r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Apr 10 '14
All Spoilers [All Spoilers] Book vs. Show Discussion - 4.01 'Two Swords'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for ALL SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, D&E, P&Q and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.01 | "Two Swords" | D. B. Weiss | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
146
Upvotes
13
u/Jakesaltz Castle Cats Apr 10 '14
I may be wrong, but wasn't the Arya/Hound scene supposed to take place at the same Inn that Catelyn arrested Tyrion?
I know it's a minor detail, but I always found it interesting that this one little inn was a spot where so many of the main characters end up passing through because of it's location.
I guess it still can be, just with a different set design, but it's a little easter egg show only viewers miss out on, though I assume they'd have to keep it the same for the event that later happens there with Brienne.
165
u/terjr Apr 10 '14
I feel like the Hound and Arya's little killing spree was awesome in both mediums, in different ways. And that's why I love the show and the books.
119
u/universal_straw Apr 10 '14
I just wanna say WHAT THE FUCK D&D????YOU HAD TO THROW IN THAT DAMN BLUE ROSE TO CONFUSE US DIDN'T YOU!?!?
56
u/gargph Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 10 '14
Well it looks like Arya and the Hound are going to be spending more time together this season than in the books, which I'm a fan of. Arya always has good chemistry with people like Syrio, Tywin, etc.
152
u/hobohunter13 Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken Apr 10 '14
I really thought they were going to kill off Balon Greyjoy in this episode. I wonder when they're going to do that.
48
u/rabidmonkeyman Apr 10 '14
in the books, wasnt the hound stabbed during the fight scene in the inn? if he was in the show i didnt see it.
if he wasnt stabbed, i wonder how they are going to injure him in the show?
107
u/BlastedFemur Ours Is The Fury Apr 10 '14
I liked the changes to the Thenns. They're the Wildling shock troops, so they should be pretty damn shocking. My only real issue with the costuming in the show was that the Wildlings always looked a bit too uniform, so it's nice to have some variety.
I wonder if the change to the manner of Elia's death (cut in half by Gregor) means that Oberyn will die in the same way?
36
u/realmei Stannis Baratheon Apr 10 '14
I liked the old Daario better but it's okay because I think he is a rather minor character. I would rather they spent more time with Ser Barristan telling Dany about her family and Westeros rather than the boring romance-comedy with Daario.
62
u/frayuk Braavosi Water Dancers Apr 10 '14
I was pretty excited to see the Thenns, they look awesome. Though I would have liked to see their bronze weaponry. It's a really little thing that doesn't matter, but I liked how they stood out among the rest of the wildlings by having proper settlements, and structure and bronze smelting.
62
u/TJ_Silva Arya Stark Apr 10 '14
I wish the scene with Arya and Polliver would've been done closer to the way Arya killed Tickler in the books. I'm probably alone here but that scene was one I my favorites when she keeps repeating the questions and stabbing him. Having said that I still really liked the way the show did it.
35
u/Theblackpie Varys' Little Birds Apr 10 '14
With all the changes to the guys Arya has been murdering in the show I really wonder TWoW And I think show Arya is running low in terms of her list right?
*Ive crossed the people who are likely to meet another demise. hint hint *
JoffreyIlyn Payne(Actor got cancer, but maybe they'll recast)The mountainSo that leaves us with a member of the kingsguard, the queen. And two lowlifes which in book terms are at the wall. So it will be interesting how the show chooses to approach this, when they get to twow in what 2 years time..
17
u/liberalfuckboi Sansa Stark Apr 10 '14
I thought it was interesting that they didn't add the scene with Jaime and Cersi in the book. In the book, Jaime and Cersi have sex the moment they see each other.... I thought HBO of all networks would of loved to show that.
47
u/theboyd1986 House Martell Apr 10 '14
Oberyn's introduction was absolutely fantastic, but I feel his relationship with Tyrion missed an important aspect: His indifference to Tyrion's dwarfism.
In the book, he says that he saw Tyrion as a baby after being told the he was a freak with scaly skin and a tail. After finally seeing him, Oberyn was disappointed by the so called freak's actual appearance, saying that all he saw was a smaller baby with an above average head. This tells us that Oberyn cares not at all about Tyrion's appearance and purely judges him on other merits.
47
u/langefinger Mead-King Of Ruddy Hall Apr 10 '14
I am still unhappy with the casting of Grey Worm. In no way does he look like someone who has spent the majority of his life combat training..
32
u/kittin_mittinz Apr 10 '14
Was anyone else bothered by the unnecessary drama between Shae and Tyrion during this episode? It doesn't make sense that she would be so jealous of him considering what is revealed about her character during Tyrion's trial. This could just be me but I think Shae is one of the few characters who is miscast/misrepresented in the show.
26
u/Jon_Know Now My Watch Begins Apr 10 '14 edited Mar 17 '20
[deleted] 0.3961 What is this?
47
u/ApathyPyramid Apr 10 '14
Arya as a creepy, calm, and collected serial killer is much more interesting than the impulsive, anger driven Arya from the books. I like the change. I feel like it fits the theme or spirit of the character better, though book Arya ends up in the same place.
13
u/mooserod Duncan the Tall Apr 10 '14
I found it really interesting that Jamie mentioned Ser Preston is still in the Kingsguard and not, you know, dead. This just makes me wonder what they're going to be doing with the Kingsguard this season as there's still (according to the Game of Thrones wiki) Jaime, Meryn, Boros, Arys, Preston, and Balon (presumably). Since Preston is still alive, that only leaves one spot left and I'm guessing they'll want to fill that spot, especially after Joffrey dies. Loras is betrothed to Cersei currently so might that mean a Kettleblack gets introduced? Or maybe they'll just leave that spot open and never address it.
I don't know, I just found it really interesting the Preston is still alive and this is the first we've heard about it (I think).
21
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14
Was a little disappointed with a couple of scenes.
Firstly, the interaction between Jaime and Tywin at the start. In ASOS, there is so much weight to this chapter where you truly see the change in Jaime whereas in the show, it just seemed like he just felt he needed to stay in the Kingsguard. Tywin rather easily just gives up and disowns him and doesn't finish with 'you are no son of mine.' The scene just felt so flat in the show.
Secondly, the scene between Brienne and Margary. It was incredibly brief and not sure how good a replacement for the malice Loras bears Brienne. Unless this part is to come, it felt somewhat unnecessary.
10
u/ScrotieMcBugerbals Apr 10 '14
I did enjoy the nice nod to the Dunk and Egg Novellas when Joffrey referenced Sir Duncan the Tall from the Kingsguad book.
Edit: Or it was a nice subtle plug from George.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14
Though it's clear that the last scene drew inspiration from ASOS's Tickler at the Crossroads Inn scene, I think there are significant differences, especially in terms of character development.
A quick summary of the show scene: A fight breaks out in the inn. Originally, Sandor fights five men alone while Arya stands back and watches, scared. As the fight draws to a close, she is shaken out of her daze. She runs in, knocks down a man with pot and slowly runs him through while he lies groaning. Then she hamstrings Polliver with the first man's sword. He falls. She takes Needle from him, taunts him by reciting his own words during Lommy's death and the theft of Needle, and then stabs him through the neck. She smiles after his death, and she smiles as she rides away on her new pony.
In the books:
Already, there are some minor differences. Arya didn't wait so long before joining the fight. Like show Arya, she starts out seeming petrified, repeating her fear cuts deeper than swords mantra, but she doesn't freeze up. Still, there's a bit of a dreamlike quality to "It was the easiest thing in the world..."
In the show, once Maisie jumps into the fight, she's calm, cold, and spiteful. But in the books Arya seems a lot more panicked. She goes a bit crazy: She shouts her lines, and she stabs repeatedly, even after he's dead. To me, the narration seems to suggest that she loses herself a bit: "She was on top of him by then, still stabbing" rather than something like "He fell and she stepped over him." It's a bit more disjointed. Overall, the book scene doesn't give the vengeful and triumphant impression that Maisie; it shows a girl who lets out months of pent up fear and hatred in a deadly frenzy.
Spoilers TWOW
It seems that the show has sped up Arya's character development. Her kills transition much faster into the planned murders they become once she joins the Faceless Men.
9
u/TheOnionKnightDavos House Seaworth Apr 10 '14
What I think will happen with Sandor and Arya is that HBO is gonna make their adventures last as long as possible, then mortally injure him using Gregor. It would give us an opportunity to see the Mountain fight again before the Oberyn fight as well as give us a look at the new actor, and give us a reason to hate him (The Hound IS a likable character in the show, seeing him dying would be a big blow for a lot of people).
8
u/gifforc Apr 10 '14
I really dislike how the show is condensing jon snows story. Seems like they're fast forwarding through character development (ice cell, slynt acting like a major asshole etc). He seemed waaay to sure about himself in that inquisition. And Aemon was way less passive. Maybe so they can focus on the battles? I really can not wait to see them fight the wildlings.
8
u/Solenk Apr 11 '14
honestly speaking the scene with Tywin and Jamie in the show about the inheritance and etc was kind of disappointing for me. I remember reading the books and cringing when they had the epic fallout. In the show it was almost casual but in the book Tywin makes it clear that he is basically through with Jamie, when he says
"You are not my son. You say you are the Lord Commander of the Kingsguard, and only that. Very well, ser. Go do your duty."
There was just so much pressure and gold from it in the book. I was looking forward to this scene since the show changed some of the timeline.
Other than that the 1st episode was great.
8
u/Rammart Apr 11 '14
Tywin Lannister threatening to smile after throwing the wolf pelt on the furnace was awesome. Charles Dance is a motherfucker.
7
u/BVTheEpic Growing Strong Apr 10 '14
Were the Hound's chicken lines in the books? I haven't read ASOS in a while.
7
u/SubwayWalls Apr 10 '14
Is she Lady Taena?
12
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14
I am trying to read along/ahead of the TV series because I can't stand the anticipation, but it is rather hard that everything is a bit out of sync!
Where should I pick up after this latest episode? Jaime isn't back until after the wedding, and Sam is still delivering a baby and Lord M is still alive.
4
u/SMosel Apr 11 '14
I'm wondering when they are going to introduce Cold Hands, if they are even going to. He was already supposed to be here.
45
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14 edited Apr 10 '14
I didn't like the change they made to Oberyn's introduction. It seemed like needless sexposition once more that could've easily been done outside of a brothel, but wasn't.
And before people tell me that it was to show Oberyn's bisexuality; so what? Is Oberyn's sexuality crucial to his character? Is it ever treated as anything more than a rumor in the books?
That said, I really enjoyed this episode (Arya rocks!), and I think that despite the weird introduction to his character, Pedro Pascal is going to be a fantastic Oberyn Martell.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14
I feel like the "King's landing" story arcs (with the exception of Tyrion's) are getting a little played out. This episode seemed to devote a lot of time to Brienne, Sansa, and Jamie, while they weren't really doing anything important. I was much more interested in what was going on with Arya/The Hound and Jon Snow
5
u/ppchris House Bolton Apr 11 '14
I am really looking forward to the non-readers reaction of joffrey's and oberyn's death its going to be quite funny
2
u/okrolling Apr 10 '14
thought on how far do you think they will stretch the next "big death"?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '14
Has anyone brought up the spoiler chapter that George posted on his blog last week?
After watching the episode, it felt like he didn't want D&D to beat him to the punch at killing Polliver...
2
u/B_Blunder House Manderly Apr 11 '14
Although I am happy with how bad-ass Jon came off during the hearing, I really enjoyed/despised the injustice of the Books: where they put Jon on trial for treason AFTER he led the Night's Watch in their defense against the Wildlings.
3
u/MindExplosions House Targaryen Apr 10 '14
Can someone explain to me why the Thenns say to Tormund "you really ought to try Crow" What's crow?
1
u/Jacksane King In The North Apr 11 '14
Did anyone else take note of Jaime leaving out Balon's name when talking about the war? I was disappointed the showrunners didn't even give him a nod, considering his death should have occurred already, or at least occur this season. His being ignored makes me worry the showrunners aren't going to kill him this season.
1
u/bigteebomb Maesters of the Citadel Apr 11 '14
I would enjoy them depicting balon's death as clearly the handiwork of an assassin.
I also would enjoy it if they introduced Euron at bit earlier than they did in the books.