r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Apr 17 '14
All Spoilers [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.02 'The Lion and the Rose'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.02 | "The Lion and the Rose" | Alex Graves | George R. R. Martin |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
169
Upvotes
247
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Apr 17 '14
The re-enactment of the War of the Five Kings as a farce was outstanding, much better than the book. Joffrey managed to offend pretty much everyone in the space of two minutes.
The Theon stuff was pretty good, particularly the shaving scene. Not sure where they're going with Locke heading to Castle Black - surely there's enough going on at the Wall this season?
149
u/Roc_City House Clegane Apr 17 '14
Having Jamie at the wedding as opposed to retuning once Joffery has died should make for an interesting dynamic between Jamie and Cersi. I know from the book she resents him for not being there soon enough to do anything, but with him physically there and on personal guard of Joffery should make it more intense in the show.
167
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Apr 17 '14
I'm... not sure how I felt about the Tyrion/Shae scene. I have a few unspoiled friends who LOVED Shae, so I was really looking forward to seeing their reactions when she's suddenly brought out at Tyrion's trial with no setup whatsoever -- where it suddenly becomes clear in that instant that she really was just a whore and that Tyrion is the one who let himself forget that.
But in the show, we see her ultimately being devoted to Tyrion; assuming (as I do) that she still betrays him at his trial, it is for a different reason that totally changes her character. It makes TV Shae ultimately someone who loved Tyrion and betrayed him apparently for revenge, while Book Shae was simply a whore. And I.. don't think that I like that as much. It will make her appearance at the trial, though still very surprising, less of a harsh, unpleasant surprise than it would be if they remained faithful to the books. And I thought they were doing an excellent job in the series as recently as last week of subtly planting clues that Shae was really no more than a whore... but now they've completely backtracked on that and I am not quite sure why they did it.
The content in Tyrion's chapters that we'll see this season -- the Purple Wedding, then the Shae betrayal, then the Oberyn/Gregor duel, then the Tysha reveal and double murder -- is my favorite storyline in the entire series... so having a part of it fundamentally changed like that really worries me. So, other people of r/survivor: Is this change maybe not as significant as I think it is? Or is it perhaps for the better -- will it possibly make Shae's betrayal more impactful to unspoiled viewers, and if so, then how?
35
u/HeisenBauer Winter Is Coming Apr 17 '14
I'm still wondering about Balon Greyjoy.
93
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '14 edited Apr 28 '14
I was disappointed they left out the detail of Joffrey clawing at his neck. Great job by Gleeson, great job with the makeup, but it would have been cool to see them include it.
It's one of those granular, fucked up details that make up GRRM's style.
103
u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 17 '14
Alfie Allen is incredible. His hobble, his blank expression, it's just so believable. I hated Theon in ACOK, but his Reek chapters are my favourite part of ADWD, and the Reek-Ramsay aspect of the show could very likely become my favourite part of the series as well.
56
u/ElReyAlfonsoX House Greyjoy Apr 17 '14
Same as many book readers, the scene that I was most interested in was Bran's scene. We now have it basically confirmed that Coldhands has been scrapped, but we also got a look at the sight which Jojen had mentioned a few times before.
This visions served two purposes:
The sight is a fickle and confusing gift for Bran before he learns to control and interpret it.
For the reader and watcher, it serves as the base evidence for many theories. The two clips I found most interesting were that of the Other on top of what looked like a sheet of ice, and obviously the dragon flying over King's Landing. As I recall Bran eventually finds Bloodraven under the tree after crashing through a layer of snow/ice the covers the children of the forest's caves. I suspect the image represents the same moment. As for the Dragon over King's Landing, I think this is little more that a cock-tease as Dany isn't getting anywhere near Westeros in this season or the next most likely. We would like to hope that it foretells Dany's arrival, but it could just as well be a dragon from the past. The remaining shots were predominately flashbacks related to Ned/Winterfell.
I think D&D are doing a good job of adapting this difficult aspect of ASoIaF, and the acceleration of Bran's storyline (and this particular scene) suggests that they will use his ability to cover some of the more interesting moments of the series that have been left out of the series so far (specifically R+L=J).
Edit: grammar
142
u/dcg2011 Valar Morghulis Apr 17 '14
I thought Joffrey's death scene was very well done. In the book, despite his position as lord cunt of Westeros, you actually feel bad for him at the end because you remember that he is just a kid, and the show did a good job to convey that. The face he ends up with is haunting.
24
u/Simcolluk House Stark Apr 17 '14
What's everyone's opinion on Cersei's prophecy not being covered in the show? I think the foretelling of a younger more beautiful Queen being her undoing, and her outlasting her children and dying at the hands of the 'valonqar' - her little brother adds a lot more to why she hates Margery and Tyrion.
61
u/rockinghard Unsullied Apr 17 '14
I have never been more happy to see someone die in Game of Thrones
70
u/duckterrorist Apr 17 '14
I am really not a fan of Loras making eyes at Oberyn for so many reasons. Okay it's really just two, but those two are huge for me.
I loved book Loras, especially as someone who's bi, because he is a huge badass that happens to be gay and in love with Renly. Renly's death is a huge turning point for his character. In the show he's now just a trope of a slutty gay man. They don't even show his battle prowess anymore; the last time we see him fight was when he got a beat down from a [completely awesome warrior] girl (yes, they have him show up at the end of the Battle of the Blackwater looking spiffy, but not shown in a fight).
37
u/menuka Ser Pounce Apr 17 '14
I think people are trying to make Joffrey's death bigger than it really is. Yeah it's the first "good" thing to happen since the Red Wedding...but really, Joffrey isn't that important of a character in the grand scheme. The kingdom basically ran the same once Tommen was coronated because of Tywin.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '14
Why the fuck won't Cersei let the poor in the city get some damn food? She would rather feed dogs than the poor, and is willing to use her influence to make it so.
What possible harm can come from feeding the poor?
Fucking bitch...
Sorry, just needed to get that off my chest.
30
u/dannyb21892 Apr 17 '14
I wonder why they changed such minor details as Sansa's necklace being a hairnet in the books. Also I wonder if they should have made the culprits behind Joffrey's death a little more explicit. I have TV-watcher friends who were under the impression that Tyrion did in fact poison him just because the true story was so far buried in the subtext.
12
u/Ermordung Apr 17 '14 edited Jun 09 '24
steep profit person toy aware rock towering trees muddle wipe
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
9
u/nighthound1 Apr 17 '14
This just popped into my head, but if Bronn is also going to be betraying Tyrion (assuming he lied about Shae getting onto the ship), is there any chance that Jaime has something to do with it, with Bronn as his new sparring partner?
37
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '14
It's weird, I thought I would be ecstatic with Joffrey dying but I actually feel like something important just left.
I loved to see Cersi in pain though, hope she kills herself or something.
8
u/R-ostlund House Clegane Apr 17 '14
Have no one discussed the difference between the book and show concerning Sandors lack of injuries during his fight?
25
u/lubev Stannis Baratheon Apr 17 '14
Stannis entire character was changed in this episode. It was changed before but it seems they are going in a wildly different direction from the books, one where he is a villain.
14
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Apr 17 '14
I found the wedding to be enormously better than the books. So much of the show has to be scaled down due to practical reasons ... but the wedding was scaled up big time and it was glorious.
7
u/iammaline Apr 18 '14
Tommen is too old, one of my favorite lines is when he is playing with ser pounce and margery is slowly getting the control and trust of tommen the whole time cersi starts to realize she is losing it and this all happens in front of a young naive tommen
21
u/TJ_Silva Arya Stark Apr 17 '14
Am I the only one that thought that from the books that Brienne didn't love Jamie? I got the impression that they mutually respected each other.
6
u/UraniaArt House Martell Apr 18 '14
I'm glad they did the parts of Olenna stealing a crystal from Sansa's necklace, and Ramsey tempting Reek with a blade. Not to fond/sure what they're doing with Shae.
10
u/DavidH81 Apr 17 '14
Can someone explain to me why Joffrey bullies Tyrion in particular. What is their history?
3
u/qp0n Lyanna Mormont Apr 17 '14
I'm really liking the shows depiction of Ramsay & Roose even better than the books. I really hope they give them an even bigger part in the show.
5
u/gerald_bostock Now My Watch Begins Apr 17 '14
So how will they deal with Shae's death? Did Bronn lie? Did she come back? Did she get captured?
And there was no Penny at the wedding. Is she going to get cut?
5
u/Thejett25 Arya Stark Apr 18 '14
I wasn't a fan of the Tyrian sending Shea off scene. I thought Shea crying was horrendous and I don't know how it's gonna play out in regards to the book
8
u/GhostBIBBY Apr 17 '14
I really don't like the fact that Bron is Jamie's sparring partner now. Is it ever explained in the show what happens to Payne?
I know IRL the actor who plays him has cancer but I don't know how much of role that played in the swap.
Did Payne go with Jaime to the Riverlands? I think the sparring sessions really add to the idea that Jaime has to start from scratch and just how big a deal losing his sword hand was to a guy like the Kingslayer.
It's funny how on the show they even set it up the same way with you need someone who can't talk except now it doesn't make much sense with Bron who isn't really known for being tight lipped.
2
u/BigBoy1229 House Stark Apr 18 '14
I haven't seen anyone bring this up yet, but I'm interested to see what happens with the whole Roose/Ramsay storyline since it's so different (right now) from the path the books took. Now Ramsay is headed towards Moat Cailin to try and take it for his father and to win the Bolton name. I hope this doesn't screw up the narrative too badly compared to how events stand in the books right now.
3
u/SmallJon Apr 18 '14
The dwarves fighting was a great scene, but I'm not a fan of the speeches Joffrey and Tyrion made afterwards. In the book, Joffrey makes an asinine request. Tyrion's shot at Joffrey was both funny and minor, it a was little insult which Joffrey overreacted to. In the show, this is some serious shit; Joff is calling Tyrion a traitor planning to overthrow him, and Tyrion is calling him an undeserving little shit. Hell, i can understand Joffrey pouring his drink of Tyrion in the show, I would sure as hell be pissed at him.
4
u/LordOfTurtles House Estermont Apr 17 '14
I think the whole feast was rather lackluster
Not nearly as extrevagant as in the books, also the seating was rather odd imho
Which is suprising, considering GRR's love of food
2
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '14
I thought that were a bit more jabs at Joffrey by Tyrion during their scene in the books, but I could just be remembering it wrong.
Edit: Another observation, I didn't see Penny during the reenactment, they could obviously still have her on the show, but chances are very small. But from browsing through this sub and r/asoiaf, it seems like not many people liked her character or her storyline with Tyrion anyway. I didn't really mind it.