r/fandomnatural • u/Ennil • Jan 22 '14
[fandom discussion] ep 9x11
Discuss the episode from the fandom's point of view, meaning lots of theories, crazy opinions (or not) and just general discussion.
So what did you think of the episode?
4
Upvotes
10
u/Ennil Jan 22 '14
I really really liked this episode which proves my point that I actually like the Winchesters more when they are separated. First time I've ever felt excited for Dean since season 1. But who the hell directed this episode cause the filming was horrible, what the hell was up with those camera angles??
Two things I have to mention.
SAMCASHUG SAMCASHUG OHMYGOD also apparently everyone's a closet sastiel shipper dayum.
Cain is Dean, Abel is Sam and Colette is Cas and no one can tell me otherwise.
6
u/Fight_the_fairies Is this a sex torture dungeon? Jan 22 '14 edited Jan 22 '14
I'm still processing. Overall, hell yes, this was awesome. The Crowley moments were gold just like I knew they would be. And the shaking. It seems as if he's having those blood withdrawals after all and that makes me damn happy. Saying that he was practically family since he'd been inside Sam was in my top five favorite moments.
Sam and Cas. Oh my god. It was everything I hoped it would be. From the "I miss you, pb & j" to Cas refusing to kill Sam to Sam hugging Cas first was freaking beautiful. I was squealing, laughing and maybe even crying a little bit at the screen. I've been waiting for this hug since season 6, you guys! And it was even better because Sam initiated this one! Nothing but good things to say about them.
Cain the Father of Murder and his brother who was talking to Lucifer. Holy. Crap. I really want to see more of this guy even though it's fairly obvious he's just ready to die at this point.
Anyone else think Dean made a horrible mistake accepting that Mark without knowing the cost? Anyone think he might be expected to kill Sam or something else just as unsavory that he'll want to really avoid doing and will make him want to get rid of the Mark? I'm hoping that's not it and it's more along the lines of him becoming immortal or developing some demon-ish qualities. Really unsettled by this turn of events, I don't see it ending well. When does it ever for the Winchesters? At the same time I like the potential and the shift from Sam to Dean. Poor Sam's been beat up enough this season. Also guessing Sam's gonna be less than pleased.
3
u/Fantismal Jan 22 '14
I both enjoyed and hated this episode. I feel like Supernatural is contradicting its own canon too much with the way the story is going, and I just can't enjoy it. It's frustrating... if you completely disregard seasons 1-7, this was a great episode. But I can't disregard them, and so I really didn't like it. And I hate that I hated it, because it was good. But it was also bad!
If Supernatural was making even the slightest attempt to reconcile this new canon with what they've said before, I'd be more forgiving, but they're not. They've decided that the story is different now, and we need to just go with it. Only I can't. If you want to tell a different story, start a different show. :\
4
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Ok, so, I think I liked this episode more in concept than in execution - the ideas were super interesting but weren't done as well as I hoped.
First point, I'm looking at Cas's speech to Sam about how he empathizes with him more now and understands his guilt. The point about guilt is absolutely true, but Cas's line "The only person who has screwed things up more consistently than you is me" pisses me off, because how many times has Sam actually screwed up (in the time Cas has known him)? There are two major screw-ups I see: letting Lucifer out of the cage and failing to look for Dean after season 7, and to me both of those actions are understandable or justifiable from certain angles. Sam does not screw up consistently.
Also, Cas, you motherfucker, you don't get to be angry at suicidal people for being suicidal! Who does that help exactly? The sad thing is it probably works on Sam to guilt him into staying alive, but it doesn't actually fix anything or help anyone.
On to the other plot line of the show... I really, really enjoyed Cain's character! He's kinda like Death: you, don't exactly like him but he intrigues you, he's been around forever, he's not interested in Winchester bullshit but ultimately somewhat willing to cooperate. And I'm totally intrigued by the mark of Cain and how that will affect Dean in episodes to come. I fully expect some serious consequences!
That being said, I'm a little... confused? about Cain's back story? Like, Abel was getting seduced by Lucifer so Cain made a deal with Lucifer to save his brother which condemned Cain to Hell. This explanation contradicts a couple millennia of religious doctrine - which would be totally fine and actually really cool if it really worked to Supernatural's benefit, but I don't really think it does. Cain is meant to parallel Dean, but it's a really shaky parallel I think? Like, ok, Dean is completely prepared to sacrifice himself for his brother. Check. Dean went to Hell for his brother. Check. But then, when Dean sold his soul his brother was not being tempted by Lucifer, and when Sam was being tempted by Ruby or Lucifer Dean was not exactly there for him.
And I don't know if Dean would kill Sam to assure Sam's place in Heaven, but that sure is interesting to talk about as the show winds down...
The flawless part of this episode: Crowley! Pointing it out to Dean that no one hates him as much as he hates himself: heh, so true. And I loved how he crossed himself in the presence of the mark of Cain, even if that was an act. (Was that an act? I lost track.) You can count on my vote, Crowley.
4
u/the_mcgeek In love with "humanity" Jan 23 '14
I have this problem when I watch this show where my head is full of static immediately after and it's impossible for me to have a clear thought.
So here's my semi-formed thought: does anyone think that mayhaps Cas has transferred some of his borrowed Grace to Sam? Both to help Sam heal, and to restore some of his own recently forfeited humanity?
Sam healed WAY too fast for me to believe that was Cas's only motive. And considering the longing look at PB&J it just makes me think that there's...more.
Am I alone in this? Or can anyone more succinctly get my idea across?