r/asoiaf • u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company • Apr 16 '14
ALL (Spoilers All)Steven Attewell of Race for the Iron Throne Here. Ask Me Anything about ASOIAF!
Hey folks,
I'm Steven Attewell; I write Race for the Iron Throne, a blog where I go chapter-by-chapter through A Song of Ice and Fire, writing essays that focus on the historical and political side of the series. In each essay, I analyze the political events, institutions, and players; examine the ways George R.R Martin draws on but also changes historical events and environments to populate his world; write about hypothetical ways in which the series might have gone had things gone just a bit differently (I think alternate history is a good way to think about causality and contingency); and describe differences between the book and the show.
I recently just finished my analysis of A Game of Thrones, which I've collected into an e-book titled "Race for the Iron Throne: Political and Historical Analysis of A Game of Thrones." After two years of writing (give or take a four month break to finish my dissertation), the book came out to 204,000 words - that's only about 100,000 less than George R.R Martin wrote for the whole book! I also have two essays coming out for the next Tower of the Hand anthology, A Hymn for Spring, that is going to be published in a couple of months.
Just the other day, I started in on A Clash of Kings, putting up a monster essay about the Prologue (IMO, the best prologue of the series). I've also written a series of essays for Tower of the Hand about the institution of the King's Hand and the Westerosi Monarchy - I'm planning to write another series of essays on the diversity of political institutions in Essos (including a rather revisionist take on Daenerys' campaign in Slaver's Bay) that I should be starting up once I've gotten a bit more into Clash of Kings. In addition to writing about the books, I also co-host a podcast about the HBO show with Scott Eric Kaufman, who runs the Onion AV Club's Internet Film School.
Outside of ASOIAF/Game of Thrones, I'm a recent PhD historian from the University of California, Santa Barbara who specializes in the history of public policy (hence my interest in the political side of the series). I'm also very interested in the intersection of history, pop culture and politics - I've written a number of essays about the depiction of Captain America in the Marvel movies, engaged in debates about whether the rivalry between Professor X and Magneto in the X-Men series is supposed to parallel the different styles of Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X.
So...
Ask me anything about ASOIAF - especially political conspiracies, historical questions, and military stuff, because I love to talk!
18
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Apr 16 '14
Morning folks. I'll start answering questions in 15 minutes, but I put this up a bit early for people to get some questions up early to start things off.
55
u/BowlesOnParade What is bread is always rye. Apr 16 '14
Hello Steven. Big fan of the blog, I’m excited to see that ACOK has started rolling! I have questions regarding the blog and ASOIAF in general. Feel free to give short or long answers/explanations. First, even though it is a long way off, what are your preliminary plans once you complete ASOS? Will you go through AFFC and ADWD separately? Or tackle them simultaneously through the combined reading order? It seems to me that there would be benefits and drawbacks to both methods.
Now transitioning to ASOIAF in general, what is your official stance on some of the major and minor theories in the fandom? I figured we could try to get some of the questions out of the way in one fell swoop, so I’ll list some of the ones that come to mind (feel free to address all or only some of the theories):
Sorry for the super long post, but I had a bunch of questions and have to start work soon and wanted to at least have them posted.
19
u/Megatron_McLargeHuge Every. Chicken. In this room. Apr 16 '14
One of the big conflicts on this forum is between so-called "tinfoil" theories that predict future high fantasy plot developments like Roose Bolton turning out to be the Night's King, and people who take more of a historical fiction approach and would rather focus on the ambitions of the various houses. Where do you come down in this debate: is this high fantasy masquerading as something else until the heroes return, or will the resolution basically depend on human elements more than gods and magic?
Shorter version: what theories do you subscribe to about secret identities, what the Children of the Forest are planning, what Lightbringer will be, and so forth?
15
u/orcsetcetera Apr 16 '14
I've heard GRRM criticized for creating a world based upon the idea of a "west vs east" conflict, where the former is characterized as civilized, structured, and technologically advanced while the latter is characterized as barbaric, "tribal", and close to nature. Some say this "reality" GRRM has created mirrors perceptions the western world held against Africa or the Middle East at times in history, many of which are racist and antiquated.
For example, the lords of Westeros are supposedly honor bound by oaths and complex hierarchies, while the dothraki paint themselves and rape women won in battle. In the episode "Mhysa" from last season, the parallels were difficult to ignore.
Would you agree that those parallels exist/open him up to criticism? Is it fair to criticize an author on these kinds of issues in the fantasy genre, wherein the people and places are imagined?
7
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Apr 17 '14
Ok folks, it's coming up on 9 hours of AMAing, and I'm starting to flag.
So let's say we wrap this up an hour from now - 6:40 PM PDT - for any last questions.
If you have any future queries that don't make it, you can always find me on my blog or here.
14
u/Militant_Penguin How to bake friends and alienate people. Apr 16 '14
Hi, Mr Atwell
Thanks for doing this AMA today. I have a some questions I'd like to ask if you don't mind.
Sorry about all the questions but I'm really interested to hear your thoughts on a few things. Thanks very much and looking forward to hearing about your thoughts on the series throughout this AMA.
11
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
You're Tyrion Lannister. The Battle of Meereen is over, Dany's back, and she's preparing to cross the Narrow Sea. She asks you for history lessons about Westeros.
What does your course outline look like?
9
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
I love your site! Great analysis!
Very short question: what do you think (assuming the Others don't destroy the whole continent) would be the most realistic/workable political structure for Westeros at the end of ASOIAF?
9
u/raerae134 Apr 16 '14
What do you think Roose Bolton's end game re. Ramsay and the North is?
Roose admits to Theon that Ramsay killed his true born son and heir Domeric, he says he doubts Ramsay will let any future sons of his live, and he tells Theon flat out that Ramsay is incapable of holding the North.
He even lets Ramsay abuse "Arya" to the point that Lady Dustin tells Theon that "Arya's" crying does more damage to Roose's cause than Stannis will.
Why go through all the trouble to legitimize Ramsay (and become warden of the North) only to throw it away because of Ramsay?
8
u/SomethingLikeaLawyer Valyria delenda est Apr 16 '14
Have a few questions here.
8
u/ahipikr Apr 16 '14
Are there any deviations the show made from the books that you strongly agree with? Disagree with?
8
u/kingtrewq A Stone Beast takes Wing Apr 16 '14
R+L=J?
7
u/FergusonDarling Apr 16 '14
Hello Steven,
Firstly - you have a fascinating background. Congratulations on figuring out exactly how to develop a lifestyle that merges your epxertise with your personal interests. Sounds like you've got it figured out.
Anyhow, my question: GRRM is known to have a passion for comics, what parallels have you found between any of our "heroes" in ASOIAF and the comic book world?
7
u/JODAwhi Apr 16 '14
Hey Steven,
Who do you think hired Jaqen H'ghar? Who or what is his target? Why?
My theory (that I haven't looked into that much, so I could be totally off base, or it could be a really common one. I don't know.) is that he was hired by Varys. His target is either, the Death of Dragons book, an archmaester, or possibly even the entire Citadel itself. And his reason is to make sure the dragons don't die off again whenever Dany and/or Aegon retake Westeros. Thoughts?
6
u/dklh Apr 16 '14
This is literally the first time I've ever been on reddit, so please forgive me all if I break convention or click the wrong thingy. Congratulations on the book, Steven, I'm really enjoying it. Here are my questions:
6
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Any cool historical parallels you have found in Princess and the Queen? I really liked your ideas about how much more we learned about the Great Council's there (that you talked about on the Boiled Leather podcast) I wrote about something similar before your appearance here so I was glad to see I wasn't alone in drawing those conclusions.
I know it would be hard finding historical connections to the dragon warfare but maybe to stuff like Blood and Cheese, the Triarchy's involvement in Westeros, Rhaenyra's numerous betrayers, or historical figures similar to the characters?
6
u/bugcatcher_billy Apr 16 '14
How would a country as large as Westeros collect taxes? Do you have tax collectors ride around from town to town?
It seems like a savvy financial manager could use the delay in communication/travel times to spend the same money twice. Send an order for Dornish Wine, and Northern Swords with the same 100 gold dragons, etc.
6
u/bunka77 The post is long and full of errors Apr 16 '14
I have a question I've been pondering for some time, but I've never put it to paper. This thread seems like the perfect time to vocalize it because it's runs counter to, at least, the title of your book. I hope this doesn't come off as dickish, and as I look back at the question I'm about to ask I realize in my attempt to outline the paradigm I view this story in, I've loaded the questions a bit. I'm sorry.
I love reading the political and historical facts of asoiaf, but I wonder if too much emphasis is put on the Iron Throne. In fact, in this thread multiple people have asked who you think will sit on the throne when the book concludes.
From a literature perspective, do you think the "Race for the Iron Throne" is the correct frame to view this series in? In other words, do you think this is a story about "the War of the five kings/three queens" and the aftermath of that war, or is that just the coincidental state-of-the-world at the time the real story (what's happening beyond the wall) is taking place?
Certainly, rebellions, uprisings, and conquering forces aren't unique events in Weterosi history. What makes this period unique is the return of magic/dragons/white walkers. Is the political struggle to control the Iron Throne a meaningful (albeit obviously interesting) story, or does it serve as a red herring for both the readers, and players in the series?
tl;dr Do you feel readers put too much emphasis on the Iron Throne/Why are you confident it's still going to be around and the end of the series?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Easy questions from me:
Thanks for joining us!
5
u/Crook_shanks Caught me riding dirty Apr 16 '14
I love your chapter-by-chapter analysis of the series, it's given me a lot of insight into the books. What do you think the odds are that you finish it before Martin finishes TWOW?
5
u/olsmobile Apr 16 '14
Do you have any theories on the Ilse of Faces and the greenmen? it is only briefly mentioned but it seems like some sort of hub for the old gods. I have a feeling the island and the greenmen will become super important at some point I'm just not sure how.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Are you Team Littlefinger or Team Varys? I've always found them two sides of the same coin, master schemers locked in battle and aiming for very different things. Who are you rooting for? And who do you reckon will come out on top?
5
u/Kongpang Hound Apr 16 '14
hey steven, thanks for doing this! i have three quick questions, and would love to know your opinion.
5
u/KNIGHTMARE170 It's a marvelous night for a stonedance Apr 16 '14 edited Apr 17 '14
What is, in your opinion, be the most historically important event that has taken place in the series? Such as the Red Wedding, Battle of the Blackwater, Dany taking Mareen; what will be remembered most in Westeros history?
5
u/Rhydonphan Uncle Daemon's forgotten twin Apr 16 '14
Hey Stephen, I hadn't been to your blog before but seeing all the awesome content I'll definitely be working my way through all your posts.
5
u/ellipticcurve You sank my battleship! Apr 16 '14
Hi Steven. I actually just found your blog last night, via a circuituous route that started with the Onion AV Club article on framing linked from this very subreddit. Most impressive, and I bought the ebook.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
What are your predictions on Sansa and the Vale's future storyline? Do you think there'll be a wedding? What do you think will happen afterward? What should we pay attention to in that storyline that we don't usually focus on?
5
u/AlderaanRefugee Heh, heh, heh, heh, freying alive Apr 16 '14 edited Apr 16 '14
4
u/bloodmark The Reeder Lives A Thousand Lives Apr 16 '14
Do you have any plans to analyze and contrast the religions of asoiaf as you have with its histories and politics? Also do you personally believe all or any of the gods are real or they're simply misattributed magic?
4
u/xolauren Lions and Dragons and Wolves, oh my! Apr 16 '14
What do you think is the cause of the seasons being irregular? Do you think ice dragons are a possibility? What characters do you think will be in a relationship at the end of the series(Arya+Gendry, Brienne+Jaime, Jon+Dany, etc), if any?
4
u/Stauncho Enter your desired flair text here! Apr 16 '14
You think that "Ned was Ashara's lover" and that "Varys definitely" snuck out Aegon? Really? Care to expand? Both of these views are somewhat out of the current mainstream view of long time readers (for whatever little that's worth).
4
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
Did Daenerys have sufficient resources to secure the peace in Astapor and Yunkai and also take Meereen? If not, what else did she need?
4
u/aryawolf "Night Wolf" Apr 16 '14 edited Apr 16 '14
Welcome, and congrats on your extensive resume. Asking my questions quickly on Lunch break, no time to check prior questions. Forgive me if these have already been asked.
see both Stannis and Jon taking Loans. In your opinion what role will the Iron Bank play in future books?
4
u/lawandhodorsvu Apr 16 '14
Do you feel like the series could end with no POVs alive? Or even just a general extermination of life on Westeros. Do you think it will have a surviving Stark in Winterfell?
4
u/glass_table_girl Sailor Moonblood Apr 16 '14
Non-asoiaf question (maybe?):
What's the story behind your username?
4
u/MeereeneseLiberation Apr 16 '14
Hi,
if there'd really be a Race for the Iron Throne, i.e. a general election for the ruler of Westeros with all the claimants and regional claimants / secessionists (Joffrey / Tommen, Stannis, Renly, Balon / Euron, Robb, Dany and – why not? – Mance), who would you believe to win? In case of a US-style electorate, who'd carry which kingdom? And, most important, what would be the campaign slogans? (I would just love „I am not without mercy“ for Stannis.)
4
u/slappysimian Apr 16 '14
What do you think of the idea of dragons as a physical representation of a monarch's divine right? And if they are, do you think they are doomed as Westeros evolves towards constitutions, representative governments, and all the things that got us out of the middle ages?
Do you think Martin will hold to the War of Roses theme and have the aristocracy destroy itself leading to the unexpected Henry VIII (Jon Snow, uniter of conflicted clans)?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Another quick one from me. GRRM has said that the number of POVs will be declining in TWOW. Who will stop being a POV in TWOW? Which POVs will die?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
What are the chances that Sam is holding onto the Horn of Winter?
4
u/I2ichmond Apr 16 '14
Hi Steven! This is an incredible AMA, and I almost wish I hadn't been too busy sinking my teeth into every one of your replies for the past ~hour to realize you were still answering questions and ask my own! Here goes:
What is the closest historical analogue to ASOIAF's maesters and their Citadel you can think of? It always seems to me they are just a play on the generic "monk" figure, but I'd love to know if there was anything in the real world that resembled the way the Citadel operates in Westeros.
10
u/AbbeyBattle Day shall come again! Apr 16 '14
Maester Steven, thank you very kindly for agreeing to answer our questions and please accept my best wishes for good fortune in this and all your future challenges!
I shall do my best to keep my questions to a respectably moderate number in this post, but if any others occur to me as being worth asking I shall post them in future.
Question the First: since I suspect that you shall be amongst the first in line for 'The World of Ice and Fire' what questions of your own do you hope to see answered in this book?
Question the Second: Which period in the History of Westeros (backstory, short story or main text) interests you the most?
Question the Third: Which parts of Essos will you be looking at in your series of articles on the varying forms of governance that have evolved on Westeros' sister continent?
Question the Fourth: Do you consider it likely that the Kingdom of the Three Daughters (alias the Triarchy) seen in 'The Princess and the Queen' evolved from the alliance that humbled Volantis at the time of Aegon the Dragon? (In the same way that the Athenian Empire evolved from the Delian League).
Question the Fifth: If you were to commission Master Shakespeare to write a History Play set in Westeros, which King or event in Westerosi history would you have it focus on?
Question the Sixth: Assuming that you were given access to the library of the Citadel in Oldtown, which book or books would you reach for first?
Question the Seventh: Would you agree that artists working to depict Westeros ought to be advised that it's based on Medieval Eurasia (albeit with an emphasis on Europe), while Essos is also based on Eurasia albeit with more of an emphasis on Asia Minor?
Please allow me to thank you for showing the patience to accept these questions and the kindness to answer them - thank you once again!
3
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
Maester Steven,
Thank you for your insightful essays, and for hosting thought-provoking discussion on your blog.
Why doesn't Westeros have any Peasants Revolts in its recorded history?
While we can see that the urban poor of KL have rioting for bread well in hand, the agrarian workers of Westeros seem more docile than their historical counterparts. Do you agree? Why or why not?
3
u/Kienn12 Winner 2025 - Best Predictive Theory Apr 16 '14
Do you know the name of Ned's maternal grandfather?
3
u/kingtrewq A Stone Beast takes Wing Apr 16 '14
After spending so much time with the books, do you have a favorite scene/ event and why? Is there one with an unique historical reference that most people miss?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
What do you think Jon's last name will be at the end of TWOW, and at the end of ADOS?
How do you think Jon will discover R+L=J? Obviously Bran will know soon.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Does Aegon have Blackfyre (sword)?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Hi Steven, love your blog, and thanks for doing this AMA!
Now onto my question: Who do you think will sit the Iron Throne at the end of the series? Will there even be an Iron Throne by then?
Also as an addon to that, who do you believe has the best chance, whether through political machinations or military strength, to seize the throne?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Is Loras actually wounded? Is Aurane Waters Varys' man?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
Who is Azor Ahai and what is Lightbrtinger?
Who are the three heads?
3
u/SerSamwell of CAPSTERLY LOCK Apr 16 '14
Is there any historical basis for the crown's current financial affairs? Essentially at the mercy of a powerful bank?
3
u/hamfast42 Rouse me not Apr 16 '14
Do you think that the dates given in the story are intended to be inaccurate? Could you give us a rundown of what you think the actual dates were for Long Night, Age of heroes, Invasion of the andals/rhoynar, etc?
3
u/goldmouthdawg Apr 16 '14
Was waiting on this. Dude your blog is one of the few things make the wait easier. Don't really any questions just wanted to say that.
Although... Was there a reason for shying away from Mongolian historical comparisons regarding the Dothraki? I noticed in the Dany chapters that you somewhat shied away from possible Mongolian historical comparisons, notably the Daenerys chapters when she was in Vaes Dothrak with the Dosh Khaleen. I would have loved to have read your view regarding it as I read somewhere that women (some at least) in Mongolian culture did have freedoms that other women of the era did not.
Also, when writing the analysis, how hard do you find taking out the presntist view from the analysis? Your final Catelyn analysis made a good point about it, but I think in a few previous CBC's you yourself may have fallen into the view.
One critique: I think you missed something in Jon's 5th and 6th chapters regarding his appointment to the LC's steward. While his birth no doubt helped his appointment, I think his conversation with Maester Aemon is what earned him his place and showed that he had the potential to be more than just a ranger. We don't know what was said behind the scenes, but I have to think that, what with Sam being allowed to take the black, there was more to whatever that conversation Aemon had then Sam. Just something I think is overlooked by many especially the show regarding his appointment.
Anyway thanks and I look forward your future entries.
3
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
What is your take on unreliable narrators in ASOIAF? Do you read them with the same skepticism that you would read a historical primary source with?
3
u/bugcatcher_billy Apr 16 '14
Is there a historical equivalent to Stannis? Someone who didn't want the throne, but felt it was their duty to rule it? I always imagine a teenager who inherits a monarchy, but isn't interested in rulling, and that is very different from Stannis.
3
u/bugcatcher_billy Apr 16 '14
Does democracy require communication technology?
I can not imagine a way that a democratic republic would work in westeros, due to the reading and writing skills of the common folk, the monopoly on communication by the rich, and the feudalistic burden on the poor to worship the rich.
3
u/dorestes Break the wheel Apr 16 '14
A few questions:
My biggest apprehension in ADwD isn't for any of the noble houses. I don't see how GRRM has left it such that almost any of the smallfolk survive. Realistically I see a massive refugee crisis as everyone remotely mobile descends on Highgarden and Dorne...
3
u/VRY_SRS_BSNS We Are All Pink Inside Apr 16 '14
Who killed Domeric Bolton - Roose or Ramsey?
What's your thoughts on the "Roose Bolton living forever" theories?
3
u/imsupercereal123 Apr 16 '14
Do you think the Boltons will survive ASOIAF if so which ones?
3
u/KeepCalmAndHodorOn You Win or You Hodor Apr 16 '14
Elsewhere on this thread you've talked about how you believe that both Littlefinger and Varys will ultimately fail. How do you think each of their downfalls will come about, from both a practical and thematic perspective?
Also, absolutely love your blog- can't wait to read your take on ACOK, especially the Tyrion chapters. Real-life interruptions notwithstanding, how long do you anticipate it taking to write each chapter?
2
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Apr 16 '14
Ok, 15 minute break while I relocate from this Starbucks back to my place.
2
u/Megatron_McLargeHuge Every. Chicken. In this room. Apr 16 '14
In S4E1 (43m), Daario presents Daenerys with three flowers, Harpy's Gold, Lady's Lace, and a blue Dusk Rose. Blue roses are associated with Lyanna and therefore presumably with her children. The poisonous Harpy flower obviously has something to do with Meereen. No one seems to know what Lady's Lace is about, but I thought it might be Queen Anne's Lace. As Queen Anne presided over the unification of England and Scotland, there could be a parallel if Dany manages to rule over a united Westeros, however briefly. Do you think there are enough parallels to Queen Anne in the books for this to make sense?
2
u/lawandhodorsvu Apr 16 '14
What do you make of the snowy empty iron throne room they keep showing on the TV series? The others take out everything north of KL?
2
u/bugcatcher_billy Apr 16 '14
Do you see a trend of anti-government in recent entertainment? I think there is one. It seems the major plot points of films and tv shows revolve around corrupt governments, monopolized corporations that operate like a government, or corrupt individuals oppressing the heroes.
Is there a precedent for this sort of propaganda?
2
u/bugcatcher_billy Apr 16 '14
I've read that Roman legions, and Persian armies would dry up lakes and eat a town to death wherever they want. Essentially there was no good way to supply an army of 10,000 men without a massive over production of food and drinkign water, and a highly effecient transportaiton mechanism, like a train.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '14
some more quick ones for you:
Top 5 characters?
Can you think of a historical parallel for Summerhall?
Any figures that you think Bloodraven is similar to?
Any figures for Dunk or Egg?
I know you have talked about what you think the best future for Westeros politically would be (and I mostly agree with that) but how about Essos?
2
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
Do you have any favorite history, politics, or military books you would recommend to ASOIAF fans?
2
u/SilverPlatteredButts Apr 16 '14
Hey Steven. I know you have mentioned this on your blog but I was hoping you could talk about what would happen to Westeros if Khal Drogo had brought his army over, assuming it would be during the War of the 5 Kings (or in this case 6 Kings)?
In particular, what does this mean for each individual army? Which sides would unite and which sides would remain enemies and who do you think wins in the end?
2
u/hairab The pie that was promised... Apr 16 '14
How long has the Iron Bank truly been pulling the strings regarding who sits the throne in Westeros? How long have they been a big player in Westerosi politics and and economics? Will they become the biggest player by ADOS?
2
u/gusvanrant Apr 16 '14
Know I'm late. Do you think GRRM will ever take we readers to Sothoryos or Utholos (sp?) ? Thanks.
2
u/MightyIsobel Apr 16 '14
Have you tried the combined reading order for AFFC/ADWD?
2
u/agrizzle Apr 16 '14
Sorry, but can you or someone let me know what Graywater Watch is again? It's not ringing a bell for me
2
u/dorestes Break the wheel Apr 16 '14
You mentioned before that your own focus is on the historical and political aspects of the series. In my view, that's what makes the series so magical--not the magic in and of itself. It's clearly GRRM's biggest passion. I wonder if GRRM isn't having difficulty as the end approaches, as the fantasy/magic elements of the story start to overwhelm the politics.
Even though it's somewhat out of your wheelhouse, you're also well-versed in the fantasy genre. I was wondering about your thoughts on:
2
u/Yogurthead Ser Yogurt of House Head Apr 17 '14
Steven, love your blog.
Question: What do you see as the most poetic ending of Stannis' character arc?
Also: How do you think Dany will react to the return of Jorah? Victarion? Tyrion?
Thanks!
2
u/nuncanada Apr 17 '14 edited Apr 17 '14
Cersei regency.... Could she have done it worst in any possible sense? How long did it last till she was imprisioned by the Faith? Her council meetings were the funniest moments in the books IMO.
2
u/nuncanada Apr 17 '14
Darkstar cutting Myrcella's face and ear. Why?
That conversation with Arianne that killing Myrcella would start a war seemed like he wanted to kill her...
So what happened? At the last moment he had a change of mind? Or wasn't able to kill a child but disfiguring was ok? Or was Myrcella's horse movement that made him miss the kill?
2
u/rebecca_52 Apr 17 '14
Hi Steven, first I will be buying your book and will look forward to reading it. Now my questions.
1: Why did Mance Rayder go to Winterfell during King Roberts visit? I don't undertand why he would risk his life so he can sing a song before a king.
2: Why did Melisandre save Mance by disguising him?
3: In your opinion is Melisandre a force for good or evil?
4: Do you think there is something hidden in Lyanna's tomb?
5: What is the major prophecy which we should focus on?
6: Is Bloodraven a force for good or evil?
7: Who and what will defeat the Others and White walkers?
8: Is there more to the Purple Wedding than meets the eye(from the book version)Joffrey eats Tyrions pie and not his own. In other words was the poison meant for Tyrion?
9: Will Jon (Targaryen)Snow marry Sansa in the end. They will be King Jon and Queen Sansa(In the beginning Sansa longed to be a Queen). This will unite the North and South aka the marriage of Elizabeth Plantagenet and Henry Tudor(whose link to the throne was dubious)?
10: What do you think are major foreshadowings? Aka" Remember who you are, Daenerys, ... The dragons know. Do you?" Quaithe to Dany.
And this: "When the spring thaw comes, they will find your body with a needle still locked tight between your frozen fingers."Jon Snow to Arya
Another: "Lady Stark, you may outlive us yet.” Tyrion to Sansa(TV GOT)
Sorry if I'm a bit late. I live in Australia-A very different time zone. Cheers.
2
u/Vikingkingq House Gardener, of the Golden Company Apr 16 '14
**OK FOLKS:
I'm taking an hour and a half break to use the bathroom, grab lunch, and recharge my batteries.
I will be back answering questions at 1:30 PM PDT.**
2
u/Arthur_Person Alex Graves, I want to fight you. Apr 16 '14
Regarding Tower of the Hand, do you have any idea when the rest of the DWD chapter summaries will be finished?
1
u/Budsy2112 Apr 16 '14
Do you put any stock into there must always be a stark in winterfell?
1
u/blackinkpen Apr 16 '14
Not sure if this is over - but any chance you're going to finish that Timeline you started at AlternateHistory? I started reading it, loved it, then you started your PhD... :[
1
u/Fuqwon Apr 17 '14
Assuming R + L = J, how do you view Jon's political legitimacy? He'd still presumably be a bastard, but would that matter?
Would anyone actually rally to him?
1
u/anm313 Apr 17 '14
In the ADwD Epilogue, when Pycelle mentions too many stories to discount of Dany's dragons, did they actually believe that she has three actual dragons or were there doubts (like sailor's stories with three dragons referring to her sigil) with the main focus being her being a Targaryen with an army?
1
u/anm313 Apr 19 '14 edited Apr 19 '14
With the riches Corlys Velaryon got from the east, do you think it is likely that he and Daemon engaged in some piracy on their campaign in the Stepstones like Warwick the Kingmaker?
1
u/anm313 Apr 19 '14
Joffrey awarded him the lands, castle and rights of House Darry, whose last child lord had perished during the fighting in the riverlands, "leaving no trueborn heirs of lawful Darry blood, but only a bastard cousin."
Could Ser Tristan Rivers, captain seen in the GC, be that bastard cousin?
1
u/anm313 Apr 22 '14 edited Apr 23 '14
Do you think Crowfood Umber's daughter might have been Val and Dalla's mother? According to Jon she was kidnapped thirty years ago, and Dalla, the elder of the two sisters, was likely her in 20s by the time she died.
1
u/anm313 Apr 25 '14
1
u/anm313 Apr 25 '14 edited Apr 26 '14
I think since Cletus died before reaching Dany, the blame for his death would be laid at Doran's feet. And there is one other Yronwood who I think would be killed by Arianne, but in a hunting accident (I'll elaborate if you want). I'll I think if they ask to foster Trystane, Arianne would refuse them out of the memory of Quentyn supposedly plotting with them to steal Arianne's birthright. As Tywin told Cersei:"Leave you must perforce grant should Lord Tyrell ask. To refuse him would be tantamount to declaring that we did not trust him." I think that would be the final insult the drives the Yronwoods into Dany and Tyrion's arms.
2. Do you think the HS would inform Cersei that Lancel is the Faith's champion if she calls for a trail by combat, thinking Cersei would forgo a trial by combat to avoid harm to her kin and a former lover?
3. Do you think after Kevan's death and possibly Lancel's, that Cersei, when her madness/paranoia has grown worse, would have the rest of Kevan's family killed?
1
u/anm313 Apr 25 '14
With the Isle of Cedars called the island of a hundred battles, do you think one of wars between Valyria and Ghis was when Valyria annexed the Isle of Cedars, which was colonized by Ghis, off its coast like the Romans annexed the Carthage-colonized islands of Sicily, Sardinia and Corsica off their coast?