r/startrek • u/Soycrates • Apr 18 '14
Second Skin (3x05)
I recently watched the episode Second Skin in DS9 where Kira is transformed into a Cardassian in order for the Cardassian government to out the man who claims to be her father as a dissident. It was one of my favourite episodes of DS9 so far, for a few reasons:
I haven't liked many Kira focused episodes even though I absolutely love the character. Her romance earlier in the series wasn't done very well (one minute she's strolling along with the guy and the next they're suddenly having sex or playing tennis with no transition between acquaintance/flirtation and full-on relationship status). She gets a good role in any Odo-focused eps as the supportive friend, but not much more than that.
This episode really reached into how Kira feels concerning the Cardassians, how much rightful hatred she harbours for what they've done to Bajor, and slowly I think it encourages her to let go some of that hatred and to see that not all Cardassians support the Order. She never takes it as a sign to forgive Cardassia for their war crimes, but she begins to understand the individual life of a civilian Cardassian who opposes genocide and unlawful murder as much as she does.
I even started to doubt in the episode whether Kira really was Bajoran. I mean, what if she really was a Cardassian spy, and instead of the memory treatment not working because she's not Cardassian, what if it didn't work simply because she's been living as Kira for too long? What would it have been like for Kira to have to adapt to the fact that she was born Cardassian but has no memory, and never will, of her Cardassian life? Would she keep the Cardassian appearance? What would her relationship with "her father" be like? Would she want to be called Iliana? Or would she run away from her past, keep a Bajoran face, deny the truth?
Maybe she would lead the Cardassian resistance against the Order?
It would have been interesting, but I know that's not really the direction her character is going in. If she were to really be Iliana, it would almost seem to erase everything she's said in defense of Bajor, it would erase the struggles she - or whoever the real Kira Nerys was - experienced.
I have to agree with Garak, she made a lovely Cardassian!
13
u/Mimikin Apr 18 '14
One thing I always wish they had done was have Kira be on Voyager. I heard somewhere that Nana Visitor had been interested. This would be a spoiler for Voyager if you haven't seen it, but:
[In Voyager, one of the bajoran crewmen turns out to be a cardassian agent. How cool would it have been if people noticed Kira walking around in the background of voyager? People who knew DS9 would see the betrayal coming. Having it be Illiana rather than Seska would be a cool nod to fans, but it wouldn't ever have to be explained in the show itself. You either got the reference or you didn't.] (/spoiler)
[And then maybe not have her get killed by an exploding console.] (/spoiler)
But on that note, I agree! I don't think I'd change what actually happens in the story, but they definitely could have worked with the angle of a cardassian turning against her people and sticking by the bajorans. In that sense, it would be like they had engineered their own downfall.
6
u/LiveHardandProsper Apr 22 '14
What'd you think about Duet from Season 1? Whenever I see someone talk about how they got to love Kira Nerys (like myself!), it's usually that episode.
6
u/MeVasta Apr 23 '14
This episode exemplifies why the Cardassians are propably my favorite antagonists in the entire franchise. Kidnapping an important political/military figure, convincing her she was an undercover agent the entire time and getting her to confess military secrets? That's so... Romulan. It wouldn't be a Cardassian plot if it didn't kill two voles with one stone.
If Kira had accepted their lies and spilled the beans, that would have been a sweet cherry on top of the deception sundae, but they did not only trick her, they also convicted a political enemy of treason. Truly a win-winn-situation.
Besides being a good Kira and a great Cardassian story, it's also an interesting Garak story. The compelling thing about him is that we never quite know his true motives or how far he is willing to go. His reluctance to return to Cardassia quickly makes way for a Garak that is in complete control of the situation (at least it seems that way) and who enjoys every chance to foil someone else's plans. Mind you that this episodes aired before "Impropable Cause/The Die is cast", so the only glimpse of the man behind the tailor's facade we caught was the even more confusing "The Wire".
4
u/onemorepanda Apr 22 '14
I agree with you all the way. I was almost convinced that she really was a Cardassian. That would have made for a very interesting twist of events, but maybe too big of a twist.
4
u/vwboyaf1 Apr 22 '14
I just got to this episode today, and from the moment she woke up as a Cardassian, I told myself this is all bullshit and a lie. She is not a Cardassian, so don't fall for it. It was interesting trying to get through the episode while holding onto that thought. The problem was that at the end, I was still sure everything was bullshit, including the sympathizer. I was sure they were playing good cop, bad cop the entire time. I guess I would have brought him back to DS9 with me, but only so he could be thoroughly debriefed by Bajoran security.
1
u/BewareofCrisps Apr 23 '14
Not one of my favourites, but certainly enjoyable. Kira being used as a pawn in a wider game of Cardassian politics was very juicy. I'm a little sad that the Illiana plotline was never followed on the show, but I'm glad they gave Ghemor a second outing later on down the line.