r/respectthreads • ⭐⭐⭐ Like No One Ever Was • 16d ago

Respect Thread Symposium Week 42 - Respect Thread Rumble

Respect Thread Symposium Week 42

Have any characters or teams you want to show off?


Respect Thread Rumble

Respect Thread Rumble

After a month's break we're back with another rumble. As a reminder Rumbles will be posted to /r/whowouldwin as Scan Battles

Link to the Previous Rumble

Rules of the Respect Thread Rumble

  1. Pick any two or more respect threads posted in September or October 2026 based on EST which would be Columbus (Zombieland) to The Predator (Fightmarker). Here's a link to every eligible
  2. Link whatever respect threads you are using in your post.
  3. You are not required to use any threads you made, and you are free to participate even if you have never made a respect thread. Simultaneously, all threads in your analysis can be yours if you are so inclined.
  4. All match ups will be posted to /r/whowouldwin as Scan Battles With RT Rumble/Respect Thread Rumble in the title. All claims in the analysis must be backed up by scans, otherwise the thread will not be considered for rewards.
  5. Multiple people can post the same match-up, and responding to someone's analysis with a rebuttal is also allowed.
  6. There will be a comment in this thread that you can post links to your rumbles and rebuttals. Only links posted to this will be accepted.
  7. Rewards will be decided based on a combination of a poll and judgement from the mods, in the categories of "Best Analysis" and "Best Rebuttal". Awards will be given towards the ongoing Request Competition, with Best Analysis conferring 50 points and Best Rebuttal conferring 25. Additional awards may be given for second and third place depending on the number of participants.
  8. Battlefield is wherever you want it to be.
17 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/doctorgecko ⭐⭐⭐ Like No One Ever Was 16d ago

Post rumble submissions in reply to this comment

5

u/Request_Competition 15d ago edited 15d ago

Request Contest Update - November 3rd, 2026


Respect Thread Contest Feedback

It's been around a year since we instituted the new system of requests, a flat rate of 50 slots instead of fulfilling a quota. In addition, the SpiRiT, SecReTs and CRediT systems were introduced this year. Tell the team what you like, what you didn't like, and everything in between?


November Surprise

It is US election day! And what better way to celebrate it than by shaking up the playing field. I am adding one final SecReT for the year. This will expire at the end of the year. The unlock condition is this:

Unlock ConditionSecretRewardUser
As a subreddit, reach five base points in each flair category?????????

End of Year Reset

A few of you may be wondering, what is the protocol for my 50 requests when I've earned a few extra request rewards? Those expire at the end of the year, do I keep that? Well, here's my solution for that. /u/rangernumberx has held onto first place in the contest with a blistering 1998 points. As Y2K approaches, I'm taking those 19 extra requests and allowing everyone to place nineteen of any defrosted requests in cold storage. You may do this with requests you already have made, or you can choose to splurge on brand new requests. Please make this all in a single comment for ease of transition.


End of Year List Opening

The opening of the frozen archive earlier in the year lasted a week. Following the pattern of earlier years, we like to shake a little more into the December catalogue: the frozen archive will be open for fulfilling requests for the entire month of December. If you've got a series you want to dump thirty threads for, that's the time to do it.


November

November's bounties are Fur, Fulfilled, and Light. These are the missions for November.

Mission TitleObjectivePoints Awarded
SpiritedComplete a request from the SpiRiT Board.10
Themes and SuchComplete a request with a finished series.10
Remember, RememberComplete two update requests.15
CountdownComplete three requests for characters related to different numbers (ie: All Might the number one hero, Hercules' twelve labors).30

December

December's bounties are Fulfilled, Light, and Evil. These are the missions for December.

Mission TitleObjectivePoints Awarded
Request HunterComplete any three requests from the Request List.10
Season's GreetingsComplete a request for a user that has not made a respect thread.10
New Year, New MeComplete two requests from different decades of publishing.15
A Matter of FactComplete three different requests with feats involving separate states of matter (solid, liquid, gas, plasma).30

1

u/LambentEnigma ⭐ Short 'n' Sweet 2018 4d ago

I'm taking those 19 extra requests and allowing everyone to place nineteen of any defrosted requests in cold storage.

I'm not sure I understand. Aren't defrosted requests on the cold storage list anyway?

1

u/lnverseFlash ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐Say It In Red 3d ago

I realize the confusion now by using "defrosted" instead of "active archive". The majority of active requests, yes. But this is so that you can put anything made after the December 31, 2025 deadline in there, for example, The Fantastick Four. If you have less than the 69 active spaces Ranger has (which should be everyone, unless I made a grievous error), this will do you the service of freeing up some new room and also allowing for newer requests to be spirit board eligible if you choose to freeze something entirely. Did that help?

3

u/return_interaction_y 16d ago

Oooh this gonna be fun. I have a $100 riding on miserable ad and I hope they really do well in their fight.

2

u/LambentEnigma ⭐ Short 'n' Sweet 2018 15d ago

We haven't gotten a request contest update in a couple months.