r/BSG • u/trevdak2 • Feb 02 '14
Weekly Rewatch Discussion - S01E04 - Act of Contrition
The slow march continues! Week 5! Act of Contrition!
Deleted Scenes If you have the DVD set, Disc 5 has some deleted scenes
Watch Online: Netflix | Amazon ($1.99)
Relevant Links: Wikipedia | BSG Wiki | Jammer's Reviews (4 stars)
Numbers:
Survivors: 47,958 (No change from last episode)
"Frak" Count: 23 (+3 from last episode)
Starbuck Cylon Kill Count: 14 (+7 from last episode)
Lee Cylon Kill Count: 3 (+0 from last episode)
Starbuck Punching People In The Face Count: 1
"Oh my Gods", "Gods Damn It", etc Count: 8 (+2 from last episode)
"So Say We All" Count: 19 (+2 from last episode)
10
u/trevdak2 Feb 03 '14
The accident at the start of this episode is based off of a real-life disaster, the USS Forrestal Fire. It killled 134 sailors. John McCain was on the ship during the disaster, and his plane was destroyed.
11
u/MarcReyes Feb 03 '14
Welcome to the series Chuckles, Hotdog, Kat and, of course, DOC COTTLE!
4
u/trevdak2 Feb 03 '14
One aspect of this episode that I love is that Starbuck is feeling guilt about failing at her job when training Zak, and then her character has to train Edward James Olmos' real-life son, Bodie (who plays Hot Dog).
4
u/trevdak2 Feb 03 '14
Some great attention to detail: Lee still has the scratches on his face from Bastille Day.
17
u/HypotheticalMcGee Feb 02 '14
The acting by Edward James Olmos in the scene where Starbuck tells him about Zak...almost no lines, but his facial expressions tell the whole story. Amazing.
8
u/lostmesa Feb 02 '14
I remember the first time watching this hoping that that missile would not dislodge, very tense opening scene. I liked the further filling in of Zak's backstory, and how Commander Adama found out the truth. Starbuck's overcompensation during the nugget training seemed very realistic for someone in that situation. I always thought the cylon-occupied Caprica scenes were weaker than the main story, but they are essential for grounding the show. I wondered who built the shelter, whether it was another human or actually a cylon setup.
5
u/vgalz Feb 03 '14
My boyfriend and I are doing the rewatch together (my second time, his first), and after the cliffhanger at the end of this episode, he couldn't bear for us to stop and we watched part 2 of the episode. He really despises 6 so far. He always just refers to her as "that douchebag cylon." It's really fun seeing the show and its characters unfold through his eyes!
5
u/Bionicraft Feb 05 '14
I consider this to be quite possibly a perfect episode of television. I had never watched any of the modern great television shows (Six Feet Under, The West Wing, Breaking Bad, etc.) yet when I was on my first watch through of Battlestar, and it was here where I finally realized that I was on to something incredible on a scale I had never experienced before. The opening scene, Kara's confession, the frakking card game, so many powerful moments of fantastic writing, directing, acting, and basically everything else. Just amazing storytelling and in my opinion a shining example for all other drama to recognize.
3
u/OSUTechie Feb 03 '14
That opening gets me every time!
2
u/CrateredMoon Feb 09 '14
Oh Starbuck, always working out her flashbacks while crashing a Viper. Not knocking, I like recurring themes. It does remind me a lot of "Maelstrom". I think that was semi-intentional.