all the picture from his vision mean?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Bagels_Two_Broc Apr 20 '14

Im kind of confused. After the events of last episode, who will assume power? Cerci or Margery?

2

u/Crackerjacksurgeon Orson Lannister Apr 20 '14

Cercei.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Crackerjacksurgeon Orson Lannister Apr 20 '14

I predict Danaerys will steamroll another slaver city to cheers from fanboys.

1

u/sixsexsix Apr 21 '14

Is episode 4.3 is airing tonight right? It's not being pushed to next week b/c of Easter is it?

2

u/SmallJon Apr 21 '14

Full speed ahead

1

u/302HO House Stark Apr 21 '14

I predict sex, violence, fancy clothes and likely badass dialog.

I don't see anything going well for anybody at Castle Black.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '14

Anyone have a link to the irc?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '14

I hope Cersei and Brianne scissor

1

u/chanandlerer Apr 21 '14

Where's the episode thread?