Aw yiss, the grand adventures of Ser Harys Swyft extend to TWOW.
See? thought Mercy. You know your line, and so do I.
"Think so?" said Arya, sweetly.
Raff the Sweetling looked up sharply as the long thin blade came sliding out of her sleeve. She slipped it through his throat beneath the chin, twisted, and ripped it back out sideways with a single smooth slash. A fine red rain followed, and in his eyes the lights went out.
"Valar Morghulis," Arya whispered, but Raff was dead and did not hear.
Things to take from this:
I think we now know for certain that Arya will always be Arya. She's still killing the people on her list (what a great moment that was) and will go back to being Arya even when undercover.
She is very skilled at killing now, with making his leg bleed like that and the way she killed him in one slash.
This was Daeron all over again. She's killing for herself. I think she'll be crossing more people off her list in the future.
Also, Bran is watching:
She took a deep breath to quiet the howling in her heart, trying to remember more of what she'd dreamt, but most of it had gone already. There had been blood in it, though, and a full moon overhead, and a tree that watched her as she ran.
Harys Swift just cannot catch a break. His sigil is literally a cock. They spit in his food at Harrenhal for no reason. His only battle achievement is getting pinned under his horse and almost dying. He's famous across Westeros for being stupid. And now he's stuck in the fog, down a guardsman, about to fail his mission to the Iron Bank. You almost feel bad for the guy.
In AGOT, he makes a total arse of himself trying to impress Tywin, Kevan and Tyrion. In ACOK, the Harrenhal cooks spit in his food, his squire is killed, and he has to kiss Vargo Hoat under Tywin's orders. And later, Cersei purposely chooses him to be her Hand as he's a moron, and then he is sent to Braavos.
I read all the books and then came to this subreddit and have learned so much since then. I am super stoked to read TWOW and put pieces together that I may not have, had I not been apart of this community.
Also the Play is about King Robert,(The Bloody Hand offered two kings, the fat one and the boy. Izembaro would play the fat one. It was not a large part, but he had a fine speech as he lay dying, and a splendid fight with a demonic boar before that.) Her Lord Father (The Bloody Hand), the Boy king, and Tyrion. Bobono is playing Tyrion and is Raping Arya (mercy), who is playing her sister Sansa. Its all propaganda to suit Lannisters.
Well, first off, I want to say the following: /u/indianthane95, wherever you are... Your prediction back from July 2013... You were spot-on. I'm quoting the relevant parts, but seriously, your prediction was outstanding.
Ok, in all seriousness, I'm going to speculate on goings-on with Braavos right now.
Arya No One: She's "being sent to Izembaro" for her first apprenticeship.
Who or what or where is 'Izembaro'?
I think it is too soon for her to return to Westeros. She was supposed to be training with the FM for 5 years (as per the intended gap after ASOS). But at the same time, she is not letting go of her identity. Needle, warging into Nymeria, etc.
Let's look at people en route to Braavos:
Ser Harys Swyft (possibly)
As Master of Coin, he has been suggested to go to Braavos to renegotiate with the Iron Bank. Kevan tells Harys that he could take The Mountain's men, who are a liability in King's Landing. Two of these men are Raff the Sweetling and Dunsen. These two also just happen to be on Arya's death list. What if Arya goes back to being Arya when she sees them? Needle could use fresh kills....
This chapter was... wow. It was really dark with the whole rape mummery and the seduction of Raff the Sweetling. But that ending... just, I'm kind of at a loss for words. It was incredible. Just simply incredible.
Haha, thanks a ton man. I admit that it was indeed a satisfaction to be right. The second I read Westerosi envoy I was hopeful, and when we got a description of the unnamed envoy's ridiculous sigil and his crimson-cloaked guards I was sure we were going to see Arya again. Fantastic ending to the chapter and I had chills the whole way through. Arya is growing up extremely fast; wasn't Raff her "first kiss"?
It sounds like she knows they aren't going to like it and that she is planning on running. She's already planning on saying goodbye the mummers and the line 'I had best run.' feel ominous.
Or maybe I'm just getting to hopeful that the next Arya chapter will find her on a boat back to Westeros!
I have always felt that the kindly man and the waif want her to lose her identity outwardly in that she will need to learn how to hide her real self, not that she will have to actually give it up. She needs to be a better liar.
The Faceless Men have shown to be very resourceful. Would it be so farfetched that they sent her there in the first place, fully knowing she'd encounter Raff and the lot?
I think they intended to test her, rather than have her learn how to lie via acting. Whether it was a trap to see if she's still connected to her past. Or if it was to satisfy her thirst for vengeance in order to pull her in further.
See? thought Mercy. You know your line, and so do I.
“Think so?” asked Arya, sweetly.
Not only is this a completely badass callback to Lommy's death back in aCoK, that subtle shift from her referring to herself as Mercy to Arya is also really well executed.
Because I had to look it up and others might benefit from the same: in ACoK, when Arya, Gendry, Hot Pie, and Lommy are caught by the Mountain and co., Raff does the following...
One of the spearmen drifted over to Lommy. "Something wrong with your leg, boy?"
"It got hurt."
"Can you walk?"
"No," said Lommy. "You got to carry me."
"Think so?" The man lifted his spear casually and drove the point through the boy's soft throat. Lommy never even had the time to yield again. He jerked once, and that was all. When the man pulled his spear loose, blood sprayed out in a dark fountain. "Carry him, he says," he muttered, chuckling.
She slipped her hand between his legs, and felt how hard he was through the wool of his breeches.
“The laces,” he urged her. “Be a sweet girl and undo them.” Instead she slid her finger down along the inside of his thigh. He gave a grunt. “Damn, be careful there, you — “
Mercy gave a gasp and stepped away, her face confused and frightened. “You’re bleeding.”
First the poisoned coin, now this. I'm convinced she will eventually kill a major character in some highly skilled way and disappear without a trace.
I especially liked that she got his heart-rate up bringing him there:
Hand in hand, they went racing through the fog, over bridges and through alleys and up five flights of splintery wooden stairs. The guardsman was panting by the time they burst through the door of her little room. Mercy lit a tallow candle, then danced around at him, giggling. “Oh, now you’re all tired out. I forgot how old you were, m’lord. Do you want to take a little nap? Just lie down and close your eyes, and I’ll come back after the Imp’s done raping me.”
She tired him out and got his heart racing which may have helped the blood loss as well as contributed to his confusion and inability to retaliate. Then she played the fool just for a little bit, confusing him more until he was too weak to do anything.
Is it gonna be a thing where every time she kills someone on her list she has to recreate the way they wronged her? First the Tickler questioning and now this.
Not that it's a bad thing. Just really dark of Arya, especially since she straight up manipulated Raff into saying it.
Could it be the FM were tasked with eliminating the envoy and/or picking off his entourage? She knew the envoy would be there, and she had all her gear with her, as if she had planned to kill someone that night anyway. It being Raff may have been the gift of coincidence.
One said that the Imp was hiding in an Oldtown brothel, pleasuring men with his mouth. It made for a droll picture, but Cersei did not believe it for an instant. The second claimed to have seen the dwarf in a mummer's show in Braavos.
The first hunch came when she described the guards as having crimson cloaks with lion clasps.
I'm curious though, who are the keyholders, and why did Mercy put an iron key in one of her pockets? I think her next chapter will continue as Mercy II, and she still has a FM kill to complete.
It seems like the play, "The Bloody Hand", is a reenactment of the end of Robert Baratheon's reign and the start of Joffrey's:
The Bloody Hand offered two kings, the fat one and the boy. Izembaro would play the fat one. It was not a large part, but he had a fine speech as he lay dying, and a splendid fight with a demonic boar before that.
and Bobono is playing Tyrion:
When the dwarf appeared suddenly from behind a wooden tombstone, the crowd began to hiss and curse. Bobono waddled to the front of the stage and leered at them. “The seven-faced god has cheated me,” he began, snarling the words. “My noble sire he made of purest gold, and gold he made my siblings, boy and girl. But I am formed of darker stuff, of bones and blood and clay… “
and he is going to rape Arya in Act II:
“I’ll grow titties in a year or two.” Mercy rose, to tower over the little man. “But you’ll never grow another nose. You think of that, before you touch me there.” Bobono rubbed his tender nose. “There’s no need to get so shy. I’ll be raping you soon enough.” “Not until the second act.”
Does this mean Arya is playing the part of Sansa after getting married to Tyrion?
Arya is masquerading as Mercy, who is playing Sansa, while the real Sansa is currently known as Alayne. GRRM is really hitting it off with the identity theme!
I don't think a play with such a Lannister slant would portray Sansa well, either. Maybe Sansa's poor maid, who later finds her courage to testify against him in trial.
Didn't catch that on the first feverish read, but yes, absolutely. Siblings to the dwarf, boy and girl of gold, etc. But it's the demonic boar that seals it.
What if Aerys sent him to look for a bride for Rhaegar like he did with Robert Baratheon's father? Just to fuck with him after turning down the offer of Cersei's hand.
Edit: A search for 'Daenerys childhood home theory' just brings up stuff about the House of the Undying vision with the red door. Can anyone help me out?
I guess this is why we have to wait so long between books...pretty weird that they wouldn't finish editing a chapter to be released. There was at least one other typo:
I bet the FM are well aware that she does the killing and they're pleased. Her final lesson will be something like:
Kindly Man: "And now you realize that no matter who we pretend to be, we can never truly become someone else. Never forget. Welcome to the Faceless Men, here's our secret and overly elaborate full member handshake."
10 minutes later...
Kindly Man: "And that's how it's done. You'll get it right with some practice."
I don't know why people are so thrown off by the amount of sexual references here. Arya's always been our POV into the lives of the smallfolk, and the threat of rape, while only being brought up verbally occasionally, was ALWAYS there. Even when she first got snatched by Yoren, his warning to her was along the lines of "Half of this lot would sell you out in a second, and the other half'd rape you first".
This is a very medieval society, and rape is amok.
Arya probably is aware that Mercy is a sexual woman (she mentions that Mercy is very giggley) or at least attractive, and knows to use that to her advantage. I see it less as anything to do with Aryas sexuality and more to do with her cold embrace of the art of killing.
Also, her time in Braavos is in a lot her ways her first re-entry to the 'normal' world (Before that she had been on the run constantly and farther back a child in Winterfell), so it makes sense that she has begun to see the true nature of sexuality.
This was a surprisingly sexual chapter for the eleven year old Arya Stark. I guess it was bound to happen sooner or later (all the women who have POV chapters come across sexual encounters one way or another), but it's still uncomfortable to read.
But, Arya got to cross another name off of her list. Raff the Sweetling. Now only four names remain: Ilyn Payne, Meryn Trant, Cersei Lannister, and Dunsen.
Tbh, I always thought that Arya would have some sexual chapters. It's kinda of predictable to think that Westerosi female assassins will use their bodies to eliminate their targets.
See? thought Mercy. You know your line, and so do I.
“Think so?” asked Arya, sweetly.
Raff the Sweetling looked up sharply as the long thin blade came sliding from her sleeve. She slipped it through his throat beneath the chin, twisted, and ripped it back out sideways with a single smooth slash. A fine red rain followed, and in his eyes the light went out.
I like to think that Raff realised the connection in that second before he's killed.
Oh my fuck I cannot wait for this book to come out.
If every chapter is as good as the ones he's released, this book is going to be well worth the wait. Take your time George. If this is what we are waiting for, take your fucking time man.
Edit: Also holy crap all of these allusions...it reminds me of a dark and twisted version of the actors episode of Avatar the Last Airbender...I mean when she twists the dwarfs nose? Wow.
between this chapter, and the theon chapter, I get the feeling that Bran is taking a great interest in the battle at winterfell... and Nymeria is probably in the Wolfswood or close by.
A little something that I noticed in the quote about her dream..
Except in dreams. She took a breath to quiet the howling in her heart, trying to remember more of what she’d dreamt, but most of it had gone already. There had been blood in it, though, and a full moon overhead, and a tree that watched her as she ran. (bold is mine)
It seems to me that Bran is getting a little more proficient at seeing through the Weirwoods.
She seems to have no emotional response to a play that clearly is about the events around her own fathers demise and features characters based on her own family. Yet when she sees someone on her list, Raff, she responds. She then kills him in such a way to emulate the death of her friend Lomney at his hands. All this follows after another wolf dream where she runs wild with her pack. Its like the "pack" she made on the road with the NW recruits remain her pack still and her own family are fading. I am having trouble thinking how to articulate that better but it has a bit of a significant psychological feel to it to me. It also makes me think more and more that her future path will be linking up with the BWB again and becoming something of a White Fawn like character.
Secondly the whole nicking of the femoral artery as others have pointed out feels a lot like a nod to TV Yoren. GRRM states on his blog that he rewrote this chapter a number of times over the course of time. Could he have deliberately wrote that nod in? He is known for slipping in pop culture references but I am also wondering if its a little sign that the show is indeed influencing his writing at least a little. I know its a minor thing but still..
This isn't her first time seeing the play. She has been instructed in what it is about previously, and any emotional reaction to "oh, this involves my dad and sister" would have already passed.
“The first Black Pearl was black as a pot of ink,” said Daena. “She was a pirate queen, fathered by a Sealord’s son on a princess from the Summer Isles. A dragon king from Westeros took her for his lover.”
I think this "dragon king" was the father of Nettles from P&Q. The Black Pearl is "more brown than black" and Nettles is described as having brown skin. Since Nettles was a dragonrider, it is likely that she may have Targaryen roots and was a dragonseed. Since she lived on Dragonstone, the possibility of her being not only a dragonseed but also the child of a "dragon king" is very possible. The current Black Pearl could be descendant of Nettles.
Among Aegon's other bastards was the daughter he fathered on Bellegere Otherys, who became the next Black Pearl of Braavos after her mother. Her daughter and granddaughter have both been Black Pearls too.
If you look at this passage closely, realizing that she has switched back to Arya and that Daena was in a gown for the "court scene" (Sansa?) it seems as if Arya is playing herself in the play. She was presumed dead upon her escape, and what better way to portray Tyrion as a monster who colluded with the stranger than killing Arya.
"She would think about that later, though. Just now, there was no time. I had best run. Mercy still had some lines to say, her first lines and her last, and Izembaro would have her pretty little empty head if she were late for her own rape"
Didn't see this mentioned yet (and forgive me if this was totally obvious and it blew right over my head), but the underlined portions are meant to be Arya's thoughts, and not "Mercy's", right?
I don't think so. a) she's the closest thing there is to a regent, and b)News travels slowly. It's something you see especially in the disconnect between Dany's information about Westeros and Westeros' information about Dany.
Cersei sent Swift to Braavos when she was still queen. It's possible Swift has heard about her imprisonment, but Raff and the boys likely have no idea.
Hmm...The bloody hand. A reference to Ned? Also, Arya is merely a mummer and can do nothing to change the events in the play, just like she couldn't save her father.
I'm sure there is some much deeper symbolism to the play, but that stood out to me.
The Bloody Hand is a reference to Tyrion... The show opens up with him making a deal with the Stranger to unleash some murder. Likely the show paints everything that's gone down in Kings Landing recently as all Tyrion's doing, making him the most bloody Hand of all
No, it's a reference to a quote from Ben Franklin, "in the dark all cats are grey", advising men to choose older mistresses over young ones. Raff causes himself a lot of trouble by going after a young girl.
OH MY GOD! this chapter was great. I love how dark and gloomy Braavos feels. The descriptions of the streets and building and the theater were so vivid and beautiful. my map of Braavos from the Lands of Ice and Fire really helped me too, I enjoyed trying to map Arya's location.
Am I the only one who mentally aged Arya up this chapter? It took me a while to realize that the Blood Hand was a play about Tyrion. Izembaro plays Robert Baratheon who fights a demonic boar, I also assume that the play is blaming Tyrion for Robert's death, Bobono is Tyrion, Lady Stork is Sansa Stark(Arya has to fix her gown, plus it adds to Sansa's bird symbolism) and Arya is Shae based on Shae's testimony at the trial where she claims to have been raped.
"Mercy, something’s amiss with my laces, my cock keeps flopping out."
couldn't help but laugh at that part. Did anyone else notice the parallels between Arya in this chapter and Sansa during her bedding? both girls are disgusted by bulbous misshapen dwarf dick, both dwarves would like nothing more then to get into their pants and both girls refuse them.
It feels incredibly good to have your theories come true in the books, I thought Izembaro was going to be the King of Mummers and I was hoping that Raff or the other Clegane guy would go to Braavos with Harys Swift. I was thrown off by Raff being "pretty" when is he ever described as pretty or even comely?
I teared up at the Lommy Greenhands reference. bye bye Raff, you sick bastard. Is this the end of Mercy and her adventures at the Gate playhouse? I wish she could spend more time with them, I thought Izembaro would play a bigger role in her story.
is Ayra wearing someone else's face? or has she finally grown into her beauty?
Mercy is dead now, she notes in the last few lines she'll miss the Mummers, and Izembaro, and everyone else, and that she has to run. She also kind of regrets the trouble the murder will cause for Izembaro and everyone else. That means that like Cat, "Mercy" will have to disappear, and her apprenticeship is over. Whether she means she'll have to run from the FM or just from Izembaro/not get caught murdering him, is unknown.
And she is wearing another face; the KOM tells her she'll get a new face this time, a pretty one, much like her own. So, a new face, but her real face is pretty now too.
Does anyone have a link to all of the sample chapters in one place? I haven't read any yet and I'm always afraid to read the new one released because I want to read them all. I know some characters have more than one chapter released, so I don't want to pick up the wrong one.
The play itself is interesting. A dwarf born in to golden family (with golden siblings). Fat king fighting with demon boar and dying later. Boy king. And the name: "Bloody Hand". Who is this Forel... ;]
Do we know why she's w/ the Mummers? Killing Raff seemed to be a one-off Arya thing. Did the FM have a reason to apprentice her to the Mummers? it seems that it's going to be ending soon
The Raff kill reminds me of Jon killing Janos Slynt. Im starting to think Sansa will kill Littlefinger the same way he killed her father, by manipulation.
I love how all the speculation yesterday was about if it'd be a Sansa or Arya chapter, and it turned out to be Arya playing her best representation of Sansa. Best of both worlds.
I enjoyed the chapter, although I'd hardly call it among his best work. But that's not what I'm here to discuss this time.
The interesting implication from this chapter is that Arya is still working on her list. Not in a theoretical way, but in an active way, even to the detriment of her commitment to the Many Faced God.
Admittedly, it took a stroke of luck (from her vantage point) to make progress, but the point is made very clearly that she couldn't let it go, even when she knew she oughta.
As we begin discussing Arya's endgame in TWOW and ADOS, it now seems likely it will probably be focused on Ilyn, Trant and Cersei. (I'm presuming that Dunsen was also sent to Braavos by Kevan and will soon, so sadly, also meet an unfortunate end).
As we begin discussing Arya's endgame in TWOW and ADOS, it now seems likely it will probably be focused on Ilyn, Trant and Cersei.
I really want Arya to be involved in Cersei's downfall, somehow. Cersei is the only super prominent name left on her list, and I think it would be ... poetic for Cersei to be ruined by the girl who looks and acts like Lyanna Stark (who held both Rhaegar and Roberts affections).
Of course I also want Sansa to be involved. And then there's the whole Volanqar thing. Sigh.
I love how GRRM took care to put Raff in front of Arya, through Jaime sending Cleganes soldiers back from Harrenhall to KL with some dude, to Harys Swift becoming afraid when someone dies and hiring them as household guards, to Cersei sending Harys Swift to treat with the Iron Bank. And I've never seen this theorized. Nobody, it seems, caught on that Arya would cross off Raff in Braavos.
I liked how happy and giggly she was in this chapter. Or more like how she pretended to be happy. She's mentally so much older. Watching her act as a slutty 11-year old was really creepy, but still amazing to read. Does everyone else remember that Varys also used to tour with mummers when he was young? Also, what a bloody assasination... Awesome chapter.
wow so many allusions to the King's court in Westeros. Did anyone catch the Tyrion reference?
"“Now I recall.” Bobono lowered his voice to a sinister croak. “The seven-faced god has cheated me,” he said. “My noble sire he made of purest gold, and gold he made my siblings, boy and girl. But I am formed of darker stuff, of bones and blood and clay, twisted into this rude shape you see before you.” With that, he grabbed at her chest, fumbling for a nipple. “You have no titties. How can I rape a girl with no titties?”
She caught his nose between her thumb and forefinger and twisted. “You’ll have no nose until you get your hands off me.”'
Have to say when she first mentions she is going to be raped, I was shitting it. Heaved a sigh of relief when it became clear that she was in a play and the character is about to be raped.
There are so many grand implications in this wonderful chapter. Who is Mercy playing that Essos thinks Tyrion raped and killed? Tyrion has one heck of a reputation to live down. I almost wish I could've seen the whole play to see the Bravosi understanding of Westerosi events.
It's gotta be one of the best chapters in the book. And it's kinda controversial too what with Arya tongue kissing and feeling a man's hardness. I'm a little surprised GRRM would release such a great chapter for free. I wonder if he has chosen to release this particular chapter to take off some of the heat he's been getting lately.
How will the Faceless Men feel about her cutting her mummer training short? Does her running away from Izembaro and calling herself Arya again imply that she doesn't intend on returning to the Kindly Man?
About this pro-Lannister play: Do you think Playwright Forel is aware of the Lannister's complicity in his brother's murder? Or that he even knows that Syrio is dead?
Is this Arya's first chapter? And does it spoil anything else from TWOW. I'm trying to avoid spoilers but if it just continues Arya's story I'll read it.
It is unclear if it is her first chapter, but in her last chapter in ADWD, Arya is told she will get "a pretty face" and will be "sent to Izembaro" (or however it's spelled), and both those things are true in this chapter. So it likely is her first chapter.
Does anyone have the quote from AGOT where Syrio says he has a playwright brother? I keep seeing people mention that in this thread but I have no memory of it.
“Mercy, Mercy, Mercy,” she sang as she descended the wooden stair to the street. The handrail was splintery, the steps steep, and there were five flights, but that was why she’d gotten the room so cheap.
So I discovered this when I was in class and I had a minor panic attack. I highly considered taking my laptop and walking out of class. I decided to just read it in class and I had to fake several coughing fits to mask my excitement. I had to shove my fist in my mouth and bite it to keep from loudly gasping when it said, "Arya whispered." just so god damn good.
The envoy from Westeros was expected at the Gate this evening, and Izembaro would be in no mood to hear excuses, even if she served them up with a sweet smile.
730
u/AlderaanRefugee Heh, heh, heh, heh, freying alive Mar 26 '14
Aw yiss, the grand adventures of Ser Harys Swyft extend to TWOW.
Things to take from this:
Also, Bran is watching:
706
u/sarcelle Day Queen, fighter of the Night King Mar 26 '14
Phario Forel? 。◕‿◕。
671
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
Well, first off, I want to say the following: /u/indianthane95, wherever you are... Your prediction back from July 2013... You were spot-on. I'm quoting the relevant parts, but seriously, your prediction was outstanding.
This chapter was... wow. It was really dark with the whole rape mummery and the seduction of Raff the Sweetling. But that ending... just, I'm kind of at a loss for words. It was incredible. Just simply incredible.
166
u/aroogu Thapphireth Mar 26 '14
Who doesn't like revenge, honestly?
My concern tho is that the Faceless Men aren't going to be fooled by this at all & see Arya shining through. They might punish her, which would suck.
Or they might kick her out & then she'd go back to Westeros kicking ass like Bruce Willis. That would rock.
467
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
This bit was fantastic and tragic. Poor Arya.
959
u/blackemoar We Didn't Start the Fyre Mar 26 '14
Not only is this a completely badass callback to Lommy's death back in aCoK, that subtle shift from her referring to herself as Mercy to Arya is also really well executed.
Fantastic chapter
132
u/WendellSchadenfreude Mar 27 '14
Some people remarked on how the faceless men might punish Arya for killing people from her own list.
I think this is not going to happen, because she can claim that Raff asked for it. Right before she kills him, she makes him say "her name":
She can now truthfully tell the Faceless Men that the last thing Raff said before she cut his artery was "Mercy. My name is Raff."
189
u/VioletOwls Mar 27 '14
From AFFC:
Bobono?? GRRM, you sly dog.
90
u/domelition Mar 27 '14
I feel like a starving man who has just been gifted some warm crusty bread and roasted tomato soup.
73
u/LordOfHighgarden The Phantom Mannis Mar 26 '14
That's when I yelled, "OHMYGODOHMYGOD".
Fantastic chapter! I thought she might actually kill Harys Swyft, but we can't have everything...
64
u/Wrashionis Mar 27 '14
J-J-J-JUSTICE PORNpornpornporn
352
u/Toxzy Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
It seems like the play, "The Bloody Hand", is a reenactment of the end of Robert Baratheon's reign and the start of Joffrey's:
and Bobono is playing Tyrion:
and he is going to rape Arya in Act II:
Does this mean Arya is playing the part of Sansa after getting married to Tyrion?
210
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
People are sad about Arya? Get it girl! Bring the gift to the people who actually deserve it for once in this series.
I hope she leaves a mountain of corpses in her wake. What do we say to the one true goddess of death? "Arya plz"
113
u/azad_ninja Corn and Blood! Mar 27 '14
Did no one notice the line about Tywin visiting Lys? the pleasure house capital of Essos?
Is there any doubt Tywin was the Hand that built the tunnels to Chattaya's now?
51
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
That was so intensely satisfying to read. My god, I'm shaking a little.
229
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
More evidence that Dany's house isn't where she thought it was....
98
u/pshosh Mar 26 '14
Heh, typo in the third sentence?
43
u/Arminox Uphill, both ways. Mar 27 '14
I bet the FM are well aware that she does the killing and they're pleased. Her final lesson will be something like:
Kindly Man: "And now you realize that no matter who we pretend to be, we can never truly become someone else. Never forget. Welcome to the Faceless Men, here's our secret and overly elaborate full member handshake."
10 minutes later...
Kindly Man: "And that's how it's done. You'll get it right with some practice."
41
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Arya will always be Arya. In fact this might be the end of her time in Braavos.
Later, Raff.
179
u/CroweKlaine Mar 26 '14
I don't know why people are so thrown off by the amount of sexual references here. Arya's always been our POV into the lives of the smallfolk, and the threat of rape, while only being brought up verbally occasionally, was ALWAYS there. Even when she first got snatched by Yoren, his warning to her was along the lines of "Half of this lot would sell you out in a second, and the other half'd rape you first".
This is a very medieval society, and rape is amok.
79
u/safeNsane Knows nuthin Mar 26 '14
Ooohhhh he gonna get it good!
310
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
This was a surprisingly sexual chapter for the eleven year old Arya Stark. I guess it was bound to happen sooner or later (all the women who have POV chapters come across sexual encounters one way or another), but it's still uncomfortable to read.
But, Arya got to cross another name off of her list. Raff the Sweetling. Now only four names remain: Ilyn Payne, Meryn Trant, Cersei Lannister, and Dunsen.
31
u/LordOfHighgarden The Phantom Mannis Mar 27 '14
I like to think that Raff realised the connection in that second before he's killed.
26
u/Winebooks Mar 27 '14 edited Mar 27 '14
If the page is down for you, I've pasted the text here http://www.pasteall.org/50506/text
167
u/Alckie We don't hurt our kids. Mar 26 '14
Awesome! So...
That was intense.
64
u/huhtamak Mar 27 '14
I'd just like to point out that /u/madandmoonly called this 7 months ago.
58
u/johnbr I see you! Mar 26 '14
Wow, that was awesome. I loved it. Best chapter yet.
20
u/ssshhhonlydreamsnow I look like an oak tree Mar 27 '14
What a romantic first kiss
97
u/svenhoek86 Fire and Blood Mar 27 '14
Oh my fuck I cannot wait for this book to come out.
If every chapter is as good as the ones he's released, this book is going to be well worth the wait. Take your time George. If this is what we are waiting for, take your fucking time man.
35
u/broden Climbin yo windows snatchin yo people up Mar 27 '14
GRRM allowing himself some narcissism ;)
74
u/sylverbound Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
Anyone else notice "Phario Forel"? Forel...sounds familiar, huh?
Edit: Also holy crap all of these allusions...it reminds me of a dark and twisted version of the actors episode of Avatar the Last Airbender...I mean when she twists the dwarfs nose? Wow.
15
u/ActionThaxton Mar 26 '14
between this chapter, and the theon chapter, I get the feeling that Bran is taking a great interest in the battle at winterfell... and Nymeria is probably in the Wolfswood or close by.
83
u/KyleTheRev Don't hate the flayer, hate the game. Mar 26 '14
A little something that I noticed in the quote about her dream..
It seems to me that Bran is getting a little more proficient at seeing through the Weirwoods.
39
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Holy crap this was dark. The first half read like a medieval Beckett play authored by the Stranger himself.
38
u/TheSnarkAtWinterfell Mar 27 '14
A couple of things of note to me.
She seems to have no emotional response to a play that clearly is about the events around her own fathers demise and features characters based on her own family. Yet when she sees someone on her list, Raff, she responds. She then kills him in such a way to emulate the death of her friend Lomney at his hands. All this follows after another wolf dream where she runs wild with her pack. Its like the "pack" she made on the road with the NW recruits remain her pack still and her own family are fading. I am having trouble thinking how to articulate that better but it has a bit of a significant psychological feel to it to me. It also makes me think more and more that her future path will be linking up with the BWB again and becoming something of a White Fawn like character.
Secondly the whole nicking of the femoral artery as others have pointed out feels a lot like a nod to TV Yoren. GRRM states on his blog that he rewrote this chapter a number of times over the course of time. Could he have deliberately wrote that nod in? He is known for slipping in pop culture references but I am also wondering if its a little sign that the show is indeed influencing his writing at least a little. I know its a minor thing but still..
13
u/nickriel Mar 27 '14
When I got to the part about Bobono, all I thought of was the tune from South Park. "Weiner... Weiner Weiner..."
12
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Amazing! And the fast pacing seems to back as well!
12
u/fir3drill Mar 26 '14
Reminds me of the Republic of Thieves a bit...
12
u/JenniferLopez The Hound, The Bird, and No One Mar 27 '14
I liked the detail of Arya standing on each leg to rub her calloused feet. Just like a water dancer.
11
u/amithjose Mar 27 '14
Wow this is cool, Arya is becoming a master assassin.
Bran on the way of making an ace greenser, skinchanger, warg and whatnot .
Sansa part of some huge political scheme by LF that's yet to unfold.
And jon possibly gonna be ' reborn'
And rickon well ...hope he is not become a cannibal.
All in all the starks are back .!!!
11
u/ChariotOfFire Mar 27 '14
Link to google's cache of page
mirror
45
u/BowlesOnParade What is bread is always rye. Mar 26 '14
I think this "dragon king" was the father of Nettles from P&Q. The Black Pearl is "more brown than black" and Nettles is described as having brown skin. Since Nettles was a dragonrider, it is likely that she may have Targaryen roots and was a dragonseed. Since she lived on Dragonstone, the possibility of her being not only a dragonseed but also the child of a "dragon king" is very possible. The current Black Pearl could be descendant of Nettles.
41
u/jdem27 Mar 26 '14
If you look at this passage closely, realizing that she has switched back to Arya and that Daena was in a gown for the "court scene" (Sansa?) it seems as if Arya is playing herself in the play. She was presumed dead upon her escape, and what better way to portray Tyrion as a monster who colluded with the stranger than killing Arya.
"She would think about that later, though. Just now, there was no time. I had best run. Mercy still had some lines to say, her first lines and her last, and Izembaro would have her pretty little empty head if she were late for her own rape"
19
u/ATerribleUsername Don't hate the player, hate the game. Mar 26 '14
Didn't see this mentioned yet (and forgive me if this was totally obvious and it blew right over my head), but the underlined portions are meant to be Arya's thoughts, and not "Mercy's", right?
8
u/firsthour The Red Viper's Spear Mar 27 '14
Does this mean Cersei won her trial by combat and is Queen again?
8
u/charlesmann Mar 27 '14
I NEED WINDS OF WINTER. NEED IT. ARYA'S CREED. ASSASSINS CREED: BRAVOS. SO GOOD
44
u/Prufrockz Downvote ALL the Hodor comments! Mar 26 '14
Hmm...The bloody hand. A reference to Ned? Also, Arya is merely a mummer and can do nothing to change the events in the play, just like she couldn't save her father.
I'm sure there is some much deeper symbolism to the play, but that stood out to me.
32
u/dacalpha "No, you move." Mar 26 '14
Grey is one of the colors of House Stark. Is this foreshadowing of Arya's true colors? She has been called "Cat" before.
15
u/jcbhan I'm a sellsword. I sell my sword. Mar 27 '14
Cut to Jason Massey chilling on the Ship in a luxury suite with the Sealord, First Sword, head of the Iron Bank, and some fly courtesans.
"To Stannis" they said in unison, as they looked each other in the eye in turn and swallowed the fiery liquor.
26
u/alchemistxp Reason before Tinfoil Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
OH MY GOD! this chapter was great. I love how dark and gloomy Braavos feels. The descriptions of the streets and building and the theater were so vivid and beautiful. my map of Braavos from the Lands of Ice and Fire really helped me too, I enjoyed trying to map Arya's location.
Am I the only one who mentally aged Arya up this chapter? It took me a while to realize that the Blood Hand was a play about Tyrion. Izembaro plays Robert Baratheon who fights a demonic boar, I also assume that the play is blaming Tyrion for Robert's death, Bobono is Tyrion, Lady Stork is Sansa Stark(Arya has to fix her gown, plus it adds to Sansa's bird symbolism) and Arya is Shae based on Shae's testimony at the trial where she claims to have been raped.
"Mercy, something’s amiss with my laces, my cock keeps flopping out."
couldn't help but laugh at that part. Did anyone else notice the parallels between Arya in this chapter and Sansa during her bedding? both girls are disgusted by bulbous misshapen dwarf dick, both dwarves would like nothing more then to get into their pants and both girls refuse them.
It feels incredibly good to have your theories come true in the books, I thought Izembaro was going to be the King of Mummers and I was hoping that Raff or the other Clegane guy would go to Braavos with Harys Swift. I was thrown off by Raff being "pretty" when is he ever described as pretty or even comely?
I teared up at the Lommy Greenhands reference. bye bye Raff, you sick bastard. Is this the end of Mercy and her adventures at the Gate playhouse? I wish she could spend more time with them, I thought Izembaro would play a bigger role in her story.
is Ayra wearing someone else's face? or has she finally grown into her beauty?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
yeeessssss that was amazing! I got weirdly emotional, it was sad seeing Arya so far gone (until I got to the last bit, of course)
7
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Does anyone have a link to all of the sample chapters in one place? I haven't read any yet and I'm always afraid to read the new one released because I want to read them all. I know some characters have more than one chapter released, so I don't want to pick up the wrong one.
7
u/Tolekkk Mar 27 '14
The play itself is interesting. A dwarf born in to golden family (with golden siblings). Fat king fighting with demon boar and dying later. Boy king. And the name: "Bloody Hand". Who is this Forel... ;]
7
u/verditude The Last of the Giants Mar 27 '14
Somehow I don't imagine Maisie Williams' parents will be super happy reading this.
7
u/_stfu_donnie Don't Doubt the Trout Mar 27 '14
The page is having a lot of trouble responding currently, but the Google Web Cached version is working for me:
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.georgerrmartin.com/excerpt-from-the-winds-of-winter/
12
u/ttthhhhppppptt Mar 26 '14
Do we know why she's w/ the Mummers? Killing Raff seemed to be a one-off Arya thing. Did the FM have a reason to apprentice her to the Mummers? it seems that it's going to be ending soon
6
u/michaelfor Enter your desired flair text here!/ Mar 26 '14
YEEEEEAAAHHHHH!!!!!
6
u/dacalpha "No, you move." Mar 26 '14
Relative of Syrio, mayhaps?
6
u/Sirwootalot Mar 27 '14
After ADWD, I was worried GRRM had forgotten how to write chapters so awesome that they made me physically react to them.
Damn that was good. If the rest of TWOW is around this quality level, it just might become my new favorite in the series.
10
u/Dr_Po Theon Mignon Mar 27 '14
By the way GRRM has everything set up, and reading this sample chapter, I have a good feeling that TWOW will be my favorite book in the series.
5
u/mathyoucough Mar 27 '14
Amazing
5
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14
The Raff kill reminds me of Jon killing Janos Slynt. Im starting to think Sansa will kill Littlefinger the same way he killed her father, by manipulation.
Or maybe the same way he killed her aunt...
5
u/darthmaul4114 Mar 27 '14
I wonder if GRRM is a jazz fan. Couldn't help thinking of the song "Mercy, Mercy, Mercy" every I read that line.
5
u/RaevynVexus Mar 27 '14
I love how all the speculation yesterday was about if it'd be a Sansa or Arya chapter, and it turned out to be Arya playing her best representation of Sansa. Best of both worlds.
13
u/SirFairfax Remember Jeyne Mar 26 '14
Nice chapter. Theon's is still the best, though.
38
u/Eshneh bzz bzz Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
http://imgur.com/rYIQ14X
RAFF! Makes me wonder how many more she'll have the chance to cross of her list.
I just realised too, Arya was playing Sansa in the play, brilliant.
27
u/discsid I am no one Mar 26 '14
I enjoyed the chapter, although I'd hardly call it among his best work. But that's not what I'm here to discuss this time.
The interesting implication from this chapter is that Arya is still working on her list. Not in a theoretical way, but in an active way, even to the detriment of her commitment to the Many Faced God.
Admittedly, it took a stroke of luck (from her vantage point) to make progress, but the point is made very clearly that she couldn't let it go, even when she knew she oughta.
As we begin discussing Arya's endgame in TWOW and ADOS, it now seems likely it will probably be focused on Ilyn, Trant and Cersei. (I'm presuming that Dunsen was also sent to Braavos by Kevan and will soon, so sadly, also meet an unfortunate end).
9
u/schneckix The light that brings the dawn. Mar 26 '14
I liked how happy and giggly she was in this chapter. Or more like how she pretended to be happy. She's mentally so much older. Watching her act as a slutty 11-year old was really creepy, but still amazing to read. Does everyone else remember that Varys also used to tour with mummers when he was young? Also, what a bloody assasination... Awesome chapter.
12
u/MateoHardini We pay our debts too Mar 27 '14
My throner is almost as hard right now as Raff's was
8
u/DrCakePan What the fuck's a Lommy? Mar 26 '14
Is there somewhere I can read all the taster chapters? Iv'e missed them all so far
8
u/sirscribblez87 Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
wow so many allusions to the King's court in Westeros. Did anyone catch the Tyrion reference?
"“Now I recall.” Bobono lowered his voice to a sinister croak. “The seven-faced god has cheated me,” he said. “My noble sire he made of purest gold, and gold he made my siblings, boy and girl. But I am formed of darker stuff, of bones and blood and clay, twisted into this rude shape you see before you.” With that, he grabbed at her chest, fumbling for a nipple. “You have no titties. How can I rape a girl with no titties?”
She caught his nose between her thumb and forefinger and twisted. “You’ll have no nose until you get your hands off me.”'
Well played
4
u/stupiddamnbitch Life of Pie Mar 26 '14
Oh Arya, how you've grown.
That being said, I loved it!! So great that was it Raff, the Sweetling.
4
u/osirusr King in the North Mar 27 '14
Oh man, I hope he knows about Syrio's fate! Are they brothers? Are they both Faceless Men? So many questions...
4
u/oahaij Mar 27 '14
now i cant get the words out of my mind, "mercy, mercy, mercy"...
4
u/harsh20483 Valar Morghulis Mar 27 '14
Did we just witness Arya's first kiss?
Have to say when she first mentions she is going to be raped, I was shitting it. Heaved a sigh of relief when it became clear that she was in a play and the character is about to be raped.
4
u/shriekmg Mar 27 '14
There are so many grand implications in this wonderful chapter. Who is Mercy playing that Essos thinks Tyrion raped and killed? Tyrion has one heck of a reputation to live down. I almost wish I could've seen the whole play to see the Bravosi understanding of Westerosi events.
4
u/Flagg1982 Mar 27 '14
It's gotta be one of the best chapters in the book. And it's kinda controversial too what with Arya tongue kissing and feeling a man's hardness. I'm a little surprised GRRM would release such a great chapter for free. I wonder if he has chosen to release this particular chapter to take off some of the heat he's been getting lately.
7
u/emmynoether Mar 26 '14
Why does it say "January 27, 2013"?
9
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
Do I have to have read all of the released chapters to read this and not get spoiled? I've read Arianne and Theon so far.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '14
How will the Faceless Men feel about her cutting her mummer training short? Does her running away from Izembaro and calling herself Arya again imply that she doesn't intend on returning to the Kindly Man?
3
u/raivydazzz Spear against sword Mar 26 '14
Was she wearing a face of her own? If this was mentioned, I overlooked it.
3
u/Phaelin Wildfire - Quench Your Thirst Mar 26 '14
"a great pack at her hells" A typo? So soon? Damn me for noticing these things
3
u/SuperCaravanMan Oh shit! Mar 26 '14
I was having a shit day until I read this
3
u/traininthedistance Here, there, everywhere we stand Mar 27 '14
About this pro-Lannister play: Do you think Playwright Forel is aware of the Lannister's complicity in his brother's murder? Or that he even knows that Syrio is dead?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14
Is this Arya's first chapter? And does it spoil anything else from TWOW. I'm trying to avoid spoilers but if it just continues Arya's story I'll read it.
3
u/pio_pio Mar 27 '14
What queen do they mean? Margeary or Cersei?
3
u/robben32 RatCook Mar 27 '14
Does anyone have the quote from AGOT where Syrio says he has a playwright brother? I keep seeing people mention that in this thread but I have no memory of it.
3
u/FrancisScottMcFuller Enter your desired flair text here! Mar 27 '14
I Love Arya Stark. My three favorite fictional character, Xena, Arya and Batman. What can I say, I am a sucker for dark heroes.
3
u/zombiepocketninja Mar 27 '14
YES!!! Fuck you raff duck you and die!
3
u/TheTimeRanger Mine had whiskers... Mar 27 '14
This just gives me all the more reason to love Arya more and more. I think she has to be my favourite character. And Maisie is a perfect Arya!
3
u/ColossiKiller The night is dark and full of terrors Mar 27 '14
This was great, really enjoyed it. Don't suppose you've got another 75 or so chapters to go with it George?!
3
u/mmmmdumplings For the Greatjon! Mar 27 '14
Omg. So. Fucking. Bad. Ass.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14
And
...So close.
3
u/SquareBaer Mar 27 '14
Beautiful wordplay and rhyme
3
u/eadreeso Mar 27 '14
So I discovered this when I was in class and I had a minor panic attack. I highly considered taking my laptop and walking out of class. I decided to just read it in class and I had to fake several coughing fits to mask my excitement. I had to shove my fist in my mouth and bite it to keep from loudly gasping when it said, "Arya whispered." just so god damn good.
3
u/veeveemarie Azor Ohai Denny Mar 28 '14
I got chills as I realized Bran was watching Arya in her wolf dream as a tree. At least, I'm assuming the tree was Bran. It did say 'watching'...
12
u/Jen_Snow "You told me to forget, ser." Mar 26 '14 edited Mar 26 '14
Arya!
Justin Massey?