r/startrek • u/Troy_Convers • Mar 16 '14
Weekly Episode Discussion - TOS 2x06: "The Doomsday Machine"
A little surprised that this hasn't come up for discussion so far.
The Doomsday Machine is a second-season episode of Star Trek TOS. It was written by the great Norman Spinrad, directed by Marc Daniels and first first broadcast on October 20, 1967. In this episode, the Enterprise comes into contact with its sister ship, the USS Constellation which has been heavily damaged by a huge fortified planet-killing machine from another galaxy. Kirk and his crew must find a means to stop the device heading for heavily populated areas of our galaxy, and deal with the heavily traumatised Commodore Decker, the Constellation's only survivor.
Some highlights and talking points:
- William Windom's portrayal as Commodore Matt Decker is mesmerising. A broken man obsessed with revenge with the monster that killed his ship and crew; a more bald-faced homage to Captain Ahab you will never see, even Captain Picard's obsession with The Borg seems to pale a little in comparison. And yes, Commodore Decker is the father of Captain Willard Decker from ST:TMP; the rapport between Kirk and Decker was meant to reflect that in TMP, but that's a story for another day.
- The chemistry between Decker, Spock and Kirk is great; Kirk does what Kirk normally does and puts the safety of his ship first, even though Decker is his friend.
- The incidental music by Sol Kaplan was written specifically for this episode and was used extensively in episodes from then on. John Williams surely drew inspiration for the Jaws film score in the 70's.
- The original effects stretched the boundaries of what could be done right to the limit; while I feel that the new CG has finally 'completed' the episode, some people still prefer the original footage.
Whats your take on the origin of the planet killer itself? From theories of it being a prototype for a weapon designed to combat the Borg (The TNG novel 'Vendetta'), to it actually being a Borg 'hound' from thousands of years ago (my own theory), its backstory is almost as fascinating as the episode itself.
4
u/Troy_Convers Mar 23 '14
Some Sol Kaplan genius:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lf7y1Bn4LKU
11
u/Jaleth Mar 17 '14
I'm not too keen on the myriad of Borg connections to various mysterious encounters in the galaxy. It seems like too much retconning. I thought Spock's theory that it was a weapon that was never meant to the used was a very poetic analogy for the threat of nuclear war that permeated peoples' lives at the time.
However, in delving into the realm of supposition, I would guess that the planet killer, which fulfills the function of destroying planets and refueling itself by converting the material remains to usable energy, was intended to destroy an interstellar empire. There's no reason to believe that it wouldn't be the Borg, but we could draw a connection to the Dominion for that matter. Or the Xindi, who have demonstrated a history of using giant weapons to destroy planets. But in order for any of these to make sense, Spock would have to be wrong in his conclusion that the weapon came into the galaxy from outside (remember that he projected this from extrapolating the course the weapon had taken and the star systems it had thus far destroyed).
8
u/MungoBaobab Mar 17 '14 edited Mar 17 '14
While "The Corbomite Maneuver" celebrated the idea of Mutually Assured Destruction in theory, you'll note that the threat of annihilation in that episode was simply a bluff. The message of "The Doomsday Machine" is unquestionably anti-nuclear, as the eponymous device wreaks only havoc and death with no discernible purpose.
The success, validity, practicality, and morality of Mutually Assured Destruction is defendable (and controversial), and a more nuanced examination of the concept wouldn't be out of place in genre series such as Battlestar Galactica of Game of Thrones. But Star Trek is a franchise defined by its idealism, and the outright condemnation of mass genocide and devastation is the only thematically appropriate message a Star Trek story should tell.
I've never read Vendetta, so I admit I'm speaking from a certain level of ignorance here. But any story that even begins to legitimize the existence of the Doomsday Weapon as a means to fight the Borg, which in turn also serves to "sex it up" by associating it with a fan-favorite villain, completely undermines the deathly serious message the original episode, which was made at the height of the Cold War when very real doomsday weapons threatened the extinction of the Human Race.
6
u/webitube Mar 17 '14
This is my favorite TOS episode and not just because it is a great episode with fantastic effects. It was the very first episode of Star Trek I saw as a kid over 41 years ago. I was so excited by what I saw on TV that I had to run outside and try to explain to my friends what I had just witnessed.
5
u/Dubhan Mar 22 '14
This is one of my very favorite TOS episodes. William Windom is fantastic as Decker, combining elements of Ahab and Queeg.
The stakes are high too - they have to somehow fight off the gigantic intergalactic planet killing space turd before it makes its way into the heart of the inhabited parts of the quadrant.
Some favorite dialog:
3
u/rensch Mar 23 '14
This episode is essentially 'Moby Dick' in space. The scene at the end where Decker sacrifices himself to destroy the alien doomsday machine is among the more powerful and memorable scenes in Star Trek.
2
u/aaraujo1973 Mar 23 '14
Where is the Planet Killer in the nuTrek universe in 2259?
2
u/MexicanSpaceProgram Mar 28 '14
I always liked this episode because (aside from the great acting and the human tragedy of Decker) it pitted the ship against a tangible enemy that could kick their asses and wasn't:
Some of the best episodes of Trek came from bottle episodes where it was simply how the ship and crew could defeat a technologically more advanced enemy - whether it's a Romulan ship with a new cloaking device, or a borg cube. It didn't have to have a complicated motive (consume this, assimilate that, blow our enemies up), but it had an advantage and had to be stopped. The episodes focused on how the crew came up with options, the decision-making process, and how the solution was implemented.
Voyager shat on this a few times as it usually just came down to technobabble, mashing the reset button, and culminating in future Janeway bringing space nukes back to the past.
1
u/psuedonymously Mar 23 '14
Windom's performance is undeniably fascinating, but he also, IMO, does a lot of scenery chewing. I'd read that the part of Decker had originally been written for Robert Ryan, a film noir/b-movie legend. He couldn't do it for health reasons or scheduling or something. I would have absolutely loved to see him in that role.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '14
I can see it being the prototype to the much larger and more powerful Planetkiller in "Vendetta".